View Poll Results: As for the MBCBP option, count me...
IN



86
44.33%
OUT



108
55.67%
Voters: 194. You may not vote on this poll
MBCBP Poll
#31
Some guys like to filling up with 401a because they can roll over a huge amount into a Roth IRA (ie...way more than the 6,500 contribution limit). Convert that to a Self Directed IRA (SDIRA) and use it to buy real estate. Then everything you make on said real estate goes back into that SDIRA tax free...including any appreciation on the sale of the house. That's one reason why some might want to do it.
#32
Some guys like to filling up with 401a because they can roll over a huge amount into a Roth IRA (ie...way more than the 6,500 contribution limit). Convert that to a Self Directed IRA (SDIRA) and use it to buy real estate. Then everything you make on said real estate goes back into that SDIRA tax free...including any appreciation on the sale of the house. That's one reason why some might want to do it.
Roth SD IRA can work for real estate.
Plain SDIRA is a bad idea for real estate because it actually increases your taxes. You pay income tax on an already tax advantaged investment.
When our plan recently (2022?) added the in plan Roth conversion, the use of 401a back door Roth became less popular.
The previous lack of RMDs on Inherited Roth IRAs made them a great estate planning tool. They were Nerfed by a change it tax law requiring distribution in 10 years.
#33
Here's the fund details.
https://www.blackrock.com/us/individ...-portcl-k-fund
As others have said, the share class is unknown.
https://www.blackrock.com/us/individ...-portcl-k-fund
As others have said, the share class is unknown.
#34
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 12,823
Likes: 168
From: window seat
They are very aware the proletariat are doing this. By the time most of us will get to that point, there will be various overlapping confiscatory schemes put into place like means testing for other benefits, wealth taxes, death taxes, unrealized gains taxes, changing thresholds, etc.
#35
They are very aware the proletariat are doing this. By the time most of us will get to that point, there will be various overlapping confiscatory schemes put into place like means testing for other benefits, wealth taxes, death taxes, unrealized gains taxes, changing thresholds, etc.
The back door Roth rules were put in the tax code by dems. They want to publicly state that they’re taxing the rich, meanwhile they just make more convoluted rules that create “loopholes” that allow for massive wealth-building. Despite the ostentatious berating of loopholes in public, their existence is no accident and any changes to tax code simply recolor the same rules with new names/codes/legislation.
So the rules may change over time, but keeping up with the changes will ensure that the opportunity to build wealth will continue for those that spend the time learning said changes, vice those that simply cash a pay or social welfare check.
MBCBP has the opportunity to build wealth within the current structure, however the direction agreed upon by ALPA and the Company is pretty much making a good idea a waste of everyone’s time (and money).
#36
Banned
Joined: Dec 2021
Posts: 598
Likes: 0
If you are a “day trader” or other style of aggressive investor, opt out.
If you have a large amount of real estate, opt out.
If you put your money in index funds or target date funds, stay in.
The plan is beneficial for the last 10-15 years (or possibly 10-15 years prior to 59 1/2 pending the in service withdrawals).
So the older you are, the more likely this is good, and the younger you are you need to see if the down line benefits are worth short term compromise.
Im in my early 40s and probably staying in, pending some analysis.
If you have a large amount of real estate, opt out.
If you put your money in index funds or target date funds, stay in.
The plan is beneficial for the last 10-15 years (or possibly 10-15 years prior to 59 1/2 pending the in service withdrawals).
So the older you are, the more likely this is good, and the younger you are you need to see if the down line benefits are worth short term compromise.
Im in my early 40s and probably staying in, pending some analysis.
#37
Isn't the company in plan conversion related to company contributions in the Roth 401K vs the Roth IRA on the Megabackdoor Roth? Might worth a new thread
#38
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 12,823
Likes: 168
From: window seat
The pesant rabble like us were never meant to be doing this to the extent we are and those in control of those pretending to be in control are well aware of it and are coming after it. We're a few votes in one chanber and 2 in the other from generational one party CCP style rule for many decades. They are coming for your wealth with overapping fields of regulatory fire.
#39
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post




