Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Major (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/)
-   -   Another self-righteous pilot makes the news (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/115388-another-self-righteous-pilot-makes-news.html)

jDSTJD 08-20-2018 05:05 PM


Originally Posted by Happyflyer (Post 2658734)
jDSTJD,

I do apologize for my earlier post and characterization. I responded incorrectly to a post I took offense too.
I do believe a senecio could exist where the CA was in the wrong and the lady was in the right, and that still does not make his motivations race related. I do think, white men, can be wrong and speak out of turn, and still not be a racist.
The original post I believe was about CA behavior until the other poster made it about white man behavior.

Thank you for your apology. I really appreciate that. I also respect your point of view.

galleycafe 08-20-2018 05:14 PM


Originally Posted by Deathwish (Post 2657900)
I thought he was talking about the women at American Airlines. Ha

Aaaaand I'm even more late to the party.

Plane Coffee

symbian simian 08-20-2018 06:00 PM


Originally Posted by galleycafe (Post 2658670)
I just realized AA women meant African American women.

I thought you guys were saying American Airlines women.

I was so confused.

More Plane Coffee!



Originally Posted by Deathwish (Post 2657900)
I thought he was talking about the women at American Airlines. Ha

Apparently you guys are not racist enough.

John Carr 08-20-2018 06:50 PM


Originally Posted by symbian simian (Post 2658829)
Apparently you guys are not racist enough.

And sexist enough!!!!!

jcountry 08-20-2018 07:04 PM


Originally Posted by galleycafe (Post 2658670)
I just realized AA women meant African American women.

I thought you guys were saying American Airlines women.

I was so confused.

More Plane Coffee!

You were not unreasonably confused.

This is the dumbest thread in the history of the internet. It’s making us all retarded.

Guppydriver95 08-22-2018 07:50 AM

[QUOTE=jcountry;2656987]This is so simple.

Just don’t get involved.

Going back and trying to talk sense to crazy will not result in any good outcome, ever.

Just stay out of it-and do only your job.


Problem with your theory is, the Captain is in charge of EVERYTHING that happens on the jet. So, if in his expert opinion, his intervention was needed, then that’s his call to make. “Stay in your lane” type comments may work for some work groups, but not when it’s your show(the Captain’s). Perhaps you’re not in our industry, and do not understand the legal responsibility the Captain has, so your ignorance is understandable.

jcountry 08-22-2018 01:22 PM

[QUOTE=Guppydriver95;2659797]

Originally Posted by jcountry (Post 2656987)
This is so simple.

Just don’t get involved.

Going back and trying to talk sense to crazy will not result in any good outcome, ever.

Just stay out of it-and do only your job.


Problem with your theory is, the Captain is in charge of EVERYTHING that happens on the jet. So, if in his expert opinion, his intervention was needed, then that’s his call to make. “Stay in your lane” type comments may work for some work groups, but not when it’s your show(the Captain’s). Perhaps you’re not in our industry, and do not understand the legal responsibility the Captain has, so your ignorance is understandable.

You are confusing operational control with emergency authority.

When the pax cause a big problem in flight, that can become an emergency. Clearly, the capt can and should deal with that.

At the gate, not only does the capt have no business back there, he/she technically doesn’t have operational control. Most airlines let it slide, but when the plane is at the gate and the door is open, the capt is not in charge.

The company/gate/dispatch still have authority at that point.

Stay out of it. Captain’s authority has nothing to do with these gate situations-any more than it has to do with some fight in a terminal restroom.

Don’t come crying to me when you are the next social media incident everyone is laughing at on late night shows.

Stay the **** out of the back. There be dragons

rickair7777 08-22-2018 04:15 PM

[QUOTE=jcountry;2660095]

Originally Posted by Guppydriver95 (Post 2659797)

You are confusing operational control with emergency authority.

When the pax cause a big problem in flight, that can become an emergency. Clearly, the capt can and should deal with that.

At the gate, not only does the capt have no business back there, he/she technically doesn’t have operational control. Most airlines let it slide, but when the plane is at the gate and the door is open, the capt is not in charge.

The company/gate/dispatch still have authority at that point.

Stay out of it. Captain’s authority has nothing to do with these gate situations-any more than it has to do with some fight in a terminal restroom.

Don’t come crying to me when you are the next social media incident everyone is laughing at on late night shows.

Stay the **** out of the back. There be dragons

This is correct. If the door is open, the CA's auth-or-itay is technically limited to programing the box and loading fuel. That's a technicality which is often disregarded, but if things get real ugly they will hold you to the letter of the law.

Guppydriver95 08-22-2018 04:44 PM

[QUOTE=jcountry;2660095]

Originally Posted by Guppydriver95 (Post 2659797)

You are confusing operational control with emergency authority.

When the pax cause a big problem in flight, that can become an emergency. Clearly, the capt can and should deal with that.

At the gate, not only does the capt have no business back there, he/she technically doesn’t have operational control. Most airlines let it slide, but when the plane is at the gate and the door is open, the capt is not in charge.

The company/gate/dispatch still have authority at that point.

Stay out of it. Captain’s authority has nothing to do with these gate situations-any more than it has to do with some fight in a terminal restroom.

Don’t come crying to me when you are the next social media incident everyone is laughing at on late night shows.

Stay the **** out of the back. There be dragons


Demonstrably false. The FOM is clear. From the time the Captain signs the release, until he releases the crew after block in, it’s his/her show. This was codified years ago, shortly after the merger. You’re free to disagree, but you would be wrong.

jcountry 08-23-2018 07:46 AM

[QUOTE=Guppydriver95;2660269]

Originally Posted by jcountry (Post 2660095)


Demonstrably false. The FOM is clear. From the time the Captain signs the release, until he releases the crew after block in, it’s his/her show. This was codified years ago, shortly after the merger. You’re free to disagree, but you would be wrong.

Go ahead and break up that fight in the terminal restroom. (Which is exactly the same as getting involved in a gateway altercation.)

Skycop a situation outside of the cockpit and come back here to tell us how it turned out.

Can’t wait to see how long you got suspended.

This is not hard stuff. Going back and getting involved in anything is not our job, and constitutes just about the most brain-dead thing any pilot can ever do.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:46 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands