Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Southwest (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/southwest/)
-   -   1221 (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/southwest/133595-1221.html)

Lewbronski 04-25-2021 03:53 PM


Originally Posted by RJSAviator76 (Post 3226611)
LOL Lew... thanks for the trigger warning... :p

Now that you've done an absolutely phenomenal job outlining everything that's wrong and taking an umpteen millionth dump on this pilot group, would THIS perhaps be the time you'd tell us what to do... maybe? Just a thought? Take pity on some of us knuckle-draggers and tell us your solutions we're obviously missing. That's all I've been asking of you for years now... specific, concrete solutions, specific steps our union should take to achieve this contractual nirvana you're seeking. Get into the weeds, man... into minutiae. Tell us HOW we can use the RLA against the company when we're negotiating a contract towards our favor, i.e. not concessions with threats of BK/furloughs. What specifically has SWAPA been doing wrong going into this? What are Casey and Jody doing wrong? What are they missing? How can we help them? Start typing.

I don't want to click on links. I don't want to 'read between the lines.' I don't want "primers." I know more about RLA, Chapter 11, and airline politics and processes than I care to. I want YOU to expend just a fraction of the energy you spend $hitting all over this pilot group every time you post and tell us exactly what we're doing wrong and how do we fix it. I want you to show the specific misses our union makes, and do so publicly. I don't wanna hear about TA1 voters... I want to hear about C2020. The only reference I want to see to the old TA1 or even TA2 is how unlike back then, we should do x,y,z.

Is it so hard to put down your solutions, or are you a one trick pony?

/trigger or something :D

Spinning wheels. If you won’t even click a link to learn a little bit about how you might help yourself, I can’t help you. Your post is much of what’s wrong in a nutshell. You want to be spoon-fed and hand-held through a process that YOU can figure out on your own. If you can’t invest a few hours to do some of your own research in order to help your own career, I don’t know what to tell you. What would you tell someone who didn’t want to do the work? What would tell someone who expected to be spoon-fed? You don’t trust the MSM, right? Why would you trust me to accurately inform you? Do the work to figure it out.

RJSAviator76 04-25-2021 04:20 PM


Originally Posted by Lewbronski (Post 3226618)
Spinning wheels. If you won’t even click a link to learn a little bit about how you might help yourself, I can’t help you. Your post is much of what’s wrong in a nutshell. You want to be spoon-fed and hand-held through a process that YOU can figure out on your own. If you can’t invest a few hours to do some of your own research in order to help your own career, I don’t know what to tell you. What would you tell someone who didn’t want to do the work? What would tell someone who expected to be spoon-fed? You don’t trust the MSM, right? Why would you trust me to accurately inform you? Do the work to figure it out.

Lew... I dealt with this sh*t in my previous life to the point I probably forgot more than you'll ever know. My challenge to you is simple, direct, and to a point - solutions. The only acceptable answer are specific points. Not links, not innuendos, not "do-your-own-research", not excuses. What solutions do you have to offer, if any?

Grumpyaviator 04-25-2021 05:18 PM


Originally Posted by CA1900 (Post 3226545)
I agree with the rest of your post, but the RLA is stacked against labor. That's by the design. It was specifically written to neuter our ability to strike, and that lessens our leverage. It's definitely not impossible to make great gains, but it's more difficult and more time-consuming than operating under the NLRA would be.

There was a really good interview between the FAs and their attorney. There is a valuable aspect to the RLA for labor. Yes it allows the company to drag out negotiations, but at the same time our cba does not expire but becomes amendable. In other industries contracts expire if not negotiated in a timely manner which allows the company to abrogate all aspects of the contract. Under RLA our interests are protected until the new contract is negotiated because it doesn’t expire but is amendable.

Caveman 04-25-2021 05:54 PM


Originally Posted by Lewbronski (Post 3226589)
It’s not stacked against labor. It is designed to draw out the negotiating process to minimize the chances of an interruption of commerce. In that sense, it’s tilted toward the flying public. If it’s tilted against either side, it’s tilted against the less patient and less informed side. That side is usually labor in the airline industry. So, in that way, yes it’s tilted against labor. But it’s not the RLA that does the tilting, it’s labor itself that tilts the RLA against labor.

The RLA doesn’t neuter our ability to strike. How does it do that? There’s only one body within the United States that can prevent labor from striking and if it does so, it occurs completely outside the bounds of the RLA and after the RLA has completely exhausted itself. It has never used that power to avert an airline strike. It’s a rare occurrence and has only happened so far within the confines of the railroad industry.

Here’s a good primer on the RLA, written by a NMB mediator.

excellent post!!!

​​​​​​

WHACKMASTER 04-25-2021 06:50 PM


Originally Posted by madduck (Post 3226455)
a 'buddy', though that relationship is waning, was 100% in on forfeiting 10% of our pay.
he preaches that "we need to do what's best for the company at all times. we need them, they dont need us."
he also voted Yes on TA1.


i told him TA1 was BS.
i told him this 10% cut was BS.
i told him 'your welcome' for your pay raise with TA2, and the B Fund.
as a senior FO the dude lived on premium, always texted me about his fat turn or 2 day he got at 1.5 pay.
he'll drop what he's doing to fly prem as a capt of course.
when i point out to him that if he got that trip at P then he for sure would have gotten it at Straight.
his response, well, it's not that much or that often.

some people are not salvagable.

Punch him in the face and tell him it was from me. Sounds like a real “winner”.

THEKERNALKLINK 04-25-2021 07:12 PM

1221 Commission
 

Originally Posted by Rolf (Post 3220441)
2020 was difficult. I'm just glad the boss was able to get thru it unscathed.
https://www.execpay.org/news/southwe...mpensation-951

I have no prob with his pay, seems low, but let's get past that and get on to the 1221 thing.

My vast military experience as both an 18 year old enlistee, and as an officer after graduating college would make me a good candidate for being a member of the steering committee or something!

I'm thinking we set up "1221" clubs in all the crew rooms, where you can get a refreshment, a snack. We can even put up a little sign "1221" and the bosses will know what it means, and they'll know that we know that they know what it means and don't care.

We'll put up a black curtain like they used to have in the old days on those camera's that puffed and smoked when you took a picture, so we can do our secret handshake without any outsiders seeing it. A suggestion box that says "contract negotiation .ideas" on it. We could just sit there and leer at everyone who is not in the club.

Just some ideas.

Lewbronski 04-25-2021 07:19 PM

Deleted. Not worth it.

GearAlarm 04-25-2021 07:45 PM


Originally Posted by Lewbronski (Post 3226595)
We also never voted on any covid concessions. How’s that saying go about it not mattering what people say, it matters what they actually spend their time and money on?

Maybe history won’t repeat itself this time around. But we have a ~50 year history of succumbing to FUD and propaganda. Maybe we’ve entered a new era with all of our millennial and Gen Z guys. Maybe. But there’s another saying that says something like history may be different but it usually rhymes. I’m pretty resigned to seeing the same old thing play out. But I hope I’m wrong.

No one knows the future. I will agree that we are doomed to repeat the past if we dont learn from it. But to draw a parallel today with SWAPA from 50 years ago is a leap. How about we look at 5 years ago. This group did in fact come together for TA2, trickle down q anon and all. Its not perfect and not an easy road, but we moved on down. Let's move a little further next time.

THEKERNALKLINK 04-25-2021 08:02 PM

Kinda reminds me of a rich liberal talking about taxes.

AdmiralofRears 04-26-2021 03:15 AM


Originally Posted by THEKERNALKLINK (Post 3226678)
I have no prob with his pay, seems low, but let's get past that and get on to the 1221 thing.

My vast military experience as both an 18 year old enlistee, and as an officer after graduating college would make me a good candidate for being a member of the steering committee or something!

I'm thinking we set up "1221" clubs in all the crew rooms, where you can get a refreshment, a snack. We can even put up a little sign "1221" and the bosses will know what it means, and they'll know that we know that they know what it means and don't care.

We'll put up a black curtain like they used to have in the old days on those camera's that puffed and smoked when you took a picture, so we can do our secret handshake without any outsiders seeing it. A suggestion box that says "contract negotiation .ideas" on it. We could just sit there and leer at everyone who is not in the club.

Just some ideas.

As Commanding Officer of Special Unit 1221, I approve of your suggestion and will transmit orders to my squad leaders. The secret handshake is in development right now.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:05 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands