Quote:
I'm curious detpilot, what 121 experience are you drawing from. How do we know you won't freeze up when you hit the line? I'm not knocking either route, I just feel you are hard stanced about a group of people you honestly know nothing about.
None, and we don't know. I sure as hell might freeze up- but generally speaking, I find it hard to believe that professional pilots can dispute the fact that 1500 hour pilots are more experienced than 300 hour ones. I'm curious detpilot, what 121 experience are you drawing from. How do we know you won't freeze up when you hit the line? I'm not knocking either route, I just feel you are hard stanced about a group of people you honestly know nothing about.
I am exposed to a lot of arrogant 200 hour-ish guys (not in 121) at my school who are p***ed about the 1500 hour rule, and honestly feel that they are just as experienced as an ATP. That's simply not true.
No one is arguing that a 300 hour guy can do the job- hell I would have taken the job if offered to me when I had 300TT. But, when the crap hits the fan, and your family is in the back- which FO would you want the captain to be discussing his possible alternatives with? Which FO would be more likely to stand up to a captain doing something wrong?
It's not just about the number of hours- it's about experience, confidence (standing up to another pilot for what you know is right), and think-outside-the-box ability. And you don't have to be a 121 pilot to understand that, hell even congress gets it.