Where did they say his last work was the holy grail? I missed that. You can like the guy and not think everything he did was great. I agree with Nicolau on several things and, just like the panel, agree with his verities.

You find one little nugget that seems to support your case and try to make more out of it than is there.

Now, how about that bid. Want to fill it with the Nic? To be fair and all and not steal a captain seat from someone senior to you on the Nic. Probably want to ignore those reinstatement rights too, right?

We won on the merits, pure and simple. The ninth got it wrong, the proof is the dissenter in the 9th correctly predicted what would happen if the 9th didn't look at the merits. The company and Silver both agree on this point. You keep harping on about the MOU and how the west did something underhanded, again you are completely delusional. There is only one underhanded party in this debacle and that is the east pilots. Anyone with half a brain "gets" what you have done, that is why you are terrified the west get to tell its story.

I have been back in the right seat for 5 years now, thanks to you and yours stealing my seat, my union and my career.

Ah, when they don't agree with you the judges are idiots. Got it. The merits were never tested on appeal, they didn't get past ripeness. Nobody knows how they would have ruled. Wake's ruling was "as if it never happened" but you guys still go back to it.

You were based in CLT on the Airbus too? Huh, I thought you were a west pilot that agreed to the terms of the transition agreement.

Hope you get your seat back, just like I got mine BACK. It wasn't yours. Blame AOL

How about you answer me. Fill the current bid with the Nic, give up reinstatement rights like Mutt and Jeff wanted to?

Had the Kirby been ratified prior to the Nicolau coming out you would likely be even further away from the left seat in PHX. But then you would have been able to take someone elses, so that would be okay.

Yeah because the east doesn't get 3 of every 4 upgrades under the Nic.

It doesn't, I've shown you that. You really need to do some research and stop believing everything you handlers shovel you. Want to answer my questions?

Can you go one day without whining you little *****.

You live in PHX for Christ's sake with that awesome contract you guys have. Oh wait, I make more than you, I am on the 76.

Not bragging here but I have 3 houses, 2 are paid for in full, 3 cars, all paid for, so if your life is **** and your career is ****, its your fault, not the Easties.

It's not how much you make, it's what you do with it.

Do any of us East guys look like we are starving?

Poor baby, you cannot come to CLT and get your 4th stripe.

He isn't whining, he is the only airline pilot in the history of US aviation to have been displaced from captain to F/O. Ever....really, it's on the internet.