Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   OO vs. YX (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/120249-oo-vs-yx.html)

rickair7777 02-26-2019 11:38 AM


Originally Posted by stabapch (Post 2770864)
Let’s keep in mind also that once that recession hits, history proves the wo’s are the first to go.


Originally Posted by dera (Post 2770868)
Your history lesson does not apply to AA. American Eagle has been going on for a very long time. I would be much more concerned if I was at Endeavor or Republic, when a recession hits.

Historical fact... AA had flow in the past and it went away real fast at one point.

Also WO's serve as capacity accumulators because the parent can downsize flying as needed. To do that at an independent regional they need to pay huge penalties to get out of contracts early, or find an excuse to fire them (the later has happened a few times).

WO's have also been shut down and liquidated for simple convenience (not AA). When you say "American Eagle" that has quite a different meaning today than when I started in the industry. Today's it's a marketing slogan. Back then it was an airline with a near-monopoly on AA feed, which could have been sold off at one point. Envoy is lucky to still be WO.

Something to consider in your decision making.

dera 02-26-2019 11:49 AM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 2770879)
Historical fact... AA had flow in the past and it went away real fast at one point.

Also WO's serve as capacity accumulators because the parent can downsize flying as needed. To do that at an independent regional they need to pay huge penalties to get out of contracts early, or find an excuse to fire them (the later has happened a few times).

WO's have also been shut down and liquidated for simple convenience (not AA). When you say "American Eagle" that has quite a different meaning today than when I started in the industry. Today's it's a brand. Back then it was an airline with a near-monopoly on AA feed, which could have been sold off at one point. Envoy is lucky to still be WO.

Something to consider in your decision making.

It only went away because the mainline was not hiring. During those years, there was no real movement from any other regionals either, so AA WO's were not singled out in this.
I'd say the AA WO's did pretty well during those years. Yes, they downsized, but looking at the turmoil rest of the regional industry went through, AA WO wasn't a bad place to be.

Currently, there are no 10 year CA's at any WO's who are there because they can't move on. There are plenty of them at other regionals. So yes, the flow works, even though there was a 7-8 year gap because of the lost decade.

So based on the history lessons, I would say AA WOs are definitely some of the more stable regionals to be in. And currently they have other added benefits too - fast upgrades, no training delays and so on.

Broncofan 02-26-2019 12:37 PM


Originally Posted by TheWeatherman (Post 2770640)
With the IROPS, strong winds, and deicing I overblocked ~6 hours already this month. It is not just some insignificant outlier, it does add up over the year to a significant chunk of change.

I think I misunderstand what your trying to say.. if you go over block at Skywest you still get paid for it.

word302 02-26-2019 12:48 PM


Originally Posted by UnderCenter (Post 2770725)
Yea, but we aren’t the only one who does it this way. That’s also a different discussion to have. I was more pointing out the inaccuracy of his post. He actually thinks that we only get paid block/historical credit which is not true at all. He actually thought that if we blocked 3 hours on a flight due to deice, flow etc that was only scheduled at 1:45 we only get paid 1:45, which is absolutely false.

Endeavor is the only other regional not getting block or better, thus why it is considered industry standard.

dera 02-26-2019 01:09 PM


Originally Posted by Broncofan (Post 2770917)
I think I misunderstand what your trying to say.. if you go over block at Skywest you still get paid for it.

So just to understand, if you go under block, you get paid less?

A.FLOOR 02-26-2019 01:15 PM


Originally Posted by dera (Post 2770868)
PDT/PSA flow is slower, that's true. Envoy has a good program going on. PDT/PSA will get better, everyone knows that, except the forum negative nancies who think they can run an airline better than their management can.

Your history lesson does not apply to AA. American Eagle has been going on for a very long time. I would be much more concerned if I was at Endeavor or Republic, when a recession hits.

"doesn't offer anything", the flow is pretty darn valuable for a lot of people. I turned down CJOs from Republic and Endeavor to go to Envoy, because their value proposition was the best for me. No regional contract is worth commuting for. And to hold CA within a reasonable commute for me would take years and years at those places. I dodged a huge bullet with them - The people who started indoc the same time I started mine aren't even in sims yet, and I'm almost consolidated. I'm months ahead already.

YX upgrades are sub-2 years only for very uncommutable bases. How long is it to hold YX CA at ORD, or IAH? 7-8 years?

Didn't Envoy's management just ask for concessions from your pilot group? As long as they have a flow, they will never have the same QOL as YX or OO. That's the trade off you make when you chase the carrot.

UnderCenter 02-26-2019 01:17 PM


Originally Posted by dera (Post 2770942)
So just to understand, if you go under block, you get paid less?

If you go under marketed block you get paid historical credit. Sometimes this is more than scheduled block and sometimes it’s less. It’s a number the company comes up with by averaging all of the block times for that segment over the year. So scheduled block might be 1:45. Historical credit might be 1:35. If you fly it in 1:20 you get paid 1:35. If you fly it in 1:40 you get 1:40. If you fly it in 2:25 you get 2:25. So it’s “historical credit or better” not “block or better”.

dera 02-26-2019 01:32 PM


Originally Posted by pilotnicco (Post 2770945)
Didn't Envoy's management just ask for concessions from your pilot group? As long as they have a flow, they will never have the same QOL as YX or OO. That's the trade off you make when you chase the carrot.

Pilot group asked first for a handout, mgmt answered by asking for something in return. Its called negotiating.
My QOL is great here. Beats flying 15 minute hops in a 200.

UnderCenter 02-26-2019 01:49 PM


Originally Posted by dera (Post 2770966)
My QOL is great here. Beats flying 15 minute hops in a 200.

Who is flying 15 min hops in a 200? Been at OO less than a year, only 2 months reserve, now a line holder. In a base with no 200s. Credit 85-95 hours a month. Have you seen the Envoy 145 flying out of DFW? Must be fun flying 15 min hops to Tyler, Waco, Texarkana, and Shepard every day.

dera 02-26-2019 01:50 PM


Originally Posted by UnderCenter (Post 2770976)
Who is flying 15 min hops in a 200? Been at OO less than a year, only 2 months reserve, now a line holder. In a base with no 200s. Credit 85-95 hours a month. Have you seen the Envoy 145 flying out of DFW? Must be fun flying 15 min hops to Tyler, Waco, Texarkana, and Shepard every day.

My point exactly. Both OO and Envoy have good and not as good flying available. Look up some flying you guys do from DTW.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:15 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands