Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/)
-   -   10-2 and U. What the contract says. (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/120149-10-2-u-what-contract-says.html)

NFLUALNFL 02-28-2019 05:54 AM


Originally Posted by Otters (Post 2771951)
Safety issue, sorry no. A learning issue, most definitely. Look, when we have a wide body fleet well in excess of 100 airplanes flying around the world on the back side of the clock , not to mention a large number of narrow bodies flying coast to coast at night, it’s a little hard to defend a group from training at less than ideal times for a couple of hours. It is a safety issue out in the real world and we’ve done it for decades and managed quite well. Let’s all man up a little on this please.


Maybe not a safety issue, strictly speaking and in an immediate sense.



However, keep showing everyone how tough you are Marvin, because the company is REALLY noticing and appreciating you. Which part of the contract will you disagree with and give back next? Nice pin.

Airhoss 02-28-2019 06:34 AM


Originally Posted by Otters (Post 2771951)
Safety issue, sorry no. A learning issue, most definitely. Look, when we have a wide body fleet well in excess of 100 airplanes flying around the world on the back side of the clock , not to mention a large number of narrow bodies flying coast to coast at night, it’s a little hard to defend a group from training at less than ideal times for a couple of hours. It is a safety issue out in the real world and we’ve done it for decades and managed quite well. Let’s all man up a little on this please.

So in one post you say this is not a dead issue? Yet here you ask us to please “man up” because ineffective training is not a safety issue?

As I mentioned just shut up and color boys and girls.

Otters are you an ALPA training rep? And if so what council? Because we need to have a talk.

Grumble 02-28-2019 08:18 AM


Originally Posted by Otters (Post 2771951)
Safety issue, sorry no. A learning issue, most definitely. Look, when we have a wide body fleet well in excess of 100 airplanes flying around the world on the back side of the clock , not to mention a large number of narrow bodies flying coast to coast at night, it’s a little hard to defend a group from training at less than ideal times for a couple of hours. It is a safety issue out in the real world and we’ve done it for decades and managed quite well. Let’s all man up a little on this please.

Thanks for defending the contract. You’re an example to us all. :rolleyes:

People buy tickets to fly a redeye, it’s the mission. I don’t have to suffer the same misery for training.

baseball 02-28-2019 03:49 PM


Originally Posted by Otters (Post 2771951)
Safety issue, sorry no. A learning issue, most definitely. Look, when we have a wide body fleet well in excess of 100 airplanes flying around the world on the back side of the clock , not to mention a large number of narrow bodies flying coast to coast at night, it’s a little hard to defend a group from training at less than ideal times for a couple of hours. It is a safety issue out in the real world and we’ve done it for decades and managed quite well. Let’s all man up a little on this please.


It's a safety issue. I'll probably trip and fall down the stairs to the sim due to fatigue.

On a serious note.....That sounds like Larry Kellner. Kellner told me this prior to FAR 117 when ALPA was fighting for proper rest..... he says "hey you ever fly the 727 or DC10?" I says...."why do you ask?" He says..."because with 3 pilots you can just take turns napping." I says...Are you assuming the engineer is a pilot, and is both left seat and right seat qualified?" He had no response. It was the company's goal to get pilots to rest on the flight deck. No rest seat, no bunk needed. We've come a long way, lets up hold what we've fought for and won, and lets improve it and raise the bar for the next generation of pilots.

Guppydriver95 02-28-2019 10:59 PM


Originally Posted by Otters (Post 2771951)
Safety issue, sorry no. A learning issue, most definitely. Look, when we have a wide body fleet well in excess of 100 airplanes flying around the world on the back side of the clock , not to mention a large number of narrow bodies flying coast to coast at night, it’s a little hard to defend a group from training at less than ideal times for a couple of hours. It is a safety issue out in the real world and we’ve done it for decades and managed quite well. Let’s all man up a little on this please.

What a ridiculous post. Yes we fly at night. But, engine failures, and other catastrophic emergencies are extremely rare. So when we have to summon the wherewithal to deal with these events, we do. And when we land, we’re DONE. We don’t reposition and do 4 more v1 cuts, rapid d’s, hydraulic failures, or windshear recoveries while having just dealt with such an event. A post like yours makes me wonder if you have been drinking TK kool aid so long that you’ve forgotten the difference between training and line flying.

Scott Stoops 03-03-2019 02:50 PM


Originally Posted by Otters (Post 2771951)
Safety issue, sorry no. A learning issue, most definitely. Look, when we have a wide body fleet well in excess of 100 airplanes flying around the world on the back side of the clock , not to mention a large number of narrow bodies flying coast to coast at night, it’s a little hard to defend a group from training at less than ideal times for a couple of hours. It is a safety issue out in the real world and we’ve done it for decades and managed quite well. Let’s all man up a little on this please.

Like the others previously, I call b.s. we fly all-nighters and limp thru them. That is a garbage training scenario and is flatly unacceptable. Our training on my fleet already sucks, let’s not make it worse by forcing sleep deprivation into the training profile. It isn’t about manning up. It’s about investing in acceptable resources to complete the mission in a productive manner. That is United managements job. It is the pilot group and ALPAs job to ensure it gets done. Spend the $$, acquire or secure the requisite training slots. Not that hard....


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:54 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands