Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/)
-   -   Lufthansa United (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/united/96405-lufthansa-united.html)

buscappy 12-31-2016 06:37 PM

no one will ever know what various folks would have done had the strike gone longer than 29 days. some striking United pilots would likely have returned to work (there were many who were on the verge); more fleet qual 75/50 folks would likely have been hired; some (or many) 570 might have showed up at ops ready to IOE (we will never know their true intentions back then. some today "doth protest too much" it seems).
there was a narrow line between the stampede of pilots back to Lorenzo's jets and the cohesion of pilots on pickets against Ferris.
as far as this off-thread thread goes, though, the 570 will forever be "questionable" as to what they would have done.
and for tie-tacker maniacs out there - many tie-tackers crossed and went to work; many pilots who didn't wear the tie tack stayed home and didn't fly a trip. symbology and actions don't always align when tough decision time comes.....

Regularguy 01-01-2017 05:09 AM

For all you know it alls who keep calling 570s potential SCABS and make comparisons between UAL 85 and CAL 83, well your wrong.

Here's the truths to put in your pockets:

1. The 570 who honored the strike were not SCABS.

2. CAL strike was declared with zero prep and was a response to 50% pay cuts unilaterally declared through, what is now illegal, the wrongful use of BK laws by an evil and self serving man, Lorenzo.

3. The UAL strike was declared through proper preparation and fully legal Railway Labor act processes. Both sides, management and union, used and applied the laws within their legal rights.

4. Had the UAL strike become long and drawn out many speculations about pilots crossing, becoming SCABS, and the hiring of outside pilots would certainly have become true. But it didn't and any conversation about whom those would have been are purely chest thumping and demeaning to those who make such declarations.

No I'm not a 570, I was there carrying a sign and did not cross the UAL line.

It's time you SCAB name callers let it go and enjoy your high pay and the luxuries of your legally negotiated contract. But remember you too may be asked to give it all up in defense of the contract that gave it to you.

krudawg 01-01-2017 05:33 AM


Originally Posted by tailwheel48 (Post 2272378)
The 570's are scab wannabes. They show up to interview at an airline going through a labor dispute - just like the guys showed up at Continental in 83.

Fortunately for them the strike was short-lived and they never had the opportunity to cross the picket line.

If the strike had lasted 3 years instead of 3 weeks they would have crossed the picket line in droves.

So, technically not scabs, just scab wannabes.

Scab this Scab that, what the h3ll are you talking about? The 570 got letters from United which said they are building a pool of qualified pilots for anticipated expansion. I got the same letter. It said that "upon successful interview process you will be sent to flight engineer training, if you pass the training you will be issued a Flight Engineer Certificate and then released from United and placed in a hiring pool. YOU ARE UNDER NO OBLIGATION TO UNITED AND ARE FREE TO SEEK EMPLOYMENT ELSEWHERE" I did get that letter but because there was no job offer contingent upon completion of training,I sent United a letter stating I will be unable to accept their offer because I could not get a leave of absence from my current employer. I had absolutely no clue they were hiring for a scab pool, I took the letter for what it was - A free Flight Engineer Certificate with no offer of employment. Over 570 people were in a position to take United up on the offer. Sometime during their training, they learned from ALpa what was going on. To their credit, 570 pilots refused to cross the picket line, a small minority crossed and scabbed. Many continue to minimize the courage of those 570 for standing shoulder to shoulder with the striking ALPA pilots for reasons unknown to me. When the strike was over, the 570 went to work and the harassment they received from Company management pilots was legendary. You want to talk about scabs, go talk about scabs but never say the 570 were scabs.

pilotgolfer 01-01-2017 02:28 PM


Originally Posted by krudawg (Post 2272650)
Scab this Scab that, what the h3ll are you talking about? The 570 got letters from United which said they are building a pool of qualified pilots for anticipated expansion. I got the same letter. It said that "upon successful interview process you will be sent to flight engineer training, if you pass the training you will be issued a Flight Engineer Certificate and then released from United and placed in a hiring pool. YOU ARE UNDER NO OBLIGATION TO UNITED AND ARE FREE TO SEEK EMPLOYMENT ELSEWHERE" I did get that letter but because there was no job offer contingent upon completion of training,I sent United a letter stating I will be unable to accept their offer because I could not get a leave of absence from my current employer. I had absolutely no clue they were hiring for a scab pool, I took the letter for what it was - A free Flight Engineer Certificate with no offer of employment. Over 570 people were in a position to take United up on the offer. Sometime during their training, they learned from ALpa what was going on. To their credit, 570 pilots refused to cross the picket line, a small minority crossed and scabbed. Many continue to minimize the courage of those 570 for standing shoulder to shoulder with the striking ALPA pilots for reasons unknown to me. When the strike was over, the 570 went to work and the harassment they received from Company management pilots was legendary. You want to talk about scabs, go talk about scabs but never say the 570 were scabs.

So they were offering "free" FE Certificates with no strings attached? That's a new twist I've not heard before.

buscappy 01-01-2017 04:50 PM


Originally Posted by pilotgolfer (Post 2272866)
So they were offering "free" FE Certificates with no strings attached? That's a new twist I've not heard before.


shack

the 570 were to fly as FE for the Fleet Qual captains (75) and copilots (50)
and for whoever crossed from United.

very few crossed. the fleet qual weren't thru sims and ioe yet. and the 570 were holed up in a hotel waiting to see the next moves.

and afa and alpa cut a deal and settled and returned just before the levy broke...




it was pretty well understood

ItnStln 01-01-2017 05:46 PM


Originally Posted by Probe (Post 2176576)
The rest of the world, including Europe and Australia, put 250 hour pilots in the right seat of a narrow body.

There's at least one in Europe who puts them in the right seat of a wide body.

syd111 01-01-2017 07:42 PM


Originally Posted by buscappy (Post 2272542)
no one will ever know what various folks would have done had the strike gone longer than 29 days. some striking United pilots would likely have returned to work (there were many who were on the verge); more fleet qual 75/50 folks would likely have been hired; some (or many) 570 might have showed up at ops ready to IOE (we will never know their true intentions back then. some today "doth protest too much" it seems).
there was a narrow line between the stampede of pilots back to Lorenzo's jets and the cohesion of pilots on pickets against Ferris.
as far as this off-thread thread goes, though, the 570 will forever be "questionable" as to what they would have done.
and for tie-tacker maniacs out there - many tie-tackers crossed and went to work; many pilots who didn't wear the tie tack stayed home and didn't fly a trip. symbology and actions don't always align when tough decision time comes.....

You have no idea what you are talking about.

syd111 01-01-2017 07:50 PM


Originally Posted by tailwheel48 (Post 2272378)
The 570's are scab wannabes. They show up to interview at an airline going through a labor dispute - just like the guys showed up at Continental in 83.

Fortunately for them the strike was short-lived and they never had the opportunity to cross the picket line.

If the strike had lasted 3 years instead of 3 weeks they would have crossed the picket line in droves.

So, technically not scabs, just scab wannabes.

Geez do you even work at UAL or in the industry?

Regularguy 01-01-2017 08:23 PM

You all need to stop pontificating about the 85 strike, 570, fleet quals and anything associated with it, because you are showing your ignorance of the subject.

The strike is long over and most of you were not even flying airplanes when it happened so move on please.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:01 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands