Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Delta (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/delta/)
-   -   Any "Latest & Greatest" about Delta? (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/delta/36912-any-latest-greatest-about-delta.html)

sailingfun 07-04-2011 03:40 AM


Originally Posted by Flamer (Post 1017588)
If ALPAs opener is what I think it will be, I bet that 50% will happen very quick. If ALPAs defense is "these guys won't vote us out during negotiations" they are in for a surprise.

Dalpa's opener will be based on the pilot contract surveys. However if you believe the opener is how you define success in contract negotiations you have a very limited grasp of the process and the RLA. Americans opener was breathtaking to read as a pilot. It contained large pay increases and huge gains in work rules. I guess you would define APA's contract negotiations as a success. I would however think otherwise at this point.

forgot to bid 07-04-2011 04:04 AM


Originally Posted by Bill Lumberg (Post 1017604)
You're damn right. The DALPA opener will make or break them. I am tired of having a concessionary contract while the airline is making huge profits, and then DALPA gives us memos trying to manage our expectations. "How to read a balance sheet" and "understanding hedging"??? How about "being paid Southwest +1% for the 737, and tightening scope?". Maybe the DPA would do a better job at directing negotiations from their constituents directly, instead of just managing expectations?

You make a great post Bill but remember that while SWA may have 738s on order they're entire fleet right now consists of aircraft smaller than the MD88, the second lowest paying aircraft in our fleet, a mission profile of high cycle domestic trips.

And some of that new fleet will be 717s that will probably be negotiated to the same pay rate as the 737 since they're the same as their 735s. The 717 is a DC9-30. We have DC9 pay rates.

So MD88/DC9 pay at SWA 737 pay.

forgot to bid 07-04-2011 04:09 AM


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1017639)
SWAPA has never fought for or achieved a thing. They simply accepted sub standard contracts throughout their history. Normally about 20 percent below the rest of the industry when generally their airline was the most profitable around. It sounds like you missed the events in the industry from 2001 to 2006 so I wont get into detail on how they got to the top of the pay scale however you can google it.
They are not going to fight to stay at the top and want us to regain our historical advantage. You might review the history of their contracts and what they normally signed for.
There is one union that has been fighting hard for the last 5 years. That is APA. They have fought long and hard. They have achieved however nothing. You need to fight hard but also smart.
SWAPA contract is not good enough as I have pointed out. When you go into negotiations and try and compare yourself to some other airline they are going to use total block hour costs. I don't want that comparison. I want a lot more.

Sailing, you saying you want a lot more than SWA pay? :)

Ans SWA scope too maybe?

As to how SWA got to where they are is inconsequential though to the fact that theyre not going to give up those rates. But as you say you want a lot more, which is good, right?

iaflyer 07-04-2011 04:44 AM


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1017513)
That metric is better because there is a substantial difference between us and Southwest in that regard. Revenue also provides the means to pay pilots. I have seen the total block hour numbers between Delta and SW. If you compare the 737 we would only need a 8 to 10 percent raise in pay and status quo on everything else to be equal to SW. I want a whole lot more then a 10 percent raise in the next contract. SW is not my goal but seems to be for a lot of people on the forum.

Only 8-10% pay raise? Seems a bit low - because we certainly have 3 day trips that pay 11-14 hours, while at SWA a 3 day trip would pay 16.89 hrs (19.5 TRP * 0.8666) of pay.

Also, just comparing 737 vs 737, Delta 12 yr Captain pays $174 while SWA pays $210 (that's not a TRP rate, that's been converted to $/hr). Maybe it's my math, but that alone requires a 21% raise, just to meet their current pay.


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1017513)
In the rotation you looked at your not comparing hours to hours. The credit numbers are in the SW trip system. A trip is worth 52 minutes.

Yep, you're right, but take those numbers and reduce the pay, it's still plenty more per day than we're making.

shiznit 07-04-2011 05:05 AM


Originally Posted by BigGuns (Post 1017554)
SWA pilots make a hell of a lot more than a 10% raise would ever give us!

Unbelievable! My DPA card is going in the mailbox tonight! You have diminished all of my faith in ALPA! I am done with ALPA...

True, they(SWA) do RECENTLY. Historically this has NOT been the case as mentioned ad nauseum.

Why are you done with ALPA? You don't know the opener. For the last time DALPA doesn't either, contract surveys have not been filled out by the pilots yet.

If DALPA put out a "wish list"/opener, minimum standard publication/press release right now; there are MANY posters here (including me) that would be ****ed at DALPA for making statements on behalf of the pilot group without even asking the pilots what they want first!!

DALPA cannot and will not publish, advertise, release to the media a fictitious set of demands when they don't know what the real desires of the pilots are!

(On a personal note: I look forward to the survey, all you DPA'ers who think we need "SWA pay" are managing my expectations, I have much higher standards than that.)

The SWA rally cry is low-balling ourselves at this point. The last full Sec. 6 contract DAL signed (C2K)was a record breaker, 1996 sucked, 1991 was good, etc.

Relax, don't shoot before you've aimed....

alfaromeo 07-04-2011 05:05 AM


Originally Posted by RockyBoy (Post 1017600)
Do you have buddies at SWA?? I do and I've seen what they make and how much they work. I don't care what you or anyone from ALPA tries to sell, they make WAY more than us and work WAY less than us.

I don't know who you are, but if you have anything to do with ALPA it is people who act like you, and Salingfun, that have pushed 1/4 of the Delta pilots to support DPA and are doing a great job of helping them get even more cards on a daily basis. Good job, keep up the good work. Hopefully you can help us get a union that will take what SWA makes and fight like hell to get that plus more for Delta pilots instead of trying to tell us we don't know what we are talking about.

All right, here is a quote straight from the DPA website:


Our contract goals should consider the profitability of the company and outside financial analysis should provide us with objective opinions on how our company can function under a given proposal.
So even DPA knows that the basis of your contract is the financial condition of the company that you work for. If you are going to negotiate, then you have to start with an accurate picture. If you pull out some propaganda from a flyer that is meant to persuade other pilots to accept a bad seniority integration, then you might as well ask the negotiators to put on a clown suit. You have to have credibility both with the people you are negotiating against and with the NMB that has the power to suspend your negotiations indefinitely.

So, everyone would like more money and more time off. Get over yourself and realize that everyone has the same goal, it is just that to accomplish your goal, you can't act like an idiot and expect any results. Maybe that will give some brief moment of Zen on the internet to spout off how tough you are, but in the end I want more money. Losing your head and making a fool of yourself is not the way to get it. Period.

So I don't know who you are, but you have convinced me that I don't want you running the show. Emotional rants will get me nothing.

727C47 07-04-2011 05:11 AM


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1017639)
SWAPA has never fought for or achieved a thing. They simply accepted sub standard contracts throughout their history. Normally about 20 percent below the rest of the industry when generally their airline was the most profitable around. It sounds like you missed the events in the industry from 2001 to 2006 so I wont get into detail on how they got to the top of the pay scale however you can google it.
They are not going to fight to stay at the top and want us to regain our historical advantage. You might review the history of their contracts and what they normally signed for.
There is one union that has been fighting hard for the last 5 years. That is APA. They have fought long and hard. They have achieved however nothing. You need to fight hard but also smart.
SWAPA contract is not good enough as I have pointed out. When you go into negotiations and try and compare yourself to some other airline they are going to use total block hour costs. I don't want that comparison. I want a lot more.

while i respect your loyalty to DAL, you are wrong about SWA,(DISCLOSURE,i have immediate family flying for them),their union is focused on their pilot group alone and has achieved great things for them,ALPA national is a contradiction ,representing groups whose interests are diametrically opposed and trying to be a fair arbiter to all,good luck with that. I have no skin in your game but i think you would be better served with a union devoted to your people and your concerns (read:SCOPE<SCOPE<SCOPE),anyway happy 4th !!! Good luck gents I have a lot of buds at DAL.

shiznit 07-04-2011 05:14 AM


Originally Posted by DAL 88 Driver (Post 1017421)
No double standard... just a different standard. SWAPA has never given me any reason to doubt what they say or their intentions.

That publication also is a management kool-aid drinkers paradise. 10 pages are devoted to how wonderful the company is and how they have picnic together, etc.

I thought that an union should NOT carry the company's water?

It is a publication that 'brags' on SWA pilots, its not filled with 10-k numbers, actual bid results, end of month numbers, etc. Just one or two anecdotal trip trades....remember that the guy who "dropped" the low time trip in the example to pick up, one person is now flying one less trip that month and/or someone else had to fly the lower time trip be it a reserve or a line holder. Its an "I LUV Me....and So Should You" rag. Little more.

Again, you hold up SWA as a model.... You're shooting way too low and damaging MY chances of a better outcome on the next PWA.

shiznit 07-04-2011 05:14 AM


Originally Posted by DAL 88 Driver (Post 1017350)
And you of course have proof of this, right?

The data in the SWAPA welcome document to the ValuTran pilots seems pretty straightforward to me. Read it again. I don't think you can explain it away that easily. And I highly doubt they have their facts wrong as I'm sure they have access to the actual data.

Where did your data come from? Anecdotal evidence from talking with a few of your friends? Sorry, but I think I'll go with the official numbers published by the folks who have access to the actual data... not a guy on an anonymous web board who constantly argues against any kind of restorative increases for our pilot group.

See previous post.

sinca3 07-04-2011 05:22 AM

Sky Team
 
The beginning of Sky Team Airlines:
Air France-KLM to Follow BA With M&A-Friendly Management Model - Bloomberg


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:47 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands