Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/)
-   -   Simulator and mask (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/131929-simulator-mask.html)

LeeFXDWG 12-27-2020 12:42 AM


Originally Posted by TodKindrsChikun (Post 3174824)
Simple. Wear a mask and protect someone else. Don’t need to hear your talking points for deflection.

You need to educate yourself on the SOP regarding masks in the cockpit vice at the training center/sim. Please stop making statements that may give people the wrong impression of what they can and cannot demand of another on this subject.

The sim policy is that you WILL wear a mask. End of discussion. Now to the aircraft.........

I personally reach out to the FO before the trip and let them know that I follow the mask guidance to the letter. However, I do not wear it once the door is closed. Again, as stated in the company/FAA approved policy!

I ask them to please let me know if that will be an issue so we can discuss the situation further and see what solution we can find including seeing if we can get reassigned rather than a last minute WOP for the pilot demanding the mask.

BTW, the above applies to the airplane and to Capts as well. I’ve been dealing with these since day one and I can tell you the pilot making the demand beyond the policy requirements has already lost the fight.

Lee

AntiPeter 12-27-2020 03:00 AM

The recommendations by the CDC are largely based on small studies with lots of flaws. Specifically, the Kansas study which ended later in the summer and has been heavily criticized, since after the study ended the facemask mandate counties had a surge in COViD.

The best science available, the Denmark mask study from the Spring and the meta-analysis by the Cochrane Group in the UK show on a population wide basis masks are ineffective at reducing the spread of COViD.

The state that has closed down the most, for the longest, with the most restrictions now has the second highest amount of active COViD cases. California is currently the only state where hospitals are overflowing.

United has the right to mandate whatever they choose, but my job description does not include mitigation of irrational hysteria from coworkers.

If pilots are that concerned about becoming infected with COVID while at work that seems to me like such an irrational, obsessive overreaction I would question their fitness for duty and ask them to leave the pairing with established and agreed upon protocols.

The self absorbed virtue signaling and narcissism has to stop.

TodKindrsChikun 12-27-2020 03:19 AM


Originally Posted by LeeFXDWG (Post 3174989)
You need to educate yourself on the SOP regarding masks in the cockpit vice at the training center/sim. Please stop making statements that may give people the wrong impression of what they can and cannot demand of another on this subject.

The sim policy is that you WILL wear a mask. End of discussion. Now to the aircraft.........

I personally reach out to the FO before the trip and let them know that I follow the mask guidance to the letter. However, I do not wear it once the door is closed. Again, as stated in the company/FAA approved policy!

I ask them to please let me know if that will be an issue so we can discuss the situation further and see what solution we can find including seeing if we can get reassigned rather than a last minute WOP for the pilot demanding the mask.

BTW, the above applies to the airplane and to Capts as well. I’ve been dealing with these since day one and I can tell you the pilot making the demand beyond the policy requirements has already lost the fight.

Lee

Honestly Lee I don’t know where you find the time or energy. I’m fully aware of the company policy and the differentiation between TK and the line. I have been aware since it’s inception. Never have I said someone MUST wear a mask in the cockpit or else so give it a rest Lee.

I don’t need to reach out to someone to inform them that I follow the mask guidance to the letter. That’s kind of expected is it not? If someone doesn’t follow it then that’s their fault. The way I operate, there is no need to reach out regarding the operation once the door is closed. No one will feel the need to excuse themself from the trip.

wrxpilot 12-27-2020 04:51 AM


Originally Posted by flightmedic01 (Post 3174965)
“Greatest Health Crisis”!?!? Thank you CNN! 🤦🏼‍♂️🤦🏼‍♂️🤦🏼‍♂️

Hey dum dum, my wife (a former firefighter/paramedic and current RN) is getting ready to do a 3 month contract in Los Angeles for hospitals that have zero capacity right now. I can’t comprehend how some of the people in the US still think it’s fake.

ReadOnly7 12-27-2020 07:39 AM


Originally Posted by TodKindrsChikun (Post 3174997)
No one will feel the need to excuse themself from the trip.

But they certainly WANT to, I’m guessing.....

Find yourself flying with lots of reserve pilots?

TodKindrsChikun 12-27-2020 07:43 AM


Originally Posted by ReadOnly7 (Post 3175045)
But they certainly WANT to, I’m guessing.....

Find yourself flying with lots of reserve pilots?

Scored one there didn’t you champ? Rarely.

ualPHLier 12-27-2020 10:39 AM


Originally Posted by AntiPeter (Post 3174994)
The recommendations by the CDC are largely based on small studies with lots of flaws. Specifically, the Kansas study which ended later in the summer and has been heavily criticized, since after the study ended the facemask mandate counties had a surge in COViD.

The best science available, the Denmark mask study from the Spring and the meta-analysis by the Cochrane Group in the UK show on a population wide basis masks are ineffective at reducing the spread of COViD.

The state that has closed down the most, for the longest, with the most restrictions now has the second highest amount of active COViD cases. California is currently the only state where hospitals are overflowing.

United has the right to mandate whatever they choose, but my job description does not include mitigation of irrational hysteria from coworkers.

If pilots are that concerned about becoming infected with COVID while at work that seems to me like such an irrational, obsessive overreaction I would question their fitness for duty and ask them to leave the pairing with established and agreed upon protocols.

The self absorbed virtue signaling and narcissism has to stop. I'll be sure to keep quiet next time I'm sitting next to you, as we blow past 500 feet at ref+30 and full scale high. Normally I would tell you that I'm uncomfortable with the situation; and if you asked I'd even explain to you why, at the appropriate time. But then again I wouldn't want to be thought of as a virtue signaling narcissist.

To be clear, I'm not actually commenting on your flying. I don't know anything about you, but hopefully you see my point.

ualPHLier 12-27-2020 11:06 AM


Originally Posted by ualPHLier (Post 3175094)
To be clear, I'm not actually commenting on your flying. I don't know anything about you, but hopefully you see my point.


​​​​​​​Edit: And yes, I get it: go-arounds are company-mandated, masks in the cockpit are not. My point is a broader one about toxic attitudes that can prevent us from even hearing each other's good faith concerns. Your (AntiPeter's) statement sounds like it assigns bad faith to those who disagree with you.

Ashes 12-27-2020 12:19 PM

I came here for boats, babes, and fishing. This pedantic tedium belongs over on the Alaska board.

LeeFXDWG 12-27-2020 01:35 PM


Originally Posted by TodKindrsChikun (Post 3174997)
Honestly Lee I don’t know where you find the time or energy. I’m fully aware of the company policy and the differentiation between TK and the line. I have been aware since it’s inception. Never have I said someone MUST wear a mask in the cockpit or else so give it a rest Lee.

I don’t need to reach out to someone to inform them that I follow the mask guidance to the letter. That’s kind of expected is it not? If someone doesn’t follow it then that’s their fault. The way I operate, there is no need to reach out regarding the operation once the door is closed. No one will feel the need to excuse themself from the trip.

Based on your prior posts, you want people to wear a mask all the time so you need to give it a rest. The post I replied to is yours.

Typical keyboard commando....seek life elsewhere!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:38 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands