Go Back  Airline Pilot Central Forums > Career Builder > Military
Military vs. airlines >

Military vs. airlines

Search
Notices
Military Military Aviation

Military vs. airlines

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 10-30-2013, 08:18 AM
  #21  
Runs with scissors
 
Timbo's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Dec 2009
Position: Going to hell in a bucket, but enjoying the ride .
Posts: 7,722
Default

With only 350 hours, you'll have to do something to build time before you will be airline eligible. Joining the Guard/Reserves is a great way to build time, they pay a lot better than instructing, and you'll get top notch pilot training, for free, (heck, they PAY YOU for lessons!).

When you return from UPT, you'll be free to pursue other flying jobs to build more time, quickly, and you'll have a great fall back job if/when you get furloughed from the airlines.
Timbo is offline  
Old 10-30-2013, 08:20 AM
  #22  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,083
Default

Originally Posted by SmilinJack View Post
Hello all,
I'm fixing to start a career in flying. I am unsure whether or not flying for the military is a good idea at this point whether its Airforce,Marines,Navy or ANG. I grew up wanting to be a fighter pilot, it has always been a lifelong goal of mine. I was heavily influenced by my grandfather who flew F-9's in the Navy during Korea. I am about to graduate college with a 3.5 gpa, I have around 300 hours with a CFI, II, and MEI, and no pinkslips or anything like that. I don't think I will have a problem with flight training if I get accepted, Im just not sure if its a good idea considering the pilot shortage that is fixing to start up with the airlines.
I guess what I am asking is, what the best course of action would be. My instructor is ex-airforce and tells me that going ANG up in Wyoming would be his first choice. I am extremely afraid of getting in and getting stuck on a UAV or something of that nature, and missing out on the hiring boom.
Any advise would be greatly appreciated
Thanks, Joe
Joe, there's a lot of good advice on this thread and a lot of different opinions... I'll give you mine.

1) You have yet to graduate from college and only think you know what you want. I know lots of pilots who joined the military to fly as a means to an airline job or avoiding the infantry during the Vietnam era draft who wound up making the military a career. I just joined as an exciting way to serve my country for a few years and no intention of being career military or an airline pilot. Almost three decades later, I'm retired from the reserves (after over a decade of AD [Active Duty]) and an airline captain. Life doesn't go the way you planned.

2) I'll go against the consensus here and suggest you look at AD service. There are lots of pitfalls (stifling bureaucracy, absurd regulations, long hours, careerist senior officers, to name a few) but you'll make decent money, get the best training in the world and be surrounded by the finest people you'll ever work with. The experience is character building if nothing else. Admittedly, the ANG/AFR offer most of the advantages of AD with few of the disadvantages, but don't dismiss AD out of hand. As far as going straight civilian, I wouldn't trade my mil time for a decade of seniority.

I was on the DC-10 flying with a 40ish captain who was only a few years older than me when we flew over a low level route I used to fly well below the trees at well over 400 knots. I finished my musing with the statement it probably wasn't very smart. He countered with how he would have loved to have traded careers with me.

3) If you go to the reserves it's best to live near both your military and civilian job. Frequently that's impossible, but at least live near one of your jobs. I've never seen anyone commute to both jobs for any length of time and have never heard of anyone doing it while holding a family together.

4) Just 'cause you've got a whopping 300 plus hours and some ratings, don't assume military flight school will be a snap, no matter what your ex-AF IP tells you. I've seen pilots with better quals wash out. To put it into perspective, for me, having a Marine DI scream at you and work you to exhaustion for a few months was a walk in the park compared to the rigors and stress of flight school.

Also, don't fall into the fighters or nothing mindset. Some of your selection will be determined by skill and some by luck beyond your control. Heavy drivers do some cool stuff and while helos might take longer to get the airline job, that's probably some of the most challenging flying available.

Just some food for thought, Joe. Good luck with your career... no matter where it takes you.
XHooker is offline  
Old 10-30-2013, 08:53 AM
  #23  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Adlerdriver's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Jul 2007
Position: 767 Captain
Posts: 3,988
Default

Originally Posted by flynutt View Post
Are you saying to live near your Guard/Reserve job? How about living in your domicile and commuting to the part-time job? That way, especially being junior, you can sit reserve from home.
Some additional thoughts: I spent most of my time commuting to the guard (not by choice, long story). For a fighter unit, that's definitely the more difficult option. I was also commuting to my airline job, so double whammy.

There are pros/cons to both ways of doing it. Some of the factors depend on your Guard unit. Some units require members to live within a specific radius - so decision made. Others (like mine was) were much more flexible, providing hotels for members who resided more than 50 miles away.

Other factors involve your unit's aircraft/mission. A fighter unit is typically very dependent on the local weather. Weather cancelling an entire day's flying because every MOA within 300 miles is socked in and your airport's weather requires higher IFR bingos can happen frequently. If you're showing up to fly a tanker mission or a multi-day cargo trip, you probably have a much higher chance that it's going. If you can count on the military flying actually happening most of the time and fit that into a reserve airline schedule, it may make sense to live in domicile and commute to the guard.

You commute to you guard fighter unit and you've blocked off 6 days of duty that month in addition to your normal airline schedule. You're going there for 3 days over drill weekend and another 3 some other time in the month. If the weather tanks over drill, you're going to have to make another trip or stay longer on your next one (unless drill is your second fly period). Other commuters are in the same boat, so you may be scrambling to find days with available sorties. Scheduling extra days means you're going to have to eat up days off with the family (maybe you only had 8 to start with) or mil dropping airline trips taking a significant financial hit (depending on mil pay vs airline).

If you lived near your unit, finding extra fly days would be minor problem. You can go in when it suits you and fly. There are always short notice "holes" in the schedule due to commuter issues, sickness, other conflicts. Nothing going on at home, wife is OTR, kids at school - go in and grab a morning BFM sortie because a commuter didn't make it into town or they need an IP. You can be home in time to meet the kids off the bus.

One other factor depends on your airline, hiring/movement and pay scales there. If you're junior at your airline and on reserve, chances are you make more money flying in the guard. If things are stagnant at your airline and will be for years, all the more reason to live near your unit and commute to the airline. Would you rather sit reserve in a crash pad away from home or fly a fighter for more money and be home those nights? You drop more R days, fly more at the guard, make more money and you're home more. Once you hold a line, you'll have more days off than a pilot on reserve and it is usually easier to manage both schedules. It's a lot easier to squeeze in local training sorties without disrupting your airline schedule when you live near your guard unit.
Adlerdriver is offline  
Old 10-30-2013, 10:10 PM
  #24  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Caution Terrain's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Apr 2012
Position: PLEASE ADVISE
Posts: 339
Default

Originally Posted by Adlerdriver View Post
You drop more R days, fly more at the guard, make more money and you're home more. Once you hold a line, you'll have more days off than a pilot on reserve and it is usually easier to manage both schedules. It's a lot easier to squeeze in local training sorties without disrupting your airline schedule when you live near your guard unit.
dude, sounds like the berries to me.
Caution Terrain is offline  
Old 10-31-2013, 05:21 AM
  #25  
What’s it doing now?
 
Joined APC: Mar 2011
Position: 190CA
Posts: 726
Default

I'll add my experience, since I faced a similar decision and made the civilian choice.

I graduated from college in 07 and at the time guys were getting picked up by regionals with 500 hours or so. I decided not to pursue military even though it was something I wanted. 10 years seemed like a long time to me when I was 20. It's not.

In a year I got all my ratings and a few hundred hours of instruction and had two interviews scheduled. Comair and eagle. They both called in the summer of 08 and cancelled the interviews. I spent the next 2 years being a cfi/cfii/mei until a bottom tier turboprop operator called me in 2010. I had 1700tt, 500ME. You'll need at least 1500 now with the new rules.

I spent about two years as an FO and caught a windfall upgrade when companies were merging. While I was in the sim doing my check ride, the company announced bankruptcy and parking my aircraft. I somehow managed to trade that for a direct entry captain spot at another bottom tier turboprop operator on the same plane.

So it's been about six years since I was where you are. I've worked steadily but didn't give up time with family for tons of flying time. 3000tt and 300 turbine pic. It will probably be 2 more years to get to 1000 turbine pic and be competitive ish. I still have no jet time. My w2s have been 24, 25, 19, 33, 40, and 40.

If I had gotten on with Comair I would have been laid off too, eagle I would still be an FO. I have many friends that have been doing it longer with less to show for it, I've been pretty lucky. If I had to do it again, I would pursue military. The air force and navy officers that I've had the pleasure of knowing and working with are some of the finest individuals I've ever met.

It could easily take 10 years of instructing/regional slogging to get your "dream job". Average age hired at a major is 34. I don't think you'll look back and say "I wish I had flown a turboprop/rj to little towns for pennies in my twenties". You might look back and think "why didn't I give military a shot when I could have."
Tom a Hawk is offline  
Old 10-31-2013, 07:23 AM
  #26  
Prime Minister/Moderator
 
rickair7777's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Jan 2006
Position: Engines Turn Or People Swim
Posts: 39,231
Default

Originally Posted by XHooker View Post
2) I'll go against the consensus here and suggest you look at AD service. There are lots of pitfalls (stifling bureaucracy, absurd regulations, long hours, careerist senior officers, to name a few) but you'll make decent money, get the best training in the world and be surrounded by the finest people you'll ever work with. The experience is character building if nothing else. Admittedly, the ANG/AFR offer most of the advantages of AD with few of the disadvantages, but don't dismiss AD out of hand. As far as going straight civilian, I wouldn't trade my mil time for a decade of seniority.
Several issues about AD to consider...

- You don't get to chose your airframe. You could end up in RW, which is a different animal than fixed-wing. Good missions and fun flying, but obviously an entirely different career track once you transition to the civilian world. The vast majority of military helo pilots I know do not have flying jobs post-military, some of that is lack of opportunity, some is by choice.

The army is almost all RW, especially for new hires. The USN/USMC/USCG have a lot of helos, probably at least 50% of their airframes. The USAF has the fewest helos, and I think they usually have enough volunteers to fill those seats (can anyone elaborate?). With the guard/USAF reserve you know what your airframe will be before you commit.

- UAVs: Not sure what the policy is this week, but I personally would not sign up for AD if there was a chance that I could get invol-ed into UAVs. UAVs will do nothing for a civilian aviation career (might as well fly wire-guide model airlines and log that), and in my opinion will not provide good career progression in the AD military. The military culture does not (and for good reason) place UAV pilots on equal footing with actual war-fighters who go in harms way, and stunts like that "RPA Hero Pilot Medal" actually make those folks a laughingstock.

- NPQ: If you get medically disqualified or wash out of training, there's a good chance you'll still owe the military some number of years. Maybe not the end of the world, some guys have gone on to have long careers in non-flying specialties after attriting from aviation.

Personally, I would only consider regular AD if:

- I just wanted to serve for a few years, and didn't care too much about what I flew, and wasn't too worried about civilian aviation. This is what I did.

- Or I was interested in serving in a variety of flying and non-flying jobs, desired to move around a lot, and wanted to achieve high rank. If you're not "in it to win it" you'll end up doing a lot of mandatory career-enhancing stuff that you'll consider a waste of your time. An AD career is a different animal compared to airlines and/or reserves.

Originally Posted by XHooker View Post
Also, don't fall into the fighters or nothing mindset. Some of your selection will be determined by skill and some by luck beyond your control. Heavy drivers do some cool stuff and while helos might take longer to get the airline job, that's probably some of the most challenging flying available.
All true, but if airlines is your long-term goal, try to stick to FW.
rickair7777 is offline  
Old 10-31-2013, 08:29 AM
  #27  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Apr 2013
Posts: 3,424
Default

What Rickair said is spot on. About half of Navy Student Naval Aviators go on to fly helos. Nothing wrong with that, they fly awesome missions, but rotary wing flight time will be nothing but a feather in your cap for an airline application. They are looking for fixed wing and especially multi fixed wing.

The AD side of the military is a minimum 10 year gig...a lot can happen in a decade. It is a lot of fun, but if you are only in it for the flight time, you will not do well. Flying, at least in the Navy and Marines, is second to being an Officer and a leader. If your heart isn't in it, you will be miserable.
e6bpilot is offline  
Old 10-31-2013, 09:50 AM
  #28  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Apr 2013
Posts: 3,424
Default

Originally Posted by voodiloquist View Post
Agreed. Except for the multi-engine bit -- F-16 and F-35 guys will get hired same as the also-rans.
Yes, my apologies, fighters not withstanding. All the current Navy inventory (not trainers) is ME, but won't be for long.
e6bpilot is offline  
Old 10-31-2013, 10:12 AM
  #29  
Gets Weekends Off
 
USMCFLYR's Avatar
 
Joined APC: Mar 2008
Position: FAA 'Flight Check'
Posts: 13,837
Default

Originally Posted by voodiloquist View Post
Agreed. Except for the multi-engine bit -- F-16 and F-35 guys will get hired same as the also-rans.
Originally Posted by e6bpilot View Post
Yes, my apologies, fighters not withstanding. All the current Navy inventory (not trainers) is ME, but won't be for long.
In the past, and who kows where future hiring trends will lead, but if you were a helo pilot for your first tour there was ample opportunity for a transition to FW or a tour with the VTs to get your FW time up to par in order to apply to the majors. FWIW - when I was going through flight training, the USMC was about 80% helo selection and it was NOT a guarantee to get FW even if you graduated Primary at the top of your class.
USMCFLYR is offline  
Old 10-31-2013, 11:10 AM
  #30  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined APC: Apr 2013
Posts: 3,424
Default

I was a primary instructor in the 06-09 timeframe, and we did have quite a few helo guys who got 1000-1500 hrs of fixed wing instructor time with us, so yes, that is definitely a possibility. In the past, those guys have been hired on with the airlines. I know because many of them were reservists.

The days of helo guys transitioning platforms to fixed wing are pretty much over. Of course, there are onesies and twosies, but with manning what it is today, most communities are loathe to let their good pilots go, and the gaining communities don't want the trash. The best way, honestly, to make this happen in the Navy is to go FTS or SELRES with a VR unit and not to stay active duty and endure the pain that comes with AD officer promotion.

Best way for a guy who selects helos to get fixed wing time in the Navy:
Kick ass as a helo guy (or you are done from the start)
Go to a VT command
Go FTS/SELRES when your commitment is up

Of course, this would require the obligatory 2 year boat tour, but if your timing is good, YMMV.
e6bpilot is offline  
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Tsuda
Major
24
12-01-2011 10:04 PM
bgmann
Regional
31
11-19-2011 07:33 PM
АЕРОФЛОТ 214
Regional
11
05-18-2007 05:18 AM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Your Privacy Choices