Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/)
-   -   Vacancy 20-03V (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/124635-vacancy-20-03v.html)

rvfanatic 10-28-2019 06:48 AM


Originally Posted by Triumph (Post 2913816)
Sounds like a good bit of jealousy. Someone got a better deal than you and you don’t like it. If people didn’t have the option to have their civilian employment rights protected while still performing their military duty (short term or long term) we wouldn’t have much of a volunteer military would we?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Gollum is preaching the truth and you’re butt hurt.

It is disingenuous and abusive of USSERA to get hired knowing that you already have a 3yr AGR secured with a bonus of 100K at 115k/yr. Then new hires drop long term mil leave as soon as consolidation is complete. MIL guys, we are just screwing our bros behind us if we do that. Look at Delta and some of the others who are not nearly as cooperative with the part time military.

Grumble 10-28-2019 07:52 AM


Originally Posted by gollum (Post 2913806)
No, it’s definitely not federal law. USERRA does not in any way require an employer to make contributions to your retirement account while on mil leave. It does have a provision to allow the service member to do make up contributions to their account.

Um, yeah it does.


Originally Posted by rvfanatic (Post 2913833)
Gollum is preaching the truth and you’re butt hurt.

It is disingenuous and abusive of USSERA to get hired knowing that you already have a 3yr AGR secured with a bonus of 100K at 115k/yr. Then new hires drop long term mil leave as soon as consolidation is complete. MIL guys, we are just screwing our bros behind us if we do that. Look at Delta and some of the others who are not nearly as cooperative with the part time military.

They’re perpetually losing USERRA lawsuits for violating it.

How about everyone mind their own business? I know plenty of mil dudes on long term orders, at home station because the squadron genuinely needs them to function. The ones that abuse it will get what’s coming to them... like coming back from 4-5 years leave and still being on probation.....

And maybe as a new guy **** for about two years, *****ing about how your winning lottery ticket requires you to commute to collect the money.

Triumph 10-28-2019 09:26 AM


Originally Posted by rvfanatic (Post 2913833)
Gollum is preaching the truth and you’re butt hurt.



It is disingenuous and abusive of USSERA to get hired knowing that you already have a 3yr AGR secured with a bonus of 100K at 115k/yr. Then new hires drop long term mil leave as soon as consolidation is complete. MIL guys, we are just screwing our bros behind us if we do that. Look at Delta and some of the others who are not nearly as cooperative with the part time military.



Butt hurt? About what exactly? Are you sure you aren’t a 15 year old troll?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

gollum 10-28-2019 10:02 AM


Originally Posted by Grumble (Post 2913862)
The ones that abuse it will get what’s coming to them... like coming back from 4-5 years leave and still being on probation.

If you go back and re-read my post, you will see that is exactly who I was referencing, the guys who get hired with a pre-meditation of going to training and then right away dropping mil leave.

rvfanatic 10-28-2019 12:41 PM


Originally Posted by Grumble (Post 2913862)
The ones that abuse it will get what’s coming to them... like coming back from 4-5 years leave and still being on probation.....

That $209 an hour on the triple will show those guys!


Originally Posted by Grumble (Post 2913862)
And maybe as a new guy **** for about two years, *****ing about how your winning lottery ticket requires you to commute to collect the money.

I do not commute. I just said that I can understand those who are frustrated they can’t hold their home town while new hires 18 months junior to them can.

My point is: if we could incentivize airframe pay better and modify seat lock rules to reduce training costs, then why wouldn’t we?

Aquaticus 10-28-2019 02:37 PM

Who here doesn't care what a military guy does within the rules? Thanks for your service. You take whatever benefit you EARNED.

baseball 10-28-2019 03:06 PM


Originally Posted by gollum (Post 2913917)
If you go back and re-read my post, you will see that is exactly who I was referencing, the guys who get hired with a pre-meditation of going to training and then right away dropping mil leave.

Lets re-litigate the Continental Airlines military discrimination lawsuit again shall we?

Seriously...…..what an idiotic thing to say. both in this post and in the previous post.

Military leave is fully protected by federal law, regardless of when the Commander in Chief activates you, voluntary, involuntary, etc.

if someone gets hired and then goes gets activated shortly after being hired it is what it is. The company is and should still be VERY delighted and very excited about hiring a fully trained, vetted, and qualified military pilot. it's a win win for the company, and Oscar Munoz is happy as a lark to have him or her on board, regardless of when they complete all of their UAL training requirements and hit the line.

baseball 10-28-2019 03:10 PM


Originally Posted by gollum (Post 2913806)
No, it’s definitely not federal law. USERRA does not in any way require an employer to make contributions to your retirement account while on mil leave. It does have a provision to allow the service member to do make up contributions to their account.

I guess we should all just give back the 11.1 million dollar federal settlement/award then huuuh?

Seriously.....You don't seem to have a good handle on this.

Any benefit (tangible, or intangible) right, benefit of employment afforded to a non military employee shall be afforded to a military employee as if he/she was still actively employed and not on military leave.

baseball 10-28-2019 03:13 PM


Originally Posted by Triumph (Post 2913807)
Wrong again....


USERRA requires that an employee's period of military duty be counted as service with the employer for purposes of eligibility, vesting, and the allocation of employer contributions under a 401(k) plan. ... An employee cannot be treated as having incurred a break in service because of a period of military service.

What other questions can we answer for you?

ding ding ding....we got a winner!

It also remains to be fully settled as to how the sick leave will get handled, but I do believe that will be a winner too. Sick leave accrual happens for other types of leave, so military pilots should accrue sick leave too.

baseball 10-28-2019 03:19 PM


Originally Posted by rvfanatic (Post 2913833)

It is disingenuous and abusive of USSERA to get hired knowing that you already have a 3yr AGR secured with a bonus of 100K at 115k/yr. Then new hires drop long term mil leave as soon as consolidation is complete. MIL guys, we are just screwing our bros behind us if we do that. Look at Delta and some of the others who are not nearly as cooperative with the part time military.

That's not in the law. I've spoken to more than one US DOT/DOL/DOJ lawyer, and Ombudsman, and military Jag attorney and USSERA experts at law schools. The words "abusive of USSERA" and "disingenuous" are not in the law. Moreover, a civilian employer is not even allowed to inquire as to your status in that regard to PREVENT discrimination in the hiring process. Allot like not having to say you're gay, or a lesbian, or a fig tree, or you're African American, American Eskimo, Cajun, etc.

Continental Airlines used to think the way you presented your argument. They got popped pretty hard for doing that. Had a guy get involuntarily activated while in new hire indoc. he got fired, and guess what, Continental got sued, and he was re-hired.

The CAL MEC had a history of cooperating with CAL management on this issue after PBS was shoved down the pilots throats due to reduction in force by management. The PBS formula failed to account for mil leave.....The system crashed. Not the fault of military employees.

Big picture.....When a person competes for a flying job at the majors they do so when they feel their timing, and preparation are ready. If they get hired, good for them. I'd rather see a military pilot get hired on then someone who hasn't paid any dues at all.

Mil pilots don't get out of probation regardless of orders. That probationary period still has to be completed and that's what really counts. who cares if they got a tour they need to complete. The guard and reserve is still under-staffed. They got staffing problems too. Military necessity trumps civilian employers feelings. it is what it is.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:23 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands