don't worry, I'm doing my part to ensure Worrall doesn't get back in. :D

Let''s say you're right and 70% of ATL pilots preferred Malone. Even if that's the case (and it might not be), why do you think 100% of the reps should have voted form him?

What about the 30-40% of ATL pilots who wanted Bartells?

He only thinks of himself. He doesn't understand that everyone has different wants/needs. Personally if I told my rep I wanted BB and they voted for JM I'd feel like he doesn't represent my beliefs but I wouldn't take it to a recall. They have the whole picture.

If 70% was the case, (likely much higher than that) then a 3-1 vote would have been more reasonable similar to the TA vote. 50/50 vote is rediculous for as much support as JM has in 44.

False. You and tunes are like Bert and Ernie. You see one you see the other wherever I post. I expand the team to gather info. Both Capt Reps have stated publically, the feedback they received had OVERWHELMING support for JM.

If that's your logic, you should recall just one of the Reps. :)


What evidence do you have that Malone likely had more support than 70% of ATL pilots?

The sad thing is beyond a moakie power grab this screams "pulling up the ladder" You have Captains, Trip7, who are attempting to recall FO reps. These FO reps are looking out for the younger pilots long term (which should include Trip) but the Captains don't want to rock the boat so they are recalling them. This is my opinion.

There is no evidence of specific numbers. The evidence we have is the statement of overwhelming support in feedback received by the Captain reps. Notice how the FO reps don't mention feedback in their decision but more their thought process after "interviewing" JM and BB. Yet in the C44 update prior to the election all CK and JJ stated were give me your input while both SD and SM gave detailed analysis about who they planned to vote for. It's clear that the majority of 44 preferred JM and the FO reps ignored it for their own agenda

Do you think perhaps the Captain reps received their feedback from mostly Captains? So 50% of the base. I'm sure the FOs talk to their own reps.

Their own reps? Do only FOs vote for FO reps and vice versa for Capts in elections/recalls? You're on quite a streak here with this and your company will unilaterally impose 9:45 post:rolleyes:

So, why do reps vote and not the pilots?

I always chuckle at pilots who want their reps to lead by taking polls. That's not how leasership works. At least where I come from.