Vaccine Development Summary
#71
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: May 2020
Posts: 484
A vaccine with a typical 5-10 year development period has some SMALL risk. But at least two of them that did have a 5-10 year development period made things worse, one of those found only in very late stage 3 testing and one not found until a million people had been given it. A vaccine developed in a year or two has an undetermined risk - because we have never done that before. Ever.
THAT was the point that was being made in the articles I referenced. I am, as I said , not in the least opposed to vaccine development and believe that all too many people fail to avail themselves of immunizations they ought to get.
I am concerned, however, that the expectations of most people touting the COVID vaccine as the answer to the pandemic indicate they do not understand how quickly a safe and effective vaccine can be produced. And their expectations of how effective that vaccine might be, and how soon a mass immunization program based upon it could help the current situation are UNREALISTIC.
There is also the ethical issue of immunizing those healthy young people to whom COVID-19 represents a fairly trivial risk to provide herd immunity to benefit the elderly and those with multiple comorbidiies and how willing those young healthy people are going to be to be vaccinated with a vaccine with little track record for - mainly - the benefit of others.
Those are real issues however much you might want to pretend they are not.
THAT was the point that was being made in the articles I referenced. I am, as I said , not in the least opposed to vaccine development and believe that all too many people fail to avail themselves of immunizations they ought to get.
I am concerned, however, that the expectations of most people touting the COVID vaccine as the answer to the pandemic indicate they do not understand how quickly a safe and effective vaccine can be produced. And their expectations of how effective that vaccine might be, and how soon a mass immunization program based upon it could help the current situation are UNREALISTIC.
There is also the ethical issue of immunizing those healthy young people to whom COVID-19 represents a fairly trivial risk to provide herd immunity to benefit the elderly and those with multiple comorbidiies and how willing those young healthy people are going to be to be vaccinated with a vaccine with little track record for - mainly - the benefit of others.
Those are real issues however much you might want to pretend they are not.
Yeah so none of that was an answer to my question. You even started a thread we need a plan B but have yet to provide one that vaccines aren’t the answer for half a decade or more.
so let’s talk about a couple of things one this virus if it doesn’t kill does seem to be leaving quite a bit of residual morbidity in patients so a vaccine is likely to still be far better them natural infection.
malaria and corona viruses are not the same class to AED remain theoretical at this point. Malaria actually gets worse every time you get it vaccine or natural infection. If antibody enhancement is common with COVID it will occur naturally as well.
Since we have decided we are only gonna go for a Pharma savior from this virus a vaccine is gonna have to do. We can’t keep let this rampage through the community. So you have vaccine or extremely strict Wuhan style police enforced forced quarantine style lockdown. That’s it there is no other plan so pick one and live with it.
#72
Yeah so none of that was an answer to my question. You even started a thread we need a plan B but have yet to provide one that vaccines aren’t the answer for half a decade or more.
so let’s talk about a couple of things one this virus if it doesn’t kill does seem to be leaving quite a bit of residual morbidity in patients so a vaccine is likely to still be far better them natural infection.
malaria and corona viruses are not the same class to AED remain theoretical at this point. Malaria actually gets worse every time you get it vaccine or natural infection. If antibody enhancement is common with COVID it will occur naturally as well.
Since we have decided we are only gonna go for a Pharma savior from this virus a vaccine is gonna have to do. We can’t keep let this rampage through the community. So you have vaccine or extremely strict Wuhan style police enforced forced quarantine style lockdown. That’s it there is no other plan so pick one and live with it.
so let’s talk about a couple of things one this virus if it doesn’t kill does seem to be leaving quite a bit of residual morbidity in patients so a vaccine is likely to still be far better them natural infection.
malaria and corona viruses are not the same class to AED remain theoretical at this point. Malaria actually gets worse every time you get it vaccine or natural infection. If antibody enhancement is common with COVID it will occur naturally as well.
Since we have decided we are only gonna go for a Pharma savior from this virus a vaccine is gonna have to do. We can’t keep let this rampage through the community. So you have vaccine or extremely strict Wuhan style police enforced forced quarantine style lockdown. That’s it there is no other plan so pick one and live with it.
This thread is. Not about my opinions of a Plan B - or Answering your questions about it. It’s about issues with coronavirus development. I pointed out some. Real one. Do you care to comment about them?
#73
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: May 2020
Posts: 484
Its been answered so many times I have lost count. Without a vaccine the world is going back to normal unless we get a seriously effective therapeutic the world is not going back to normal. Also it should be added the effects found after millions have been vaccinated is in a phase 4 trail. That occurs after approval.
#74
#75
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: May 2020
Posts: 484
I thought that is what the vaccine had shown so far. Some upper respiratory infections in animals but no advancement. Granted I gather these are animals and not humans but that seems to be the goal break the severe disease and move on.
#76
A vaccine with a typical 5-10 year development period has some SMALL risk. But at least two of them that did have a 5-10 year development period made things worse, one of those found only in very late stage 3 testing and one not found until a million people had been given it. A vaccine developed in a year or two has an undetermined risk - because we have never done that before. Ever.
Again, they are completing the full development programs. I had speculated early on that they *might* deploy a vaccine prior to completion of all clinical trials IF the pandemic turned out to be really awful. That didn't happen, and there's no indication that anyone (including China) is skipping anything safety related.
They're just doing as much in parallel as they can, and are not being held up by red tape or financial considerations at all.
There is also the ethical issue of immunizing those healthy young people to whom COVID-19 represents a fairly trivial risk to provide herd immunity to benefit the elderly and those with multiple comorbidiies and how willing those young healthy people are going to be to be vaccinated with a vaccine with little track record for - mainly - the benefit of others.
They sure as hell "vaccinated" the economy for the benefit of 5% of the population. Euthanzed more like.
So how do you establish a "track record" anyway? In the industry that's called phase 4 trials.
Most of the things we vaccinate for are a serious health risk to a small subset of the population... vaccination programs are as much about herd immunity as individual protection.
Bottom line, all civilian vaccinations are optional at least in the US. So feel free to wait if you like. Many folks will do it so they can go back to work or school, if for no other reason.
Worst case, China will vaccinate all their folks at gunpoint and you can watch and see how it works out for them.
Bottom line, there's risks and obstacles but there's no reason to believe that EVERY risk and obstacle will come to fruition. The people working on this know what all of the risks and obstacles are. I think you're underestimating human perseverance and stubborness on this one.
#77
Ideally you want a vaccine to prevent infection because that prevents further contagion and stops the spread.
A vaccine affect which reduces severity would be a consolation prize, since a patient with a mild case of covid would likely still be infectious to others. Time will tell.
#78
Yeah so none of that was an answer to my question. You even started a thread we need a plan B but have yet to provide one that vaccines aren’t the answer for half a decade or more.
so let’s talk about a couple of things one this virus if it doesn’t kill does seem to be leaving quite a bit of residual morbidity in patients so a vaccine is likely to still be far better them natural infection.
malaria and corona viruses are not the same class to AED remain theoretical at this point. Malaria actually gets worse every time you get it vaccine or natural infection. If antibody enhancement is common with COVID it will occur naturally as well.
Since we have decided we are only gonna go for a Pharma savior from this virus a vaccine is gonna have to do. We can’t keep let this rampage through the community. So you have vaccine or extremely strict Wuhan style police enforced forced quarantine style lockdown. That’s it there is no other plan so pick one and live with it.
so let’s talk about a couple of things one this virus if it doesn’t kill does seem to be leaving quite a bit of residual morbidity in patients so a vaccine is likely to still be far better them natural infection.
malaria and corona viruses are not the same class to AED remain theoretical at this point. Malaria actually gets worse every time you get it vaccine or natural infection. If antibody enhancement is common with COVID it will occur naturally as well.
Since we have decided we are only gonna go for a Pharma savior from this virus a vaccine is gonna have to do. We can’t keep let this rampage through the community. So you have vaccine or extremely strict Wuhan style police enforced forced quarantine style lockdown. That’s it there is no other plan so pick one and live with it.
#80
Gets Weekends Off
Joined APC: Dec 2017
Position: Retired NJA & AA
Posts: 1,920
3rd Vaccine Shows Promise, 90% effective rate
https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/04/healt...=1596622315220
A third company has released study results showing it's COVID-19 vaccine is safe and effective. 131 volunteers developed neutralizing antibodies at levels more than 4 times higher on average than persons who had recovered from the virus.
A third company has released study results showing it's COVID-19 vaccine is safe and effective. 131 volunteers developed neutralizing antibodies at levels more than 4 times higher on average than persons who had recovered from the virus.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post