Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Major (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/)
-   -   Former Labor Sec appointed as Trans Sec (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/98571-former-labor-sec-appointed-trans-sec.html)

SayAlt 11-30-2016 01:37 PM


Originally Posted by climb (Post 2252788)

Campaign theme is right. But the campaign is over... No need to keep promises.

:/

I disagree.

The outgoing guy made major promises re: national unity and gov't transparency, neither of which he made any serious attempt to keep. As Jon Stewart so aptly said in a Rolling Stone interview in 2011, "It is as if he was over us (the voters) as soon as he took office."

Look where that got him and, more importantly, his party. One has to go all the way back to the 1920s to find democrats so politically weak nationwide as of Jan. 2017. History will inescapably show him to be a political aberration, not the "new normal". And his failures, almost all of them, go back to failing to keep those two central campaign promises of unity and transparency.

But then, that's what ya get when you promote a guy with no experience whatsoever to be the chief executive. Remember Democrats insisting his lack of experience didn't matter?? Well sir, it will be generations before they make that mistake again, if ever!

The new guy, on the other hand, has decades of experience being a chief executive, and a very successful one at that. He isn't likely to make the same novice mistakes in leadership the outgoing guy did...like failing to keep key, important campaign promises. Can he fail to keep them? Of course. Will he? I don't think so, not the important ones. If he doesn't, he is unlikely to win a 2nd term.

Voters don't like being lied to. See: the last 8 years

CBreezy 11-30-2016 02:24 PM


Originally Posted by n9810f (Post 2252535)
She was a long time member of the board of directors at Northwest Airlines Corporation.

During the good or bad years? I'm concerned by menus memos released by the Heritage Foundation that essentially say NAI is good for the economy. I'd imagine she had some say in those releases.

CBreezy 11-30-2016 02:32 PM


Originally Posted by SayAlt (Post 2252682)
Take a deep breath and try to relax.

The new SoT is NOT going to be operating in a vacuum and do whatever she wants in spite of the incoming administration's #1 campaign theme "fair deal for the American worker(s)".

And the Heritage Foundation is not going to be running the gov't.

Geez. :rolleyes:

I'm not panicking. I'm asking questions that we should all be asking. And yes, the SoT is the one who approves foreign carrier permits so, technically, she could allow the flag of convenience model.

Finally, she is known to leave organizations she doesn't agree with, for example she left a group that invested in a cause that supported clean energy because it hurt the coal industry. She is/was fellow at the HF. Having expertise as former SoL and under Sec of transportation, you can bet that anything that is published regarding labor and transportation was probably run by her desk. To think otherwise is naïve. She was chosen by Trump specifically and I would bet she wants and believes that NAI is good for the economy.

Molon Labe 11-30-2016 02:32 PM


Originally Posted by CBreezy (Post 2252975)
During the good or bad years? I'm concerned by menus memos released by the Heritage Foundation that essentially say NAI is good for the economy. I'd imagine she had some say in those releases.

The bad years! She is a free trade type not fair trade...She is bad for working USA...rhetoric one way actions equal "you can't give away an American job fast enough"

krudawg 11-30-2016 03:46 PM


Originally Posted by thevagabond (Post 2252849)
People actually believe aviation pensions disappeared because of a terrorist attack? Wow.

911 was responsible for a very heavy drop-off in flying customers. It is the paying customer who pays our wages and paid for our pension. When they stopped coming, the money airlines used to pay our wages dried up. It wasn't George Bush or any of his "misguided" policies, it was simply airlines going in survivor mode and peeling back their overhead. The PBGC aggravated our situation because they demanded the company "hand over" our pensions and after some foot dragging, they got all our pension money. Federal law (Bankruptcy) allowed our "underfunded" pension to be "unloaded" by the airlines. It was tragic what happen to us and a double-wammy, when you consider our ESOP stock loss.

SpeedyVagabond 11-30-2016 04:50 PM

Well then according to that logic since the airlines are making money hand over fist we'll all be pensioned soon. Right? Trying not to be facetious but 9/11 wasn't the reason. It certainly helped with their justification for doing it.

SayAlt 11-30-2016 05:42 PM


Originally Posted by CBreezy (Post 2252981)

I'm not panicking. I'm asking questions that we should all be asking.

Agreed.



Originally Posted by CBreezy (Post 2252981)

yes, the SoT is the one who approves foreign carrier permits so, technically, she could allow the flag of convenience model. I would bet she wants and believes that NAI is good for the economy.

Maybe so. However, the question at hand is not what is good for the economy per se, but what is best for the American worker, the vast middle class that elected Trump.

If Trump were inexperienced as was his predecessor, I would be very concerned he might make the mistake you are worried about. But he is a businessman first and foremost. He understands the issues of flags-of-convenience instinctively, and his core campaign promise was to say NO to issues and deals that were unfair to American workers.

My point is that it isn't what the new SoT thinks is best, but what her boss thinks is best. And he...unlike her...has a promise to keep. And importantly, not just to red state America, but to the blue state workers who voted in their millions for him, as they did for Reagan.

You raise an important issue. Let's see what happens. I think Trump is sincere. Like he says....he didn't need the job, or the headaches that come with it. He was already set for life. Let's give him a chance to put his newly-given clout where his mouth has been. If he reneges on his promise...specifically as concerns NAI...I will join you in condemning him. It's a prefect issue to test his sincerity, and there is little doubt that Doug Parker and Co. will have their chance to bend his ear on the matter. Moreover, cheap international air travel is not of paramount concern to the well-being of the American economy. Good paying jobs that keep the consumer-based economy afloat are far more important than cheap cost of international travel. Trump will understand that without lengthy explanation.

Let's see what happens first and not read too much into a(ny) cabinet appointment. If we know anything about Trump, it is that HE calls the shots, not those under him. Like I said, he has decades of experience as a CEO. Let's see how he leads before throwing him under the bus.

That is, unless one happens to be part of the extremist fringe the American electorate has thrown back into obscurity for at least the next several years, at a minimum. For those, there is nothing he can do that will not be met with cries of faux outrage and hair-pulling, drama-queens to the last.

Nevjets 11-30-2016 06:11 PM

Former Labor Sec appointed as Trans Sec
 

Originally Posted by thevagabond (Post 2253064)
Well then according to that logic since the airlines are making money hand over fist we'll all be pensioned soon. Right? Trying not to be facetious but 9/11 wasn't the reason. It certainly helped with their justification for doing it.


In essence, yes. Instead of the defined benefit plans, airlines are compensating you at the same rate, if not better, with a defined contribution plan. What's is up to now? Sixteen percent?

BigDukeSix 11-30-2016 06:35 PM


Originally Posted by thevagabond (Post 2252810)
I love when people open their mouths and remove all doubt. So, where exactly did you go to school and what did you study? My first degree was engineering. And like 99.9% of scientifically trained people I know climate change is happening and that it has been brought on by human activity since the start of the Industrial Revolution. It's no longer a debate. Only fools don't acknowledge and accept our impact.

Who really cares if the temperature goes up 1 or 2 degress C in a hundred years anyway? It would be nice to have winters a little warmer. If the cavemen could handle the end of the ice age I think we're fine. And by the way since when was engineering the same as a climatology or meteorology degree? That is like saying someone with a CDL is qualified to fly an airliner.

kevbo 11-30-2016 07:38 PM


Originally Posted by thevagabond (Post 2253064)
Well then according to that logic since the airlines are making money hand over fist we'll all be pensioned soon. Right? Trying not to be facetious but 9/11 wasn't the reason. It certainly helped with their justification for doing it.

I remember seeing $1200 one ways turn into $400 round trips in 6 months. The Internet and an oversupply of seats let it happen fast. Well funded startups (jet blue) bled the legacys dry.

NEDude 11-30-2016 11:18 PM


Originally Posted by BigDukeSix (Post 2253129)
Who really cares if the temperature goes up 1 or 2 degress C in a hundred years anyway? It would be nice to have winters a little warmer. If the cavemen could handle the end of the ice age I think we're fine. And by the way since when was engineering the same as a climatology or meteorology degree? That is like saying someone with a CDL is qualified to fly an airliner.

So New York, Miami, Los Angeles all being underwater will be good for the economy huh?

Sniper66 12-01-2016 12:08 AM


Originally Posted by CBreezy (Post 2251989)
I'm going to put this here in hopes of having an important discussion.

Elaine Chao, former Labor secretary and heritage foundation fellow is going to become the next Transportation Secretary. From reading some of the Heritage Foundation publications, it looks like they want to dissolve the TSA, oppose the Airport Improvement taxes, and are pro ATC privatization.

It also appears the Heritage Foundation considers the Deny NAI movement as anti-competition. What are your thoughts on how this move affects two of our most important movements (ME3 and NAI)?







On the Board at Northwest Airlines or high VP position, can't recall her exact position back at the day .... and we are familiar with their strikes there......

Not good for unions

Gunga Din 12-01-2016 02:55 AM


Originally Posted by BigDukeSix (Post 2253129)
Who really cares if the temperature goes up 1 or 2 degress C in a hundred years anyway? It would be nice to have winters a little warmer. If the cavemen could handle the end of the ice age I think we're fine.

I hope my sarcasm meter is broken because, damn. I've heard some scientifically ignorant statements in my time but this takes the cake. You need to open a science book or three.

NEDude 12-01-2016 03:10 AM


Originally Posted by Gunga Din (Post 2253208)
I hope my sarcasm meter is broken because, damn. I've heard some scientifically ignorant statements in my time but this takes the cake. You need to open a science book or three.

Remember that Republicans are on record as being opposed to education or anything that challenges people's "fixed belief systems". (Read the 2012 Texas state Republican party platform to see how truly anti-education they are).

GogglesPisano 12-01-2016 03:57 AM


Originally Posted by Gunga Din (Post 2253208)
I hope my sarcasm meter is broken because, damn. I've heard some scientifically ignorant statements in my time but this takes the cake. You need to open a science book or three.

Or spend an hour or two watching some NOVA's or a Cosmos episode. The majority of scientists -- climate scientists in particular -- see this as the greatest threat facing our species today -- oh wait, I'll bet they're part of the liberal atheist conspiracy, too.

BigDukeSix 12-01-2016 04:10 AM


Originally Posted by NEDude (Post 2253195)
So New York, Miami, Los Angeles all being underwater will be good for the economy huh?

We can just hire the Dutch to build some dykes. They're good at that sort of thing. Not too worried about those doomsday predictions.

NEDude 12-01-2016 04:27 AM


Originally Posted by GogglesPisano (Post 2253229)
Or spend an hour or two watching some NOVA's or a Cosmos episode. The majority of scientists -- climate scientists in particular -- see this as the greatest threat facing our species today -- oh wait, I'll bet they're part of the liberal atheist conspiracy, too.

Yep, and all the scientists around the globe, who have no investment in American politics, are in on the conspiracy as well.

SpeedyVagabond 12-01-2016 05:08 AM

Yup. There are a lot of intelligent people who choose to be dumb through lack of continuing education or just basically not being educated to a minimum acceptable level to begin with. This forum is a perfect example of that. Lots of fools here spouting their poorly spelled and grammatically incorrect nonsense daily. It's an undisputable fact that basic education levels in this country have plummeted. And it shows. 'Murica was once great. And I love this Republic but I don't really believe that we have much of a future any longer. I wish the many idiots in this country would take to heart what the many great people who have built and have struggled to hold together our republic have said about maintaining it. But it's far easier to go back home or to the hotel room and turn on the brain anesthetizer and be spoon fed whichever side's comforting and dumbed down propaganda one chooses to swallow.

SpeedyVagabond 12-01-2016 05:13 AM


Originally Posted by NEDude (Post 2253195)
So New York, Miami, Los Angeles all being underwater will be good for the economy huh?

BigDukeSix loves the smell of napalm in the morning. He may have inhaled a little too much. . . : )

BigDukeSix 12-01-2016 05:28 AM


Originally Posted by thevagabond (Post 2253248)
Yup. There are a lot of intelligent people who choose to be dumb through lack of continuing education or just basically not being educated to a minimum acceptable level to begin with. This forum is a perfect example of that. Lots of fools here spouting their poorly spelled and gramatically incorrect nonsense daily. It's an undisputable fact that basic education levels in this country have plummeted. And it shows. 'Murica was once great. And I love this Republic but I don't really believe that we have much of a future any longer. I wish the many idiots in this country would take to heart what the many great people who have built and have struggled to hold together our republic have said about maintaining it. But it's far easier to go back home or to the hotel room and turn on the brain anesthetizer and be spoon fed whichever side's comforting and dumbed down propaganda one chooses to swallow.

You should have run for president. All of us idiots need to follow and learn from someone as wise and enlightened as you are. Help this padawan to understand the world with your sage advice!

SpeedyVagabond 12-01-2016 05:38 AM


Originally Posted by BigDukeSix (Post 2253257)
You should have run for president. All of us idiots need to follow and learn from someone as wise and enlightened as you are. Help this padawan to understand the world with your sage advice!

Well sir you prove your stupidity and ignorance with your statements here. Turn off the tv and read. You won't say such foolish things any longer. Have a nice day.

BigDukeSix 12-01-2016 05:44 AM


Originally Posted by thevagabond (Post 2253262)
Well sir you prove your stupidity and ignorance with your statements here. Turn off the tv and read. You won't say such foolish things any longer. Have a nice day.

I'll bet your...sorry you're the smartest person in every room you walk in to. All people have to do is ask you! See ya oh wise one.

baseball 12-01-2016 05:53 AM


Originally Posted by Arty13 (Post 2252040)
This ^^^^
We all understand that Uncle Sam has its place. And I believe our civic duty is to be suspicious of anything coming from D.C. Let's not kick this can around. Instead discuss specific issues.

I am concerned about what the new appointment means concerning NAI, and about our future ability to strike. But I'll reserve judgement until I see what actually happens.

The current administration decided to punt on NAI and the ME3.

SayAlt 12-01-2016 05:56 AM


Originally Posted by Sniper66 (Post 2253197)

On the Board at Northwest Airlines or high VP position, can't recall her exact position back at the day .... and we are familiar with their strikes there......

Not good for unions


Hmmmm. Nope. Nothing in her Bio about any position with an airline. Sounds like made up rumor or bad recall to me. Way to weigh in with a meaningful contribution, though!


Let's see...

Elaine Chao

- Taiwanese immigrant who came to the US at age 8 with her family, fleeing Mao's communists in 1961 (I think it's safe to assume she didn't speak any english at the time, don't you?)

- father was a common deck hand who later founded his own successful shipping co. (...the American dream, writ large)

- worked hard enough to go on and eventually earn an MBA from Harvard in 1975 (American dream, con't)

- former Deputy Maritime Administrator

- former Chairwoman of the Federal Maritime Commission

- former Director of the Peace Corp

- former President and CEO of the United Way of America

- former US Sec. of Labor

- first Asian American woman to be appointed to a cabinet-level position

Oh, this is interesting...



Under her leadership, the U.S. Department of Labor achieved record results in protecting the health, safety, wages, and retirement security of the nation’s workforce. These included recovering record levels of back wages and monetary recoveries for pension plans, and obtaining record financial settlements for discrimination by federal contractors.
Wow! Sounds pretty good, doesn't it? Highly qualified, distinguished career, successful immigrant family and individual contributor to the nation, first female appointed to a Cabinet level position, etc, etc.










Ahhh, now I see why leftists are already gunning for her.

She's a republican with ties to the Heritage Foundation. GASP! That MUST mean she's anti-labor, right? Nevermind the quote above detailing how, as the first Asian American female Sec. of Labor (and the first to hold a cabinet level position -->appointed by a republican, no less!), she "recover(ed) record levels of back wages and monetary recoveries for pension plans, and obtain(ed) record financial settlements for discrimination by federal contractors."

Funny how leftiest say that stereo-typing people is a "micro-aggression" and, in the case of minorities, blatantly racist...

...unless they are the ones doing it.

baseball 12-01-2016 05:59 AM


Originally Posted by CBreezy (Post 2252325)
I'm not trolling. I'm inviting a legitimate conversation because this will have immediate implications to our careers.

The horse already left the barn. Current administration allowed NAI. Open Skies treaty is the airborne equivalent of NAFTA, and you can't really fight the ME3 on a level playing field.

The only real leverage we have left is age 65. It must hold firm.

SpeedyVagabond 12-01-2016 06:11 AM


Originally Posted by BigDukeSix (Post 2253270)
I'll bet your...sorry you're the smartest person in every room you walk in to. All people have to do is ask you! See ya oh wise one.

I love having discussions with people like you in the morning. It smells like victory. Later.

tomgoodman 12-01-2016 07:27 AM


Originally Posted by BigDukeSix (Post 2253231)
We can just hire the Dutch to build some dykes. They're good at that sort of thing.

I doubt that even the Dutch can build a dyke. ;)

SpeedyVagabond 12-01-2016 07:40 AM


Originally Posted by tomgoodman (Post 2253385)
I doubt that even the Dutch can build a dyke. ;)

Laugh out loud!

jcountry 12-01-2016 07:44 AM

I find it humorous that everyone thought a democrat would be so great for labor.

Obama hasn't lifted a finger to help anyone in our industry-or pretty much any other.

All politicians suck! Until we get rid of the Railway Labor Act (unlikely,) things will never improve.

Gunga Din 12-01-2016 07:56 AM


Originally Posted by BigDukeSix (Post 2253231)
We can just hire the Dutch to build some dykes. They're good at that sort of thing. Not too worried about those doomsday predictions.

Know this. The conservative parties in Germany, Australia, England, Spain, and every other developed country agree with the science. That's the CONSERVATIVE parties. We alone have a single party that denies the obvious. What could possibly cause this? Hmmmm? I wonder?

iceman49 12-01-2016 08:35 AM


Originally Posted by SayAlt (Post 2253284)
Hmmmm. Nope. Nothing in her Bio about any position with an airline. Sounds like made up rumor or bad recall to me. Way to weigh in with a meaningful contribution, though!

Let's see...

Elaine Chao
.

She was on the BOD of Northwest Airlines under Gary Wilson.

iceman49 12-01-2016 08:37 AM


Originally Posted by BigDukeSix (Post 2253129)
Who really cares if the temperature goes up 1 or 2 degress C in a hundred years anyway? It would be nice to have winters a little warmer. If the cavemen could handle the end of the ice age I think we're fine. And by the way since when was engineering the same as a climatology or meteorology degree? That is like saying someone with a CDL is qualified to fly an airliner.

The Sixth Extinction by Kolbert is a good read.

SayAlt 12-01-2016 08:41 AM


Originally Posted by Gunga Din (Post 2253418)

We alone have a single party that denies the obvious. What could possibly cause this?

Just a guess, mind you, but I'd say it's the kind of utter insanity behind actually attempting to regulate cow farts, all while demanding to be taken seriously...

Cow Fart Regulation Passed Into California Law « CBS San Francisco

:eek:

Other nominees include:

- deliberately manipulating climate data to reflect the results desired to support a socio-economic agenda

- getting caught over, and over, and over, and over doing this ^^^^^

- declaring wildly theoretical science to be "settled" based upon consensus vs. irrefutable, scientific proof

- using fear-mongering tactics, based upon all the above, to appropriate public funds in order to fund the socio-economic agenda

- unapologetically and openly profiting from same, both fiscally and politically, proving the lie behind the "doing good for all" pablum

- the rank, vile, constant, never-ending hypocrisy of leftist celebrities ...who have absolutely nothing in common with the avg person... rushing here and there to lecture everyone else about their GW religion in their private jets and SUV motorcades

- the snide, condescending, smarmy, elitist group-think that believes anyone who won't convert to their climate religion is (insert your insult here)


I could go on and on, but no need.

CA will regulate it's cow farts and the like while committing economic suicide. The political fringe won't make any new inroads to rural America while become increasingly isolated in their big city islands. Crime there will continue to skyrocket while the same insane idiots make war against their police protection. And in the end, this generation's love-affair with socialism will, once again, fail and fade to nothing. Just as it has throughout World history.

Good luck with those cow fart regulations. Looking forward to hearing about the new advances in controlling chicken poop. ;)

SpeedyVagabond 12-01-2016 08:45 AM

He won't read it. Like Gore said it's inconvenient. So he and the many other "deciders" in our country choose the path of ignorance. And that's why this country will fail.

SayAlt 12-01-2016 08:51 AM


Originally Posted by iceman49 (Post 2253441)
She was on the BOD of Northwest Airlines under Gary Wilson.

I see.

So NAI is a done deal, right?

SpeedyVagabond 12-01-2016 09:20 AM

There is a fair bit of unspun factual information out there about how the labor department handled complaints of wage theft and workplace safety while she was heading it up. It's not very flattering from labor's point of view.

SpeedyVagabond 12-01-2016 09:37 AM

"The labor department became a useful tool for predatory employers. Labor Secretary Elaine Chao ignored flagrant union busting and the widespread theft of wages and benefits." - James Hoffa
That's only a direct quote from the President of one of the major unions representing pilots.

Mesabah 12-01-2016 11:49 AM


Originally Posted by thevagabond (Post 2253248)
Yup. There are a lot of intelligent people who choose to be dumb through lack of continuing education or just basically not being educated to a minimum acceptable level to begin with. This forum is a perfect example of that. Lots of fools here spouting their poorly spelled and grammatically incorrect nonsense daily. It's an undisputable fact that basic education levels in this country have plummeted. And it shows. 'Murica was once great. And I love this Republic but I don't really believe that we have much of a future any longer. I wish the many idiots in this country would take to heart what the many great people who have built and have struggled to hold together our republic have said about maintaining it. But it's far easier to go back home or to the hotel room and turn on the brain anesthetizer and be spoon fed whichever side's comforting and dumbed down propaganda one chooses to swallow.

Yes, they lowered the standards so everyone could get in, and afford to go to college, with a double digit interest loan. The liberals would shut down any educational institution that functioned solely on merit, however, colleges are no longer places that allow diversity of opinion.

Gunga Din 12-01-2016 12:34 PM


Originally Posted by SayAlt (Post 2253284)
Hmmmm. Nope. Nothing in her Bio about any position with an airline. Sounds like made up rumor or bad recall to me. Way to weigh in with a meaningful contribution, though!


Let's see...

Elaine Chao

- Taiwanese immigrant who came to the US at age 8 with her family, fleeing Mao's communists in 1961 (I think it's safe to assume she didn't speak any english at the time, don't you?)

- father was a common deck hand who later founded his own successful shipping co. (...the American dream, writ large)

- worked hard enough to go on and eventually earn an MBA from Harvard in 1975 (American dream, con't)

- former Deputy Maritime Administrator

- former Chairwoman of the Federal Maritime Commission

- former Director of the Peace Corp

- former President and CEO of the United Way of America

- former US Sec. of Labor

- first Asian American woman to be appointed to a cabinet-level position

Oh, this is interesting...

Wow! Sounds pretty good, doesn't it? Highly qualified, distinguished career, successful immigrant family and individual contributor to the nation, first female appointed to a Cabinet level position, etc, etc.










Ahhh, now I see why leftists are already gunning for her.

She's a republican with ties to the Heritage Foundation. GASP! That MUST mean she's anti-labor, right? Nevermind the quote above detailing how, as the first Asian American female Sec. of Labor (and the first to hold a cabinet level position -->appointed by a republican, no less!), she "recover(ed) record levels of back wages and monetary recoveries for pension plans, and obtain(ed) record financial settlements for discrimination by federal contractors."

Funny how leftiest say that stereo-typing people is a "micro-aggression" and, in the case of minorities, blatantly racist...

...unless they are the ones doing it.

I don't recall anyone saying anything about her being racist. It's weird why you focus on that.
While she is qualified, the argument is if she friendly to labor and good for working Americans in general.

She cut hundreds of safety inspectors as Labor secretary. She was blamed for the poor oversight when a mine collapsed killing 12 miners.
She has refused to go after employers that stole wages from employees.
Under her leadership OSHA didn't issue one single new safety regulation in 4 years.
When it comes to regulating drones or the implementation of the next gen ATC do you really think she's going to have workers in mind or the corporations?

Oh and the real chestnut... she's still pro TPP and lobbies for the Chinese in several areas.

Dolphinflyer 12-01-2016 02:24 PM

I'm going to have to step back and give some deep thought to the thought of an Asian woman in charge of regulating the quality of transportation in this country :eek:

;):D


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:06 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands