Airline Pilot Central Forums
4  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  24 
Page 14 of 31
Go to

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Delta (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/delta/)
-   -   New Contract Opener 22 Dec 15 (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/delta/92342-new-contract-opener-22-dec-15-a.html)

Elliot 12-28-2015 03:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Timbo (Post 2035652)
What bothers me most about our last counter proposal was the lack of restoring our DB value. 18% DC won't begin to be enough for the Dead Zone to replace the value of the DB plan that part of our deferred compensation, but was taken from us.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Commando (Post 2035911)
If you want a DB plan then you should have gone to FDX or UPS.

http://gifrific.com/wp-content/uploa...miling-SNL.gif

OldFlyGuy 12-28-2015 03:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BobZ (Post 2036012)
Would it help?..... not if the airline revisits bankruptcy.

But as a going concern.... absolutely.

Tim is looking for tangible return on the surrendered DB. Its not likely to happen..... but the LEAST the CBA responsible for constructing and perpetuating such a failed economic model should be required to do..... is at least attempt to prevent any further losses for the membership that has paid so dearly for alpas galactic incompetence.

Apparently not enough people asked for this item as it didn't make it on the list. I'm not sure exactly how we would calculate the "loss." My own math counts both Claim and Note monies and the PBGC $; some would not. Last I checked the single employer PBGC is about 75% funded and that is what I use. Backstopping the future PBGC payments would be the "right thing to do," but I'm not holding my breath. OFG

Big E 757 12-28-2015 06:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OldFlyGuy (Post 2036033)
Apparently not enough people asked for this item as it didn't make it on the list. I'm not sure exactly how we would calculate the "loss." My own math counts both Claim and Note monies and the PBGC $; some would not. Last I checked the single employer PBGC is about 75% funded and that is what I use. Backstopping the future PBGC payments would be the "right thing to do," but I'm not holding my breath. OFG


Couldn't Delta just take out an insurance policy in the event of a PBGC failure? Kind of like the golf outings that offer a car if you make a hole in one on a par 3? They don't buy the car, they buy an insurance policy! Just in case someone actually drains one. I'm sure we could find an insurance company to underwrite it. Determine the risk, and estimate how much money it would take to cover what we have coming from the PBGC.

Personally, I'm not counting on the money being there when I retire, but it sure would be nice to believe it's going to be there.

Purple Drank 12-28-2015 06:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Commando (Post 2035911)
If you want a DB plan then you should have gone to FDX or UPS.

backside of the clock flying --> shorter life span --> DB pays out for a shorter time.

BobZ 12-28-2015 07:49 PM

OFG.......The criminal shame of it all is for $50M/year and a CBA called THE AIRLINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION....... filled with financial and legal experts......NO ONE SHOULD HAVE TO BE ASKING FOR THIS ON A CONTRACT SURVEY.

This is a national issue. The signatory party to alpa pilots working agreements is ALPA.......That is where the gatekeeper resides for this issue.

ANY airline that used bankptcy to relegate an alpa pilot groups pension to the insolvent pbgc should be held accountable in backstopping that benefit payment.

We are not talking about defunct, fragmented carriers..... we are talking about viable multi-billion profitable corporations that USED bankruptcy for arguably the EXPRESS PURPOSE of shedding pension obligations...

If alpa refuses to ratify a Ta without this provison....it can get dun.

badflaps 12-29-2015 03:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Commando (Post 2035911)
If you want a DB plan then you should have gone to FDX or UPS.

Of course.. Why didn't I think of that?.... Oh! Now I remember, neither aviation departments existed then... Sheeesh...

forgot to bid 12-29-2015 05:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by badflaps (Post 2036228)
Of course.. Why didn't I think of that?.... Oh! Now I remember, neither aviation departments existed then... Sheeesh...

Not to mention Timbo was here for 2 decades or more before the pension was cancelled.

OldFlyGuy 12-29-2015 06:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BobZ (Post 2036153)
OFG.......The criminal shame of it all is for $50M/year and a CBA called THE AIRLINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION....... filled with financial and legal experts......NO ONE SHOULD HAVE TO BE ASKING FOR THIS ON A CONTRACT SURVEY.

This is a national issue. The signatory party to alpa pilots working agreements is ALPA.......That is where the gatekeeper resides for this issue.

ANY airline that used bankptcy to relegate an alpa pilot groups pension to the insolvent pbgc should be held accountable in backstopping that benefit payment.

We are not talking about defunct, fragmented carriers..... we are talking about viable multi-billion profitable corporations that USED bankruptcy for arguably the EXPRESS PURPOSE of shedding pension obligations...

If alpa refuses to ratify a Ta without this provison....it can get dun.

Well Z, When they canned the DB DL made the case they couldn't restructure AND maintain the DB plan and PBGC bought it. Doing the "right thing" now and "what's legally required" now might be quite different. I don't know how successful anyone has been at post-termination efforts, but obviously DL can afford a fix.. I just doubt they will. I think we are truly in a weird position. Plan terminated and a few years later the company is minting money. Hmm. We should at least ask. OFG

Turbo1 12-29-2015 07:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BobZ (Post 2036153)
OFG.......The criminal shame of it all is for $50M/year and a CBA called THE AIRLINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION....... filled with financial and legal experts......NO ONE SHOULD HAVE TO BE ASKING FOR THIS ON A CONTRACT SURVEY.

This is a national issue. The signatory party to alpa pilots working agreements is ALPA.......That is where the gatekeeper resides for this issue.

ANY airline that used bankptcy to relegate an alpa pilot groups pension to the insolvent pbgc should be held accountable in backstopping that benefit payment.

We are not talking about defunct, fragmented carriers..... we are talking about viable multi-billion profitable corporations that USED bankruptcy for arguably the EXPRESS PURPOSE of shedding pension obligations...

If alpa refuses to ratify a Ta without this provison....it can get dun.

we should be listening to this guy....he speaketh with straight tongue....

BobZ 12-29-2015 07:46 AM

OFG because of thru criminally incompetent manner in which alpa had structured our DB plan..... with nearly half the benefit streaming from current year operating revenues..... just like fuel and leases..... it was an argument any 5 year old could have made to the court and prevailed.

That is why.... the morning after the bk filing..... the very first operating expense the corporation asked the court to terminate..... was the payment of the unqualified portion of the pension plan.

And the retired guys got zeroed out immediately.

What I am advocating is an effort to prevent history from repeating itself..... again.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:53 PM.
4  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  24 
Page 14 of 31
Go to


User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons

Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.

Website Copyright ©2000 - 2017 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands