Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/)
-   -   We are not close (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/141875-we-not-close.html)

AxlF16 03-06-2023 07:03 AM


Originally Posted by sleeves (Post 3602659)
Ya it’s not the “authorities” that track you down. It is company paid goons. There are literally Hundreds of Millions of dollars at stake. They will aggressively come at you, they love to take hostages. Then we get to pay for you with negotiating capital.

Exactly!

Tread extremely lightly.

RaginCajun 03-06-2023 07:36 AM

Sounds like company/ALPA talks are happening today behind the scenes prior to the Thursday/Friday meeting.

A320 03-06-2023 08:20 AM


Originally Posted by AxlF16 (Post 3602761)
Exactly!

Tread extremely lightly.

it's a fact that most pilots are about as clueless on posting inappropriate things online as 14 year old girls

rickair7777 03-06-2023 10:53 AM


Originally Posted by Cameronhoward (Post 3602456)
Not that it matters but most newish android devices automatically randomize your MAC address every time you connect to any wifi connection. That would make it nearly impossible for anyone to look at forum data and know who's android device it came from. Especially using a VPN as well.

Yes, if you use a VPN (or even a public wifi) and randomize (or manually change) your MAC address they probably can't find you that way in this day and age. Even home internet routers swap out their IP addresses periodically, although it's possible service providers log that and it could be subject to subpoena.

But if you screw up, even once, that's all it takes so in general I would avoid online behavior which rises to a termination offense because if you annoy them and get on their radar they will come out guns blazing if they get a hint as to your actually identity.

And they don't even have to *know*, just suspect and then they have justification to ask the question... that will be awkward, are you going to lie, not knowing exactly how much they actually know?

Labor organizing speech is protected... assuming you correctly comprehend where that reservation begins and ends (not all of you do).

Threats or harassment of other employers is always a third rail, same for disclosing info the company deems or considered confidential or privileged. Unless your CBA specifically addresses freedom of speech, your company policy will apply and those tend to be pretty draconian as far as public speech/journalism/social media is concerned.

If you're going to aggressive in your SM use, better educate yourself about digital hygiene, stay up to date on that, and be VERY disciplined in practice. Good Luck.

unstabilized 03-06-2023 11:19 AM

I feel like the same people that advocate for work actions are the same people that know nothing about the nuances of being tracked on the internet.

jdavk 03-06-2023 11:27 AM


Originally Posted by unstabilized (Post 3602933)
I feel like the same people that advocate for work actions are the same people that know nothing about the nuances of being tracked on the internet.

That is the post of the month. 100% agree.

Grumble 03-06-2023 11:31 AM


Originally Posted by hummingbear;[url=tel:3602525
3602525]Advocating a slowdown is a very poor idea. It’s illegal & will land you in a great deal of personal distress & accomplish nothing of substance on a large scale. What I don’t know if the company realizes, though, is that organic loss of enthusiasm is way more destructive than an intentional slowdown. An organized action can be turned off & on like a light switch. (Contract signed, everything goes back to normal immediately.) Employee morale? Once that’s gone, it’s gone.

Workplace enthusiasm is like a speed/drag power curve. Once you get on the backside of it, it becomes exponentially difficult to get it back. Scott would not be the first airline manager to lose the confidence of his pilots then lazily conclude that they’re just insatiable money grabbers when modest attempts to buy it back fail. We’ve all seen this movie before.

For the last couple years, all I’ve heard from this airline is how powerful & meaningful are personal touches from the pilots. Which, honestly, great- let’s be the customer service airline. But there’s nothing new or creative about wanting “Give A *******“ employees under DGAS conditions. Telling us for months that you’re planning to give us an industry leading contract in 2 weeks then finally making a mediocre offer & suggesting we’re not being reasonable is a major flub up. I think the “we are not close” statement was the beginning of a rapid drop in general enthusiasm, & honestly, I worry about where we end up as an airline if he hasn’t cleaned this up by the summer. A contract today would continue United’s meteoric momentum. A contract in a few months could just be a more expensive way to have p1$$ed off pilots.

Nailed it.

Herb Kelleher understood this, take care of your employees and everything else will fall into place.


Originally Posted by unstabilized;[url=tel:3602933
3602933]I feel like the same people that advocate for work actions are the same people that know nothing about the nuances of being tracked on the internet.

It shouldn’t even be a case of being tracked down and caught. The history of people doing such things and the damage it caused should be motivation enough to not engage in such behavior. In no way does it benefit labor and in fact has the extreme opposite effect.

You can be angry and we have a right to be, however professionalism is not letting that anger get in the way of doing your job (and continuing to demonstrate your worth and value add). The limits of that are a personal decision to each individual.

I will continue to do my job to the best of my ability with the upmost professionalism until ALPA officially tells me we’re doing otherwise.

sailingfun 03-06-2023 01:28 PM


Originally Posted by Grumble (Post 3602942)
Nailed it.

Herb Kelleher understood this, take care of your employees and everything else will fall into place..

Here is the funny thing about Herb. He paid his employees well below industry wages and terrible work rules and kept them smiling. Only after Herb left did SWA get contracts near the majors and industry average.

Cameronhoward 03-06-2023 02:24 PM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 3602912)
Yes, if you use a VPN (or even a public wifi) and randomize (or manually change) your MAC address they probably can't find you that way in this day and age. Even home internet routers swap out their IP addresses periodically, although it's possible service providers log that and it could be subject to subpoena.

But if you screw up, even once, that's all it takes so in general I would avoid online behavior which rises to a termination offense because if you annoy them and get on their radar they will come out guns blazing if they get a hint as to your actually identity.

And they don't even have to *know*, just suspect and then they have justification to ask the question... that will be awkward, are you going to lie, not knowing exactly how much they actually know?

Labor organizing speech is protected... assuming you correctly comprehend where that reservation begins and ends (not all of you do).

Threats or harassment of other employers is always a third rail, same for disclosing info the company deems or considered confidential or privileged. Unless your CBA specifically addresses freedom of speech, your company policy will apply and those tend to be pretty draconian as far as public speech/journalism/social media is concerned.

If you're going to aggressive in your SM use, better educate yourself about digital hygiene, stay up to date on that, and be VERY disciplined in practice. Good Luck.

I certainly was not advocating saying things that would be actionable offenses. I myself make it a habit to not say anything online that I wouldn't be willing to say in person. I was simply informing people that your MAC address is hideable if you know what you're doing.

Lenticularis 03-06-2023 03:06 PM

Moderators, with all this talk on tracking down individuals and work action/illegal job actions. Have you suspended any perpetrators?

Grumble 03-06-2023 03:14 PM


Originally Posted by sailingfun;[url=tel:3603022
3603022[/url]]Here is the funny thing about Herb. He paid his employees well below industry wages and terrible work rules and kept them smiling. Only after Herb left did SWA get contracts near the majors and industry average.

Did their operation ever really have the money to prior to 9/11? They never really rocketed to the top, everyone else just crumbled around them and they were able to capitalize on the chaos that was the 2000’s.

Now they’re a real airline, with melt downs, bad press and strike talk. :D

Dave Fitzgerald 03-06-2023 04:04 PM


Originally Posted by Grumble (Post 3602942)
I will continue to do my job to the best of my ability with the upmost professionalism until ALPA officially tells me we’re doing otherwise.

I'm sure you know this, but ALPA will never tell you to do otherwise. ALPA saying pretty much anything at all other than do your job, will be taken to be a job action, in the courts. You will not hear this, so don't be waiting for it.

sleeves 03-06-2023 04:51 PM


Originally Posted by Dave Fitzgerald;[url=tel:3603117
3603117[/url]]I'm sure you know this, but ALPA will never tell you to do otherwise. ALPA saying pretty much anything at all other than do your job, will be taken to be a job action, in the courts. You will not hear this, so don't be waiting for it.

ALPA has done this actually. At Continental in 1983, United in 1985, Eastern in 1989, Northwest in 1998, Comair in 2001. With various levels of success….

rickair7777 03-07-2023 04:04 AM


Originally Posted by Lenticularis (Post 3603083)
Moderators, with all this talk on tracking down individuals and work action/illegal job actions. Have you suspended any perpetrators?


Yes. 10+.
.........

WHACKMASTER 03-07-2023 05:40 AM


Originally Posted by OOfff (Post 3601467)
do you think that your coworkers are not currently “flying safe, flying professionally, and flying the contract?” If they are, what are you advocating? If they aren’t, how so?

Oh geez……trolls gonna troll I suppose.

OOfff 03-07-2023 07:05 AM


Originally Posted by WHACKMASTER (Post 3603343)
Oh geez……trolls gonna troll I suppose.

questioning the intent of a post isn’t trolling, but following people around the site insulting them sure is.

Dave Fitzgerald 03-07-2023 08:32 AM


Originally Posted by sleeves (Post 3603144)
ALPA has done this actually. At Continental in 1983, United in 1985, Eastern in 1989, Northwest in 1998, Comair in 2001. With various levels of success….

Yes ALPA has done this in the past. It will not happen again in this era of management friendly court injunctions.

I would urge everyone to carefully read the SPSC ALPA email yesterday regarding Status Quo.

Delta757 03-07-2023 03:39 PM

Since the topic is already off track, I don't feel too bad adding one more off topic question that I've always wondered about, and I promise I'm not planning on doing this, I'm just curious, regarding illegal job actions:

Can the airlines go after a pilot at another ALPA carrier?
A pilot at a non ALPA carrier?
A random person?

As in someone that works at Home Depot coming on these forums advocating illegal job actions

khergan 03-07-2023 05:04 PM


Originally Posted by Delta757 (Post 3603706)
Since the topic is already off track, I don't feel too bad adding one more off topic question that I've always wondered about, and I promise I'm not planning on doing this, I'm just curious, regarding illegal job actions:

Can the airlines go after a pilot at another ALPA carrier?
A pilot at a non ALPA carrier?
A random person?

As in someone that works at Home Depot coming on these forums advocating illegal job actions

As a Home Depot employee I feel personally attacked..

andydwyer 03-07-2023 08:09 PM

Back to the “close” part of this. There is a boiling at TK of PIs that have been waiting and waiting, almost all can hold captain in Denver, talk of 45 day notices has risen substantially. News needs to come soon or the more senior of the building will be leaving.

RaginCajun 03-07-2023 09:45 PM


Originally Posted by andydwyer (Post 3603827)
Back to the “close” part of this. There is a boiling at TK of PIs that have been waiting and waiting, almost all can hold captain in Denver, talk of 45 day notices has risen substantially. News needs to come soon or the more senior of the building will be leaving.

Also hearing this…I may or may not be in this same boat.

EwrRocks 03-08-2023 03:08 AM


Originally Posted by andydwyer (Post 3603827)
Back to the “close” part of this. There is a boiling at TK of PIs that have been waiting and waiting, almost all can hold captain in Denver, talk of 45 day notices has risen substantially. News needs to come soon or the more senior of the building will be leaving.

This ^^^^^^^^^

rvfanatic 03-08-2023 03:49 AM


Originally Posted by andydwyer (Post 3603827)
Back to the “close” part of this. There is a boiling at TK of PIs that have been waiting and waiting, almost all can hold captain in Denver, talk of 45 day notices has risen substantially. News needs to come soon or the more senior of the building will be leaving.

Threats do nothing. If they are unhappy with their compensation under the current contract, they should vote with their feet.

Sunvox 03-08-2023 04:01 AM

AA CEO message to AA pilots



To match Delta's deal, Isom said American pilots would receive on average pay increases of 21% in the first year of contract. Total pay increases in the fourth year of the contract deal would be 40%, he said.

The Atlanta-based carrier's new contract provides a 34% cumulative pay increase, a lump-sum one-time payment, reduced health insurance premiums and improvements in holiday pay, vacation, company contributions to 401(k) and work rules.
In the world of CEOs poking at each other perhaps this will be a nudge to get us one step closer. IDK but hopefully. Of course no mention of QWL improvements from Isom, at least not in that article.

EDIT: I found this in the AA forum. Speaking with my LEC Cap rep via email it appears the last line is the sticking point for us as the company and ALPA are VERY far apart on what is "the quality life and benefits that matter most to you".


Originally Posted by Otterbox (Post 3603859)
Hi everyone, Delta’s Pilots recently ratified a new for your deal that it is unprecedented in the history of collective bargaining, profoundly changing the economics of Delta’s pilot career; and that’s not just for Delta’s pilots, that deal with determine compensation benefits, and quality of life for pilot across the rest of the industry. That means something extraordinary for American’s Pilots. That’s because our commitment, my commitment, remains unchanged; Our team members, including our pilot will be paid well, and they will be paid competitively.

Let me be clear, American is prepared to match Delta pay rates and provide American’s pilots with the same profit-sharing formula as Delta’s pilots. American pilot’s would receive pay increases of an average 21% in the first year of the new contract; Begin participation in a much richer profit sharing program and receive a bump in the companies annual contribution to your 401(k) in a second year of the deal. The total pay increase for pilots on average is 40% in the fourth year of the deal. Let me give you a few examples of what this would mean by the end of the agreement, factoring in base salary and increase 401(k) contributions from the company; a narrow body, captain at the top of the scale would make $475,000 a year or $135,000 more a year than they do today. A widebody Captain of the top of the scale order in $590,000 a year that’s $170,000 more a year than they earn today; and participation in the new profit-sharing program will increase the payout pool from 5% of pretax earnings too 10%, and up to 20% earnings about $2.5 billion.
And it’s not just about Delta pay, it’s about making sure this works for American’s Pilot. You would see significant improvements to scheduling related and quality of life items. That means improved trip construction, and more certainty when it comes to replacement flying and recovery obligation.

A deal like this would be a game changer for our pilots. It would be worth more than $7 billion in incremental compensation, benefits, and quality life improvements over the term of the four year agreement. This would allow you to join Delta’s pilots is the industries leader’s in pay, but with more quality of life improvements unique to American Airlines. It’s what you deserve and it can be negotiated and made available quickly. Like you I’m extraordinarily excited about the coming new contract and all that it means for you and American.

As we proceed down the negotiation homestretch, I plan to reach out frequently, share updates and make sure you have the company’s perspective and our unequivocal commitment to completing a new contract expeditiously. I want to assure you that there’s no question of our intent; That is we want you to be paid as well as your peers. We want you to have the quality life and benefits that matter most to you and we don’t want you to have to wait, Now lets get this deal done.

Thanks for listening and thanks for all you do every day.

~Robert Isom


blockplus 03-08-2023 04:37 AM

All the pi’s leaving would be a status quo violation and a job action. Too late… a court would make them stay now.

FlewNavy 03-08-2023 04:46 AM


Originally Posted by andydwyer (Post 3603827)
Back to the “close” part of this. There is a boiling at TK of PIs that have been waiting and waiting, almost all can hold captain in Denver, talk of 45 day notices has risen substantially. News needs to come soon or the more senior of the building will be leaving.

I'm hearing the senior folks saying "I'm waiting on the contract" and the junior/commuters are saying "I'm waiting to see how IE PBS works out". I would not expect significant movement out of the building until after the summer flying season. If we don't have a contract by then the IEs will probably play in the big fall bids setting up next years staffing and then pull the trigger. Nothing happens overnight EXCEPT the flood gates closed when TUMI TA was announced which temporarily solved SKs problem without him spending a dime out of pocket. This is why some form of full retro is important...otherwise he will be getting years and years worth of labor at a discount until a deal is signed.

FlewNavy 03-08-2023 04:53 AM


Originally Posted by blockplus (Post 3603925)
All the pi’s leaving would be a status quo violation and a job action. Too late… a court would make them stay now.

I'm not sure if this is true - the status quo prior to the TUMI TA was continuous river of PIs leaving. Would that data not be considered? The only thing that stopped them from leaving was the conclusion of negotiations and a TA. Staffing stabilized due to massive hiring and the TA vote pending but PIs electing to exercise their bids to return to the line would be a return to the climate that was in place while we were negotiating last year.

WXS15 03-08-2023 05:14 AM


Originally Posted by FlewNavy (Post 3603932)
This is why some form of full retro is important...otherwise he will be getting years and years worth of labor at a discount until a deal is signed.

Even in an unrealistic world where the company agreed to our ask on a compounded and pensionable retro payment to account for the lack of raises in hourly pay rates, they will still have saved money over the last 4 yrs. Unless that retro payment includes compensation for all of the soft pay and QOL improvements that are contained in the new contract, then the company will still have ended up operating at a discount from when it became amendable until DOS. Those items have a significant cost to the company which is why they are a sticking point in the negotiations.

Chuck D 03-08-2023 06:22 AM

Can Isom not actually spell?

Also, PI’s not being allowed to upgrade to Captain as a status quo violation lol.

DashTrash 03-08-2023 06:23 AM


Originally Posted by HSLD (Post 3601216)
It is against the APC Forum Rules for forum users to advocate any labor action which is not authorized by the RLA/NMB. This applies to the advocacy of ANY wildcat actions, including slowdown, work-to-rules, withdrawal of enthusiasm (WOE), sickouts, etc. It is irrelevant whether the union itself has anything to do with the action.

Major unions have lost court cases and in one instance suffered severe financial damage in the process. Online posts, including anonymous posts and posts made here on APC, have been used in lawsuits against unions.

The rules on APC have not changed, but the enforcement will now result in a 30 day ban from APC for violations. Please don't sabotage your own union's efforts to secure industry leading

Thank you…. Thank you…. Thank you!!!! For saying this. I have seen many stupid posts on social media lately because pilots are disappointed with the progress (lack there of) of our negotiations. Status quo is a real thing and has a catalog of case history to support it.

Unfortunately we have many pilots that have not gone through Section 6 negotiations in their past. They don’t understand the peril that they can put on their Union and their pilot groups by saying stupid stuff. Remember, what you say can and will be used against you!!!

We have a rule book that we MUST follow!!!

rvfanatic 03-08-2023 06:42 AM


Originally Posted by blockplus (Post 3603925)
All the pi’s leaving would be a status quo violation and a job action. Too late… a court would make them stay now.

I never advocated for such. I’m just pointing out that taking a job with the hopes of a new contract is dumb. Staying in a seat or airplane after your seat lock is up if you’re not enjoying it with the hopes of a new contract is also dumb.

El Peso 03-08-2023 06:46 AM


Originally Posted by Chuck D (Post 3603993)
Can Isom not actually spell?

Also, PI’s not being allowed to upgrade to Captain as a status quo violation lol.

He didn’t write that, he said that in a video. You’re reading a transcript by someone else, who may or may not be able to spell.

Nucflash 03-08-2023 08:19 AM


Originally Posted by andydwyer (Post 3603827)
Back to the “close” part of this. There is a boiling at TK of PIs that have been waiting and waiting, almost all can hold captain in Denver, talk of 45 day notices has risen substantially. News needs to come soon or the more senior of the building will be leaving.

1. It’s a bit late for that now. There’s only 10 (advertised) DEN 737 CA vacancies for this, the last bid prior to the summer.
2. They’d actually have to fly and be away from home. The thought might not be so appealing when the mouse pointer is hovering over “save” on the vacancy bid screen.

GolferNJ 03-08-2023 10:22 AM


Originally Posted by Nucflash (Post 3604068)
1. It’s a bit late for that now. There’s only 10 (advertised) DEN 737 CA vacancies for this, the last bid prior to the summer.
2. They’d actually have to fly and be away from home. The thought might not be so appealing when the mouse pointer is hovering over “save” on the vacancy bid screen.

1. Instructors have standing bids. They are the SUPs on the category summary. They can exercise their bids whenever they want with the appropriate notice. This vacancy is irrelevant. 2. Many of my friends who are instructors commute to Denver. You'd be surprised how may nights they are away from home.

Sniper66 03-08-2023 10:24 AM

We are very very close

jdavk 03-08-2023 10:54 AM


Originally Posted by andydwyer (Post 3603827)
News needs to come soon or the more senior of the building will be leaving.

The company would probably be happy to replace the senior instructors with cheaper, more junior pilots.

Flyfasteatassss 03-08-2023 11:27 AM


Originally Posted by Sniper66 (Post 3604213)
We are very very close

Elaborate….please

EwrRocks 03-08-2023 11:29 AM


Originally Posted by jdavk (Post 3604256)
The company would probably be happy to replace the senior instructors with cheaper, more junior pilots.

They would be ecstatic to replace them all with way cheaper contract instructors.

jdavk 03-08-2023 12:02 PM


Originally Posted by EwrRocks (Post 3604288)
They would be ecstatic to replace them all with way cheaper contract instructors.

Absolutely correct - 100%.

gollum 03-08-2023 12:39 PM


Originally Posted by Nucflash (Post 3604068)
1. It’s a bit late for that now. There’s only 10 (advertised) DEN 737 CA vacancies for this, the last bid prior to the summer.
2. They’d actually have to fly and be away from home. The thought might not be so appealing when the mouse pointer is hovering over “save” on the vacancy bid screen.

1. most already hold bids for captain In the base they would want to be in if they left TK.

2. Guess you don’t really know how many commute and are away from home anyway.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 02:50 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands