Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   News Report: Comair getting shut down? (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/68953-news-report-comair-getting-shut-down.html)

RedBaron007 07-19-2012 05:26 PM


Originally Posted by N2Core (Post 1232451)
Being owned by or working under DAL has zero benefits. They will slaughter every regional carrier under that umbrella and force thousands of pilot out on the street, or out of the business altogether. But hey, they are getting 717's. So in the creation of those jobs, they've destroyed double at their partners.

Just to remember it in full historical detail, DAL also created the regionals (as we know them today) and moved many jobs from the mainline to the regional level. I'm not saying that justifies abetting putting a brother on the street, but it is something to remember to keep everything in perspective.

It is sickening that any company would be reduced to this, and I sure hope the end isn't as near as everyone thinks. Any pilot group - especially those who have the experience, resolve, and respect that Comair pilots do - doesn't deserve to be treated with less than the utmost respect.

mach80guy 07-19-2012 07:02 PM

I thank you. But after 19 yrs. at this place, it's like having cancer and lying in a bed waiting to die - or better yet - instead of feeling helpless, and worthless, look at it as a new chapter that life throws at you. There is much more to life than living out of a roller board. In fact, the last 8 yrs at OH have been so bad (employee attitudes) , why even bother?

PILOTGUY 07-20-2012 12:13 AM


Originally Posted by RedBaron007 (Post 1232510)
Just to remember it in full historical detail, DAL also created the regionals (as we know them today) and moved many jobs from the mainline to the regional level.

Actually that would be Air Alpes in 1974, who painted their planes in Air France colors.

In the USA, it would be AA who combined American Eagle Airlines and Executive Airlines 1982.

UCLAbruins 07-20-2012 02:47 AM


Originally Posted by mach80guy (Post 1232575)
I thank you. But after 19 yrs. at this place, it's like having cancer and lying in a bed waiting to die - or better yet - instead of feeling helpless, and worthless, look at it as a new chapter that life throws at you. There is much more to life than living out of a roller board. In fact, the last 8 yrs at OH have been so bad (employee attitudes) , why even bother?

and that's the problem for senior guys like your self. You have SO MUCH time invested in this company that you can't just get up and leave.

757upspilot 07-20-2012 05:36 AM


Originally Posted by UCLAbruins (Post 1232642)
and that's the problem for senior guys like your self. You have SO MUCH time invested in this company that you can't just get up and leave.

UPS has many pilots who made the choice to give up years of longevity and seniority at Delta, United , NWA and TWA . If you find yourself on dying horse don't ride it until its in the dirt.

Superpilot92 07-20-2012 05:40 AM


Originally Posted by 757upspilot (Post 1232677)
UPS has many pilots who made the choice to give up years of longevity and seniority at Delta, United , NWA and TWA . If you find yourself on dying horse don't ride it until its in the dirt.

exactly! the problem is alot of these guys "plan" their careers based on 5-10 years when they have 20+ years left....:rolleyes:

200SR20 07-20-2012 05:45 AM


Originally Posted by PILOTGUY (Post 1232632)
Actually that would be Air Alpes in 1974, who painted their planes in Air France colors.

In the USA, it would be AA who combined American Eagle Airlines and Executive Airlines 1982.

Hahaha nothing in Eagles history goes that far back... American Eagle was many carriers back in the day and started merging them in 98 with our current 16yr contract. First "American Eagle Flight" was a metro liner in 84. Eagle and Exec are still separate certificates with one seniority list.

frmrdashtrash 07-20-2012 06:25 AM


Originally Posted by PILOTGUY (Post 1232632)
Actually that would be Air Alpes in 1974, who painted their planes in Air France colors.

In the USA, it would be AA who combined American Eagle Airlines and Executive Airlines 1982.

Piedmont Airlines - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Std Deviation 07-20-2012 10:17 AM


Originally Posted by buddies8 (Post 1232447)
delta forced pinnacle into bk by withholding payments

Witholding payments...seems a familiar strangle tactic:

"United withheld $1.1 million in payments in June and threatens to withhold portions of its July and August payments, he said. Atlantic Coast has turned to the bankruptcy court to compel United to pay money still due under the code-share contract.
Atlantic Coast ends its relationship with United on Aug. 3 when its flies its last flight of that day. At that time, all 87 Bombardier [BBD] CRJ 200s will be devoted to the Independence fleet and all Jetstream 41 turboprops will be retired. By Sept. 1, Independence will have completed its initial launch with 600 daily departures based at Washington Dulles International Airport to 35 destinations."

Bozo 07-20-2012 10:27 AM


Originally Posted by Std Deviation (Post 1232802)
Atlantic Coast ends its relationship with United on Aug. 3 when its flies its last flight of that day. At that time, all 87 Bombardier [BBD] CRJ 200s will be devoted to the Independence fleet and all Jetstream 41 turboprops will be retired. By Sept. 1, Independence will have completed its initial launch with 600 daily departures based at Washington Dulles International Airport to 35 destinations."

Didn't XE try this also? Oh yeah, that's right. They didn't make it on their own either but instead of going into BK they were bought/saved by another airline. ohh missed that bullet.

Erdude32 07-20-2012 10:42 AM

Re-sourcing jobs to mainline= good news for long term career progression for all involved. Hopefully the DCI fleet will be downsized again in 2015. The additional jobs created at mainline DAL combined with upcoming retirements will provide a place for those furloughed to go. Once you get here you will never look back. Not being elitest, snobbish or smug, simply realistic. The regionals were never intended to be a career stop but a stepping stone. The last 10 years this was skewed and got out of proportion. Our TA at mainline has begun to swing the pendulum in the right direction. Hopefully you'll get in at the beginning of the hiring wave. For those of you in the right seat and looking for someplace to go.....do NOT start over at another Regional. Go expat now while the getting is good. Go to India, China or Africa and fly anything from the left seat that will get you turbine pic ASAP. Do it NOW and you'll be back here at a major within 12-18 mos. Your LONG term career aspects gave just improved dramatically, even though things look dire now.

Best of luck to all. You will all survive this and emerge stronger as a result.

blastoff 07-20-2012 11:28 AM


Originally Posted by Bozo (Post 1232808)
Didn't XE try this also? Oh yeah, that's right. They didn't make it on their own either but instead of going into BK they were bought/saved by another airline. ohh missed that bullet.

XE's Branded operation was shut down because Continental wanted those airframes back in their system and threatened to cancel their contract at its expiration and/or hostile takeover to make it happen. No bankruptcy on the radar.

JetBlast77 07-20-2012 12:19 PM


Originally Posted by blastoff (Post 1232845)
XE's Branded operation was shut down because Continental wanted those airframes back in their system and threatened to cancel their contract at its expiration and/or hostile takeover to make it happen. No bankruptcy on the radar.

Load factor average 89% the day the doors closed. So sick of people hating on good companies.

buddies8 07-20-2012 01:32 PM

they are new to the industry or only know what is posted on forums,

blastoff 07-20-2012 02:11 PM


Originally Posted by buddies8 (Post 1232897)
they are new to the industry or only know what is posted on forums,

No, Bozo likes to flame XE.

FlyJSH 07-20-2012 03:04 PM


Originally Posted by 757upspilot (Post 1232677)
UPS has many pilots who made the choice to give up years of longevity and seniority at Delta, United , NWA and TWA . If you find yourself on dying horse don't ride it until its in the dirt.

Would you mind carrying in my resume? I could sure use a reference. :o

I like long walks on the beach and dream of hauling boxes under a moonlit sky!

Embraego 07-20-2012 03:36 PM

John Bendoraitis
Career progression in short:
Northwest Mechanic
Northwest Mechanic with Degree
Northwest Maintenance Manager
Northwest no longer exists
President Compass Airlines
Compass sold to TSA
President Comair
Comair Soon to die
President Frontier Airlines
Frontier for sale-soon to die

He's just that good!

JonnyKnoxville 07-21-2012 05:09 AM


Originally Posted by Erdude32 (Post 1232813)
Re-sourcing jobs to mainline= good news for long term career progression for all involved. Hopefully the DCI fleet will be downsized again in 2015. The additional jobs created at mainline DAL combined with upcoming retirements will provide a place for those furloughed to go. Once you get here you will never look back. Not being elitest, snobbish or smug, simply realistic. The regionals were never intended to be a career stop but a stepping stone. The last 10 years this was skewed and got out of proportion. Our TA at mainline has begun to swing the pendulum in the right direction. Hopefully you'll get in at the beginning of the hiring wave. For those of you in the right seat and looking for someplace to go.....do NOT start over at another Regional. Go expat now while the getting is good. Go to India, China or Africa and fly anything from the left seat that will get you turbine pic ASAP. Do it NOW and you'll be back here at a major within 12-18 mos. Your LONG term career aspects gave just improved dramatically, even though things look dire now.

Best of luck to all. You will all survive this and emerge stronger as a result.

Great Post! Pure class coming from a Delta pilot on a topic that rarely brings out the best in pilots....thank you.

Doug Masters 07-21-2012 08:40 PM


Originally Posted by Erdude32 (Post 1232813)
Re-sourcing jobs to mainline= good news for long term career progression for all involved. Hopefully the DCI fleet will be downsized again in 2015. The additional jobs created at mainline DAL combined with upcoming retirements will provide a place for those furloughed to go. Once you get here you will never look back. Not being elitest, snobbish or smug, simply realistic. The regionals were never intended to be a career stop but a stepping stone. The last 10 years this was skewed and got out of proportion. Our TA at mainline has begun to swing the pendulum in the right direction. Hopefully you'll get in at the beginning of the hiring wave. For those of you in the right seat and looking for someplace to go.....do NOT start over at another Regional. Go expat now while the getting is good. Go to India, China or Africa and fly anything from the left seat that will get you turbine pic ASAP. Do it NOW and you'll be back here at a major within 12-18 mos. Your LONG term career aspects gave just improved dramatically, even though things look dire now.

Best of luck to all. You will all survive this and emerge stronger as a result.

While I'll agree with most of what you say, you gotta remember not all RJ guys are young single dudes that can go expat on a whim. We are talking about people potentially losing jobs that have wives, kids, etc.. I'm all for us reigning in scope but it does affect lives and families.

jrmyl 07-21-2012 09:18 PM


Originally Posted by Doug Masters (Post 1233494)
While I'll agree with most of what you say, you gotta remember not all RJ guys are young single dudes that can go expat on a whim. We are talking about people potentially losing jobs that have wives, kids, etc.. I'm all for us reigning in scope but it does affect lives and families.

So are you saying that all expats are young, single dudes? I am an expat and I see mostly older, experienced, married guys. It really isn't that hard to be an expat. There are commuting contracts that you can get. There are nice places to move your family as well. If your spouse supports your career then it shouldn't be a problem. If the spouse doesn't support your career choice then that is another matter. Mine supports it and the lifestyle it gives her and accepts the 3 weeks away at a time.

All I'm saying is don't rule it out just because you are married.

Saabs 07-21-2012 11:34 PM


Originally Posted by blastoff (Post 1232845)
XE's Branded operation was shut down because Continental wanted those airframes back in their system and threatened to cancel their contract at its expiration and/or hostile takeover to make it happen. No bankruptcy on the radar.

So ur saying in 2007-2008 cal wanted more xr's from expressjet! Cuz I remember xe furloughing

OutsideLookinIn 07-22-2012 12:14 PM


Originally Posted by Erdude32 (Post 1232813)
Re-sourcing jobs to mainline= good news for long term career progression for all involved. Hopefully the DCI fleet will be downsized again in 2015. The additional jobs created at mainline DAL combined with upcoming retirements will provide a place for those furloughed to go. Once you get here you will never look back. Not being elitest, snobbish or smug, simply realistic. The regionals were never intended to be a career stop but a stepping stone. The last 10 years this was skewed and got out of proportion. Our TA at mainline has begun to swing the pendulum in the right direction. Hopefully you'll get in at the beginning of the hiring wave. For those of you in the right seat and looking for someplace to go.....do NOT start over at another Regional. Go expat now while the getting is good. Go to India, China or Africa and fly anything from the left seat that will get you turbine pic ASAP. Do it NOW and you'll be back here at a major within 12-18 mos. Your LONG term career aspects gave just improved dramatically, even though things look dire now.

Best of luck to all. You will all survive this and emerge stronger as a result.

Not so much elitist, snobbish or smug, rather, self-serving.

Hopefully it'll work out better than it did for the Eastern pilots, how many did DAL hire again? Was it three or was it four?

Best of luck to all.

dc10guy 07-22-2012 12:26 PM


Originally Posted by Doug Masters (Post 1233494)
While I'll agree with most of what you say, you gotta remember not all RJ guys are young single dudes that can go expat on a whim. We are talking about people potentially losing jobs that have wives, kids, etc.. I'm all for us reigning in scope but it does affect lives and families.


Yep, been there done that along with alot of other 9-11 furloughed pilots.

Lowlevel 07-22-2012 12:32 PM


Originally Posted by Boomer (Post 1231517)

"Comair was the only airline to operate from Concourse C" - the other only airlines to operate from Concourse C were ASA, Skywest, Shuttle America, and Chautauqua.

You forgot the greatest of all! Freedom Airlines!! Remember how they were kicked from JFK and sent to CVG?

The thing with Comair is....there will be no buyer. I love how some think that there will be a savior that rises and rescues them. It's over Johnny...it's over. No company owned planes, just Delta leased planes. Very senior pilots (since all the lower ones will be gone). Not even a building!! Nobody will make that investment thinking they could turn a former gem, turned turd, back into a gem.

Lowlevel 07-22-2012 12:39 PM


Originally Posted by Erdude32 (Post 1232813)
Re-sourcing jobs to mainline= good news for long term career progression for all involved. Hopefully the DCI fleet will be downsized again in 2015. The additional jobs created at mainline DAL combined with upcoming retirements will provide a place for those furloughed to go. Once you get here you will never look back. Not being elitest, snobbish or smug, simply realistic. The regionals were never intended to be a career stop but a stepping stone. The last 10 years this was skewed and got out of proportion. Our TA at mainline has begun to swing the pendulum in the right direction. Hopefully you'll get in at the beginning of the hiring wave. For those of you in the right seat and looking for someplace to go.....do NOT start over at another Regional. Go expat now while the getting is good. Go to India, China or Africa and fly anything from the left seat that will get you turbine pic ASAP. Do it NOW and you'll be back here at a major within 12-18 mos. Your LONG term career aspects gave just improved dramatically, even though things look dire now.

Best of luck to all. You will all survive this and emerge stronger as a result.

You have to remember the pilot group you are targeting. The older pilots at Comair are not going to go ex-pat. Hell, they stayed at Comair all these years because they didn't even want to leave Cincinnati or commute for their jobs. You think they will go overseas...with only a few years till retirement?

Back in mid-2010, when this "downsizing" was announced, it was estimated that the junior captain would be a 1999 hire. What are the latest thoughts on this?

Junior captain, on reserve, after 13 years?? WOW, sounds like USAirways with lower pay!

makersmarc 07-22-2012 12:47 PM


Originally Posted by dc10guy (Post 1233756)
Yep, been there done that along with alot of other 9-11 furloughed pilots.

I would be curious how many pilots that were furloughed after 9-11 a) were recalled by their employer(s), b) hit the bricks and found a flying job elsewhere or c) left aviation completely. Could be a lesson in there somewhere.

ShyGuy 07-22-2012 01:55 PM


Originally Posted by Lowlevel (Post 1233761)
You have to remember the pilot group you are targeting. The older pilots at Comair are not going to go ex-pat. Hell, they stayed at Comair all these years because they didn't even want to leave Cincinnati or commute for their jobs. You think they will go overseas...with only a few years till retirement?

