401K Dues
#51
If regional pilots were smart (and had some balls), they'd form a half dozen or so pilots in a group and get grass roots movement to form a new union strictly for the interests of regional airline pilots and coordinate with equivalent groups at other regional carriers.
If you could form a new regional union for the largest 2 or 3 regionals, I'm sure most others would follow. If you really examine ALPA's effectiveness over the last decade for ALL its represented pilots, you'd see they've become virtually worthless.
You have nothing to lose and everything to gain.
If you could form a new regional union for the largest 2 or 3 regionals, I'm sure most others would follow. If you really examine ALPA's effectiveness over the last decade for ALL its represented pilots, you'd see they've become virtually worthless.
You have nothing to lose and everything to gain.
#52
Banned
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 8,350
Likes: 0
Yes, that sounds like a great idea. Then they could pay 5% dues because that's what it would take to fund such a venture, and even then only if the biggest regionals like Eagle and ASA/XJT were to join. Without them, think 10% dues. So, in other words, that wouldn't be such a smart move after all.
An initial funding of perhaps $1,000 per pilot of say 6,000 pilots of the top 2 regionals would be an initial stake of 6 million which would serve those pilots well considering their numbers. More pilots = more stake. 1% annual dues would do well also as you wouldn't be paying half million dollar annual compensation for the top officers or have an excessively bloated operational structure. They could join the AFL-CIO too, not that clout in Washington means anything as ALPA has proved over the last decade with their continued impotence.
Exiting quickly may also free them from the likely massive assessment and/or additional dues increase to pay for their malfeasance in representing the interests of the former TWA pilots.
Nope, this is a no-brainer and even a cave man could see that. The only ones who can't are hopeless ALPA lapdogs and lackeys.
#53
Go ahead and continue your ignorant ranting. ALPA has effected more positive changes for our industry than any independent pilot union (or non-union group) could ever dream of doing. Anyone advocating for the demise of ALPA truly belongs in a different industry. I'm not thrilled by the recent changes related to the 401k; however, I understand why it happened. This merely leveled the playing field on dues contribution.
#54
If regional pilots were smart (and had some balls), they'd form a half dozen or so pilots in a group and get grass roots movement to form a new union strictly for the interests of regional airline pilots and coordinate with equivalent groups at other regional carriers.
If you could form a new regional union for the largest 2 or 3 regionals, I'm sure most others would follow. If you really examine ALPA's effectiveness over the last decade for ALL its represented pilots, you'd see they've become virtually worthless.
You have nothing to lose and everything to gain.
If you could form a new regional union for the largest 2 or 3 regionals, I'm sure most others would follow. If you really examine ALPA's effectiveness over the last decade for ALL its represented pilots, you'd see they've become virtually worthless.
You have nothing to lose and everything to gain.
#55
Hello pot, this is kettle.....
It's ironic how many people advocate the reduction of other's salaries; yet when someone comes knocking for theirs, the sabers are rattled. What a freaking joke!
#56
Perhaps you make too much as well? Please, let us all know why you believe you're worth the money you earn???
Hello pot, this is kettle.....
It's ironic how many people advocate the reduction of other's salaries; yet when someone comes knocking for theirs, the sabers are rattled. What a freaking joke!
Hello pot, this is kettle.....
It's ironic how many people advocate the reduction of other's salaries; yet when someone comes knocking for theirs, the sabers are rattled. What a freaking joke!
#57

Talk about "pure B.S."
More pilots = more stake. 1% annual dues would do well also as you wouldn't be paying half million dollar annual compensation for the top officers or have an excessively bloated operational structure.
As far as a 1% dues structure being able to fund a regional pilot's union, that's nothing but pure fantasy. We had an independent union at AirTran prior to joining ALPA. Our dues rate during contract negotiations was 2.15%. Even with that dues rate, we struggled to have enough money to fund the essentials, and that was with very few people ever on flight pay loss. I have a feeling that you don't have an understanding of just how much it costs to hire attorneys, professional negotiators, accountants, and financial analysts, all of which are absolutely necessary for even the basic functioning of a labor union. That doesn't even begin to look at the other people like R&I specialists, Aeromedical, accident investigators, and so on. The costs to fund all of this are astronomical. Your $6 million figure as being something that could work shows just how clueless you are about how expensive this stuff is. You wouldn't even scratch the surface of necessary services for several pilot groups at that amount of money.
They could join the AFL-CIO
Exiting quickly may also free them from the likely massive assessment and/or additional dues increase to pay for their malfeasance in representing the interests of the former TWA pilots.
#58
Banned
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 8,350
Likes: 0
Yes, because I know a whole lot of regional FOs (or even captains) who can throw down $1,000 at the drop of a hat. 
Talk about "pure B.S."
Anyone who thinks that the ALPA structure is "bloated" hasn't been to Herndon or the DC Office in many, many years (or never). Such an argument might have been made in the "good old days," but not now. ALPA runs quite lean. Some would say too lean.
As far as a 1% dues structure being able to fund a regional pilot's union, that's nothing but pure fantasy. We had an independent union at AirTran prior to joining ALPA. Our dues rate during contract negotiations was 2.15%. Even with that dues rate, we struggled to have enough money to fund the essentials, and that was with very few people ever on flight pay loss. I have a feeling that you don't have an understanding of just how much it costs to hire attorneys, professional negotiators, accountants, and financial analysts, all of which are absolutely necessary for even the basic functioning of a labor union. That doesn't even begin to look at the other people like R&I specialists, Aeromedical, accident investigators, and so on. The costs to fund all of this are astronomical. Your $6 million figure as being something that could work shows just how clueless you are about how expensive this stuff is. You wouldn't even scratch the surface of necessary services for several pilot groups at that amount of money.
Highly doubtful that the AFL would ever accept a competing pilot's union for membership. Our profession doesn't have a big enough membership to justify multiple unions within the AFL.
There will be no assessments or additional dues.

Talk about "pure B.S."
Anyone who thinks that the ALPA structure is "bloated" hasn't been to Herndon or the DC Office in many, many years (or never). Such an argument might have been made in the "good old days," but not now. ALPA runs quite lean. Some would say too lean.
As far as a 1% dues structure being able to fund a regional pilot's union, that's nothing but pure fantasy. We had an independent union at AirTran prior to joining ALPA. Our dues rate during contract negotiations was 2.15%. Even with that dues rate, we struggled to have enough money to fund the essentials, and that was with very few people ever on flight pay loss. I have a feeling that you don't have an understanding of just how much it costs to hire attorneys, professional negotiators, accountants, and financial analysts, all of which are absolutely necessary for even the basic functioning of a labor union. That doesn't even begin to look at the other people like R&I specialists, Aeromedical, accident investigators, and so on. The costs to fund all of this are astronomical. Your $6 million figure as being something that could work shows just how clueless you are about how expensive this stuff is. You wouldn't even scratch the surface of necessary services for several pilot groups at that amount of money.
Highly doubtful that the AFL would ever accept a competing pilot's union for membership. Our profession doesn't have a big enough membership to justify multiple unions within the AFL.
There will be no assessments or additional dues.
The top officers total compensation approaches $500K which is obscene considering their performance......or lack thereof. I'll continue to laugh heartily at any sucker who's convinced themselves throwing their money away to these people is worthwhile.
#59
A beautiful (but empty) propagandist diatribe. Every day regional pilots keep their cart hitched to this wobbly horse is another lost day. The lapdogs and lackeys don't want regional pilots to leave ALPA because that way ALPA can't control them and continue to use them as doormats for mainline pilots interests. As long as any regional chains themselves to this master they will remain indentured servants in perpetuity.
The top officers total compensation approaches $500K which is obscene considering their performance......or lack thereof. I'll continue to laugh heartily at any sucker who's convinced themselves throwing their money away to these people is worthwhile.
The top officers total compensation approaches $500K which is obscene considering their performance......or lack thereof. I'll continue to laugh heartily at any sucker who's convinced themselves throwing their money away to these people is worthwhile.
Deleted......just not worth it.
Last edited by Cruise; 10-21-2012 at 10:15 AM.
#60
The lapdogs and lackeys don't want regional pilots to leave ALPA because that way ALPA can't control them and continue to use them as doormats for mainline pilots interests. As long as any regional chains themselves to this master they will remain indentured servants in perpetuity.
The top officers total compensation approaches $500K
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



