Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   COVID19 (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/covid19/)
-   -   “Reasonable Accommodation” (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/covid19/135156-ireasonable-accommodationn.html)

rickair7777 10-10-2021 08:36 AM


Originally Posted by ThumbsUp (Post 3306893)
Right now there isn’t. At least with us, it’s the the accommodation of unpaid leave, suspended until the ruling.

I don’t think they’ll say yes to LTD either, I just think those folks probably have a legitimate claim and may actually be successful in fighting it given the terms. I mean realistically, if it’s legit, why shouldn’t they be given it? It’s different if it’s conspiracy driven, but if you really can’t, sure seems valid to me.

Every other vaccine mandate, ever for anything, has allowed for legit medical exemptions. Only exception might be for someone working in a bio-weapons research lab.

That should be very easy to fight, if it even came to that.

ThumbsUp 10-10-2021 08:42 AM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 3306895)
Every other vaccine mandate, ever for anything, has allowed for legit medical exemptions. Only exception might be for someone working in a bio-weapons research lab.

That should be very easy to fight, if it even came to that.

I’m just referring to UA’s specific case. I have no idea what other companies are doing. At the moment we are not allowing for exemptions, just accommodations in the form of unpaid leave.

fadec 10-11-2021 08:08 PM

Looks like Governor Abbot won't be accommodating UAL's commie vax mandate. Could this affect IAH?

https://www.rt.com/usa/537207-abbott-bans-vaccine-mandates/

Maybe guys will get to come back IAH based.

rickair7777 10-11-2021 08:17 PM


Originally Posted by fadec (Post 3307710)
Looks like Governor Abbot won't be accommodating UAL's commie vax mandate. Could this affect IAH.

No. Fed supersedes states on some things, and two very clearly established examples of those things are...

- Aviation & airlines

- Federal employees & contractors


If you want to over-rule the federal executive, you need the federal courts, not locals.

To me it seems that the fed might not have solid grounds to mandate vaccination for all employees of a federal contractor carte blanche, but rather only those employees who actually do federal work or are exposed to federal persons. That would include all cabin crew obviously, and quite possibly pilots who are locked in the same tube with DTS-ticketed federal travelers but I don't see what it has to do with mechanics, call-center agents, rampers, etc. who have no contact with federal pax.

TransWorld 10-11-2021 10:22 PM

It is pretty certain one or the other will say, “See you in court”.

ThumbsUp 10-11-2021 11:23 PM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 3307712)
No. Fed supersedes states on some things, and two very clearly established examples of those things are...

- Aviation & airlines

- Federal employees & contractors


If you want to over-rule the federal executive, you need the federal courts, not locals.

To me it seems that the fed might not have solid grounds to mandate vaccination for all employees of a federal contractor carte blanche, but rather only those employees who actually do federal work or are exposed to federal persons. That would include all cabin crew obviously, and quite possibly pilots who are locked in the same tube with DTS-ticketed federal travelers but I don't see what it has to do with mechanics, call-center agents, rampers, etc. who have no contact with federal pax.

On that note, the current contractor-focused EO on vaccinations applies to new contracts. I’m not sure how often the are revised, so mandates external to the companies themselves may get a stay until the next contract revision.

Although, I’m sure there are very few companies who would not comply if the government were to give the contractual notice to an amendment requiring it.

rickair7777 10-12-2021 08:10 AM


Originally Posted by ThumbsUp (Post 3307736)
On that note, the current contractor-focused EO on vaccinations applies to new contracts. I’m not sure how often the are revised, so mandates external to the companies themselves may get a stay until the next contract revision.

Although, I’m sure there are very few companies who would not comply if the government were to give the contractual notice to an amendment requiring it.

I'm sure the fed has anough leeway/force majeure in it's contracts that it can address a public health crisis. Also the contractors really don't mind at all, they WANT their employees vaccinated and are happy that the fed is playing bad cop.

Employees (or any other third party) are not going to be able to contest the contracts their employers have with the federal government, they have no standing. That would probably get tossed out in five minutes. Only the company holding the contract can do that.

GeeWizDriver 10-12-2021 08:42 AM

A friend at AA told me this morning "don't plan on traveling this Thanksgiving."

November 24 is the deadline. He'll apparently be fired that day.

rickair7777 10-12-2021 09:44 AM


Originally Posted by GeeWizDriver (Post 3307916)
A friend at AA told me this morning "don't plan on traveling this Thanksgiving."

November 24 is the deadline. He'll apparently be fired that day.

A PATCO-style showdown looming? Will the powers-that-be suck up the short-term pain to make their point?

GeeWizDriver 10-12-2021 11:49 AM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 3307969)
A PATCO-style showdown looming? Will the powers-that-be suck up the short-term pain to make their point?

He also told me 4000 AA pilots still haven't taken the needle. If half of those stick to their guns or are close to retirement (like my friend) and let the company fire them, the holiday flying season will be "interesting." There is an out for Parker at AA and Kelly at SWA.

"Given the legal uncertainties regarding pending vaccine mandates, we have elected to postpone enforcement of the mandate until the legal issues are clarified."


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:50 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands