Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Union Talk (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/union-talk/)
-   -   Jetblue and ALPA election (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/union-talk/60416-jetblue-alpa-election.html)

johnso29 07-03-2011 02:03 PM


Originally Posted by Clear Right (Post 1017406)
This is exactly the Mentality that is ruining this profession and this country, people want to get paid big bucks for doing as little as possible. How about being a productive member of society and your company. Featherbedding is ruining the profession in my opinion. Southwest pilots lead the industry because they are productive, not because they featherbed. Just my opinion.

SWA pilots average 18 days off. That's what I want. I also see how maximizing days off is failing to be a productive member of society. Last time I checked, the government gets a good chunk of my salary. The same can't be said for those who are too good to go flip burgers or work at a retail store but don't mind sucking off the unemployment teet.

scambo1 07-03-2011 05:52 PM


Originally Posted by shiznit (Post 1016941)
Don't forget that just recently AirTran voted ALPA IN, the guys at FDX voted ALPA IN, both had independent unions and BOTH groups have fared MUCH better with ALPA rather than being on their own. APA has hired the ALPA law firm to help negotiate a new deal.

DAL has about 2500 guys out of 12300 who are unhappy with ALPA. That will NOT get ALPA off property.

SWA has NEVER established a new bar. They were compensated 20-30% less than other major airline pilots since their inception. They are at the top right now because others fell back, not because they have "outperformed" ALPA as an independent bargaining agent.

Shiz;

do you have historic w-2 comparisons to prove this or are you repeating what you've been told?

DAL 88 Driver 07-03-2011 06:05 PM


Originally Posted by shiznit (Post 1016941)
Don't forget that just recently AirTran voted ALPA IN, the guys at FDX voted ALPA IN, both had independent unions and BOTH groups have fared MUCH better with ALPA rather than being on their own. APA has hired the ALPA law firm to help negotiate a new deal.

http://www.x-entertainment.com/pics/kool1.jpg



Originally Posted by shiznit (Post 1016941)
DAL has about 2500 guys out of 12300 who are unhappy with ALPA.

You sure about that? DPA has over 3000 cards now. And from what I've seen and heard around campus, that doesn't even begin to touch the number of guys who are unhappy with ALPA. Some are just more willing than others to do something about it, and some have different ideas about what to do.


Originally Posted by shiznit (Post 1016941)
That will NOT get ALPA off property.

That's probably right.


Originally Posted by shiznit (Post 1016941)
SWA has NEVER established a new bar. They were compensated 20-30% less than other major airline pilots since their inception. They are at the top right now because others fell back, not because they have "outperformed" ALPA as an independent bargaining agent.

So how did they get to an average of over $230K for a Captain? That's MORE than our MD-88/90 Captains were making with C2K! I'm not aware of the SWA pilots getting any big pay increases since then. How did they get there?

RedeyeAV8r 07-03-2011 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by DAL 88 Driver (Post 1017537)
http://www.x-entertainment.com/pics/kool1.jpg

So how did they get to an average of over $230K for a Captain? That's MORE than our MD-88/90 Captains were making with C2K. I'm not aware of the SWA pilots getting any big pay increases since then. How did they get there?

I would like some stats and proof to back up that the AVG SWA Capt makes over 230K. Maybe a few do but I bet they work extra to get it, or they are an LCA or something with an override.

But to answer your question. SWA has remained profitable and an even bigger
point is they didn't file Bankruptcy and void contracts with the Bankruptcy Judge,
The have never had an A plan (Which all the ALPA legacies had prior to the Bankruptcies of post 9/11) and only have a 401K match, albeit a decent match.

SWA just like FedEx trailed the legacies until the great devastation that followed 9-11. It was only after FedEx voted ALPA back (for the 2nd time) that we were able to actually negotiate a contract. Our 1st contract under the FPA was basically imposed after our In house Union imploded on itself. Not picking on the SWA pilots by any stretch. SWA is clearly a top choice for a Pilot Job. It is just that they, like FedEx, never really raised the bar, we just haven't let it slip. A profitable company with consistent performance is one Big reason. Having a Union is another.

Happy 4th Everybody. Be safe out there!

slowplay 07-03-2011 06:20 PM


Originally Posted by scambo1 (Post 1017532)
Shiz;

do you have historic w-2 comparisons to prove this or are you repeating what you've been told?

If you're making a W-2 argument, was Delta Express a "C" scale? I seemed to remember a lot of those very junior Captains really cleaning up with the efficiency of that operation and prudent use of our contract.;)

Carl Spakler 07-03-2011 06:28 PM


Originally Posted by DAL 88 Driver (Post 1017537)
So how did they get to an average of over $230K for a Captain? That's MORE than our MD-88/90 Captains were making with C2K! I'm not aware of the SWA pilots getting any big pay increases since then. How did they get there?

They patterned off the rates that were established at UAL & DAL in 2000-2001.

They were able to avoid sliding backwards because their airline didn't go into bankrputcy.

It's a happy circumstance for all of us that SWA has been able to hold on. We'll have a nice reference point.

scambo1 07-03-2011 06:57 PM


Originally Posted by slowplay (Post 1017547)
If you're making a W-2 argument, was Delta Express a "C" scale? I seemed to remember a lot of those very junior Captains really cleaning up with the efficiency of that operation and prudent use of our contract.;)


"Prudent" is an interesting choice of words for how Express made bank. Are you somehow trying to imply that SWA has an organized sickout/greenslip gig going? Because I'm not buying that.

FlyingViking 07-03-2011 07:04 PM


Originally Posted by eaglefly (Post 1017251)
..........ALPA has in fact, become pointless for collective bargaining. They should stick to the role of a safety advocate as they offer nothing for pilots to better themselves (and even attempt to stiff their lower-end workers). With grotesquely bloated salaries, perks and bennies for the upper staff, they're nothing more then an aviation Enron.

Post of the month !

slowplay 07-03-2011 07:09 PM


Originally Posted by scambo1 (Post 1017557)
"Prudent" is an interesting choice of words for how Express made bank. Are you somehow trying to imply that SWA has an organized sickout/greenslip gig going? Because I'm not buying that.

Are you implying the Delta Express had an organized sickout campaign going on? Because the data doesn't support that. Yes, they used greenslips, just like SWA uses overtime to get to their "average" pay.

I note that you didn't answer the question. Is it W-2 or wage rates? B-scale or not?

DAL 88 Driver 07-03-2011 07:16 PM


Originally Posted by Carl Spakler (Post 1017549)
They patterned off the rates that were established at UAL & DAL in 2000-2001.

You sure about that? I don't remember them getting any huge pay increases back then. I always bought into the conventional wisdom that they were quite a bit behind us (prior to 9/11) in pay. But then again, the only thing I ever saw was the pay rates. That obviously doesn't tell the whole story with SWA and is actually quite misleading because of their TFP thing. I'm beginning to wonder if they were really all that far behind us back then.

Of course, that's really not all that important now. What IS important is that their average Captain makes over $230K/year and their average First Officer makes over $140K/year. When you compare a Delta MD-88/90 Captain averaging 75 hours per month on our current pay rates, you get an $83,000 per year deficit compared to an SWA Captain doing essentially the same kind of flying. For those of you in Rio Linda/Herndon... that's HUGE!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 01:05 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands