Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   American (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/)
-   -   Vote NO. Why: (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/143687-vote-no-why.html)

FangsF15 07-15-2023 01:16 PM


Originally Posted by El Peso (Post 3666428)
Top rate of 417.54 vs 421.72 is 1%. Where are you getting 2?

Did involuntary FSB survive?

I do think many will change to a no just on principle.

DL's contract takes a look at the top captain rate, and if higher takes that higher number and add's 1% to it. The tables in UA's AIP (which trigger the DL 1% Me-Too) have not yet included that 1%, so you need to add another 1% to that 421.72. After that math, the new top rate is $425.94, or about 2.01% above the current DL/AA rate of 417.54.

No more involuntary FSB for UA,

Name User 07-15-2023 01:21 PM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by FangsF15 (Post 3666432)
It's not $2. It's more like 2%. Over every cell on every Table. after you do the require math, that will put the NB rate you just quoted at about 356.52. $20 bucks an hour enough to make you reconsider? The 2026 value will be about $404.86. Top end caption will be 483.68.

Can you explain how $338.48 becomes $356.52? And why it doesn't say $356.52 instead?

I took Calculus at a community college so I am math challenged.

FangsF15 07-15-2023 01:26 PM


Originally Posted by Name User (Post 3666437)
Can you explain how $338.48 becomes $356.52? And why it doesn't say $356.52 instead?

I took Calculus at a community college so I am math challenged.

Keep in mind that table does not yet include the 1% snap up, according to the text below that table in the UA AIP. That's why it doesn't say 356.52.

As I stated above, DL's me too is tiggered off the top paying captain rate, then takes that % and adds it to the rest of the tables. UA's AIP adds 2.01% to every single cell. UA then "snaps up" to match the new DL rate making UA&DL the same for the duration of the contract. The top NB rate at DL is for the 757 and 321 NEO, which will now become about 356.52. AA did not include a me-too in thier AIP, correct?.

In all the haste of math, need to make sure are comparing apples to apples here too. We may have crossed the streams, I can't keep up on the fly. So correct me if I'm wrong.

*Edit* I think we (I?) mixed two different airframes from 2 different tables. The top NB rate is 356.52, but the cell you are going off of isn't the top rate. So 338.48 becomes 345.24. I thought the rate you were quoting was the top rate for comparison. My apologies for the mix up.

Name User 07-15-2023 01:28 PM


Originally Posted by FangsF15 (Post 3666441)
As I stated above, DL's me too is tiggered off the top paying captain rate, then takes that % and adds it to the rest of the tables. UA's AIP adds 2.01% to every single cell. UA then "snaps up" to match the new DL rate making UA&DL the same for the duration of the contract. AA did not include a me-too in thier AIP, correct?.

2% on $338.48 is $345.25, where did $356.52 come from again? That's a 5% difference in pay vs AA(!).

No snap up, but we did get perpetual 3% raises after agreement expires. APA felt that was a fair trade. If the difference is $20/hr, certainly not agreeable with that but I still can't follow your pilot math.

thrust 07-15-2023 01:34 PM


Originally Posted by Name User (Post 3666444)
2% on $338.48 is $345.25, where did $356.52 come from again? That's a 5% difference in pay vs AA(!).

No snap up, but we did get perpetual 3% raises after agreement expires. APA felt that was a fair trade. If the difference is $20/hr, certainly not agreeable with that but I still can't follow your pilot math.

”Perpetual” raises? As in every year for infinity? No they didn’t.

Name User 07-15-2023 01:37 PM


Originally Posted by thrust (Post 3666453)
”Perpetual” raises? As in every year for infinity? No they didn’t.

You might be right. I had read that somewhere but it sounded too good to be true. I wonder why they didn't get a snapup, what was the trade?

OK I see it. We got a 3% raise after agreement expires for that year. That was the trade. WTF were they thinking with that.

Jdub2 07-15-2023 01:47 PM

And to reiterate what was said earlier United has improved Reserve QOL including the elimination of FSB/Hot reserve

Montcalm 07-15-2023 01:50 PM


Originally Posted by Name User (Post 3666423)
UA has hot reserve, AA does not. Would you trade that? Would you throw the junior under the bus for the stuff in the UA contract? I bet most would but definitely not a great look.

Wrong. Field standby becomes VOLUNTARY ONLY, and is compensated well. Just like Delta. Are you guys being disingenuous, or just lazy?



Page 13 of UPA23.

NEW - No mandatory Field Standby assignments; Voluntary Field Standby pays 3 hours of Add Pay
Clearly you care about the "junior". Thanks for the laugh.

ImSoSuss 07-15-2023 01:52 PM


Originally Posted by Jdub2 (Post 3666468)
And to reiterate what was said earlier United has improved Reserve QOL including the elimination of FSB/Hot reserve

HUGE! Absolutely huge!

For the people in the back, this is what it looks like to score a significant QOL gain during the most pilot friendly negotiating environment we have ever seen.

LAXtoDEN 07-15-2023 01:56 PM


Originally Posted by ImSoSuss (Post 3666474)
HUGE! Absolutely huge!

For the people in the back, this is what it looks like to score a significant QOL gain during the most pilot friendly negotiating environment we have ever seen.

I can’t tell you if you’re a massive troll or just an idiot, but Delta and American never had FSB to negotiate because THEY CURRENTLY DON’T HAVE FEILD STANBY. Only one major airline pilot group had to suck that up for the last 5 years.

If that’s considered a “Win” for UAL ALPA it’s the most pathetic W in the history of airline bargaining. They shouldn’t have wasted a dime of barging on FSB.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:36 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands