Go Back  Airline Pilot Central Forums > Airline Pilot Forums > Regional
Prevent Whipsaw: One Pilot Group(XJT/ASA/SKW) >

Prevent Whipsaw: One Pilot Group(XJT/ASA/SKW)

Search

Notices
Regional Regional Airlines

Prevent Whipsaw: One Pilot Group(XJT/ASA/SKW)

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 08-26-2010 | 08:41 AM
  #91  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 191
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
Why do you keep saying this? When SKW bought ASA we all thought there would be whipsaw and that he would simply bleed ASA to death, taking our planes and flying. This did not happen. So why do you think there will suddenly be whipsaw now? Get over yourselves! As Rikair said, it's best to get on board now and go after the SkyWest pilots later.



Sorry, Bills, but you're in over your head. I could easily turn what you said around and state that since he walked away once before because the deal wasn't on his terms, he will walk away again. You clearly know nothing about Jerry. Why do you act like you do? You don't work for him. We have worked for him for 5 years now! One thing you must get through your head about SkyWest, Inc: Jerry Atkin does not bluff, and does not play games. When you are dealing directly with him, his first offer is also his last, best, and final offer. He does not posture. He simply tells you the deal, and you can take it or leave it.
How many did ASA furlough?
How many did Skywest Furlough?

We have gotten 2 offers from Jerry so far, one in 08 (which we turned down) and we are getting another offer right now. So apparently jerry makes multiple offers. Let me just say that I do not represent the entire XJT pilot group, so if I sound like I am beating my chest, then do not think that the rest of our pilots are doing the same. XJT pilots want to uphold our contract, that is all, nothing more, nothing less. We dont want to steal your bases, or staple you to the bottom of our seniority list, or ruin your QOL. I say again, put down your swords, and understand what we are trying to accomplish here, it is simple. Honestly Skywest pilots have nothing to do with any of this at this point, so it is all just opinions. Jerry will be the ultimate decider of how both our companies move forward, so you disagreeing with all of this doesn't matter really. I think Rickair gets the whole idea here, and seems to be the most level headed, which is good to see.
Reply
Old 08-26-2010 | 08:44 AM
  #92  
Slaphappy's Avatar
Banned
 
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 1,192
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by TheBills
No you wouldn't.
Yes I would because then there would be a chance that skywest would grow especially due to your financial state.
Reply
Old 08-26-2010 | 08:51 AM
  #93  
Captain Tony's Avatar
Line Holder
 
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 1,967
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by TheBills
How many did ASA furlough?
How many did Skywest Furlough?
You're got to be kidding me! You're comparing apples to oranges!

ASA furloughed because Delta cut our flying and transferred it to Pinnacle, Compass, Republic, and all the other DCI carriers we must compete with. At the time, Delta was our only mainline partner. SkyWest does mostly business with UAL so they weren't as affected.

Did any ASA flying go to SkyWest during our furlough? NO Did they ask for concessions to get the pilots back? NO. This was not whipsaw. End of story.

Originally Posted by TheBills
We have gotten 2 offers from Jerry so far, one in 08 (which we turned down) and we are getting another offer right now. So then apparently jerry makes multiple offers. Let me just say that I do not represent the entire XJT pilot group, so if I sound like I am beating my chest, then do not think that the rest of our pilots are doing the same. XJT pilots want to uphold our contract, that is all, nothing more, nothing less. We dont want to steal your bases, or staple you to the bottom of our seniority list. I say again, put down your swords, and understand what we are trying to accomplish here, it is simple.
I really don't need a history lesson, I'm aware of what happened. As I said, he walked away once, and he will walk away again. If Jerry suddenly changed his mind about one list, he wouldn't have gone to the pains of setting up ASA to buy you, he would have just done it with INC. There's your biggest sign!

As for the swords, we don't have swords out, we have shields out. You are the one with the sword. Like I said, we don't need 2800 rabble rousers coming over here and thumbing their noses at the hand that feeds us. So if that's what you guys intend, just tell Jerry no thanks, and take your chances alone. That's all I've got.
Reply
Old 08-26-2010 | 11:12 AM
  #94  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 326
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
Why do you keep saying this? When SKW bought ASA we all thought there would be whipsaw and that he would simply bleed ASA to death, taking our planes and flying. This did not happen. So why do you think there will suddenly be whipsaw now? Get over yourselves! As Rikair said, it's best to get on board now and go after the SkyWest pilots later.
During contract negotiations, several 700s and 900s Delta originally designated for ASA ended up at Skywest. In your mind, how do you justify that outside of whipsaw?

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
You're got to be kidding me! You're comparing apples to oranges!

ASA furloughed because Delta cut our flying and transferred it to Pinnacle, Compass, Republic, and all the other DCI carriers we must compete with. At the time, Delta was our only mainline partner. SkyWest does mostly business with UAL so they weren't as affected.

Did any ASA flying go to SkyWest during our furlough? NO Did they ask for concessions to get the pilots back? NO. This was not whipsaw. End of story.
You're kidding, right? 'ASA will not grow without PBS.' 'ASA needs to be more cost competitive.' Then bam, we furlough unnecessarily? SH and other chief pilots claimed furloughs were only cost effective if for a year or more, so I'll grant the first 80. Given the way this summer went (before any new aircraft arrived) it's difficult to believe the second round was anything more than a doom and gloom negotiation tactic.
Reply
Old 08-26-2010 | 11:23 AM
  #95  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 453
Likes: 0
Default

You guys keep talking like XJT needs this, the clock is ticking and we are about to implode. If the deal doesn't happen, it doesn't happen. It's like talking to the CAL guys with the scope that management wants to get rid of. Smisek wants the UAL merger BAD and acts like the wholething is gonna tank if scope isn't relieved.

JA knew what he was buying and what was written down in the contract. Unless a cubicle drone at Ford and Harrison found a way around it, then he has nothing to worry about.

His current "No SLI or no deal" stance shows he is worried. Like others have stated he wants the new UAL contract bad. My guess is he will buy XJT regardless of what will happen.
Reply
Old 08-26-2010 | 02:27 PM
  #96  
Banned
 
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 437
Likes: 0
From: Furlough/Gun Driver
Default

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
I'm glad you brought that up. That's a prime example of what happens when you "call Jerry's bluff" and tell him to pack sand. That a lesson ASA ALPA learned the hard way. That wasn't whipsaw, it was punishment for not playing ball.
Is that kind of like when GoJet was used as punishment because TSA didn't play ball? As long as one company is allowed to hold multiple 121 certificates by the FAA these companies will gladly pit one pilot group against another. Republic, TSA, Skywest, and Pinnacle are all comprised of multiple certificates which is just nuts in my opinion.
Reply
Old 08-26-2010 | 02:52 PM
  #97  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 320
Likes: 0
From: Auto
Default

Originally Posted by dosbo
Is that kind of like when GoJet was used as punishment because TSA didn't play ball? As long as one company is allowed to hold multiple 121 certificates by the FAA these companies will gladly pit one pilot group against another. Republic, TSA, Skywest, and Pinnacle are all comprised of multiple certificates which is just nuts in my opinion.
Ding ding ding ding. We have a winner.

Skywest guys seem to a little too much faith in the word of Jerry. They also assume he will always be the one in charge. What happens if an Ornstein type CEO takes the reins?

Here is a opportunity to show some unity and get everyone on the same team and Skywest pilots can't think past tomorrow. In a side note I believe I saw Slapphappy in an earlier post speak of going to Skywest because they were not union. I suppose he won't be applying to any legacy carriers then.
Reply
Old 08-26-2010 | 02:59 PM
  #98  
Banned
 
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 2,934
Likes: 0
From: EMB 145 CPT
Default

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
This letter was sent by the ASA MEC chairman today:


Sounds like Atkin is playing hardball, as predicted. If XJET ALPA attempts to challenge the scope provision, the deal is off.

Which is probably best for SkyWest and ASA anyhow.
And best for the profession. Now I'm ready to call the deal off, or in other words, I'm ready to fight to uphold my contract.

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
What say you, Nevets, self appointed spokesman for the XJET pilot group? Will you "call his bluff" (he's not bluffing) or will you give up on the 3-way?

What's the line in Vegas? I put my money on giving up on the 3-way, but you never know. ALPA likes telling its regionals to fall on their swords for the "greater good".
I've said multiple times that I only speak for myself. Although there are many of the same opinion as mine. I will gladly call his bluff, AGAIN. If it was solely up to me, I would not give up on one list.

We all tell the mainline pilots they should have upheld their scope clauses but when its up to us, you seem to vilify us for even thinking about it. Why?

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
Because we will get it anyhow, but at a fire sale in 6-24 months without a seniority merger if you shoot this down.
If that was really the case, JA wouldn't be trying to buy us now. He puts great value in XJT now then later or in bk. In any case, I don't know why anyone in the profession would want that unless you only cared about yourself and didn't care about other people.

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
We were fine before the announcement of this possible merger, and we will be fine if it doesn't happen.

It's you guys decision. You can get on board and help make ASA/XJET a powerhouse (then go after SkyWest at a later date) or you can fall on your swords for ALPA. But I for one am glad to hear that Jerry is not going to let you guys tie this up in litigation forever.

Either get on board or get left out. That's the way SkyWest does things. Get used to it or take your chances alone.
I hope this isn't tied up in litigation. I don't know why JA is even playing these antics to begin with if he doesn't want this tied up in arbitration. He should have just asked the MEC if they were willing to put aside certain contract provisions first before announcing his definitive merger agreement. Oh wait, he already tried that...didn't work. Something tells me he is more apt to go through with it even if we manage to one list this.

One list or stop trying to buy us. That's the way XJT pilots does things. Get used to it or take your chances alone.

Originally Posted by Slaphappy
XJT is on life support, your ceo is basically there to trim the fat and sell the company. Your own managment has said you can't make money in your current state. The buyout is the only thing keeping you out of the unemployment line.
I don't mind him trimming the fat and selling the company. Maybe a more honorable company would actually abide by our contract. Of course our management tells us we wont make money. They want this just as bad as JA. Like you said, our ceo is just here to sell us...duh.

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
Why do you keep saying this? When SKW bought ASA we all thought there would be whipsaw and that he would simply bleed ASA to death, taking our planes and flying. This did not happen. So why do you think there will suddenly be whipsaw now? Get over yourselves! As Rikair said, it's best to get on board now and go after the SkyWest pilots later.
He did take airplanes away from ASA and gave them to SKW. He did it during your negotiations. In fact, that is probably the reason why you have language in your contract to prohibit that in the future. I wonder how much it cost you in pay and work rules to get that little paragraph in your contract. That is the definition of whipsaw!

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
Sorry, Bills, but you're in over your head. I could easily turn what you said around and state that since he walked away once before because the deal wasn't on his terms, he will walk away again. You clearly know nothing about Jerry. Why do you act like you do? You don't work for him. We have worked for him for 5 years now! One thing you must get through your head about SkyWest, Inc: Jerry Atkin does not bluff, and does not play games. When you are dealing directly with him, his first offer is also his last, best, and final offer. He does not posture. He simply tells you the deal, and you can take it or leave it.
He does not posture? That is BS. I was in the room when he told us himself that "XJT would be bk in 6-9 months", "we need to see him as our lifeboat", "its up to you if you want to be cost competitive." Its been over two years and we are still here.

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
So would I. It seems all you guys do is beat your chests. Too much drama, and not interested in 2800 pilots who want to burn down the company. That's bad for my career.
We have sheilds and swords out because it was JA that is wielding his sword at us first. We will fight for our contract against JA and anyone else who gets in our way. I hope ASA pilots don't get in the way of us trying to enforce our contract because I don't think we would ever get in the way of you wanting to enforce yours.

Originally Posted by Slaphappy
Yes I would because then there would be a chance that skywest would grow especially due to your financial state.
That doesn't seem to be what your CEO wants.

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
You're got to be kidding me! You're comparing apples to oranges!

ASA furloughed because Delta cut our flying and transferred it to Pinnacle, Compass, Republic, and all the other DCI carriers we must compete with. At the time, Delta was our only mainline partner. SkyWest does mostly business with UAL so they weren't as affected.

Did any ASA flying go to SkyWest during our furlough? NO Did they ask for concessions to get the pilots back? NO. This was not whipsaw. End of story.
Well, if you were one list, one pilot group wouldn't be suffering while the other one hires. After all, the money all goes to the same coffers.

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
I really don't need a history lesson, I'm aware of what happened. As I said, he walked away once, and he will walk away again. If Jerry suddenly changed his mind about one list, he wouldn't have gone to the pains of setting up ASA to buy you, he would have just done it with INC. There's your biggest sign!
Biggest clue is that he is buying XJT and said he "may" back out if we one list it. He will lose $4M in the process as well.

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
As for the swords, we don't have swords out, we have shields out. You are the one with the sword. Like I said, we don't need 2800 rabble rousers coming over here and thumbing their noses at the hand that feeds us. So if that's what you guys intend, just tell Jerry no thanks, and take your chances alone. That's all I've got.
Sounds good to me. Too bad JA doesn't see the value in happy employees.

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
I'm glad you brought that up. That's a prime example of what happens when you "call Jerry's bluff" and tell him to pack sand. That a lesson ASA ALPA learned the hard way. That wasn't whipsaw, it was punishment for not playing ball.
This is the classic definition of whipsaw! You are so far in it, you can't even see it even though you explain it very simply yourself!
Reply
Old 08-26-2010 | 07:52 PM
  #99  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 191
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by Captain Tony
You're got to be kidding me! You're comparing apples to oranges!

ASA furloughed because Delta cut our flying and transferred it to Pinnacle, Compass, Republic, and all the other DCI carriers we must compete with. At the time, Delta was our only mainline partner. SkyWest does mostly business with UAL so they weren't as affected.

Did any ASA flying go to SkyWest during our furlough? NO Did they ask for concessions to get the pilots back? NO. This was not whipsaw. End of story.



I really don't need a history lesson, I'm aware of what happened. As I said, he walked away once, and he will walk away again. If Jerry suddenly changed his mind about one list, he wouldn't have gone to the pains of setting up ASA to buy you, he would have just done it with INC. There's your biggest sign!

As for the swords, we don't have swords out, we have shields out. You are the one with the sword. Like I said, we don't need 2800 rabble rousers coming over here and thumbing their noses at the hand that feeds us. So if that's what you guys intend, just tell Jerry no thanks, and take your chances alone. That's all I've got.
Jerry shouldn't you be working on this deal, instead of posting on the message boards. Face it, you need XJT for the continued success of your holding company, and all we ask is for one list. Show me the money jerry!
Reply
Old 08-26-2010 | 09:36 PM
  #100  
Banned
 
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 2,934
Likes: 0
From: EMB 145 CPT
Default

Originally Posted by SkyWestPilot1
To the XJet pilots:

You need to understand, for SkyWest pilots there is no personal benefit for INC to buy you.
Your CEO seems to disagree with you.
Reply
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
BoilerUP
Regional
103
02-26-2010 02:31 PM
djrogs03
Regional
12
01-17-2010 07:53 PM
Longbow64
Part 135
117
07-23-2009 08:46 AM
JetBlast77
Regional
44
07-19-2009 01:19 PM
JungleBus
Major
121
12-20-2008 04:13 PM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Your Privacy Choices