Back in mid-2010, when this "downsizing" was announced, it was estimated that the junior captain would be a 1999 hire. What are the latest thoughts on this?

Junior captain, on reserve, after 13 years?? WOW, sounds like USAirways with lower pay!

Why not leave in 2006 when the BK and paycuts ensued? You have to pick your battles. Either be willing to leave CVG, or commute to a new job, or stay put at Comair and hope it sticks out til retirement. 2006 was a good time to get hired, and everyone was hiring except American Airlines.

blastoff 07-22-2012 05:44 PM


Originally Posted by Saabs (Post 1233519)
So ur saying in 2007-2008 cal wanted more xr's from expressjet! Cuz I remember xe furloughing

We furloughed 340+. The XR's & some LR's came back to COEX, the E-135's went to the desert. Net loss of 30 + airframes. All but 7 of them are still there.

PILOTGUY 07-23-2012 12:43 AM


Originally Posted by 200SR20 (Post 1232679)
Hahaha nothing in Eagles history goes that far back... American Eagle was many carriers back in the day and started merging them in 98 with our current 16yr contract. First "American Eagle Flight" was a metro liner in 84. Eagle and Exec are still separate certificates with one seniority list.


Originally Posted by frmrdashtrash (Post 1232699)

Not to try and derail this thread on inaccurate histories, but "Code sharing" is not a mainline airline using a smaller airline, with smaller planes, as regional lift.

OceanicPilot 07-23-2012 04:24 AM


Originally Posted by Doug Masters (Post 1233494)
While I'll agree with most of what you say, you gotta remember not all RJ guys are young single dudes that can go expat on a whim. We are talking about people potentially losing jobs that have wives, kids, etc.. I'm all for us reigning in scope but it does affect lives and families.


It all comes down to the families themselves but I personally have been an expat in China with my lovely wife and two young daughters for four years. Next month we are all moving to Qatar as a family unit to pursue another great flying job where my skills will be well compensated. If you have a wife (or a husband) that's open to a life changing experience it can be a great option. I understand not everyone can see the benefit or is willing to make the adjustment for one reason or another. Best of luck to all the Comair pilots and any other furloughed pilot at any airline.

Oh, and don't assume that you're significant other will just say "no" if you bring up a move overseas and so you never bring it up. I did and then when I mentioned it in jest she surprised me and said, "Let's do it."
You never know what you are capable of until you try.

MunkyButtr 07-23-2012 11:28 AM


Originally Posted by Lowlevel (Post 1233761)
You have to remember the pilot group you are targeting. The older pilots at Comair are not going to go ex-pat. Hell, they stayed at Comair all these years because they didn't even want to leave Cincinnati or commute for their jobs. You think they will go overseas...with only a few years till retirement?

Back in mid-2010, when this "downsizing" was announced, it was estimated that the junior captain would be a 1999 hire. What are the latest thoughts on this?

Junior captain, on reserve, after 13 years?? WOW, sounds like USAirways with lower pay!

Im pretty sure the 1999 would be the plug's doh when the 50's were parked.

Lowlevel 07-23-2012 12:35 PM


Originally Posted by ShyGuy (Post 1233791)
Why not leave in 2006 when the BK and paycuts ensued? You have to pick your battles. Either be willing to leave CVG, or commute to a new job, or stay put at Comair and hope it sticks out til retirement. 2006 was a good time to get hired, and everyone was hiring except American Airlines.

Because BK and paycuts is not a cut down to 44 aircraft (or maybe less now). Back in 2010, Comair said by year end 2012 only 44 planes...which is roughly 440 pilots. At the time, there were around 1100-1200 pilots. If that didn't make you leave...I don't know what would.

PeezDog 07-23-2012 12:56 PM

If there's not a flying job here in the US, then I quit. This job is not worth turning yourself into a nomad just to find a decent job. While the US has lots of issues, I'm not about to go to the middle east, or any where else for that matter, just to build time. I will not chase flying jobs around the globe. I'd rather do something else in that case. Just my 2 cents

Peez

8hourrule 07-23-2012 01:06 PM


Originally Posted by PeezDog (Post 1234210)
If there's not a flying job here in the US, then I quit. This job is not worth turning yourself into a nomad just to find a decent job. While the US has lots of issues, I'm not about to go to the middle east, or any where else for that matter, just to build time. I will not chase flying jobs around the globe. I'd rather do something else in that case. Just my 2 cents

Peez

that's a big +1.

cvg4now 07-23-2012 01:35 PM


Originally Posted by PeezDog (Post 1234210)
If there's not a flying job here in the US, then I quit. This job is not worth turning yourself into a nomad just to find a decent job. While the US has lots of issues, I'm not about to go to the middle east, or any where else for that matter, just to build time. I will not chase flying jobs around the globe. I'd rather do something else in that case. Just my 2 cents

Peez

Very well said, my thoughts exactly!

Boomer 07-23-2012 04:06 PM


Originally Posted by MunkyButtr (Post 1234160)
Im pretty sure the 1999 would be the plug's doh when the 50's were parked.

Close, I think early 98 got to stay in the left seat in the 50. It's 91 or 92 to hold Captain in the 70.
Don't we still have some 50s to park? Or are we already at 16?

9easy 07-23-2012 05:18 PM

Hard to fathom that plenty of pilots at 9E, OO, RP, have gone on to fruitful careers at fedex, virgin, emirates, spirit, jetblue, atlas, and were barely in high school when most of the current comair pilots were hired..

DoubleD 07-23-2012 05:46 PM

It's not hard to fathom why senior pilots have stayed on at OH.
After the strike life was good at OH. When I was hired in '03 it was touted as "A place you can stay". Life was very good for those senior. Pay for those most senior was about upper 90's or so, retirement, excellent pass benefits, and because of PBS they bid what fit their personal needs and some were living the dream.
I flew with some who were content and had no desire to leave. Some Capt's I flew with saw OH as a means to an end and some saw it as an end.
Hopefully things do not close up at OH but if they make it out of this drama this should be a strong wake up call to move on to the majors and not be picky about where you go.

ShyGuy 07-24-2012 01:02 PM


Originally Posted by DoubleD (Post 1234343)
It's not hard to fathom why senior pilots have stayed on at OH.
After the strike life was good at OH. When I was hired in '03 it was touted as "A place you can stay". Life was very good for those senior. Pay for those most senior was about upper 90's or so, retirement, excellent pass benefits, and because of PBS they bid what fit their personal needs and some were living the dream.
I flew with some who were content and had no desire to leave. Some Capt's I flew with saw OH as a means to an end and some saw it as an end.
Hopefully things do not close up at OH but if they make it out of this drama this should be a strong wake up call to move on to the majors and not be picky about where you go.

Sounds like drinking the KoolAid instead of focusing on where a regional makes its living: feeding a major airline, with contracted flying. That feed and contract can and will be eliminated at the whim of the major airline partner. You'd bet your career on that? I wouldn't.

Geardownflaps30 07-24-2012 01:13 PM


Originally Posted by ShyGuy (Post 1234682)
Sounds like drinking the KoolAid instead of focusing on where a regional makes its living: feeding a major airline, with contracted flying. That feed and contract can and will be eliminated at the whim of the major airline partner. You'd bet your career on that? I wouldn't.

There was a time when being a "wholly owned subsidiary" meant something different than being a "contract carrier". Perhaps you
are too young or lacking in vocational experience to remember...

Many of you forget that this consolidation/shifting of flying amongst regional carriers has been ongoing for >10 yrs. Some of us that were caught up in the first rounds moved to a wholly owned for what was supposed to be stability. Many forget that there was a time where getting hired at a wholly owned was perceived to having attained the "Holy Grail" of regional jobs. But as I've said, many of you on these boards have been in this industry for too short of time to remember. It is shocking how many have not heard and do not know the history and likes of former regional carriers such as Skyway, Chicago Express, Atlantic Coast, etc to name but a few.

I agree that today though, it is virtually meaningless.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:21 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands