Comair to be shut down 9/29
#74
Can't abide NAI
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 12,078
Likes: 15
From: Douglas Aerospace post production Flight Test & Work Around Engineering bulletin dissembler
Delta management was very clear they were going to reduce 50 seat flying either with, or without, the Delta pilots. The difference the Delta pilots made was allowing MORE next generation 76 seat jets, which were not allowed in the Joint Pilot Working Agreement. Facilitating the "trade" would expedite a swap into more economically viable equipment. Back channel (unconfirmed) rumor was that the DAL MEC had informally counselled Comair's MEC to bid for the new flying to come.
It appears plan A was to renegotiate with SkyWest. SkyWest refused.
Look; Comair is a Delta asset. No one is pleased to see a part of our Company mismanaged into liquidation. No one is happy to see our management (from Northwest) take this action. There is no reason to believe they view us any differently. It is just that our circumstance is different today.
In case you have not been following our news, our SkyTeam "partners" are eating us alive just as the pantheon of DCI carriers took work you considered to be "yours." Lesson to all of us, our jobs are only as secure as the scope we negotiate.
#75
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
From: G650 Captain
First, I want to offer my sympathy to all the employees of Comair. Keep your heads high!
While I'm here I'll throw in my 2 cents as well :sigh:
I was a Comair pilot from 96-07 before I finally realized there was no career there. Of course, that was only my opinion.
I think anyone who feels the Delta TA shut down Comair hasn't been watching the same slow motion train wreck that I have been since before I left.
I also believe that anything that creates mainline jobs is good for the pilot groups as a whole.
I'm proud of my Comair heritage and don't wish unemployment on anyone. Comair has always had an outstanding group of pilots, fa's, mechanics, gate agents, dispatchers, and everyone else. Hold you heads high, go get some interviews and don't bash them when they ask about your Comair experience.
I've posted it before but if anyone would like more info on jobs overseas you guys and girls know where to find me.
Good luck and God speed!
While I'm here I'll throw in my 2 cents as well :sigh:
I was a Comair pilot from 96-07 before I finally realized there was no career there. Of course, that was only my opinion.
I think anyone who feels the Delta TA shut down Comair hasn't been watching the same slow motion train wreck that I have been since before I left.
I also believe that anything that creates mainline jobs is good for the pilot groups as a whole.
I'm proud of my Comair heritage and don't wish unemployment on anyone. Comair has always had an outstanding group of pilots, fa's, mechanics, gate agents, dispatchers, and everyone else. Hold you heads high, go get some interviews and don't bash them when they ask about your Comair experience.
I've posted it before but if anyone would like more info on jobs overseas you guys and girls know where to find me.
Good luck and God speed!
#76
Line Holder
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 75
Likes: 0
I consider myself pretty well informed and I did not know ....
Delta management was very clear they were going to reduce 50 seat flying either with, or without, the Delta pilots. The difference the Delta pilots made was allowing MORE next generation 76 seat jets, which were not allowed in the Joint Pilot Working Agreement. Facilitating the "trade" would expedite a swap into more economically viable equipment. Back channel (unconfirmed) rumor was that the DAL MEC had informally counselled Comair's MEC to bid for the new flying to come.
It appears plan A was to renegotiate with SkyWest. SkyWest refused.
Look; Comair is a Delta asset. No one is pleased to see a part of our Company mismanaged into liquidation. No one is happy to see our management (from Northwest) take this action. There is no reason to believe they view us any differently. It is just that our circumstance is different today.
In case you have not been following our news, our SkyTeam "partners" are eating us alive just as the pantheon of DCI carriers took work you considered to be "yours." Lesson to all of us, our jobs are only as secure as the scope we negotiate.
Delta management was very clear they were going to reduce 50 seat flying either with, or without, the Delta pilots. The difference the Delta pilots made was allowing MORE next generation 76 seat jets, which were not allowed in the Joint Pilot Working Agreement. Facilitating the "trade" would expedite a swap into more economically viable equipment. Back channel (unconfirmed) rumor was that the DAL MEC had informally counselled Comair's MEC to bid for the new flying to come.
It appears plan A was to renegotiate with SkyWest. SkyWest refused.
Look; Comair is a Delta asset. No one is pleased to see a part of our Company mismanaged into liquidation. No one is happy to see our management (from Northwest) take this action. There is no reason to believe they view us any differently. It is just that our circumstance is different today.
In case you have not been following our news, our SkyTeam "partners" are eating us alive just as the pantheon of DCI carriers took work you considered to be "yours." Lesson to all of us, our jobs are only as secure as the scope we negotiate.
One thing I can't figure out is how DAL expects to "save" money. Comair flies 1% of DAL routes. How could any sub-business with that low of a percentage inflict any damage to a multi-billion dollar industry? And that's even if you *buy* their argument that the RJs cost them money? (I still have not seen definitive figures that show conclusively that OH costs them money. Just because mgmt says so, doesn't make it so.)
Getting back to my point of "saving" money; closing Comair solves their problem of "high" labor costs. So how is adding planes to mainline, along with the higher wage level that comes with it, going to "save" DAL money? Yeah, maybe in the short run since 1600 people are now out of a job, but in the long-run, no way.
Which leads me to my 2nd point. DAL only is concerned with the here and now. Tomorrow is another day, another deal to be made, another promise to be broken. Previous posters have stated it more eloquently than I, do not beleive for one second that you are safe, no matter if you are DCI or DAL. In big business, tomorrow is a whole new day.
#77
Another long time lurker here and posting my first message. I have to say, Bucking Bar, I have ejoyed your posts and the knowledge that you bring. I can't blame the OH pilots for voicing some anger at mainline pilots and can understand how they must feel. This last post definitely puts it into perspective though.
One thing I can't figure out is how DAL expects to "save" money. Comair flies 1% of DAL routes. How could any sub-business with that low of a percentage inflict any damage to a multi-billion dollar industry? And that's even if you *buy* their argument that the RJs cost them money? (I still have not seen definitive figures that show conclusively that OH costs them money. Just because mgmt says so, doesn't make it so.)
Getting back to my point of "saving" money; closing Comair solves their problem of "high" labor costs. So how is adding planes to mainline, along with the higher wage level that comes with it, going to "save" DAL money? Yeah, maybe in the short run since 1600 people are now out of a job, but in the long-run, no way.
Which leads me to my 2nd point. DAL only is concerned with the here and now. Tomorrow is another day, another deal to be made, another promise to be broken. Previous posters have stated it more eloquently than I, do not beleive for one second that you are safe, no matter if you are DCI or DAL. In big business, tomorrow is a whole new day.
One thing I can't figure out is how DAL expects to "save" money. Comair flies 1% of DAL routes. How could any sub-business with that low of a percentage inflict any damage to a multi-billion dollar industry? And that's even if you *buy* their argument that the RJs cost them money? (I still have not seen definitive figures that show conclusively that OH costs them money. Just because mgmt says so, doesn't make it so.)
Getting back to my point of "saving" money; closing Comair solves their problem of "high" labor costs. So how is adding planes to mainline, along with the higher wage level that comes with it, going to "save" DAL money? Yeah, maybe in the short run since 1600 people are now out of a job, but in the long-run, no way.
Which leads me to my 2nd point. DAL only is concerned with the here and now. Tomorrow is another day, another deal to be made, another promise to be broken. Previous posters have stated it more eloquently than I, do not beleive for one second that you are safe, no matter if you are DCI or DAL. In big business, tomorrow is a whole new day.
- 80 (a no voter on the DL TA)
Speaking of sending the jets elsewhere- how long until a suit for the pilots to follow them?
#78
Banned
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 3,655
Likes: 0
From: Narrow/Left Wide/Right
If your Dal why not wait a few months and then start up a regional flying 76 seaters under the brand of compass 2. Heck even promise some flow through. Now labor all reset to year 1 pay. Voila money saved!
#79
On Reserve
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
From: CL65 FO
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post




