30 Million Americans Vaccinated In 25 Days
#1101
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Mar 2016
Posts: 377
Thoughts on J&J vaccine?
None of my RN relatives are getting the shot, nor are many of the docs they work with.
That said, I had to get the shot and decided J&J was the most traditional and safest vaccine based on my own research.
Assuming published ingredients of the J&J are accurate, thoughts?
None of my RN relatives are getting the shot, nor are many of the docs they work with.
That said, I had to get the shot and decided J&J was the most traditional and safest vaccine based on my own research.
Assuming published ingredients of the J&J are accurate, thoughts?
#1102
#1103
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Mar 2016
Posts: 377
#1105
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Feb 2016
Position: NBC
Posts: 763
I consulted a friend who is a chief of emergency medicine back where I grew up and my wife works in Medicine. She used to work in infectious disease with Ebola...I was strongly encouraged not to get the J&J due to the amount of preservatives in the vaccine, several websites say that there are no preservatives but that is false information when you look at individual ingredients it potential may seem that way but together it's not as ideal as the other two vaccines. This is the reason why they don't have to store it similar to Moderna and the Pfizer vaccine. It's efficacy is an issue as well. I also was a little concerned that J&J was a DNA vaccine vs an mRNA vaccine. IMHO something is better than nothing, the long term potential of issues due to contracting Covid are far more of an issue than what we know today about the vaccine. I ended up going the Pfizer route...
I really thought the mRNA aspect required the extreme refrigeration, not the lack of preservatives that are supposedly in J&J. As you stated, my understanding was that the ingredients weren’t too much different than other traditional vaccines.
Oh well, so much for doing my own research.
#1106
An interactive visualization of COVID-19 | 91-DIVOC
Take a breath, dude.
#1107
I consulted a friend who is a chief of emergency medicine back where I grew up and my wife works in Medicine. She used to work in infectious disease with Ebola...I was strongly encouraged not to get the J&J due to the amount of preservatives in the vaccine, several websites say that there are no preservatives but that is false information when you look at individual ingredients it potential may seem that way but together it's not as ideal as the other two vaccines. This is the reason why they don't have to store it similar to Moderna and the Pfizer vaccine. It's efficacy is an issue as well. I also was a little concerned that J&J was a DNA vaccine vs an mRNA vaccine. IMHO something is better than nothing, the long term potential of issues due to contracting Covid are far more of an issue than what we know today about the vaccine. I ended up going the Pfizer route...
Turns out that's not what efficacy in this context means, at all. Very much an apples and oranges comparison: different trial groups for one, and crucially, the M/P trials were run at relatively low infection rates in the trials vs. the J&J which was run at some of the highest spikes in Covid infections. This matters because in a double blind test, a good portion of the test group is getting placebos; if they're in an area/point in time when the R value is low, the M/P vaccines look really good, but that might not be an accurate reading.
Bottom line though: J&J and the M/P have thus far been equally successful in preventing hospitalizations and/or deaths from the Covid strains they've been tested against. In other words, there is no difference between them all for that outcome, which is really all they're promising.
Vox (yuck, but even a broken clock...) had a great 6 min explanation of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K3odScka55A
(Not advocating any of these, just addressing the efficacy issue. All 3 vaccines equally effectIVE, but that's different than trial efficACY.
ALSO: I see the US production of the J&J vaccine just had to throw out 15 million doses; the J&J that's thus far been used in the US was made in Europe. I doubt the J&J is going to be readily available anytime soon)
#1109
#1110
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Sep 2019
Posts: 1,538
Yeah, it's not so much a PAN-demic as a FAT-demic. It's been obvious for at least the last 6 months. The only world leader I'm aware of who directly addressed this was Boris Johnson in the UK.
Could've saved hundreds of thousands of US lives if we just made the 50+ year old fatties live like biblical lepers. I'm not even kidding. Want to go out in public? Lose some weight. But, you know, fat shaming is worse than anything.
Found the graph of Israel interesting because US media is still peddling non stop doom-porn along the lines of "You must vax!!! But you also must mask! But the rates won't go down anyway and the fourth wave is coming!" Then a CDC director cries on tv about a sense of "impending doom". At least Israel is showing some hard data about how vaccinations can impact infection rates.
With high vaccination rates, Israel will also be a bellwether to the rest of the world if something goes seriously amiss.
You're right about the long term effects though. Nobody knows.
Could've saved hundreds of thousands of US lives if we just made the 50+ year old fatties live like biblical lepers. I'm not even kidding. Want to go out in public? Lose some weight. But, you know, fat shaming is worse than anything.
Found the graph of Israel interesting because US media is still peddling non stop doom-porn along the lines of "You must vax!!! But you also must mask! But the rates won't go down anyway and the fourth wave is coming!" Then a CDC director cries on tv about a sense of "impending doom". At least Israel is showing some hard data about how vaccinations can impact infection rates.
With high vaccination rates, Israel will also be a bellwether to the rest of the world if something goes seriously amiss.
You're right about the long term effects though. Nobody knows.
It's no wonder we had a worse outcome than many other countries. The three biggest contributors to Covid death beyond age are weight, heart health, and diabetes. All three are a result of our terrible diet. In the US 40% of us are obese. In Japan it is 4%. But masks and lock downs are the key.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post