Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Spirit (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/spirit/)
-   -   The Signing "Bonus" is the problem (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/spirit/111498-signing-bonus-problem.html)

Planepirate 02-16-2018 11:44 AM


Originally Posted by CMFIC (Post 2529963)
Serious question:

What would the consensus among our yes voters be if there was no one-time taxed "bonus" for trading away so much... to be locked into a subpar agreement for the next 5-8 years?

I’m a yes voter but I would vote no if there was not a ratification/retro payment. However, I’m jot voting yes BECAUSE of it either. Not paying us anything for our pain and suffering for the past three years would make me so angry that I would vote no out of spite.

Happy Grapes 02-16-2018 02:08 PM


Originally Posted by Ed Force One (Post 2530019)
Anything less than 100% retro is a joke. It sends a message to the company that it was okay to drag this out for 3 years.

They get to keep our 43% pay raises for themselves. (Minus the bonus, which makes it about, roughly, approximately, plus or minus, 2 years pay we lose.) That's about 6 figures for nearly every pilot who's been here since early openers.)

Oh, and expect nothing to change in 5 years when we do this all again.

Good news and bad news for you...


Good news is there are enough level headed pilots at Spirit to vote this thing in, keeping you from making a horrible decision by sailing into the unknown without the proper industry protections one needs in this career. So thats the good thing, you get LTD, DC, huge raise, substantial scope improvements, etc...

Bad News is you will never be happy at Spirit because you are simply just unrealistic.

otter1 02-16-2018 02:36 PM

I don't know anyone that's voting in this TA for the signing bonus. I am voting yes because of a number of reasons:

Over 5000/month pay raise (A 2 year F/O gets about 2700/month) (those numbers include the DC plan)
A great LTD plan
A good DC plan
Better Scope

I don't think we'd ever get full retro. And I'm not willing to lose 5000/month to take that chance.

astral 02-16-2018 07:01 PM


Originally Posted by otter1 (Post 2530358)
I'm not willing to lose 5000/month to take that chance.

This is exactly how the company wants us to vote, by thinking how much we are "losing/mo". This takes our focus away from the severe QOL losses.
Sending this back is a worthy "sacrifice" when we regain provisions, which will be maintained as ammunition for the next round.
Otherwise what will be left to negotiate with in 5-7 years?
June is just 3 months away.
Have faith, this is a great time for gains, it may not be this favorable in the future.

Dukeuno 02-16-2018 07:38 PM


Originally Posted by astral (Post 2530512)
This is exactly how the company wants us to vote, by thinking how much we are "losing/mo". This takes our focus away from the severe QOL losses.
Sending this back is a worthy "sacrifice" when we regain provisions, which will be maintained as ammunition for the next round.
Otherwise what will be left to negotiate with in 5-7 years?
June is just 3 months away.
Have faith, this is a great time for gains, it may not be this favorable in the future.

What does June have to with this vote? If you think we are going to have a melt down if this gets shot down you are completely wrong. They have enough people coming over to fill classes right now. Maybe reach out and ask the NC what plan B is if this fails? I think they said there is no plan. I am not telling you how to vote, but if you vote No don’t do it thinking the company will come crawling back to the table. Vote No because you are willing to work under the current CBA for who knows how long. Just like the No voters have said don’t vote Yes out of fear.

dotslash 02-16-2018 08:04 PM


Originally Posted by Dukeuno (Post 2530535)
ask the NC what plan B is if this fails? I think they said there is no plan.

I hear they did this also last time, scares people into yes vote with having no back up position. I think may be TA was loss when same negotiator was picked for this time. Hope we learn this time.

Happy Grapes 02-16-2018 08:19 PM


Originally Posted by astral (Post 2530512)
This is exactly how the company wants us to vote, by thinking how much we are "losing/mo". This takes our focus away from the severe QOL losses.
Sending this back is a worthy "sacrifice" when we regain provisions, which will be maintained as ammunition for the next round.
Otherwise what will be left to negotiate with in 5-7 years?
June is just 3 months away.
Have faith, this is a great time for gains, it may not be this favorable in the future.

Cant wait for this to pass!

Back to your hole, Cole.

lowandslow 02-16-2018 08:21 PM


Originally Posted by Dukeuno (Post 2530535)
What does June have to with this vote? If you think we are going to have a melt down if this gets shot down you are completely wrong. They have enough people coming over to fill classes right now. Maybe reach out and ask the NC what plan B is if this fails? I think they said there is no plan. I am not telling you how to vote, but if you vote No don’t do it thinking the company will come crawling back to the table. Vote No because you are willing to work under the current CBA for who knows how long. Just like the No voters have said don’t vote Yes out of fear.

I’m sorry but they’ve had meltdowns every summer. This TA gives them meltdown protection.

Dukeuno 02-16-2018 08:23 PM


Originally Posted by lowandslow (Post 2530551)
I’m sorry but they’ve had meltdowns every summer. This TA gives them meltdown protection.

Hmmm besides the May meltdown which resulted in our TRO I don’t recall another melt down last summer ( June through August)

lowandslow 02-16-2018 08:25 PM


Originally Posted by Dukeuno (Post 2530554)
Hmmm besides the May meltdown which resulted in our TRO I don’t recall another melt down last summer ( June through August)

I said EVERY summer not ALL summer. Meltdown 2015, for example, was when we simulated TA 2018 for a few days thanks to JA.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:14 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands