Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   Eagle or Pinnacle?? (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/57243-eagle-pinnacle.html)

Bartok 02-25-2011 06:23 AM


Originally Posted by mooney (Post 954202)
Now Bartok, you know that if some 21 year old 300 hour Big Sky punk was arguing with you back in the day of the sham bankrupcy/XJ Holdings formation/Big Sky purchase and told you "you didn't buy me XJ Holdings did" you would have slapped his candy *ss all the way back to Montana.....:D

Not true mooney, I did want them to integrate the seniority lists, but I didn't feel any entitlement because I work for XJ, only that my DOH was used as the more weighted factor in SLI.

Nothing has changed.

ebl14 02-25-2011 07:40 AM


Originally Posted by Bartok (Post 954216)
Not true mooney, I did want them to integrate the seniority lists, but I didn't feel any entitlement because I work for XJ, only that my DOH was used as the more weighted factor in SLI.

Nothing has changed.

Out of curiosity, what would your relative senority at xj be if you subtracted all saab positions?

Bartok 02-25-2011 07:46 AM


Originally Posted by ebl14 (Post 954254)
Out of curiosity, what would your relative senority at xj be if you subtracted all saab positions?

Less than it is.

Let me ask you a question, 9E I presume, are you in the top 25 - 30% at 9E?

Because straight DOH helps everyone at 9E below that.

ebl14 02-25-2011 11:27 AM


Originally Posted by Bartok (Post 954257)
Less than it is.

Let me ask you a question, 9E I presume, are you in the top 25 - 30% at 9E?

Because straight DOH helps everyone at 9E below that.

That may be true, it is also probably true that doh will hurt the lower 50% of mesabas pilots. So are you suggesting, the junior 9e guys get together with the senior xj guys and play "let's ****** our buddies"? I just thought a some thought should be given to the fact that pre-purchase xj was going to furlough roughly half the list. The same consideration should be given to the fact that Colgan would never have the growth from the q400s if they had not been aquired and funded by Pinnacle. As long as those two factors weigh in to the sli I will think the outcome is "fair".

Bartok 02-25-2011 11:59 AM


Originally Posted by ebl14 (Post 954373)
That may be true, it is also probably true that doh will hurt the lower 50% of mesabas pilots. So are you suggesting, the junior 9e guys get together with the senior xj guys and play "let's ****** our buddies"? I just thought a some thought should be given to the fact that pre-purchase xj was going to furlough roughly half the list. The same consideration should be given to the fact that Colgan would never have the growth from the q400s if they had not been aquired and funded by Pinnacle. As long as those two factors weigh in to the sli I will think the outcome is "fair".

And consideration should be given to that fact that Pinnacle pilots own nothing, Pinnacle Holdings owns all 3 of us, Pinnacle airlines purchased nothing.

Your argument holds as much weight as the fact that XJ negotiators got this deal done for 9E.

And I'm not saying screw anyone, I just think straight DOH is the fairest method to most pilots.

CAPTAINPCL 02-26-2011 12:32 AM


Originally Posted by Bartok (Post 954395)
And consideration should be given to that fact that Pinnacle pilots own nothing, Pinnacle Holdings owns all 3 of us, Pinnacle airlines purchased nothing.

Your argument holds as much weight as the fact that XJ negotiators got this deal done for 9E.

And I'm not saying screw anyone, I just think straight DOH is the fairest method to most pilots.

Just so you know, Pinnacle Corp didn't even exist until after Colgan was purchased by Pinnacle Airlines Inc...

BlueMoon 02-26-2011 03:46 AM


Originally Posted by djrogs03 (Post 953856)
on top of that, you do realize Delta gave away XJ and Compass...82.5 million was a steal for 126 airplanes... especially considering...77 of them are 76 seaters

Doesn't DL still owns Mesaba's 76 seaters? That is why the price was a "steal"

Bartok 02-26-2011 04:00 AM


Originally Posted by CAPTAINPCL (Post 954650)
Just so you know, Pinnacle Corp didn't even exist until after Colgan was purchased by Pinnacle Airlines Inc...

I know, I just think this "ownage" argument is funny.

We're all "owned".

Just pawns in someone elses game.

WIFlyer 02-26-2011 07:05 AM

Exactly!

I find it so funny that people always spout off against management until they get in these little poop throwing contests. Then, all of a sudden it is 'we' bought you and 'we' did this or that. We are all just cogs in a wheel, if one of us falls off there are 8,000 more in a spare parts box to take our place, at a cheaper rate! All we can do is operate the aircraft safely, go home and vote on things with our conscience. I sleep well at night, do you?

Mason32 02-26-2011 08:04 AM


Originally Posted by CAPTAINPCL (Post 954650)
Just so you know, Pinnacle Corp didn't even exist until after Colgan was purchased by Pinnacle Airlines Inc...

edit - deleted


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:12 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands