Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   News Report: Comair getting shut down? (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/68953-news-report-comair-getting-shut-down.html)

evilboy 07-24-2012 01:19 PM


Originally Posted by ShyGuy (Post 1234682)
Sounds like drinking the KoolAid instead of focusing on where a regional makes its living: feeding a major airline, with contracted flying. That feed and contract can and will be eliminated at the whim of the major airline partner. You'd bet your career on that? I wouldn't.

Guy, OH was largest privately owned "Regional" carrier in the world before DL bought it (still not sure why) and screwed it up. It WAS a place to work and retire from. You'd surprised how many pilots retired from there after 15, 20, 25+ years in the line. It wrote its own ticket (per say) for a very long time, and was bigger than lots of the majors of this time (Airtran, Spirit, and I believe Jetblue). And at one time was hellbent on moving on up (to the east side) to "major" status by buying bigger aircrafts (757, 737 and others), and join the fray against the DL, US, AA, etc in this country. Btw, I believe after the purchase, there were 10-15 of the DL MD-88 that were fully purchased with OH assets (money) and for some years flew under the Comair Holdings registration. I jumpsat in a couple of those and got a kick by seeing the registration.
Please research it.....bet you it will surprise you.

PerpetualFlyer 07-24-2012 01:38 PM


Originally Posted by evilboy (Post 1234693)
Guy, OH was largest privately owned "Regional" carrier in the world before DL bought it (still not sure why) and screwed it up. It WAS a place to work and retire from. You'd surprised how many pilots retired from there after 15, 20, 25+ years in the line. It wrote its own ticket (per say) for a very long time, and was bigger than lots of the majors of this time (Airtran, Spirit, and I believe Jetblue). And at one time was hellbent on moving on up (to the east side) to "major" status by buying bigger aircrafts (757, 737 and others), and join the fray against the DL, US, AA, etc in this country. Btw, I believe after the purchase, there were 10-15 of the DL MD-88 that were fully purchased with OH assets (money) and for some years flew under the Comair Holdings registration. I jumpsat in a couple of those and got a kick by seeing the registration.
Please research it.....bet you it will surprise you.

Nothing surprises "Shy the all-knowing".

ShyGuy 07-24-2012 02:31 PM


Originally Posted by Geardownflaps30 (Post 1234691)
There was a time when being a "wholly owned subsidiary" meant something different than being a "contract carrier". Perhaps you
are too young or lacking in vocational experience to remember...

Many of you forget that this consolidation/shifting of flying amongst regional carriers has been ongoing for >10 yrs. Some of us that were caught up in the first rounds moved to a wholly owned for what was supposed to be stability. Many forget that there was a time where getting hired at a wholly owned was perceived to having attained the "Holy Grail" of regional jobs. But as I've said, many of you on these boards have been in this industry for too short of time to remember. It is shocking how many have not heard and do not know the history and likes of former regional carriers such as Skyway, Chicago Express, Atlantic Coast, etc to name but a few.

I agree that today though, it is virtually meaningless.

How do you get stability in a wholly-owned? That's probably the worst model, because the major partner can cut flying, park fleets, or outsource to another regional in an instant. How does that help?


Guy, OH was largest privately owned "Regional" carrier in the world before DL bought it (still not sure why) and screwed it up. It WAS a place to work and retire from. You'd surprised how many pilots retired from there after 15, 20, 25+ years in the line. It wrote its own ticket (per say) for a very long time, and was bigger than lots of the majors of this time (Airtran, Spirit, and I believe Jetblue). And at one time was hellbent on moving on up (to the east side) to "major" status by buying bigger aircrafts (757, 737 and others), and join the fray against the DL, US, AA, etc in this country. Btw, I believe after the purchase, there were 10-15 of the DL MD-88 that were fully purchased with OH assets (money) and for some years flew under the Comair Holdings registration. I jumpsat in a couple of those and got a kick by seeing the registration.
Please research it.....bet you it will surprise you.
Air Wisconsin was the oldest privately held regional airline until United screwed it up. Same story, 15, 20, 25+ year guys in the line. Now they're down to 70 CRJs with all senior pilots being forced a two leg commute from ATW to PHL/DCA.


Btw, I believe after the purchase, there were 10-15 of the DL MD-88 that were fully purchased with OH assets (money) and for some years flew under the Comair Holdings registration.
After the purchase, it's all Delta's money. On paper they can show whatever they want. Sure Comair probably made them money back then. And sure some of that money was funneled for purchasing MD80s, and even registered in Comair holdings. However, being wholly owned means wholly owned. Delta can show whatever profit or loss it wants, just as AMR has been doing at Eagle for years.

DoubleD 07-24-2012 03:25 PM

Shy,

We all have the advantage of hindsight now. As to why people would stay some reasons were given. It was a case of perception. Being junior, I moved on as soon as I could. I'm sure the senior people now are not at all happy with the present situation not just their personal situation but also Comair's too. They held out hope that things would recover as OH went through NG2,3,4 and whatever they are up to now.
I was recently in Narita with some UA and CO guys. They also spoke of how trhings had changed for them in ways they would have never dreamed in their worst dreams (regarding the last 15years). It's not just OH that has hit a wall, the difference is, as you mention, being wholly owned they are at the owning airlines mercy in the race to the bottom that is not a good place to be.
One thing posters fail to mention is the great people who are at OH and their families. Hopefully DL pulls a "just kidding" and lets the good people continue.

ASAnotASAP 07-24-2012 03:25 PM

Heard from a reliable source on Virginia Ave that all CRJ-200 flying will end on 9/4 and the rest will be wound down by the 28th.

Spoilers 07-24-2012 04:02 PM

Except an announcement Friday.

Geardownflaps30 07-24-2012 04:18 PM


Originally Posted by Spoilers (Post 1234749)
Except an announcement Friday.

Source please.

evilboy 07-24-2012 04:26 PM


Originally Posted by Spoilers (Post 1234749)
Except an announcement Friday.


Hey Spoils, been a while my friend. Hope you're well. Anyhow, yes they do like to hand out bad news the friday before a big date. Very sad.

Pilotguy143 07-24-2012 04:36 PM

How "firm" is the Friday announcement?

MunkyButtr 07-24-2012 05:47 PM


Originally Posted by Pilotguy143 (Post 1234765)
How "firm" is the Friday announcement?

Depends, is she over 40?

JustAMushroom 07-24-2012 06:11 PM


Originally Posted by ASAnotASAP (Post 1234738)
Heard from a reliable source on Virginia Ave that all CRJ-200 flying will end on 9/4 and the rest will be wound down by the 28th.

Damn... I sure hope this isn't correct. I've been treated well by many OH folks over the years. This would not be a fitting end, after all the years of service they gave to Mother D.

Geardownflaps30 07-24-2012 06:40 PM


Originally Posted by JustAMushroom (Post 1234815)
Damn... I sure hope this isn't correct. I've been treated well by many OH folks over the years. This would not be a fitting end, after all the years of service they gave to Mother D.

Untrue. Fearmongering. Carry on.

9easy 07-24-2012 06:44 PM

Delta made a lot of updates to the GDS this weekend, and I can still find comair flights into 2013... not to mention, it would take some prior planning and announcements to transfer their current fleet to another airline, as well as legal obligations to warn pilots of impending furlough. Does not seem likely Delta has made any final decisions yet.

evilboy 07-24-2012 06:51 PM


Originally Posted by 9easy (Post 1234839)
Delta made a lot of updates to the GDS this weekend, and I can still find comair flights into 2013... not to mention, it would take some prior planning and announcements to transfer their current fleet to another airline, as well as legal obligations to warn pilots of impending furlough. Does not seem likely Delta has made any final decisions yet.


As much as I'd like to think you're right, it's only a 30 days notice for furloughs, and same amount of time to increase/decrease flight schedules for other companies. So if they have something in mind, 30 days is all they need.

GrUpGrDn 07-24-2012 07:06 PM

As per the contract, 14 days written notice prior to the furlough.

Geardownflaps30 07-24-2012 07:17 PM


Originally Posted by evilboy (Post 1234845)
As much as I'd like to think you're right, it's only a 30 days notice for furloughs, and same amount of time to increase/decrease flight schedules for other companies. So if they have something in mind, 30 days is all they need.

Yeah. 30 days to staff 28+ aircraft. Righttttt....

FlyingKat 07-24-2012 07:22 PM


Originally Posted by Geardownflaps30 (Post 1234856)
Yeah. 30 days to staff 28+ aircraft. Righttttt....


Delta always pulls flying down for the Fall, and supposedly Gojet is overstaffed right now.....

We'll see what happens. Hope all these rumors are untrue....

9easy 07-24-2012 07:39 PM


Originally Posted by GrUpGrDn (Post 1234855)
As per the contract, 14 days written notice prior to the furlough.

Aren't they required to give WARN notices 60 days in advance?

http://www.doleta.gov/programs/factsht/warn.htm

GrUpGrDn 07-24-2012 08:37 PM

Was not aware of that. Thanks, I was just quoting per our contract of any furloughs. I would think if OH ceases operations, then it would be covered under WARN.

DrivinTheDash 07-24-2012 09:07 PM


Originally Posted by ASAnotASAP (Post 1234738)
Heard from a reliable source on Virginia Ave that all CRJ-200 flying will end on 9/4 and the rest will be wound down by the 28th.


Originally Posted by 9easy (Post 1234870)
Aren't they required to give WARN notices 60 days in advance?

Fact Sheet - The Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act

Announcement this Friday (7/27) would allow for 63 days notice if a shutdown was, in fact, planned for 9/28.

Av8rking 07-24-2012 09:25 PM

Believe what you want. About 5 weeks ago, I too heard 7/27 as "the announcement" from a very reliable source. And this was just before that painful memo came out. And no, I will not post my source on an anonymous forum. I truely hope something has changed recently to prevent this. I have only love and hope for my former Comair peeps! :(

P.S. Doesn't it seem odd that this memo came out just days after the passage of the Delta TA that includes a large reduction in overall DCI flying?

What 07-25-2012 02:09 AM


Originally Posted by 9easy (Post 1234870)
Aren't they required to give WARN notices 60 days in advance?

Fact Sheet - The Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act

They are required to give you the WARN notice, like someone said a few posts ago they will likely hand them out Friday if what most dates that are being said are true. We got ours at Eagle after they filled BK and we set to closed the DFW ATR base, hope all works out for you guy and I am sorry to hear that this will happen to you guys/gals.

skywatch 07-25-2012 04:06 AM


Originally Posted by Geardownflaps30 (Post 1234856)
Yeah. 30 days to staff 28+ aircraft. Righttttt....

28+ aircraft, of which you don't want to fly all of them and plan to park some/most...and spread out among what, 4-5 airlines...right?

amcnd 07-25-2012 04:43 AM


Originally Posted by skywatch (Post 1234941)
28+ aircraft, of which you don't want to fly all of them and plan to park some/most...and spread out among what, 4-5 airlines...right?

I would say over 2-3 airlines, and they would drop 200's so it would end up as = staffing.. My thinking would be....If Comair was going to be around long term, they would have countered the bad pess about getting shutdown..

Geardownflaps30 07-25-2012 05:32 AM


Originally Posted by amcnd (Post 1234955)
I would say over 2-3 airlines, and they would drop 200's so it would end up as = staffing.. My thinking would be....If Comair was going to be around long term, they would have countered the bad pess about getting shutdown..

Once again. You forget the fact that Comair is in contract negotiations with all THREE UNIONS SIMULTANEOUSLY! A company NEVER counters bad press at this time and in fact may encourage it.

evilboy 07-25-2012 06:30 AM


Originally Posted by Geardownflaps30 (Post 1234966)
Once again. You forget the fact that Comair is in contract negotiations with all THREE UNIONS SIMULTANEOUSLY! A company NEVER counters bad press at this time and in fact may encourage it.

As you can tell, everybody else has countered point your claims (btw it is only required 30 days notice to DOT to change an ENTIRE schedule, never the less one that might be spread about different airlines). However this statement is probably the smartest you have made about this situation. Yes it is a small possibility to use the bad press and info circulating as a contract negotiation point. Yet my question would be (if i were an union negotiator), "why would I be affraid of those rumors if you (mgmt) is still negotiating for a new contract?. What's the point if you (mgmt) are going to closes us down?".
Anyhow, truly hope you're correct about that.

Geardownflaps30 07-25-2012 07:09 AM


Originally Posted by evilboy (Post 1235000)
As you can tell, everybody else has countered point your claims (btw it is only required 30 days notice to DOT to change an ENTIRE schedule, never the less one that might be spread about different airlines). However this statement is probably the smartest you have made about this situation. Yes it is a small possibility to use the bad press and info circulating as a contract negotiation point. Yet my question would be (if i were an union negotiator), "why would I be affraid of those rumors if you (mgmt) is still negotiating for a new contract?. What's the point if you (mgmt) are going to closes us down?".
Anyhow, truly hope you're correct about that.

The point is to instill fear and intimidate the rank and file into accepting and voting in a new contract with even greater cuts.

8hourrule 07-25-2012 07:19 AM


Originally Posted by Geardownflaps30 (Post 1235025)

Originally Posted by evilboy (Post 1235000)
As you can tell, everybody else has countered point your claims (btw it is only required 30 days notice to DOT to change an ENTIRE schedule, never the less one that might be spread about different airlines). However this statement is probably the smartest you have made about this situation. Yes it is a small possibility to use the bad press and info circulating as a contract negotiation point. Yet my question would be (if i were an union negotiator), "why would I be affraid of those rumors if you (mgmt) is still negotiating for a new contract?. What's the point if you (mgmt) are going to closes us down?".
Anyhow, truly hope you're correct about that.

The point is to instill fear and intimidate the rank and file into accepting and voting in a new contract with even greater cuts.

optimistic at best. Delusional at worst.

Bozo 07-25-2012 07:20 AM


Originally Posted by Av8rking (Post 1234904)
Believe what you want. About 5 weeks ago, I too heard 7/27 as "the announcement" from a very reliable source. And this was just before that painful memo came out. And no, I will not post my source on an anonymous forum. I truely hope something has changed recently to prevent this. I have only love and hope for my former Comair peeps! :(

P.S. Doesn't it seem odd that this memo came out just days after the passage of the Delta TA that includes a large reduction in overall DCI flying?

Bulletin "400" will be loaded on 07/28/2012 with many changes.

makersmarc 07-25-2012 07:52 AM

From what I understand, two of three unions have proposals before the company. The IBT has not as far as I know.

I still think that Delta's intention is to shut us down; though I am sure they would love to get a very favorable contract from pilots, what pilots do means nothing if the others don't play ball.

Here's how I would handicap this: 65% chance we are shut down outright. 20% chance of some sort of hybrid arrangement that calls for some airplanes/crews to go elsewhere. 15% chance of new contract with drastically low rates (lower than gojets) and hope for expansion.

Of course, Comair could merely be a stalking horse to used in negotiations with Pinnacle.

BE19Pilot 07-25-2012 08:11 AM

COMAIR is in it's situation simply because they cost too much to operate the types of equipment they fly and the amount of revenue the operation generates for "Big D". Bottom-line is "meat in the seat" (pilots) as cheaply as possible. Customer service that was once legendary at Delta has taken a backseat to profitability and cost reduction.

Spoilers 07-25-2012 08:47 AM


Originally Posted by Geardownflaps30 (Post 1234752)
Source please.

Don't worry about my source. From what I've been told there's a meeting scheduled between DL/OH mgmt tomorrow night, with some sort of press release Friday.

Bozo 07-25-2012 09:19 AM


Originally Posted by makersmarc (Post 1235048)
From what I understand, two of three unions have proposals before the company. The IBT has not as far as I know.

I still think that Delta's intention is to shut us down; though I am sure they would love to get a very favorable contract from pilots, what pilots do means nothing if the others don't play ball.

Here's how I would handicap this: 65% chance we are shut down outright. 20% chance of some sort of hybrid arrangement that calls for some airplanes/crews to go elsewhere. 15% chance of new contract with drastically low rates (lower than gojets) and hope for expansion.

Of course, Comair could merely be a stalking horse to used in negotiations with Pinnacle.

I hope for the best but if you look at the sch. to be posted on 07/28/2012 and break it down to specific city pairs a long with the specific departure time.....it doesn't look good.

makersmarc 07-25-2012 10:47 AM

You know what we will all feel Friday? Relief. No matter what happens, we will feel relief. Unless of course Delta kicks the can down the road again....

SuperPilotJesse 07-25-2012 12:50 PM

My question is: what will happen to my flight benefits that were set to expire OCT 2013? Five years after furlough?

Please say extended.

mosquito 07-25-2012 01:05 PM


Originally Posted by SuperPilotJesse (Post 1235212)
My question is: what will happen to my flight benefits that were set to expire OCT 2013? Five years after furlough?

Please say extended.

I was wondering the same

GrUpGrDn 07-25-2012 01:10 PM

I would imagine since ops would cease, active pilots would be terminated, not furloughed, and all benefits would not exist. However I wonder about COBRA, since it is partial employer and employee paid now. Please correct me if I am wrong.

B317 07-25-2012 01:36 PM

If Comair shuts down all Pass Benifits will cease no mater if you're retired, took a buyout or got furloughed. We have never been employed by Delta. This came right from the Pass department.

andreas500 07-25-2012 02:55 PM

nevermind.....

BitterOHFO 07-26-2012 10:41 AM

I wonder if the almighty PresBo had a talk with Richard about putting 3000 more people on the street during an election year? Not going to help his job numbers!

Maybe we have a snowball's chance in hell that we will survive!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:29 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands