UA verse AA
#96
Line Holder
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 670
Likes: 1
From my outside the company perspective it seems like all the UAL talk of adding capacity hasnt resulted in more pilots being hired. There aren't any classes posted for Jan yet. Meanwhile AA has announced officially 925 new hires and has scheduled pilots for Jan class dates and has Feb class dates on the books.
I do keep reading about new RJ's at UAL though.
I do keep reading about new RJ's at UAL though.
Having said all that, the mgmt plan is either going to take off soon (pun intended), or capacity growth will stall and wall street will be the first to get notified. New mgmt has not been ambiguous about saying UAL's previous shrinkage was a bad idea, so if you had to pick a legacy that will offer the most relative seniority progression over the next few years due to SL expansion, UAL is what I'd bet on.
#97
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 6,418
Likes: 120
From: Window seat
“so if you had to pick a legacy that will offer the most relative seniority progression over the next few years due to SL expansion, UAL is what I'd bet on.“
Alex - for $500 I’ll take “which legacy offers the best relative seniority gain?”
17/22/27/32 yr seniotity number forecast, early 2027 data, using APC’s data -
AA - 4500/2000/950/400
UA - 5100/2550/1250/650
DL - 6500/4350/3000/1700
Alex - for $500 I’ll take “which legacy offers the best relative seniority gain?”
17/22/27/32 yr seniotity number forecast, early 2027 data, using APC’s data -
AA - 4500/2000/950/400
UA - 5100/2550/1250/650
DL - 6500/4350/3000/1700
Last edited by Sliceback; 12-10-2017 at 08:38 AM. Reason: Added “Alex”
#98
Line Holder
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 670
Likes: 1
“so if you had to pick a legacy that will offer the most relative seniority progression over the next few years due to SL expansion, UAL is what I'd bet on.“
Alex - for $500 I’ll take “which legacy offers the best relative seniority gain?”
17/22/27/32 yr seniotity number forecast, early 2027 data, using APC’s data -
AA - 4500/2000/950/400
UA - 5100/2550/1250/650
DL - 6500/4350/3000/1700
Alex - for $500 I’ll take “which legacy offers the best relative seniority gain?”
17/22/27/32 yr seniotity number forecast, early 2027 data, using APC’s data -
AA - 4500/2000/950/400
UA - 5100/2550/1250/650
DL - 6500/4350/3000/1700
#99
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 6,418
Likes: 120
From: Window seat
For the next 8 yrs AA has more retirements, both as a percentage and actual count.
Your first statement related to relative seniority gain. The data doesn’t support your statement that UA’s relative gain exceeds AA’s.
UA’s larger w/b total makes your second statement, using a different comparison, perhaps true. Using today's bidding patterns guys might be CA’s at AA in five years. 3,600+ retirements, 25% of the list, in the next five years makes that possible. All it will take is 2% more retirements in the next five years, vs the planned retirements, as well as everyone having the same bidding patterns in the future.
Your second comparison, using w/b FO’s, is tricker. We don’t have UA’s G4 data. In five years only 3 of 9 G4 FO bid statuses will at AA be available to a current newhire using today’s bidding/planning data. In six years it advances to 5 of 9 due to retirements and in 7 yrs it will be 9 of 9.
You’re also assuming UA will expand faster than DL or AA in the next five years? Has a management mentioned that?
Your first statement related to relative seniority gain. The data doesn’t support your statement that UA’s relative gain exceeds AA’s.
UA’s larger w/b total makes your second statement, using a different comparison, perhaps true. Using today's bidding patterns guys might be CA’s at AA in five years. 3,600+ retirements, 25% of the list, in the next five years makes that possible. All it will take is 2% more retirements in the next five years, vs the planned retirements, as well as everyone having the same bidding patterns in the future.
Your second comparison, using w/b FO’s, is tricker. We don’t have UA’s G4 data. In five years only 3 of 9 G4 FO bid statuses will at AA be available to a current newhire using today’s bidding/planning data. In six years it advances to 5 of 9 due to retirements and in 7 yrs it will be 9 of 9.
You’re also assuming UA will expand faster than DL or AA in the next five years? Has a management mentioned that?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



