Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/)
-   -   Enormous Cultural Gap. (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/73653-enormous-cultural-gap.html)

Snarge 03-13-2013 10:17 AM


Originally Posted by Poppy (Post 1371132)
OK, we get it you have work rules. Good on you!

BTW, you guys wax poetic about how wonderful your work rules are, and how they are so good that they are worth giving up money for. Now you sound just a little jealous.

I was not trying to rub anyone's nose in it, just trying to point out the holier than thou attitude on the part of some/many of the U posters here that wears a little thin. If you had taken a little time to read my entire post you might have notice a conciliatory gesture regarding the merging of the cultures. Of course that might be difficult-----can you have double wides in ORD??:D


Help me understand here....

You guys had (02) minimal work rules, and make more money. Also meaning, your time off is not always yours... or you can to work when you don't expect to... but you make more money....

What else does CAL bring to the table? I can think of the low number of MELs CAL pilots fly with whereas UAL pilots will operate with more....

What else?

tkhayes90 03-13-2013 10:17 AM


Originally Posted by Poppy (Post 1371037)
You miss the point completely. We are not talking about chump change here. I know FOs at CAL who have made just under 200K for the past 10 years, I know Captains at CAL who have made over 250 for the past several years. All the while your A320 guys were taking it in the shorts. The rest of your pilots, while not as bad, were taking it in the shorts also. I still ask, how do you pay for your child's college with all the stuff that you United guys seem to hold so dear.

BTW,I like all the work rules as much as the next man, but I just can't make a bank deposit with that stuff. No matter how you slice the pie, if the company prices a particular work rule out at $10.00 per flight hour, that is $10/hour less that I make.

By the time that all the work rules kick in, I will have taken a pay cut under this new UPA. Even with the raise next January, it will still be a pay cut. My QOL will be better, but nevertheless, my pay will be less. Not whining by the way, just stating fact. And this illustrates one of the vast cultural differences, we went for the money, and you went for the work rules.

Because they continually prostitute themselves to the company.

Poppy 03-13-2013 10:20 AM


Originally Posted by tkhayes90 (Post 1371158)
Because they continually prostitute themselves to the company.

OK, I get it, if you f... for money just the right amount, you are a wise, virtuous, professional, but if you f... just a little bit more, you are a wh.... What a concept!!!!!!

Poppy 03-13-2013 10:22 AM


Originally Posted by Snarge (Post 1371157)
Help me understand here....

You guys have minimal work rules, and make more money. Also meaning, your time off is not always yours... or you can work when you don't expect you... but you make more money....

What else does CAL bring to the table? I can think of the low number of MELs CAL pilots fly with whereas UAL pilots will operate with more....

What else?

I admit that the reserves got beat up. That was one of my show stoppers for this CBA, even though I have never really been on reserve, and don't plan to in the future.

Aside from that, if you flew over your days, then it was your own fault, and often very profitable.

Snarge 03-13-2013 10:31 AM


Originally Posted by Poppy (Post 1371167)
I admit that the reserves got beat up. That was one of my show stoppers for this CBA, even though I have never really been on reserve, and don't plan to in the future.

Aside from that, if you flew over your days, then it was your own fault, and often very profitable.

Copy that... we are talking about the culture gap.... what else does CAL bring to table that would be attractive to the UAL pilots.... you mentioned work your tail off for a bigger W2.

I mentioned good MX/low MELS on the CAL side...

What else?

LAX Pilot 03-13-2013 10:43 AM


Originally Posted by Snarge (Post 1371174)
Copy that... we are talking about the culture gap.... what else does CAL bring to table that would be attractive to the UAL pilots.... you mentioned work your tail off for a bigger W2.

I mentioned good MX/low MELS on the CAL side...

What else?

Routes and planes. Yes I agree that ultimately there is more upside for sCAL pilots, but they did bring flying to the show. They do have 777's and they have pilots retiring, just not as many as sUAL. Plus they had 787s on order like we did.

We also got the individual leg overs, which is new.

I don't feel for a second it was a bad merger. I'm pretty pleased overall.

Freight Dawg 03-13-2013 11:15 AM


Originally Posted by Snarge (Post 1371073)
yup..... valid point..... UAL pilots loathed the CAL influence in the JCBA that devalued their QOL for money.....

+1

QWL is no. 1 in my book. Nice house you never sleep in F that. Toys you never play with F that. Nice car you only drive to the airport F that.

Sunvox 03-13-2013 12:07 PM


Originally Posted by liquid (Post 1371139)

So now because of your post above EVERY CAL pilot carries open write ups. Not even close to true.

That's what's happened on this thread, what you thought was a simple observation is really NOT that simple.

My post clearly states I do not assume all CAL pilots behave in this manner, but that it is one more piece of personal experience I have that tells me there is a large cultural difference. Not better; not worse. Different. You are putting words in my mouth.





Originally Posted by liquid (Post 1371139)
As for your grievance comments, the great perceived injustice of the CAL system bid.
Have you contacted any of the 400+ UAL pilots working on the CAL side to find out if we're understaffed?
Called manpower planning at CAL?
Read the CAL contract?
The CAL side desperately NEEDS pilots, we have for years. Our reserve pilots work 90+ hours a month in the summer, rolled days off, max duty days, 7 days in a row etc... VJM bulletins ALL summer.
No one ever asked why we had the bid, just that the UAL pilots "deserve" those Captain seats, they belong to UAL. HUH? again does that make sense?

You either have an LEC rep or Grievance rep who likes to hear themselves talk, or someone is feeding you info they shouldn't be


As for the bid grievance, I'm afraid you are missing the logic entirely. No one is questioning the need for pilots, and no one is saying UAL pilots "deserve" anything other than their contractual rights. What is in question is what rules govern any United Airlines pilot vacancy bid now that the UPA has passed.


25-A Amendable Date

This Agreement shall become effective on the date of signing hereof, shall continue in full force and effect through and including January 31, 2017, and shall renew itself without change each succeeding February 1st thereafter unless written notice of intended change is served in accordance with Section 6, Title I, of the Railway Labor Act, as amended, by either party hereto at least thirty (30) days but no more than two hundred seventy (270) days prior to January 31, 2017, or any year thereafter. The parties shall commence direct negotiations with respect to such notice no later than thirty (30) days following the delivery of such notice.


25-B Incorporation of Other Agreements


This Agreement and any Letters of Agreement and Memoranda of Understanding entered into by the parties after the date hereof constitute the sole and entire agreement between the parties while they remain in effect, and shall cancel all Agreements, Supplemental Agreements, Amendments, Letters of Understanding and similar related documents executed between the Company and the Air Line Pilots Association prior to the signing of this Agreement.
Some believe this means neither the TPA nor prior CBAs are in effect. IF that logic holds then the only means of deciding how to implement a bid prior to SLI is through Section 8 and LOA 26. LOA 26 says only the implementation team can decide how to implement a bid and if they can't agree it must go to an arbitrator. This is NOT MY grievance so please do not jump on me personally. I am explaining the logic of the grievance. It is my personal OPINION that the logic is sound, but only some arbitrator in the future will know the answer for sure. We are all United pilots now and any vacancy available to one should be available to all regardless of whether SLI is complete. If that proves problematic then it's up to the Joint Implementation Team to figure out how to resolve the issue, but the company can not unilaterally chose to exclude more than half the pilot population from a large career changing bid simply because it is inconvenient to solve the puzzle. How about 1/2 the bid for each pilot group? How about a temporary list based on relative seniority using the 2010 snapshot? How about delaying the bid until at least September when the SLI is expected to be completed? Anything is better than shutting out more than half the United pilots from a vacancy bid now that we are operating under one unified contract.




NOW THEREFORE, the parties hereto agree as follows:

A General

A-1 This LOA contains the full understandings and complete agreement of the parties regarding the implementation of the terms of the Agreement and the conversion from two separate collective bargaining agreements and two separate flight operations to a single pilot group operating a single operation under a single Agreement.


A-2 Any disputes regarding this LOA that the Joint Implementation Team is unable to resolve shall be referred to a group of four, composed of the MEC Chairmen and two flight operations officials designated by the Company, and if the matter still cannot be resolved, to the dispute resolution procedure identified in Paragraph C of this Letter of Agreement

beeker 03-13-2013 01:36 PM


Originally Posted by Poppy (Post 1371144)
If we are going to talk about B737 window washers on the L-Cal side, do we get to talk about the brain surgeons on the L-Ual side?:rolleyes:

Fake Doctor: Pilot Duped AMA With Fake M.D. Claim

You mean cardiologist.

tailwheel48 03-13-2013 01:55 PM

This is the most ridiculous thread I've yet seen on this board! Clearly the original author must be suffering from low self-esteem if he feels it necessary to slander the other group, in an effort to make himself feel better!

Neither group is superior to the other!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:09 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands