Military vs. airlines
#31
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 4,551
Likes: 395
I was a primary instructor in the 06-09 timeframe, and we did have quite a few helo guys who got 1000-1500 hrs of fixed wing instructor time with us, so yes, that is definitely a possibility. In the past, those guys have been hired on with the airlines. I know because many of them were reservists.
The days of helo guys transitioning platforms to fixed wing are pretty much over. Of course, there are onesies and twosies, but with manning what it is today, most communities are loathe to let their good pilots go, and the gaining communities don't want the trash. The best way, honestly, to make this happen in the Navy is to go FTS or SELRES with a VR unit and not to stay active duty and endure the pain that comes with AD officer promotion.
Best way for a guy who selects helos to get fixed wing time in the Navy:
Kick ass as a helo guy (or you are done from the start)
Go to a VT command
Go FTS/SELRES when your commitment is up
Of course, this would require the obligatory 2 year boat tour, but if your timing is good, YMMV.
The days of helo guys transitioning platforms to fixed wing are pretty much over. Of course, there are onesies and twosies, but with manning what it is today, most communities are loathe to let their good pilots go, and the gaining communities don't want the trash. The best way, honestly, to make this happen in the Navy is to go FTS or SELRES with a VR unit and not to stay active duty and endure the pain that comes with AD officer promotion.
Best way for a guy who selects helos to get fixed wing time in the Navy:
Kick ass as a helo guy (or you are done from the start)
Go to a VT command
Go FTS/SELRES when your commitment is up
Of course, this would require the obligatory 2 year boat tour, but if your timing is good, YMMV.
#32
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 4,551
Likes: 395
#33
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Aug 2013
Posts: 627
Likes: 0
From: FO
The days of helo guys transitioning platforms to fixed wing are pretty much over. Of course, there are onesies and twosies, but with manning what it is today, most communities are loathe to let their good pilots go, and the gaining communities don't want the trash. The best way, honestly, to make this happen in the Navy is to go FTS or SELRES with a VR unit and not to stay active duty and endure the pain that comes with AD officer promotion.
As far as the trash comment, I will take that as a complement, since we do refer to ourselves as rotor trash. We do all the dirty work while you burn holes in your pedestal in the sky with a wire.

AND since I've done my homework as a Navy helo guy who sees no future in civilian rotary wing flying without another 1000 hours, I am happy to report that the majority of operators will count some if not all of your total time when applying. Hell, even Atlas Air will count 100% of rotary wing time, and 50% of your multi engine helo time. Even I think that's a little ridiculous, although very much to my advantage. Sure the majors won't, but with a couple years of some 121 or 135 in your logbook, it won't matter anyway.
Best way for a guy who selects helos to get fixed wing time in the Navy:
Kick ass as a helo guy (or you are done from the start)
Go to a VT command
Go FTS/SELRES when your commitment is up
Of course, this would require the obligatory 2 year boat tour, but if your timing is good, YMMV.
Kick ass as a helo guy (or you are done from the start)
Go to a VT command
Go FTS/SELRES when your commitment is up
Of course, this would require the obligatory 2 year boat tour, but if your timing is good, YMMV.
#34
Just remember, every post in here is probably correct for the time frame that we've experienced. Today is a very different environment that any military or civilian pilot has experienced over the last 20 years. Even though we mean well, none of us can predict the future and IMO you should do what your gut tells you. If you want to be in the military, join the military. If you want to be an airline pilot then IMO you are going to be unhappy in the military and you should focus on civilian flying.
BTW, USAF is by far your best bet if you decide to stick with the ends justifies the means approach. Very few rotary wing assignments and UAVs have their own career track now -- you should be safe from that line of work. Guard/reserve is even better than AD since you can have your cake and eat it too.
BTW, USAF is by far your best bet if you decide to stick with the ends justifies the means approach. Very few rotary wing assignments and UAVs have their own career track now -- you should be safe from that line of work. Guard/reserve is even better than AD since you can have your cake and eat it too.
#35
Line Holder
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
#36
The days of helo guys transitioning platforms to fixed wing are pretty much over. Of course, there are onesies and twosies, but with manning what it is today, most communities are loathe to let their good pilots go, and the gaining communities don't want the trash. The best way, honestly, to make this happen in the Navy is to go FTS or SELRES with a VR unit and not to stay active duty and endure the pain that comes with AD officer promotion.
Best way for a guy who selects helos to get fixed wing time in the Navy:
Kick ass as a helo guy (or you are done from the start)
Go to a VT command
Go FTS/SELRES when your commitment is up
Of course, this would require the obligatory 2 year boat tour, but if your timing is good, YMMV.
I was one of the few who got a Helo to FW transition (60Bs to E-2s) and rolled the career dice and lost when the LCDR selection rates went to crap the same time I got pulled up a YG.. Ended up leaving my E-2 tour at about the 2 year mark, and as a result of how the upgrades work there have very little FW PIC (A-Time) and as a result, have been working as an Engineer vice flying. (Pay's good. Hours suck, been home 5 days in the last 3 months, and still worked 8-10 hours a day out of my home office)
Bolded the best part of E6B's advice. Jumping communities, even when it is going away (I was HSL, it was becoming HSM, and I left for VAW/VRC) is playing with fire. Luck and timing have just as much as performance, and without all three, you are up the creek.
#37
Prime Minister/Moderator

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 44,870
Likes: 665
From: Engines Turn or People Swim
You need to be doing the military for reasons other than just flight training and PIC time....but nothing says you can't have the right reasons and also be interested in an airline future.
Almost every military person has to plan a career transition at some point anyway. Very, very few make it to age 60+ in the military and they don't do it by flying airplanes.
BTW, USAF is by far your best bet if you decide to stick with the ends justifies the means approach. Very few rotary wing assignments and UAVs have their own career track now -- you should be safe from that line of work. Guard/reserve is even better than AD since you can have your cake and eat it too.
x2
#38
On Reserve
Joined: Jul 2011
Posts: 65
Likes: 0
I would respectfully disagree. The two tracks CAN complement each other. Big Caveat though...you must be FULLY committed to the military mission and lifestyle for that period you expect to serve. You'll also need to at least attempt to manage your military assignments to obtain FW (and preferably ME) turbine PIC to set yourself up for the civilian side...this may hamper your military career progression, but sometimes you can't have your cake AND you ice cream and eat them both. There's absolutely nothing wrong with honorable service for a one term followed by greener pastures, or retiring at 20 as a terminal O-4.
You need to be doing the military for reasons other than just flight training and PIC time....but nothing says you can't have the right reasons and also be interested in an airline future.
Almost every military person has to plan a career transition at some point anyway. Very, very few make it to age 60+ in the military and they don't do it by flying airplanes.
x2
You need to be doing the military for reasons other than just flight training and PIC time....but nothing says you can't have the right reasons and also be interested in an airline future.
Almost every military person has to plan a career transition at some point anyway. Very, very few make it to age 60+ in the military and they don't do it by flying airplanes.
x2
If you ask me, there is absolutely nothing wrong with using the service as a stepping stone platform to achieve your life goals, and in this case flying. It's your career and you shouldn't have to fit into someone's own version of idealism. However, if you have the attitude purposely not caring about the military and are in it for the sole purpose to achieve something else on the outside, then of course that's a poor position to take. But I think that's a little too theoretical. I've yet to meet anyone who thinks like that.
Besides, 10-20 years in the military is a decent amount of time. Your attitude, family, and entire situation will change and evolve over time. And your outlook will most likely be completely different from once you started in your early 20's.
My 2 cents.
#39
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,083
Likes: 0
Just remember, every post in here is probably correct for the time frame that we've experienced. Today is a very different environment that any military or civilian pilot has experienced over the last 20 years. Even though we mean well, none of us can predict the future and IMO you should do what your gut tells you. If you want to be in the military, join the military. If you want to be an airline pilot then IMO you are going to be unhappy in the military and you should focus on civilian flying.
#40
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 1,083
Likes: 0
I'll add my experience, since I faced a similar decision and made the civilian choice.
I graduated from college in 07 and at the time guys were getting picked up by regionals with 500 hours or so. I decided not to pursue military even though it was something I wanted. 10 years seemed like a long time to me when I was 20. It's not.
It could easily take 10 years of instructing/regional slogging to get your "dream job". Average age hired at a major is 34. I don't think you'll look back and say "I wish I had flown a turboprop/rj to little towns for pennies in my twenties". You might look back and think "why didn't I give military a shot when I could have."
I graduated from college in 07 and at the time guys were getting picked up by regionals with 500 hours or so. I decided not to pursue military even though it was something I wanted. 10 years seemed like a long time to me when I was 20. It's not.
It could easily take 10 years of instructing/regional slogging to get your "dream job". Average age hired at a major is 34. I don't think you'll look back and say "I wish I had flown a turboprop/rj to little towns for pennies in my twenties". You might look back and think "why didn't I give military a shot when I could have."
From a purely rational outlook, I can't justify AD except as a means to leave no stone unturned in looking for a military job. However, I think AD gives you a big picture appreciation of the airline life you might not get if you never see anything outside of the regionals/ANG. Yes, I know it's a little crazy to say the best thing about AD is it leaves you a little jaded about the world and a little more appreciative of airline life.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Past V1
Regional
61
01-22-2009 07:17 AM



