Go Back  Airline Pilot Central Forums > Airline Pilot Forums > Regional
1500 hours / ATP for Part 121 rule? >

1500 hours / ATP for Part 121 rule?


Notices
Regional Regional Airlines

1500 hours / ATP for Part 121 rule?

Old 06-26-2011 | 10:02 AM
  #131  
DashDriverYV's Avatar
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 406
Likes: 0
From: back in the right
Default

Originally Posted by saab2000
Don't misunderstand me. I'm not against raising the bar of entry to the airlines. I'm just saying that a metric of just hours does not necessarily equate to quality. When I flew in Europe I was hired with far fewer hours than is normal in the US and this is probably why I say it's OK. But there is no question at all that I look back with horror at how great I thought I was and how sucky I really was.

I guess I don't know what to say. The ATP requirement, if/when it ever happens, is not a bad thing. But it may also have unintended consequences. There WILL be a need for pilots in this country in great numbers over the next 10 years and the traditional path of instructing, flying Barons at night, etc. will not produce the thousands of pilots needed. I fear what the airlines will try to do if there is a shortage of qualified pilots to fill seats - contract pilots from outside the US? Don't say it can't happen. Other parts of the world do it all the time.
The ATP certificate is much more than 1500 hours. In fact I would bet a pilot who only flight instructs would not have the correct time to receive it. As for the shortage question, easy, fly bigger planes with less frequency. When the smallest thing serving most of the city pairs if a 737, there will be enough pilots.
Reply
Old 06-26-2011 | 03:30 PM
  #132  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 2,168
Likes: 0
From: Reclined
Default

Originally Posted by Duksrule
With some of the people that think that the only way to really "know" how to fly is to be a CFI for 2-3 years riding in the right seat while someone else is "trying to kill you" maybe rather than the 1500 rule, it should be 1500 dual given. Isn't the reason the FAA has check flights are to ensure you are able to fly? Is 500 hours low to be a 121 pilot? I don't know the answer to that. I think the answer has a lot to do with how you learned to fly, the quality of instruction, the QUALITY of the time you have and many other things. There isn't a cookie cutter number. A guy with 1500 hours of point A-B, pattern work and even some CFI work isn't automatically a better pilot than someone who got their COMM at 200 hours, done a lot of real world flying in weather and has had equipment issues that required them to make a choice and get the airplane down safe. I know that some CFIs work hard for the hours and know a lot. I have also seen CFIs that just ride around in the right seat, never see a real emergency or any weather. While not a CFI myself I would imagine that after 20 hours or so probably 75% of students aren't "trying to kill" the CFI anymore if at all. Not dogging CFIs in any way, I am just saying that 1500 hours in the right seat doesn't make you ready to fly the space shuttle. It is about the quality of your flight time, not the quantity.
Perfectly spoken by somebody who has never has one of those student try to kill them. You belittle something you knowthing about. Let me clue you into something. The reason there are 6 month and 1 year checks at 121 airlines is because some people make not practice or study enough to remain sharp enough for abnormal and emergency situations. I will bet you ANY amount of money that a former CFI will recognizge when a CA is about to fly them into the dirt before one of your 500 hour wonder kids.
They also have less trouble speaking up about somebody elses flying than 500 hour wonder new hires... and don't try to say otherwise, because we've seen it. Work in the industry long enough, and you'll be able to look back and see how wrong your posting really was.
Reply
Old 06-26-2011 | 03:40 PM
  #133  
Are we there yet??!!
 
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 2,010
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by saab2000
There WILL be a need for pilots in this country in great numbers over the next 10 years and the traditional path of instructing, flying Barons at night, etc. will not produce the thousands of pilots needed.
I have heard that same crap since I started flying in the mid 80s.
There never has been a shortage and everytime there looks like one might be a possible shortage few yrs away, some black swan event happens. The only shortage in this country is of people willing to work for crap wages.

I have said it before and I 'll say it again. 1500 hrs used to be the defacto hiring minimum. Now the mins went down for a little while and the newbies scream about how unfair it is now that there is going to be a mandated minimum. Sheez.
Reply
Old 06-26-2011 | 03:42 PM
  #134  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 2,168
Likes: 0
From: Reclined
Default

Originally Posted by Celeste
I'm not against the 1500 hour/atp rule per se, but my question is, how are newer pilots supposed to get there? (I know I’ll get a lot of snide remarks to instruct, banner tow, etc, etc.) But hours are even harder to get then they were several years ago. The number of students has dropped drastically, and other non-instructing time building options have dried up with increasing fuel prices. Example: I don’t know how many pilots have told me to go fly checks to build time -well they don’t fly bank checks anymore that’s all electronic.
your posting makes it painfully obvious to anybody in this profession that you haven't even botherd to look for any jobs. AEPS, climbto350, and tons of other places list unfilled job after unfilled job....

You're correct, there are less pilots than a few years ago... and perhaps a few less jobs, but most places are starving to find pilots. The 135 guys can't get pilots because the airlines are allowed to hire ink wet new kids, while they are required to hire people with at least some experience.

It's not a snide remark to make the observation that you really aren't interested in anythign else but an airline job, or you wouldn't have made the comment about there being no jobs, becuase there are more jobs than there are pilots.

Originally Posted by Celeste
In adddition to the declining number of students, cfi wages are worse than they were in the past –a lot of places pay only $10-15, even as low as $7 or 8. I like instructing and don’t have a problem with doing that, but I’m lucky if I get 30 or 35 hours in a month at $17/hr (sadly that is a decent cfi wage these days) and after working a second job been taking home less than $1000 per month. Living on that is simply not sustainable. I’m not sure if it is financially possible to get to 1500 hours, and then probably instructing until at least 2000-2500+ hours to get the 500 XC for the ATP, AND then shelling out a few more thousand to rent a plane and pay a DPE to actually get the ATP cert. Bannertowing and diver driving could help build TT faster, but will not help with the 500 XC which will be harder to get than getting to the 1500 hour TT point.
Make your own business card, place a few ads on barnstormers and AOPA and get yourself some quality students. Visit a busier airport and slip your card in the door of all the twin's offering BFR and IPC's. Oh, one last thing - which also shows how little you actualy looked into the field - you would be surprised how far banner tow pilots take those things. One NJ are operator I know of goes from NY to Cape May NJ with fuel stops throughout the day at various airports.

stop whining, and start learning.
Reply
Old 06-26-2011 | 03:51 PM
  #135  
Line Holder
 
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 1,015
Likes: 27
From: 737 CA
Default

I don't really care whether the number is 1000, 1500, 2000, whatever, but as a relative new hire (who had just a bit over 1500), I don't think instructing alone is the best way to get there.

I learned considerably more about airline style flying from 135 than I did from instructing. I would hope people would instruct to get their 135 mins then find a 135 job...it's valuable experience and the best bet for multi time.

Just my opinion of course, and I'm sure somebody will jump all over me for not treating instructing like the holy grail.
Reply
Old 06-26-2011 | 06:57 PM
  #136  
PilotJ3's Avatar
Gets Weekends Off
15 Years
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,870
Likes: 117
Default

Originally Posted by DirectTo
I don't really care whether the number is 1000, 1500, 2000, whatever, but as a relative new hire (who had just a bit over 1500), I don't think instructing alone is the best way to get there.

I learned considerably more about airline style flying from 135 than I did from instructing. I would hope people would instruct to get their 135 mins then find a 135 job...it's valuable experience and the best bet for multi time.

Just my opinion of course, and I'm sure somebody will jump all over me for not treating instructing like the holy grail.
I used to fly 135, flight instructing (same place) and fly banners in other place. I also had two students with their own plane.

As you said, flying 135 made me a better pilot, because you don't always fly in the best of weather. (Like CFIing a Student Pilot, which is only VFR and if is raining you just don't go). Also you are the one responsible for the whole operation. Going to fly without the tanks all the way filled.

Young people want to have a great job without working hard. That's the main problem. Because with that in mind they'll take whatever job to make TT, lowering the overall payment, doing it for free or even paying to get a job. For me, that's unacceptable!!!!!
Reply
Old 06-27-2011 | 12:31 AM
  #137  
FlyJSH's Avatar
Day puke
 
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 3,865
Likes: 0
From: Out.
Default

Originally Posted by PilotJ3
I used to fly 135, flight instructing (same place) and fly banners in other place. I also had two students with their own plane.

As you said, flying 135 made me a better pilot, because you don't always fly in the best of weather. (Like CFIing a Student Pilot, which is only VFR and if is raining you just don't go). Also you are the one responsible for the whole operation. Going to fly without the tanks all the way filled.

Young people want to have a great job without working hard. That's the main problem. Because with that in mind they'll take whatever job to make TT, lowering the overall payment, doing it for free or even paying to get a job. For me, that's unacceptable!!!!!


Absolutely true! Add to that the FNG with 500 hours may not have the backbone to challenge a CA when things so south.

The toughest job is an FO because he needs to stand tall even if it puts his job at risk.
Reply
Old 06-27-2011 | 01:02 AM
  #138  
Gets Weekend Reserve
 
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 4,277
Likes: 273
From: B737CA
Default

Originally Posted by Hacker15e
What business plan at which regional would support that kind of pay?
It's not the question of business plan. It's the question of mentality. As long as pilots view those hours in their logbook as "compensation", Roger Cohen can keep getting that fake tan and regular Botox shots.

Airlines could and do adjust... when they have to. They had to adjust with the rising fuel cost. You don't think they'd adjust if they simply couldn't recruit any more people for wages they're paying? Why do you think wages at foreign airlines keep going up?
Reply
Old 06-27-2011 | 02:10 AM
  #139  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 481
Likes: 0
From: CFI/II/MEI
Default

Originally Posted by DirectTo
I learned considerably more about airline style flying from 135 than I did from instructing. I would hope people would instruct to get their 135 mins then find a 135 job...it's valuable experience and the best bet for multi time.
I have to agree. Not to belittle instructing- I have learned a ton from the instructing I've done so far, but the little bit of 135 flying I've gotten to do has been a huge learning experience. Its a different kind of flying than what I've done in training and in CFIing, all different types of wx, busy airports, more complex planes, etc. I imagine it is a lot closer to what I'll be doing at the airlines when I eventually get there. My 135 flying is nowhere near a full-time gig, but I'm vary fortunate to have this opportunity at this point in my career.

So much in the 135 world is based on connections and networking and not everyone is who is qualified is going to end up with these jobs. I have a feeling (I can't predict the future, but this is my guess) when the ATP rule goes into effect the 135 opportunities are going to be a lot harder to come by. Pilots are going to need them to build TT and especially that 500 cross country. The 135 job postings looking for pilots with type-ratings, ATPs, x amount of PIC turbine or time in type, etc will always be there. But the outfits who are willing to hire the 1,200 hour guys without previous turbine experience and relatively low multi-time are going to be flooded with applications when the airlines suddenly cannot hire these people. It will be another case of a too many qualified pilots lining up to fill a limited number of slots.

Originally Posted by PilotJ3
Young people want to have a great job without working hard. That's the main problem. Because with that in mind they'll take whatever job to make TT, lowering the overall payment, doing it for free or even paying to get a job. For me, that's unacceptable!!!!!
IMO, there are a lot of people working very hard for slave wages, just no other options to break into the industry. CFI wages have pretty much stagnated, many pilots I talk to were making the same or more 10-15 years ago than what is offered now. I'm always looking for jobs with more pay and hours, but my search isn't yielding any better results. One place offered me a CFI job for only $8.50/hour, and a couple others that paid slightly more but had no guarantee of students (still would have to go out and find my own students) and I can't afford to relocate for uncertain pay/hours. A banner towing offer required that I paid them $4500 up front for training and offered abysmal pay. I'm against 'buying' a job.

It gets tricky is in situations like my 135 flying gig. They have several salaried pilots and the charter business is slow. When I get the opportunity to fly it is because one of the pilots wants to 'sit out' that flight for some reason, maybe they want the weekend off, or don't want to be away from the family overnight, and they feel like they are doing me a favor by giving me their flight time. In the FBO's eyes they have already paid for the pilot's salaries, and all they are willing to pay me is my lineservice wage. It is the only source of multi time in the area; no schools with multis, not many based on the field. By taking up 135 trips, I can build multi time that I would otherwise have to pay for (that is like buying a job), and keeps from having to go out and rent a multi to stay current. Definitely not ideal situation, but I'm networking and applying and not getting any better options atm.
Reply
Old 06-27-2011 | 02:38 AM
  #140  
PilotJ3's Avatar
Gets Weekends Off
15 Years
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 3,870
Likes: 117
Default

Originally Posted by DirectTo
I learned considerably more about airline style flying from 135 than I did from instructing. I would hope people would instruct to get their 135 mins then find a 135 job...it's valuable experience and the best bet for multi time.
I have to agree. Not to belittle instructing- I have learned a ton from the instructing I've done so far, but the little bit of 135 flying I've gotten to do has been a huge learning experience. Its a different kind of flying than what I've done in training and in CFIing, all different types of wx, busy airports, more complex planes, etc. I imagine it is a lot closer to what I'll be doing at the airlines when I eventually get there. My 135 flying is nowhere near a full-time gig, but I'm vary fortunate to have this opportunity at this point in my career.

So much in the 135 world is based on connections and networking and not everyone is who is qualified is going to end up with these jobs. I have a feeling (I can't predict the future, but this is my guess) when the ATP rule goes into effect the 135 opportunities are going to be a lot harder to come by. Pilots are going to need them to build TT and especially that 500 cross country. The 135 job postings looking for pilots with type-ratings, ATPs, x amount of PIC turbine or time in type, etc will always be there. But the outfits who are willing to hire the 1,200 hour guys without previous turbine experience and relatively low multi-time are going to be flooded with applications when the airlines suddenly cannot hire these people. It will be another case of a too many qualified pilots lining up to fill a limited number of slots.

Originally Posted by PilotJ3
Young people want to have a great job without working hard. That's the main problem. Because with that in mind they'll take whatever job to make TT, lowering the overall payment, doing it for free or even paying to get a job. For me, that's unacceptable!!!!!
IMO, there are a lot of people working very hard for slave wages, just no other options to break into the industry. CFI wages have pretty much stagnated, many pilots I talk to were making the same or more 10-15 years ago than what is offered now. I'm always looking for jobs with more pay and hours, but my search isn't yielding any better results. One place offered me a CFI job for only $8.50/hour, and a couple others that paid slightly more but had no guarantee of students (still would have to go out and find my own students) and I can't afford to relocate for uncertain pay/hours. A banner towing offer required that I paid them $4500 up front for training and offered abysmal pay. I'm against 'buying' a job.

It gets tricky is in situations like my 135 flying gig. They have several salaried pilots and the charter business is slow. When I get the opportunity to fly it is because one of the pilots wants to 'sit out' that flight for some reason, maybe they want the weekend off, or don't want to be away from the family overnight, and they feel like they are doing me a favor by giving me their flight time. In the FBO's eyes they have already paid for the pilot's salaries, and all they are willing to pay me is my lineservice wage. It is the only source of multi time in the area; no schools with multis, not many based on the field. By taking up 135 trips, I can build multi time that I would otherwise have to pay for (that is like buying a job), and keeps from having to go out and rent a multi to stay current. Definitely not ideal situation, but I'm networking and applying and not getting any better options atm.
I perfectly understand your situation. I'm a MEI and didn't have any students for long time. My ME gig was flying with a friend of mine that have PVT ME and needed a CFII with ME.

Banner gig for 4500 up front??? Not good. I signed a one year contract for training payment.

My 135gig was a VFR 135 in which I practice ILS approach in VFR conditions to stay current. I tried to get hired for 135 IFR, they wanted to hired me after I got the Eagle job. Too late for them because I was trying to get hired for a Year!!!!

So IMO your doing good, just hang there, get your experience (not tt) and when you think you're ready then move up


And guys remember, when airlines are short of pilots, schools get too short of CFIs. You can request more money and if they really needs you they will pay it.
Reply
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
KennyG1700
Flight Schools and Training
40
08-01-2019 12:53 AM
jdr7225
Flight Schools and Training
22
09-13-2011 08:29 AM
duvie
Regional
31
08-03-2009 09:00 AM
Engineer Pilot
Flight Schools and Training
18
07-11-2007 09:56 AM
bqmassey
Flight Schools and Training
4
02-02-2007 05:03 AM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Thread Tools
Search this Thread
Your Privacy Choices