...things left out in the contract comparison
#41
Moderator
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 7,265
Likes: 112
From: DAL 330
I also Agree Reserve is much better. I don't like the ALV +15 part, but I also think it gets a disproportionate amount of attention. I would like to correct it, but first I would like to try to improve a lot of things that impact a much larger proportion of our Pilots.
Scoop
#42
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 4,116
Likes: 1
agreed. that is exactly what would happen. because that would be the economic reality.
the way is forward. with the (de?)-evolving pwa work rules we have fundamentally altered the role and behavior of a cba represented employee.
in large measure what we have become is akin to independent contractors operating within an employment contract framework.
think...'uber'.
in our present circumstance....economic reward is more based on the individuals motivations, priorities, and acumen at navigating the contract parameters.....instead of the historic norm of collective limitations set to insure uniformity of economic outcome.
Management clearly gets (and wanted/desires) this.......and the argument of if we want it or not is immaterial.....we have it.
the pwa imperative has always been to protect you from predatory management.....AND given the new paradigm....from the other 13,000 now predatory pilots on the property.
the way is forward. with the (de?)-evolving pwa work rules we have fundamentally altered the role and behavior of a cba represented employee.
in large measure what we have become is akin to independent contractors operating within an employment contract framework.
think...'uber'.
in our present circumstance....economic reward is more based on the individuals motivations, priorities, and acumen at navigating the contract parameters.....instead of the historic norm of collective limitations set to insure uniformity of economic outcome.
Management clearly gets (and wanted/desires) this.......and the argument of if we want it or not is immaterial.....we have it.
the pwa imperative has always been to protect you from predatory management.....AND given the new paradigm....from the other 13,000 now predatory pilots on the property.
#43
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 5,152
Likes: 130
You are welcome, sorry it went on much longer than I had intended and I left a lot out, but the bottom line is, we are working a LOT more now, than we ever did before PBS, which was the intent of PBS all along. And we are working for rates that are still 18% BELOW 2004 rates, with less vacation weeks as well.
Add in the fact that due to the FAR change to age 65, we are now the oldest pilots in the history of commercial aviation, with guys trying to fly maximum time lines at age 64+ to try to recover the millions they lost in the DB termination, and the company has the gall to claim our sick leave is up too much??
We need to restore our retirement, restore our pay rates, and restore our 75 hour cap. But ALPA National acts like the last 12 years never happened, not a peep about restoring the profession.
Of course if your real aim is to take a job as the President at National, then move on to an A4A consulting gig, well, why would you want to rock that boat?
Add in the fact that due to the FAR change to age 65, we are now the oldest pilots in the history of commercial aviation, with guys trying to fly maximum time lines at age 64+ to try to recover the millions they lost in the DB termination, and the company has the gall to claim our sick leave is up too much??

We need to restore our retirement, restore our pay rates, and restore our 75 hour cap. But ALPA National acts like the last 12 years never happened, not a peep about restoring the profession.
Of course if your real aim is to take a job as the President at National, then move on to an A4A consulting gig, well, why would you want to rock that boat?

#44
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 5,152
Likes: 130
Timbo provided and excellent history lesson, but let's not forget the other side of the "good ol days." Ideally we restore the good and permanently discard the bad.
1. Pre 1996 the DAL pilots didn't have the jumpseat, even on their own airline!
2. In the 80s reserve was perpetual 24/7 short call for all the days you were on the hook! That can't happen now due to FAR 117. Still when I got hired 19 yrs ago your first day on reserve was automatic short call at 0300. To be fair with the old move up system you could often minimize the number of days you were on reserve.
3. As well as I did with our old Line of Time system I wouldn't want to go back. No vacation slide and no bidding for CQ. My last two sessions of CQ that were scheduled the old way (ie the company scheduled you and you couldn't bid on any CQ patterns) were almost comical in how much it screwed up my personal home life.
4. The biggest thing of all is that reserves were paid far less for the same trip as a regular line holders in the other seat. This was literally fixed two years ago with our FAR 117 side letter! It was a tremendous accomplishment, that many DALPA haters dismiss as if it were nothing.
I just like to point out both sides of the issues, because there usually are at least that many.
1. Pre 1996 the DAL pilots didn't have the jumpseat, even on their own airline!
2. In the 80s reserve was perpetual 24/7 short call for all the days you were on the hook! That can't happen now due to FAR 117. Still when I got hired 19 yrs ago your first day on reserve was automatic short call at 0300. To be fair with the old move up system you could often minimize the number of days you were on reserve.
3. As well as I did with our old Line of Time system I wouldn't want to go back. No vacation slide and no bidding for CQ. My last two sessions of CQ that were scheduled the old way (ie the company scheduled you and you couldn't bid on any CQ patterns) were almost comical in how much it screwed up my personal home life.
4. The biggest thing of all is that reserves were paid far less for the same trip as a regular line holders in the other seat. This was literally fixed two years ago with our FAR 117 side letter! It was a tremendous accomplishment, that many DALPA haters dismiss as if it were nothing.
I just like to point out both sides of the issues, because there usually are at least that many.
#45
Runs with scissors
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 7,847
Likes: 0
From: Going to hell in a bucket, but enjoying the ride .
agreed. that is exactly what would happen. because that would be the economic reality.
the way is forward. with the (de?)-evolving pwa work rules we have fundamentally altered the role and behavior of a cba represented employee.
in large measure what we have become is akin to independent contractors operating within an employment contract framework.
think...'uber'.
in our present circumstance....economic reward is more based on the individuals motivations, priorities, and acumen at navigating the contract parameters.....instead of the historic norm of collective limitations set to insure uniformity of economic outcome.
Management clearly gets this.
the pwa imperative has always been to protect you from predatory management.....AND given the new paradigm....from the other 13,000 now predatory pilots on the property.
the way is forward. with the (de?)-evolving pwa work rules we have fundamentally altered the role and behavior of a cba represented employee.
in large measure what we have become is akin to independent contractors operating within an employment contract framework.
think...'uber'.
in our present circumstance....economic reward is more based on the individuals motivations, priorities, and acumen at navigating the contract parameters.....instead of the historic norm of collective limitations set to insure uniformity of economic outcome.
Management clearly gets this.
the pwa imperative has always been to protect you from predatory management.....AND given the new paradigm....from the other 13,000 now predatory pilots on the property.
But the huge pay and retirement cuts we had forced on us in bankruptcy have turned us from enjoying our 18 days off every month, to a "How many greenslips can I get this month?" type mentality, because we are now trying to self fund our retirement plans and make up for the 42% pay cut by flying 90+ per month.
The company LOVES the extra productivity we are -voluntarily- giving them by working more by picking up trips in every vacation month, swapping way above the cap, picking up more time off the pilot to pilot swap board, etc.
Just that many fewer guys they have to upgrade to Captain and that many fewer guys they'll have to hire to fly the schedule.
We could try to fix all this extra overtime flying by changing the PBS scheduling rules; make a hard 75hr. ALV with a fixed cap every month, making vacation both pay AND credit, etc. but so many guys have become addicted to a 90+ hour month, plus green slips, you would hear a lot of screaming if we did, no doubt.
#46
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 5,152
Likes: 130
Bob brings up an excellent point that has been lost on this pilot group since bankruptcy. When I was a new hire we were often told that the contract served two purposes; to protect us from the company and to protect us from ourselves. We flew about 12 days a month for 75 hours and that paid the bills.
But the huge pay and retirement cuts we had forced on us in bankruptcy have turned us from enjoying our 18 days off every month, to a "How many greenslips can I get this month?" type mentality, because we are now trying to self fund our retirement plans and make up for the 42% pay cut by flying 90+ per month.
The company LOVES the extra productivity we are -voluntarily- giving them by working more by picking up trips in every vacation month, swapping way above the cap, picking up more time off the pilot to pilot swap board, etc.
Just that many fewer guys they have to upgrade to Captain and that many fewer guys they'll have to hire to fly the schedule.
We could try to fix all this extra overtime flying by changing the PBS scheduling rules; make a hard 75hr. ALV with a fixed cap every month, making vacation both pay AND credit, etc. but so many guys have become addicted to a 90+ hour month, plus green slips, you would hear a lot of screaming if we did, no doubt.
But the huge pay and retirement cuts we had forced on us in bankruptcy have turned us from enjoying our 18 days off every month, to a "How many greenslips can I get this month?" type mentality, because we are now trying to self fund our retirement plans and make up for the 42% pay cut by flying 90+ per month.
The company LOVES the extra productivity we are -voluntarily- giving them by working more by picking up trips in every vacation month, swapping way above the cap, picking up more time off the pilot to pilot swap board, etc.
Just that many fewer guys they have to upgrade to Captain and that many fewer guys they'll have to hire to fly the schedule.
We could try to fix all this extra overtime flying by changing the PBS scheduling rules; make a hard 75hr. ALV with a fixed cap every month, making vacation both pay AND credit, etc. but so many guys have become addicted to a 90+ hour month, plus green slips, you would hear a lot of screaming if we did, no doubt.
The idea of a career full of 75 hour max months sounds amazing to me. Perhaps sharing those ideas with the spouses and kids at home would provide some needed pressure to back off the time card!
#47
This thread alone has already opened my eyes. You may get a lot of screaming with these types of changes, but there are a ton of new folks coming on board who aren't addicted to anything just yet. They just need more information that ISN'T all about maximizing green slips or rolling thunder. We've got a great bunch who are willing to listen and learn.
The idea of a career full of 75 hour max months sounds amazing to me. Perhaps sharing those ideas with the spouses and kids at home would provide some needed pressure to back off the time card!
The idea of a career full of 75 hour max months sounds amazing to me. Perhaps sharing those ideas with the spouses and kids at home would provide some needed pressure to back off the time card!
Anybody know what the revenue/.pilot was pre-PBS versus now? THAT would be an interesting number to see. Then compare that to the cost/pilot. Of course cost is like getting a real read on the CPI from the government. You never know what important factor they are leaving out that would vhange the numbers.
#48
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Sep 2014
Posts: 5,152
Likes: 130
You can bid only 75 hours/month if you want. There is no minimum requirement. You can fly 50 if you want.
Anybody know what the revenue/.pilot was pre-PBS versus now? THAT would be an interesting number to see. Then compare that to the cost/pilot. Of course cost is like getting a real read on the CPI from the government. You never know what important factor they are leaving out that would vhange the numbers.
Anybody know what the revenue/.pilot was pre-PBS versus now? THAT would be an interesting number to see. Then compare that to the cost/pilot. Of course cost is like getting a real read on the CPI from the government. You never know what important factor they are leaving out that would vhange the numbers.
#49
Runs with scissors
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 7,847
Likes: 0
From: Going to hell in a bucket, but enjoying the ride .
This thread alone has already opened my eyes. You may get a lot of screaming with these types of changes, but there are a ton of new folks coming on board who aren't addicted to anything just yet. They just need more information that ISN'T all about maximizing green slips or rolling thunder. We've got a great bunch who are willing to listen and learn.
The idea of a career full of 75 hour max months sounds amazing to me. Perhaps sharing those ideas with the spouses and kids at home would provide some needed pressure to back off the time card!
The idea of a career full of 75 hour max months sounds amazing to me. Perhaps sharing those ideas with the spouses and kids at home would provide some needed pressure to back off the time card!
I asked how.
He said he always flew 120 hours in 30 days, and the last 32 of it was usually on a green slip, now he's limited to -only- 100 in 28 days.

He usually buddy bids with the LCA's and drops a lot of his trips, which is good for him, I have no problem with that, but then picking up all that extra time is a bit much. I'm still married to the same wife after 28 years of this stuff. I always chose time off at home with the wife/4 kids over flying more for more money. A long time ago I set a personal limit at 15 days a month, only because most months are 30 days. I said to myself, "When you are gone more than you are home, it's time to cut back."
Life is short, you never know when you're going to check out, and nobody on their death bed ever said, "I wish I had worked more!"
This is part of the reason I never moved to ATL, choosing to commute from someplace I like to spend my 18 days off per month instead. That way I wouldn't be tempted to fly all the GS I could, as some guys have become addicted to.
The ironic part of all this is, if you really want 'More Money, More Time Off' you would work LESS, not more. If everyone was still only flying 75 hours, there would be 20% more wide body captains and all the way down the list there would be 20% more guys in higher paying seats, working less, not more.
#50
Trust me, I do. Min credit, RLL when able. However, I could still end up with a line worth over 80 and no or limited ability to drop based on manning being horrendous (see discussion about reserves on hand). That being said, it doesn't do any of us any good it COULD do if other guys are flying 90+. Hence, COLLECTIVE bargaining. All the posts above (not mine) hit the nail on the head...I believe the PWA should very much save us from ourselves.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



