Timeline for a JCBA?
#1
Thread Starter
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 306
Likes: 0
From: 737 Right
Does anyone have a best guess on when United will have a Joint Collective Bargaining Agreement? I know it is anyone's guess; but, I'd like to hear from current UCAL pilots on their best guesses. Are we talking another 2-3 years or is it within 6-9 months.
And let's be realistic about the possibility of the Federal NMB mediator releasing the pilots for self help -- not going to happen in an election year. Obama can't afford to have the nations largest airline on strike during his re-election. Every day that goes by is lost money. Hoping for the best but preparing for the worst.
And let's be realistic about the possibility of the Federal NMB mediator releasing the pilots for self help -- not going to happen in an election year. Obama can't afford to have the nations largest airline on strike during his re-election. Every day that goes by is lost money. Hoping for the best but preparing for the worst.
#2
Keep Calm Chive ON
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 2,086
Likes: 0
From: Boeing's Plastic Jet Button Pusher - 787
March 24th, 2014....You heard it here first.
And let's be realistic about the possibility of the Federal NMB mediator releasing the pilots for self help -- not going to happen in an election year. Obama can't afford to have the nations largest airline on strike during his re-election. Every day that goes by is lost money. Hoping for the best but preparing for the worst.
#5
That said, no way they should let off the hook, that's money they owe the pilots. When the contract became amendable, I don't think anyone considered giving these guys a free loan or worse, forgiving that debt.
In a recent conversation, the idea of amortizing retro came up that's interesting.
************************************************** *
Assumptions:
As an example, let's say pay increased by 20% in your fleet and seat. On the UAL side, amendable date was April 2009 and at as of today it's hard to imagine a ratified agreement before April 2012. So for easy math 36 months of retro. Also for easy math below I'm using guarantee of 75 hours, but obviously actual pay records for monthly credit would be used.
(Current Rate x 1.2) - Current Rate = Hourly Raise
(Hourly Raise x 75hr guarantee) x 36 Months = Retroactive pay
Let's say the contract was amendable in 48 months, then:
Retroactive pay/48 months = Monthly Retro Pay in the new contract addition to new pay rates.
Potential Benefits:
- The company would have a difficult argument trying to reduce of eliminate full retro as it avoids a lump sum payout.
- Could potentially reduce the tax burden to a pilot of a (single year) lump sum payout.
- Forces the company to pay benefits (B/C plan) on retro which it may try to avoid with a lump sum payout/signing bonus.
************************************************** *
This model is thrown out for the sake of discussion only, I realize that this is a horrible model for a pilot reaching 65 before the amendable date of the next contract. (in that case maybe a lump sum of the balance at retirement?).
Anyway, for the sake of discussion - discuss!
March 24th sounds about right (not sure what year)
Last edited by HSLD; 11-20-2011 at 10:37 PM.
#6
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 880
Likes: 0
I'm am going to throw out Spring 2012. SOC by this month will really show the direction were heading. Most say the company wasn't motivated to pay us more until SOC complete. Mgmt is already posturing more aggressively i.e. trying to make the other employee groups hate us and etc... They are turning up the heat because they know they need us to sign a contract sooner than later.
I just worry that American's negotiations may hurt us if they fail.
I just worry that American's negotiations may hurt us if they fail.
#7
Line Holder
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 673
Likes: 13
From: B767 Captain
Does anyone have any historical data on retro pay? Is getting full retro pay something that happens very often? The only new contract I've ever worked under was at Trans States in 2000, and we certainly didn't get full retro, although the RJ pilots got some, if my memory serves me correctly.
#8
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 2,750
Likes: 0
From: 737 CA
Full retro is a must, but everyday that goes by, the company is going to say they don't have the cash to provide a lump sum and will try to weasel out. They've painted themselves into a corner with retro, after all, a billion dollar lump sum payout is going to be hard to sell to shareholders and you can be sure they'll use every excuse not to pay.
That said, no way they should let off the hook, that's money they owe the pilots. When the contract became amendable, I don't think anyone considered giving these guys a free loan or worse, forgiving that debt.
In a recent conversation, the idea of amortizing retro came up that's interesting.
************************************************** *
Assumptions:
As an example, let's say pay increased by 20% in your fleet and seat. On the UAL side, amendable date was April 2009 and at as of today it's hard to imagine a ratified agreement before April 2012. So for easy math 36 months of retro. Also for easy math below I'm using guarantee of 75 hours, but obviously actual pay records for monthly credit would be used.
(Current Rate x 1.2) - Current Rate = Hourly Raise
(Hourly Raise x 75hr guarantee) x 36 Months = Retroactive pay
Let's say the contract was amendable in 48 months, then:
Retroactive pay/48 months = Monthly Retro Pay in the new contract addition to new pay rates.
Potential Benefits:
************************************************** *
This model is thrown out for the sake of discussion only, I realize that this is a horrible model for a pilot reaching 65 before the amendable date of the next contract. (in that case maybe a lump sum of the balance at retirement?).
Anyway, for the sake of discussion - discuss!
March 24th sounds about right (not sure what year)
That said, no way they should let off the hook, that's money they owe the pilots. When the contract became amendable, I don't think anyone considered giving these guys a free loan or worse, forgiving that debt.
In a recent conversation, the idea of amortizing retro came up that's interesting.
************************************************** *
Assumptions:
As an example, let's say pay increased by 20% in your fleet and seat. On the UAL side, amendable date was April 2009 and at as of today it's hard to imagine a ratified agreement before April 2012. So for easy math 36 months of retro. Also for easy math below I'm using guarantee of 75 hours, but obviously actual pay records for monthly credit would be used.
(Current Rate x 1.2) - Current Rate = Hourly Raise
(Hourly Raise x 75hr guarantee) x 36 Months = Retroactive pay
Let's say the contract was amendable in 48 months, then:
Retroactive pay/48 months = Monthly Retro Pay in the new contract addition to new pay rates.
Potential Benefits:
- The company would have a difficult argument trying to reduce of eliminate full retro as it avoids a lump sum payout.
- Could potentially reduce the tax burden to a pilot of a (single year) lump sum payout.
- Forces the company to pay benefits (B/C plan) on retro which it may try to avoid with a lump sum payout/signing bonus.
************************************************** *
This model is thrown out for the sake of discussion only, I realize that this is a horrible model for a pilot reaching 65 before the amendable date of the next contract. (in that case maybe a lump sum of the balance at retirement?).
Anyway, for the sake of discussion - discuss!
March 24th sounds about right (not sure what year)

sled
#9
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 1,559
Likes: 0
From: A Nobody
Duckdude asked:
"Is getting full retro pay something that happens very often? "
At UAL (at least for the 33+ years I've been here) the pilots have only gotten "retro" pay once and it wasn't full.
So for all you types who want a 40% raise and "full" retro pay I guess what you really want is to strike and make management pay for "their" greed. Because full retro pay is a dream which historically has never happened.
My personal observation, having walked the picket line, is that talking tuff and strutting one's stuff before a strike is awful easy to do.
"Is getting full retro pay something that happens very often? "
At UAL (at least for the 33+ years I've been here) the pilots have only gotten "retro" pay once and it wasn't full.
So for all you types who want a 40% raise and "full" retro pay I guess what you really want is to strike and make management pay for "their" greed. Because full retro pay is a dream which historically has never happened.
My personal observation, having walked the picket line, is that talking tuff and strutting one's stuff before a strike is awful easy to do.
#10
Keep Calm Chive ON
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 2,086
Likes: 0
From: Boeing's Plastic Jet Button Pusher - 787
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post




