Delta Ponders Pilot Sources
#111
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 6,434
Likes: 124
From: Window seat
Depending on which FAA spreadsheets you look at comm/ATP growth is as high as 3% in the last decade, or up to a 22% reduction.
Very interesting is the 2009 drop in Table 18 (additional certificates issued). 2009 comm/ATP dropped 16% in one year, and is 36% lower than 2000/2001.
Very interesting is the 2009 drop in Table 18 (additional certificates issued). 2009 comm/ATP dropped 16% in one year, and is 36% lower than 2000/2001.
#112
Skyhigh -
Your average legacy value($2.625 mil/30 yrs) works out to be $87K per year. Obviously it's wrong. Avg salary(w/o benefits) data for 2009 -
DL - 138K
AA - 138K
UA - 125K
CO - 150K
US - 111K
SW - 176K
JB - 125K
AS - 163K
AT - 104K
Your $10 million/30 yrs seems high. That would equal $333,000 per year as an average. Even if you subtract benefits(20-40%) the quoted average pay is significantly above what Captain's pay used to be. Early 1990's w/b pay was around $140-150K for n/b's and $160-170 for 767 class a/c.
Your average legacy value($2.625 mil/30 yrs) works out to be $87K per year. Obviously it's wrong. Avg salary(w/o benefits) data for 2009 -
DL - 138K
AA - 138K
UA - 125K
CO - 150K
US - 111K
SW - 176K
JB - 125K
AS - 163K
AT - 104K
Your $10 million/30 yrs seems high. That would equal $333,000 per year as an average. Even if you subtract benefits(20-40%) the quoted average pay is significantly above what Captain's pay used to be. Early 1990's w/b pay was around $140-150K for n/b's and $160-170 for 767 class a/c.
50% of pilots are Captains and 50% are FO's. It is reasonable to assume that half a pilots career at a legacy will be in the right seat and the other half in the left seat. I used the average between the two to come up with an annual average wage then multiplied over 30 years. It is inaccurate to only look at top captain wages.
As pilots we are seduced by the promise of the 20 year captain salary. The reality is that those years comprise only a small portion of ones career. The rest is in much lower ranks of income. The entire career needs to be evaluated.
Ten years in college and as a flight instructor is off set by ten years captain salary at 140K. The average is often less than that of a mailman.
Skyhigh
Last edited by SkyHigh; 04-24-2011 at 07:51 AM.
#113
Many here are more than half way through their careers and have enjoyed times when when wages were better. My calculations are projected into the future. From the perspective of a new pilot who is starting college in the fall. What are their prospects?
I am glad that many here have enjoyed better careers than I however my interest is in the future not the past. How are new pilots supposed to afford the cost of college and flight training in light of a profession that is on a path to continue loosing ground?
Skyhigh
I am glad that many here have enjoyed better careers than I however my interest is in the future not the past. How are new pilots supposed to afford the cost of college and flight training in light of a profession that is on a path to continue loosing ground?
Skyhigh
#114
Depending on which FAA spreadsheets you look at comm/ATP growth is as high as 3% in the last decade, or up to a 22% reduction.
Very interesting is the 2009 drop in Table 18 (additional certificates issued). 2009 comm/ATP dropped 16% in one year, and is 36% lower than 2000/2001.
Very interesting is the 2009 drop in Table 18 (additional certificates issued). 2009 comm/ATP dropped 16% in one year, and is 36% lower than 2000/2001.
When I was at a regional they intentionally hired 300 hour guys over experienced pilots and it made me wonder. Why would they do that? I think the reason is that they want to hire low timers to save money.
Legacy carriers are no different. They have been loosing billions over the last ten years. The way forward lies in cutting costs to survive. Whatever it takes to secure lower pilot wages will be pursued.
Skyhigh
#115
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Oct 2010
Posts: 123
Likes: 0
From: New to mother D
If you really want to compare, lets compare us to similar professionals...like medical doctors....
Lets look at why doctors are paid much higher than us? Not because they are more valuable. It is because they have one of the most powerful lobbies in the US. Much more powerful than ALPA. The AMA controls the number of med. school seats in the US and they are very good at controlling supply through various means.
Lets look at why doctors are paid much higher than us? Not because they are more valuable. It is because they have one of the most powerful lobbies in the US. Much more powerful than ALPA. The AMA controls the number of med. school seats in the US and they are very good at controlling supply through various means.
So, a whole new path to a medical profession has exploded in the last 15 with a number of similar effects. While it's harder to get a more prestigious Residency (Surgery, etc.) as a D.O., they have flooded the family practice ranks and have substantially degraded the pay in the family practice market, drastically reducing the income. Yeah, they can't put M.D. behind their name, and in most case they are not the quality candidates their M.D. brothers are, nor did they make it through such a rigorous weeding process... but they get to say they're doctors!
A secondary effect these guys have on the industry- D.O. Schools are substantially more expensive than M.D. schools, which increases the load of their student loans. When they finish training, many of them have to take the first job that comes get cracking on those loans, regardless of pay, etc.
In fact, some jobs once done by medical doctors have been completely undercut. If you get an operation, instead of an Anesthesiologist, you'll likely be put under by a Nurse Anesthetist. A whole career path that used to belong to Medical Doctors is now on it's way to being totally outsourced to less trained and lower paid people who are willing to work for less.
Anyone else see any parallels?
#116
The big picture is that the legacy airlines have been in full retreat over the last 30 years. Giants have been ground into dust in that time. One time stalwarts of the industry are merged and shrunk on a continuing basis.
All the while the regionals and low cost carriers take over the industry. Anyone who has 30 or more years ahead of themselves in this profession should have grave concerns about their future.
So far nothing real is on the horizon to suggest that wages or conditions will get better. Airlines have proved that they will go to great lengths to keep downward pressure on wages. It is the only way to get ahead in the modern corporate world. The company with the lowest costs will win.
Skyhigh
All the while the regionals and low cost carriers take over the industry. Anyone who has 30 or more years ahead of themselves in this profession should have grave concerns about their future.
So far nothing real is on the horizon to suggest that wages or conditions will get better. Airlines have proved that they will go to great lengths to keep downward pressure on wages. It is the only way to get ahead in the modern corporate world. The company with the lowest costs will win.
Skyhigh
#117
I like this web site:
What Flying Was Like In The 1960s
It chronicles the glory of airlines past and shows how far we are from the good old days. The author concludes that ticket prices were four times more expensive in the 1960's than today. The only way to significantly raise pilot wages is to bring up ticket prices.
Even a slight increase in prices has a massive effect upon demand. Flying is barely tolerable as it is with TSA and all the hassles that go with flying. In addition there is a lot of competition that the airlines did not have in the 1960s; teleconferencing, the national highway system and a failing economy. Double ticket prices and I believe that passengers will disappear.
Our industry is propagated by $69 ticket prices. An entire generation of Americans are use to jumping on a jet to fly 1000 miles to attend a dinner party. All that will go away with a significant increase in prices and so will go most of the job market for pilots.
Skip the flight to grandmas house and buy her an XBox with Kinect instead. They you can visit all you want for free.
Syhigh
What Flying Was Like In The 1960s
It chronicles the glory of airlines past and shows how far we are from the good old days. The author concludes that ticket prices were four times more expensive in the 1960's than today. The only way to significantly raise pilot wages is to bring up ticket prices.
Even a slight increase in prices has a massive effect upon demand. Flying is barely tolerable as it is with TSA and all the hassles that go with flying. In addition there is a lot of competition that the airlines did not have in the 1960s; teleconferencing, the national highway system and a failing economy. Double ticket prices and I believe that passengers will disappear.
Our industry is propagated by $69 ticket prices. An entire generation of Americans are use to jumping on a jet to fly 1000 miles to attend a dinner party. All that will go away with a significant increase in prices and so will go most of the job market for pilots.
Skip the flight to grandmas house and buy her an XBox with Kinect instead. They you can visit all you want for free.
Syhigh
Last edited by SkyHigh; 04-24-2011 at 08:53 AM.
#118
China Visa Applicant
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 1,964
Likes: 16
From: Midfield downwind
I like this web site:
What Flying Was Like In The 1960s
It chronicles the glory of airlines past and shows how far we are from the good old days.
What Flying Was Like In The 1960s
It chronicles the glory of airlines past and shows how far we are from the good old days.
Looks to me like it's always been a completely screwed up career, and the flavor just changes by decade.
#119
Which is why there will be plenty of guys flying overseas. The US doesn't lead in ANY airline pilot category. Not pay, not work rules, not even soft issues like prestige.
The only real benefit in the US is commuting to your job in another state.
The only real benefit in the US is commuting to your job in another state.
#120
50% of pilots are Captains and 50% are FO's. It is reasonable to assume that half a pilots career at a legacy will be in the right seat and the other half in the left seat. I used the average between the two to come up with an annual average wage then multiplied over 30 years. It is inaccurate to only look at top captain wages.
As pilots we are seduced by the promise of the 20 year captain salary. The reality is that those years comprise only a small portion of ones career. The rest is in much lower ranks of income. The entire career needs to be evaluated.
Ten years in college and as a flight instructor is off set by ten years captain salary at 140K. The average is often less than that of a mailman.
Skyhigh
As pilots we are seduced by the promise of the 20 year captain salary. The reality is that those years comprise only a small portion of ones career. The rest is in much lower ranks of income. The entire career needs to be evaluated.
Ten years in college and as a flight instructor is off set by ten years captain salary at 140K. The average is often less than that of a mailman.
Skyhigh
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
wannabepilot
Flight Schools and Training
34
07-07-2008 12:15 PM
Carl Spackler
Mergers and Acquisitions
495
06-28-2008 06:11 PM



