Envoy or Mesa?
#81
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 540
Likes: 0
Just about, but not quite. They are still whistling past the cemetery. When the tsunami really hits, it will be far too late and there will be a lot of grief and casualties. Some of those casualties will be innocent victims of collateral damage.
The only thing that can really delay the wave is an economic or political situation (or combination) that results in this industry entering another period of stagnation resulting in the music stopping for a period of time at the mainline level. Considering the retirements, it would actually be a period of contraction, but the result would be the same for regional pilots.
Nowhere to really go and all day to get there. Considering the present state of geopolitics and other issues, it's a risky time indeed and the industry is overdue for one of its historically solid dips. Perhaps that's one reason some are so desperate to claim any rogue unspoken for soul in the regional wannabe ranks ?
The only thing that can really delay the wave is an economic or political situation (or combination) that results in this industry entering another period of stagnation resulting in the music stopping for a period of time at the mainline level. Considering the retirements, it would actually be a period of contraction, but the result would be the same for regional pilots.
Nowhere to really go and all day to get there. Considering the present state of geopolitics and other issues, it's a risky time indeed and the industry is overdue for one of its historically solid dips. Perhaps that's one reason some are so desperate to claim any rogue unspoken for soul in the regional wannabe ranks ?
As to Flames numbers. Even in the best case scenario, it's just way too optimistic. Don't forget who you are dealing with here. AAG. They can and do whatever they choose to fit their needs. But, but they do what they say they are going to, right? Yes, when it fits their purpose they will. Right now as they shrink Envoy, I believe their goal is to sweep out the 400 or so remaing 824 and re-evaluate. If market forces finally create a shortage at Envoy for the amount of airframes they want to fly, they ain't gonna let you flow while airplanes sit idle.
Undefers have till 5/1/16 to make their final decision on returning. While AA has to treat undefers as new hires for flow purposes, it's just going to delay Envoy guys flowing until later in the year. Depending on how many undefers decide to come back, Envoy pilots will be left out in the cold until years end. Then, if it requires too many Envoy bodies at that time, you may see AA work a deal with Envoy ALPA, who will play ball by the way, to spill over some flows required in 2016 into 2017.
All that said, I wouldn't recommend Envoy. Especially if you are trying to flow.
#82
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 304
Likes: 0
They will be the casualties. And they will take the innocent victims down with them.
#83
Banned
Joined: Sep 2015
Posts: 519
Likes: 0
I appreciate that, and TBH, I put more weight in your posts than I do for quite a few others here. You seem to post honestly, and with good intent. I can understand how anyone would be frustrated with their company at any given point in their career.
Unfortunately, no one can tell me where the best place to go is. If they could, I would gladly pay for that advice. In addition to that, my crystal ball is OOF, so it is not working either.
. At the end of the day, I will take in all I can, roll the dice, and hope for the best with the options I am currently being offered. As with anyone, there are places that aren't interested, places where I already have a CJO, and places I wouldn't want to be.
Please don't take what I say as an attempt to act as if I know more than you do. I know what I don't know; I just try to piece together as much as I can, and "putting it out there" here in APC is a means to get input on what I perceive to be the truth, as another way of validating (or not) what I am learning/understanding.
Unfortunately, no one can tell me where the best place to go is. If they could, I would gladly pay for that advice. In addition to that, my crystal ball is OOF, so it is not working either.
. At the end of the day, I will take in all I can, roll the dice, and hope for the best with the options I am currently being offered. As with anyone, there are places that aren't interested, places where I already have a CJO, and places I wouldn't want to be.Please don't take what I say as an attempt to act as if I know more than you do. I know what I don't know; I just try to piece together as much as I can, and "putting it out there" here in APC is a means to get input on what I perceive to be the truth, as another way of validating (or not) what I am learning/understanding.
#84
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 854
Likes: 0
16 years. 9-11, terrible economy and age 65 didn't help. However, I enjoyed being home almost every day, not commuting, working for a good solid company with an above average contract and excellent quality of life. Most people overlook quality of life. Marriage and family were always number one with me. Career and money was next. I survived off low pay for a couple years, but as a captain was making 100k. I budgeted my life off of that amount and was happy. Envoy has a great 401k match as well. Not to mention free travel on AA. And once you get to AA, they give you 16% of your salary into your 401k for free. Not bad. First year pay is around $80/hr and second year pay is $115 at AA. Slow down and smell the roses. Don't follow the crowd jumping ship to the fastest upgrade. Your wife and family will thank you for the stability.
That being said, we will have movement, which should improve our awful reserve and upgrade times at least somewhat. And the flow will be fantastic for many pilots (how many is a guess).
Even though my opinion of our current management team almost couldn't be any worse, I still might pick envoy over mesa. If you do, pick it because you're gambling on the flow, not because you'll see your family more with envoy vs. mesa. QoL here is not what it used to be.
#86
Well, as a Piedmont pilot we wouldn't expect you to. Or are you a disgruntled recent Flowthrough pilot, haven't quite decided yet. At any rate, saying AA will do this or will do that without any actual basis for your position means nothing. Anyone can tell stories and saying, "because it's AA, they can do anything." Doesn't count.
#87
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 540
Likes: 0
Well, as a Piedmont pilot we wouldn't expect you to. Or are you a disgruntled recent Flowthrough pilot, haven't quite decided yet. At any rate, saying AA will do this or will do that without any actual basis for your position means nothing. Anyone can tell stories and saying, "because it's AA, they can do anything." Doesn't count.
I hope you enjoy the right seat at Envoy because with your seniority, that's where you are going to be for a long, long time.
Enjoy the 40 bucks an hour kid.
#88
Banned
Joined: Mar 2014
Posts: 787
Likes: 0
Well, as a Piedmont pilot we wouldn't expect you to. Or are you a disgruntled recent Flowthrough pilot, haven't quite decided yet. At any rate, saying AA will do this or will do that without any actual basis for your position means nothing. Anyone can tell stories and saying, "because it's AA, they can do anything." Doesn't count.
#89
#90
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 977
Likes: 0
Go to Envoy. Prior121 and I have historically been two of the biggest Mesa cheerleaders on here for the last three years, and we're both telling you to go to Envoy over Mesa now. That should speak volumes to you.
Someone has to end up stuck at the bottom of our list when we're done with the growth and the economy inevitably cycles back downward. By my estimation, anyone hired between now and the end of the EJet deliveries this summer/early Fall is at risk of being in one of those "last classes."
Mesa is a great place to work--for those of us who benefitted from the express train to lineholder/hours/upgrade. I can't in good conscience tell you to come here now, though, because I personally don't think you're going to hold a line/upgrade nearly as fast as people currently on property did. IMHO there's much less risk and much bigger rewards on offer at Envoy--just my two cents...feel free to disagree!
Last edited by flapshalfspeed; 01-07-2016 at 02:52 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post


Nailed it. You're a pretty smart fella.

