We need to amend the RLA
#11
On Reserve
Joined: Sep 2021
Posts: 72
Likes: 1
Geeze people I know it’s APC but the amount of defeatism is staggering.
Also…..why was NOTHING done in 2009-2010 when the dems had a supermajority in the senate and the presidency? What a wasted window.
I’m not a partisan guy but I’m SMH.
Additionally I’m still not buying that a bill to amend it wouldn’t be successful. I mean look at our neighbors to the north and how Westjet got a deal because they were about to strike less than a year after their contract was amendable.
Now THATs what you call results.
We aren’t talking France here where they strike every hour on the hour, we are talking Canada whose cultural is most similar to the US compared to any other nation.
Also…..why was NOTHING done in 2009-2010 when the dems had a supermajority in the senate and the presidency? What a wasted window.
I’m not a partisan guy but I’m SMH.
Additionally I’m still not buying that a bill to amend it wouldn’t be successful. I mean look at our neighbors to the north and how Westjet got a deal because they were about to strike less than a year after their contract was amendable.
Now THATs what you call results.
We aren’t talking France here where they strike every hour on the hour, we are talking Canada whose cultural is most similar to the US compared to any other nation.
#12
Prime Minister/Moderator

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 44,618
Likes: 558
From: Engines Turn or People Swim
Nobody who hopes to be elected again can torpedo the economy.
Also... many of today's Dems are fairly lukewarm on the more successful unions, by their success their members are comfortable middle or upper-middle class. That makes them more enemy than friend.
Not defeatism, but reality: we will not be allowed to willy-nilly shut down a major economic enabler or even a significant part of it on a whim. Not even in a localized geographic area... that's a problem with the airline industry, it's not like FDX, Arby's, or Riteaid where their competition is homogeneous across the land. Any of the top six airlines would have a devastating effect on their concentration areas if shut down. The SWA meltdown was actually mitigated by the fact that they don't really dominate any major metro areas.
Additionally I’m still not buying that a bill to amend it wouldn’t be successful. I mean look at our neighbors to the north and how Westjet got a deal because they were about to strike less than a year after their contract was amendable.
Now THATs what you call results.
We aren’t talking France here where they strike every hour on the hour, we are talking Canada who’s cultural is most similar to the US compared to any other nation.
Now THATs what you call results.
We aren’t talking France here where they strike every hour on the hour, we are talking Canada who’s cultural is most similar to the US compared to any other nation.
They get paid roughly half of what we do? But they make up for it because their taxes are double?
#13
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 2,716
Likes: 39
I'm so sick and tired of being hamstrung by the overbearing RLA, like I'm sure many others are.
It's long past time that we use our collective horsepower to get a bill through congress and signed by the president that amends the RLA significantly.
It's likely next to impossible to eliminate it, but realistic amendments could absolutely be made.
For example, automatic chronological benchmarks after a certain time period after the amendable date. For example, release to self help after 18 months if no deal is made.
If that's too much to ask, since the purpose is to keep commerce moving, then how about an automatic 10-15% payment penalty compounded per year past the amendable date when the companies drag on.
I'm not buying the excuse that we don't have enough political horsepower either. Pilots have more power now than they have had in decades with such a massive shortage.
Additionally, I remember someone saying a while back that ALPA is too afraid to go there for fear of coming out with something worse in the end if the winds shift.
I'm calling baloney on that. It's ALREADY aint labor as it is, it CAN'T get much worse than its current form.
Lastly, IF.......and that's a big IF......age 67 looked like it was about to be passed, wouldn't it be smart to attach these RLA amendments to an age 67 bill to help it get passed?
Frustrated AF. Sorry, but we just shouldn't be just along for the status quo and sit back and do nothing.
It's long past time that we use our collective horsepower to get a bill through congress and signed by the president that amends the RLA significantly.
It's likely next to impossible to eliminate it, but realistic amendments could absolutely be made.
For example, automatic chronological benchmarks after a certain time period after the amendable date. For example, release to self help after 18 months if no deal is made.
If that's too much to ask, since the purpose is to keep commerce moving, then how about an automatic 10-15% payment penalty compounded per year past the amendable date when the companies drag on.
I'm not buying the excuse that we don't have enough political horsepower either. Pilots have more power now than they have had in decades with such a massive shortage.
Additionally, I remember someone saying a while back that ALPA is too afraid to go there for fear of coming out with something worse in the end if the winds shift.
I'm calling baloney on that. It's ALREADY aint labor as it is, it CAN'T get much worse than its current form.
Lastly, IF.......and that's a big IF......age 67 looked like it was about to be passed, wouldn't it be smart to attach these RLA amendments to an age 67 bill to help it get passed?
Frustrated AF. Sorry, but we just shouldn't be just along for the status quo and sit back and do nothing.
Last edited by fcoolaiddrinker; 06-02-2023 at 06:15 PM.
#14
That/It/Thang
Joined: Aug 2020
Posts: 3,448
Likes: 256
#15
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 2,716
Likes: 39
#16
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Nov 2016
Posts: 2,594
Likes: 7
I don’t know all the ins and outs but to me, we’re in the RLA because we’re in an industry that is critical to the economy such that it’s important to keep it going. We also got paid during COVID because we’re in an industry that is important to the economy such that the government didn’t want to fully shut us down. You give some. You take some.
I know I’m glad to have continued to get a pay check. A really good pay check at that.
ALSO, as others have pointed out, NO ONE is going to be sympathetic to the poor pilot making 6 figures. Did you know that only about 18% of American individuals make over $100k. Do you think the other 82% gives a rats ass about our plite when we make more than they do and get more days off per month (they’ll ignore the nights gone number, you have to know that).
I know I’m glad to have continued to get a pay check. A really good pay check at that.
ALSO, as others have pointed out, NO ONE is going to be sympathetic to the poor pilot making 6 figures. Did you know that only about 18% of American individuals make over $100k. Do you think the other 82% gives a rats ass about our plite when we make more than they do and get more days off per month (they’ll ignore the nights gone number, you have to know that).
#17
I don’t know all the ins and outs but to me, we’re in the RLA because we’re in an industry that is critical to the economy such that it’s important to keep it going. We also got paid during COVID because we’re in an industry that is important to the economy such that the government didn’t want to fully shut us down. You give some. You take some.
I know I’m glad to have continued to get a pay check. A really good pay check at that.
ALSO, as others have pointed out, NO ONE is going to be sympathetic to the poor pilot making 6 figures. Did you know that only about 18% of American individuals make over $100k. Do you think the other 82% gives a rats ass about our plite when we make more than they do and get more days off per month (they’ll ignore the nights gone number, you have to know that).
I know I’m glad to have continued to get a pay check. A really good pay check at that.
ALSO, as others have pointed out, NO ONE is going to be sympathetic to the poor pilot making 6 figures. Did you know that only about 18% of American individuals make over $100k. Do you think the other 82% gives a rats ass about our plite when we make more than they do and get more days off per month (they’ll ignore the nights gone number, you have to know that).
btw, PPP wasn’t about keeping just airlines afloat, it was about keeping the economy going and helping people buy groceries and pay rent.
#18
Banned
Joined: Sep 2016
Posts: 8,831
Likes: 499
They’re not sympathetic to us but when airlines pull out of podunkville because there’s not enough pilots, or prices skyrocket because airlines can’t meet demand they’ll expect airlines to pay whatever it takes to crew the airplanes and provide reliable reasonable service.
btw, PPP wasn’t about keeping just airlines afloat, it was about keeping the economy going and helping people buy groceries and pay rent.
btw, PPP wasn’t about keeping just airlines afloat, it was about keeping the economy going and helping people buy groceries and pay rent.
#19
Line Holder
Joined: Aug 2016
Posts: 367
Likes: 62
Never going to happen. The self righteous Congress makes $173,000 a year. Absolutely no sympathy for a self righteous pilot making double that. Our difficulties hammering out contracts will always come down to resolve. Our leverage is dictated by whims of the industry. After 911 = no power. Pilot shortage = power. Deal with it.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



