Go Back  Airline Pilot Central Forums > Airline Pilot Forums > Major > American
Pilot shortage: AA cancelled 100's of flights >

Pilot shortage: AA cancelled 100's of flights

Search

Notices

Pilot shortage: AA cancelled 100's of flights

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 06-22-2021 | 11:39 AM
  #61  
Line Holder
 
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 949
Likes: 58
Default

Originally Posted by Speed Select
Will do! Before I go, however, what are the "right" reasons for getting into this career?

Just remember, this thread started with loganeich posting that he was going to leave a six-figure career to start at a regional in hopes of eventually getting hired by a major and earning $300K+/year. His daughter isn't even driving age yet and his wife thinks doing this is crazy. I agree with is wife.

Just trying to paint realistic expectations for the guy. Starting this career as a 42 year-old retired O5 with no hopes of promotion or another flying assignment is one thing. It's another thing thing to leave a six-figure career for a regional job in hopes of one day, barring no swan events or a recession, getting hired at a major and holding enough seniority to earn $300K, just because you like flying.

Loganeich, good luck!
You know, I was going to jump on the bandwagon about your negativity, blah, blah, blah, and I do think it’s funny that you say it’s a grueling job - I guess everything is relative. But coming from the point of view you posted above, it does change perspective a bit. While I can’t think of a less stressful, less all-consuming, easier job for equal level of pay, I really don’t think leaving a 300k/yr career (unless you absolutely hated it and/or it went against your values as a person) to start in this industry would be high on my list.
Reply
Old 06-22-2021 | 11:53 AM
  #62  
Line Holder
 
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 554
Likes: 24
From: On all fours
Default

Originally Posted by Speed Select
^^^ This.

Take everything you hate about traveling (running late, waiting in a line 50 deep to depart, deicing, maintenance delays, diversions, poor sleep in declining hotels, insufficient time between flights to get food or coffee or even use the restroom, the monotony of the same thing over and over and over, waiting for rampers, the decline of civility) and multiply that times 20 legs (typical 4-5 day trip at a regional).

But you can usually take a minute and enjoy a sunset, so that's a plus.

All of this tends to kill your idealistic vision of this career (and subsequently your love of flying).

If you love flying, stick to hundred dollar hamburgers. If you already make six figures and are looking for a change, consider CRNA, PA, actuary-all jobs that earn well into six figures and aren't really affected by many of the "swan events" that can torpedo this career. You can also start earning good money in another career sooner than you can as an airline pilot.

Also, the whole idea that you don't take work home is false. You still need to do quarterly training, submit your bids, get your uniform dry cleaned, prep for trips, plan your commute unless you already live in a junior base, commute to work and then back home, live with the anxiety of losing your medical or getting busted on a bad day by a fed or check airman, take calls from the company on why you went around, file ASAPs, deal with pay disputes after a reroute or tag-on, etc.

This is from the perspective of a line holder. I haven't sat reserve since the regionals. Reserve is a entirely different level of pain, especially if you have to commute to reserve.
you sound fun
Reply
Old 06-22-2021 | 12:12 PM
  #63  
C17B74's Avatar
Line Holder
 
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 1,606
Likes: 4
From: No Hats No Jackets No PAX
Default

Originally Posted by Pilot X
you sound fun
Yeah maybe not, but then again he could be. Plenty of reality in that block of information most have experienced or are experiencing. Not all flying gigs are created equal so - May everyone find what’s tolerable, manageable but most of all enjoyable.
Reply
Old 06-22-2021 | 12:15 PM
  #64  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 647
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by Speed Select
Meh. I can make $200K+ and be home every night doing another job that is a lot more stable than airline pilot.

I also don't care for the way pilots are treated. I'm not looking to be put on a pedestal by any means, but after years of flying in the military, at a regional, and now at a major, I would appreciate some professional actualization. Airline pilot lacks any real professional respect. A lot of that is our fault. We're treated and portrayed more like a bunch of Glenn Quagmires than we are Chesley Sullenbergers. Maybe airline pilot just isn't for me. Frankly, with the high level of automation, brutal 4-5 leg/day 4-days, the complete lack of influence pilots have on the operation (other than failing to show up ready to fly), groveling every time you do make a decision, having to chasedown down pay questions/disputes, the physical and psychological wall between the cockpit and the cabin, and "sprint-to-the-bottom" civility, airline pilots have been reduced to glorified button pushers. EU countries seem to have pretty good success putting pilots in the cockpit of wide bodies with just a few hundred hours of flight time, and at much lower wages. Is their safety record much different from US carriers?

Mainline wages are going to keep falling behind inflation. The purchasing power of our salaries will continue to diminish. $300K+ salaries will become more and more rare, especially in the post-CV contract negotiations. Will we see bankruptcies? More instability? I wouldn't spend a dime on civilian training to become an airline pilot. That money can be much better spent on other more-stable and equally (or near equally) lucrative careers. I certainly wouldn't leave a six-figure career to start at the bottom of a regional seniority list. We're just another pandemic, terrorist attack, war, or recession from experiencing another lost decade. Lots of risk with diminishing reward.

Yes, I have a pretty good seniority.

Anyway, pilot shortage.
I left a 6-figure job as an engineer, got stuck in the right seat of regional during the pandemic, and this is still the best job I've ever had. I'm curious, besides CRNA, what other jobs you know of that pay people $200k/yr. You make it sound like this is the rule rather than the exception.

As an engineer, I was looking at topping out at maybe $150k, and that was as a commercial heavy construction manager (the actual engineer jobs paid less). My aero engineer and mech friends have even worse prospects because most of those jobs are govt or working for large corporations with set payscales. Hell, my cousin is a doctor, top of her class in med school, and she'll be lucky to make narrow-body CA pay one day, after residency. In the real world there are no 117 limitations and if you're not doing 60-hour work weeks, you'll permanently dead end in some soul-crushing, fluorescent light, cubicle farm, making $60k/yr, where you'll still have to deal with just as much BS from management (likely more, because their office is 20' away). And that's for a govt job. In the corporate world they'll just fire you and hire someone fresh out of college whose looking to prove themselves on Burger King salary. If you're complaining about the decreasing purchasing power of $300k, imagine how much more that sucks for most other white collar professionals who barely make 6 figures. I doubt their pay will triple and ours will stagnate.

Also, even getting 11 days off, I have more useful time at home than I ever did when I was an engineer, and that's not factoring in the overnights with 117 rest requirements in pretty decent hotels. On top of everything else, flying is like riding a motorcycle or hiking Zion; it never gets old. As far as I know, there's nothing else that will pay you this much to work this little, and is actually fun.

Last edited by Duffman; 06-22-2021 at 12:53 PM.
Reply
Old 06-22-2021 | 12:34 PM
  #65  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 647
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by Pilot X
you sound fun
Unless I missed something, I read it that he was making 6 figures, as in $100k+. Captains at the regionals make low 90s with normal lines, more if they're check airmen or sim instructors. I think most people on here have never worked in a real office and really underestimate the hours of mind-numbing work and overestimate the pay. Personally, switching careers was the best thing I ever did.
Reply
Old 06-22-2021 | 12:42 PM
  #66  
Mainline Mulier's Avatar
Line Holder
 
Joined: Aug 2020
Posts: 77
Likes: 0
From: Boeing 737 CA
Default

Originally Posted by Duffman
I left a 6-figure job as an engineer, got stuck in the right seat of regional during the pandemic, and this is still the best job I've ever had. I'm curious what other jobs you know of that pay people $200k/yr. The only way you can make that type of money is if you have your business. As an engineer, I was looking at topping out at maybe $150k, and that was as a commercial heavy construction manager (the actual engineer jobs paid less). My aero engineer and mech friends have even worse prospects because most of those jobs are govt or working for large corporations with set payscales. Hell, my cousin is a doctor, top of her class in med school, and she'll be lucky to make narrow-body CA pay one day, after residency. In the real world there are no 117 limitations and if you're not doing 60-hour work weeks, you'll permanently dead end in some soul-crushing, fluorescent light, cubicle farm, making $60k/yr, where you'll still have to deal with just as much BS from management (likely more, because their office is 20' away). And that's for a govt job. In the corporate world they'll just fire you and hire someone fresh out of college whose looking to prove themselves on Burger King salary. If you're complaining about the decreasing purchasing power of $300k, imagine how much more that sucks for most other white collar professionals who barely make 6 figures. I doubt their pay will triple and ours will stagnate.

Also, even getting 11 days off, I have more useful time at home than I ever did when I was an engineer, and that's not factoring in the overnights with 117 rest requirements in pretty decent hotels. On top of everything else, flying is like riding a motorcycle or hiking Zion; it never gets old. As far as I know, there's nothing else that will pay you this much to work this little, and is actually fun.
My neighbor is a bond trader and makes 500k+ a year. Most finance and medical professionals make more than 200k. They also sleep in their own bed every night.

Once the novelty wears off, you’ll realize how much life leaves you behind while you hang out in the double tree with strangers you’ll never see ever again. Kids grow old, spouses leave, family members die.

All to aimlessly bounce around the country as a glorified truck driver.
Reply
Old 06-22-2021 | 01:06 PM
  #67  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 647
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by Mainline Mulier
My neighbor is a bond trader and makes 500k+ a year. Most finance and medical professionals make more than 200k. They also sleep in their own bed every night.

Once the novelty wears off, you’ll realize how much life leaves you behind while you hang out in the double tree with strangers you’ll never see ever again. Kids grow old, spouses leave, family members die.

All to aimlessly bounce around the country as a glorified truck driver.
I see what you're saying, but what I've seen from my personal experiences and all my friends in their respective industries, is that life is really hard for professionals. Even sleeping in your own bed every night doesn't mean much after working 10-12 hour days, plus commuting home in rush hour traffic, and then working some weekends. Coming home exhausted, reheating whatever I find, then going to bed, and doing it all over again with maybe a Sunday afternoon with the family wasn't quality time. When I'm on the road with the airline I have my nights to myself, with no other distractions, to do whatever I want, often in a city that's worth exploring. A few years from now, I'll have even more nights at home and overnights in generally a better pool of cities. In my professional experience, most people work themselves to death, and in the airlines, it's much less so.
Reply
Old 06-22-2021 | 01:37 PM
  #68  
On Reserve
 
Joined: Mar 2014
Posts: 193
Likes: 15
Default

Some good points made from both perspectives here. A few years prior to retiring from the military I was working on my MBA. Flying professionally after the Marines wasn't really on my radar. For many military aviators (not all), the mindset is "I gotta go to the airlines, that's what people like me do." I wasn't really like that, and knew there were plenty of cool things to do besides being an airline pilot. But as the time got closer and hiring really started to pick up, I did some soul searching and number crunching and realized (through many conversations with friends in the business world) that nowhere else was someone going to compensate me this well for this amount of work. Yes, there's a lot of responsibility in the sense of many lives depending on you not screwing it up, but it isn't the responsibility of being beholden to a corporation and management 24/7 as a salaried professional. We are highly skilled, trained professionals, and making an airline pilot isn't easy, but our day-to-day job is ridiculously easy. Widebody captains making north of $400k per year basically have the job obligations of a minimum wage worker (show up on time, do your job, don't steal anything, don't yell at the customers). Again, we have a lot more riding on our performance, but it isn't like we're sitting up there white-knuckled, sweating under the pressure.

I know everyone can point to random cushy corporate gigs or working for certain small business sectors where the pay is really good for not a lot of stress/work. But those are the exception. Fortune 500 management types with graduate degrees from really good universities and a decade plus of experience are fighting to crack $200k, and they are working their asses off to get it. Making that as a five year FO at a legacy/major is the norm. I know the regionals are a different story and that it's not guaranteed, but in the current environment, it isn't a complete stretch to think that a regional pilot today who keeps their nose clean has a pretty good shot at getting hired by a legacy eventually.

Now, commuting will obviously add to your stress level and time away from home. That last part, time away from home is the biggy. Regardless of how you slice it, you will be gone a lot. Some people mentioned that their "useful" time at home is actually better as a pilot, as opposed to working long days and only seeing your family a bit in the mornings and evenings. I get that. Still, at least for me, there is a difference between being gone several days at a stretch and seeing your kids a little each day. As much as you try to amp up the family time when you are home as a pilot, they still have school, activities, life that goes on, so I don't think it completely evens out.

But ultimately, if you get to a point where you live in base, and have a bit of seniority built up, it can be an extremely flexible, lucrative and stress free career. And even though the romantic nature of flying does wear off quite a bit, you still occasionally enjoy things about that as well.
Reply
Old 06-22-2021 | 01:49 PM
  #69  
Line Holder
 
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 949
Likes: 58
Default

Originally Posted by Brillo
Some good points made from both perspectives here. A few years prior to retiring from the military I was working on my MBA. Flying professionally after the Marines wasn't really on my radar. For many military aviators (not all), the mindset is "I gotta go to the airlines, that's what people like me do." I wasn't really like that, and knew there were plenty of cool things to do besides being an airline pilot. But as the time got closer and hiring really started to pick up, I did some soul searching and number crunching and realized (through many conversations with friends in the business world) that nowhere else was someone going to compensate me this well for this amount of work. Yes, there's a lot of responsibility in the sense of many lives depending on you not screwing it up, but it isn't the responsibility of being beholden to a corporation and management 24/7 as a salaried professional. We are highly skilled, trained professionals, and making an airline pilot isn't easy, but our day-to-day job is ridiculously easy. Widebody captains making north of $400k per year basically have the job obligations of a minimum wage worker (show up on time, do your job, don't steal anything, don't yell at the customers). Again, we have a lot more riding on our performance, but it isn't like we're sitting up there white-knuckled, sweating under the pressure.

I know everyone can point to random cushy corporate gigs or working for certain small business sectors where the pay is really good for not a lot of stress/work. But those are the exception. Fortune 500 management types with graduate degrees from really good universities and a decade plus of experience are fighting to crack $200k, and they are working their asses off to get it. Making that as a five year FO at a legacy/major is the norm. I know the regionals are a different story and that it's not guaranteed, but in the current environment, it isn't a complete stretch to think that a regional pilot today who keeps their nose clean has a pretty good shot at getting hired by a legacy eventually.

Now, commuting will obviously add to your stress level and time away from home. That last part, time away from home is the biggy. Regardless of how you slice it, you will be gone a lot. Some people mentioned that their "useful" time at home is actually better as a pilot, as opposed to working long days and only seeing your family a bit in the mornings and evenings. I get that. Still, at least for me, there is a difference between being gone several days at a stretch and seeing your kids a little each day. As much as you try to amp up the family time when you are home as a pilot, they still have school, activities, life that goes on, so I don't think it completely evens out.

But ultimately, if you get to a point where you live in base, and have a bit of seniority built up, it can be an extremely flexible, lucrative and stress free career. And even though the romantic nature of flying does wear off quite a bit, you still occasionally enjoy things about that as well.
This all day long...VERY well said. The guys that are the worst to fly with are the guys that think we're curing cancer or something. To me, if your family/life/personality can handle the away time, I can't think of a better gig.
Reply
Old 06-22-2021 | 02:04 PM
  #70  
DeltaboundRedux's Avatar
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Nov 2020
Posts: 2,900
Likes: 155
From: Enoch Powell Enthusiast
Default

Median = The median is the middle number in a sorted, ascending or descending, list of numbers and can be more descriptive of that data set than the average.

(No clue how accurate this table is. Note the (*); some of these figures are averages, not medians)

Personally, I'd say over the life of a pilot career, it feels about right. Maybe even on the low side. Good money for the amount of work involved.

Last edited by DeltaboundRedux; 03-15-2022 at 07:01 AM.
Reply
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
oldmako
United
103
10-25-2019 12:02 PM
Fly Navy
Career Questions
63
02-06-2014 08:39 AM
Ottopilot
Hangar Talk
26
01-01-2011 06:20 PM
RockBottom
Major
0
07-12-2005 11:15 AM
Freighter Captain
Major
2
06-10-2005 11:32 PM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Your Privacy Choices