Does ASA's TA influence SKYW's ALPA Vote?
#51
When I pay ALPA I expect to get something in return immediately.
What a shining example of the "ME!" generation and their sense of entitlement in that post right there...

I'd refute the selfishness, ignorance, and narrow mindedness of it line-by-line...but I know it'd be a grand waste of time and effort because the poster already his his mind made up...
#52
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 104
Likes: 0
From: CRJ-700
Thank you, I take care of me and my family first!!
Wow....just wow.
What a shining example of the "ME!" generation and their sense of entitlement in that post right there...
I'd refute the selfishness, ignorance, and narrow mindedness of it line-by-line...but I know it'd be a grand waste of time and effort because the poster already his his mind made up...
What a shining example of the "ME!" generation and their sense of entitlement in that post right there...

I'd refute the selfishness, ignorance, and narrow mindedness of it line-by-line...but I know it'd be a grand waste of time and effort because the poster already his his mind made up...
#53
Line Holder
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 36
Likes: 0
So if I vote for a union and can expect to wait 5 years for a new contract when I am no longer at Skywest how would voting for a union benefit me and most of the other pilots at Skywest. Most pilots I talk to plan on moving on to other airlines after 3-5 years. It took ASA 5 years to get a contract. So if this is the case we will pay 5 years of union dues and get nothing in return. If someone comes back and says "it's for the industry as a whole, it's for your fellow pilots, blah blah blah" I am going to puke. It would be ignorant for someone to try to say they are only thinking of the industry and not themselves or their families. People work for themselves and for their families, nobody else. So trying to convince me that me voting a union in will help my fellow pilot at some other airline who I will never meet will not cut it for me. If someone can convince me that ALPA will put money and benefits in me and my families pocket directly then I will seriously consider it. I would need this as a guarantee because 5 years of bargaining and telling me to be patient does not cut it. When I pay ALPA I expect to get something in return immediately. I don't go to the gas station give them money and have them put gas in my car 5 years later. I don't go to the store and pay for groceries and expect them to give me food 5 years later. When I pay ALPA I want something in return for my money, not an empty guarantee, not a promise someone will back me up if I violate a rule or get in trouble, I want something "hard" in return. 5 years is much too long to wait and I am sure ASA pilots will agree. I bet there are some ASA pilots who are dead and buried waiting for this contract.
#55
No I'm not saying unions take so much that they keep the middle class down. If Skywest goes union it will only amount to around half a million per year in dues. Sounds like a lot but its just one more customer for alpa. Although it seems like the guy that started Mcdonalds had the same idea. What I'm saying is that Alpa is a business just like any other business. Their "product" is a services product just like insurance. Its intangible. Their objective is to make money, period. If they have to help someone achieve something that requires their services then they'll do what they can or are willing to do to help, unless one of their other "customers" is on the other side of the fence, then it becomes "who's paying us more for our services". Please please don't rely on unions to make the future of America better, they're in it for themselves not you. I talk to so many people who want more out of life but yet they are always looking to someone else to make that happen. If you want more then go get it, your not a tree if you don't like where you are in life then move. I wanted more out of life as well,,, looked around, nobody handing me money so I went out and started my own business. It pays the bills, if I want it to pay for more then guess what I have to work harder, simple as that. If you want the unions or the government to make your life better then I suggest looking at some other countries they'll take care of you. Although it seems now that I think about it that it doesn't work very well,,, living in a socialist society. Looking back at this rant I think its a little strong, however someone who I respect very much told me this very thing long ago and I'm forever grateful. Made me get off my rear.
I’m tired of watching the middle class disappear.
Today on msn http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21256709/
A union is the only way our middle class can hold what they have there is no argument.
Let me see if I understand you correctly, you say that instead of unions we should work two jobs to get by? Or just quit? Sure that works, but it adds to the increasing disparity in classes.
#56
Bla Bla
First off let me say I'm sorry, I wasn't referring to you personally I was talking about the average middle class american. However my post certainly looks like I was referring to you, I wasn't, sorry for my poor writing.
You know I don't really have an answer, this is a problem that has been occuring for hundreds of years. The people in power beat the little guy into submission and thats how it goes. Logic would say we have to unite, so we get a group of people together who think the same way. They don't have any experience putting something together like this so they hire someone to represent them. A union. Unfortunately the people who run the union have become very powerful themselves and human nature takes over. They become one of the groups in power that we were trying to combat in the first place. This is what I meant in my earlier post about this being a vicious circle.
At Skywest we are very fortunate. We have pay and work rules that other companys have without the need for a union. (btw these are driven by the market and our leadership not because of other unions) We aren't beat down by a dictator type of leader. We work for a company that still has the original leader in place. This will not always be the case but hopfully it will for several more years. The last time I listened to JA speak he said he has no plans for retirement, that will change sooner or later but for now we're safe. Usually when a original company leader steps down he hand picks his succesor, looking for somone who will continue the tradition and mindset he had. Hopefully that somone will be a good choice for SkyWest when that day comes. Time will tell.
Sorry again for my lack of skill and proof reading of my previous post. I wish you the best of luck with your new business, when I started mine I too had a full time job and thru hard work and good fortune I was able to make it successful. If I can do it anyone can....... believe me!
First off let me say I'm sorry, I wasn't referring to you personally I was talking about the average middle class american. However my post certainly looks like I was referring to you, I wasn't, sorry for my poor writing.
You know I don't really have an answer, this is a problem that has been occuring for hundreds of years. The people in power beat the little guy into submission and thats how it goes. Logic would say we have to unite, so we get a group of people together who think the same way. They don't have any experience putting something together like this so they hire someone to represent them. A union. Unfortunately the people who run the union have become very powerful themselves and human nature takes over. They become one of the groups in power that we were trying to combat in the first place. This is what I meant in my earlier post about this being a vicious circle.
At Skywest we are very fortunate. We have pay and work rules that other companys have without the need for a union. (btw these are driven by the market and our leadership not because of other unions) We aren't beat down by a dictator type of leader. We work for a company that still has the original leader in place. This will not always be the case but hopfully it will for several more years. The last time I listened to JA speak he said he has no plans for retirement, that will change sooner or later but for now we're safe. Usually when a original company leader steps down he hand picks his succesor, looking for somone who will continue the tradition and mindset he had. Hopefully that somone will be a good choice for SkyWest when that day comes. Time will tell.
Sorry again for my lack of skill and proof reading of my previous post. I wish you the best of luck with your new business, when I started mine I too had a full time job and thru hard work and good fortune I was able to make it successful. If I can do it anyone can....... believe me!
#57
most of you bring up several reasons why you dont want a union at skywest. but let me ask you this... why does YOUR MANAGEMENT not want a union at skywest, and why are they doing everything they can to PREVENT a union at skywest?
with all the scenarios you mentioned about having a union, why is management so scared of a collective bargaining agreement. whats their motivation to keep a union off the property? based on some of your logic, you would think having a union would actually HELP management (i.e. lots of red tape because you cant just call crew support and fix your pay etc). However thats not the case. Management is AFRAID of you guys having a union because it will EMPOWER you. Now, why would management be afraid of you guys having a little power to defend yourselves? I just dont get it, unless of course management likes knowing they have the ability to do whatever they want to you. But still theres something fishy about the way your management is acting, and that should cause the hair on the back of your neck to stand up...
with all the scenarios you mentioned about having a union, why is management so scared of a collective bargaining agreement. whats their motivation to keep a union off the property? based on some of your logic, you would think having a union would actually HELP management (i.e. lots of red tape because you cant just call crew support and fix your pay etc). However thats not the case. Management is AFRAID of you guys having a union because it will EMPOWER you. Now, why would management be afraid of you guys having a little power to defend yourselves? I just dont get it, unless of course management likes knowing they have the ability to do whatever they want to you. But still theres something fishy about the way your management is acting, and that should cause the hair on the back of your neck to stand up...
#58
What's fishy? Why would they not want us to be able to work directly with crew support to fix pay issues etc.? I know exactly what your talking about though because I was at an employer previously who literally it seemed was out to screw us. There are very few companies out there who still treat their employees right. Guys I fly with at skywest as a rule are trying to do a good job, trying to get out on time, trying to watch spending (except on the last leg of a 4 day) Gotta get home you know. If you treat your employees right they will treat you right, thats how it is at skywest, I thought you used to work here, didn't you? Maybe I'm thinking of somone else. These are the very reason we don't have a union yet.
As far as why don't they want a union, well, thats simple it throws a big ol bunch of red tape into the works and slows everything down. Want to pick up some more work,,,, gotta ask the union etc. etc. Not having a union makes it easier for us to get new work, its not everything but just one more feather in our cap when potential new relationships are built. Just one more small reason to maybe lean our way.
As far as why don't they want a union, well, thats simple it throws a big ol bunch of red tape into the works and slows everything down. Want to pick up some more work,,,, gotta ask the union etc. etc. Not having a union makes it easier for us to get new work, its not everything but just one more feather in our cap when potential new relationships are built. Just one more small reason to maybe lean our way.
#59
i find it fishy only because your management is trying a little too hard to sway opinions about this vote. if things really were 100% great then theoretically there would be no need to get involved and the pilots would be able to unanimously defeat the alpa drive. something just doesnt add up about the way they are going about all of this. since the drive started, its fairly obvious that theyve given you guys things that most people think they otherwise would have withheld. why the sudden change in the way they were acting?
im also just not convinced about this being about red tape. sure you can move a little faster, but other union carriers dont really have a problem landing some extra flying in a short period of time (RAH, XJT, etc) and relationships arent damaged so long as neither side abuses the other.
I worked at skywest for a short period of time and I really had a great time with my fellow pilots there. I quickly earned a reputation for being pro-union, but I always respected others who were adamently opposed and went on to build strong friendships with them. I was unreasonably harsh on this board in the past and since then have lightened up, because I know where your coming from in your reasoning for not wanting a union. But hey what can I say, I still care because I do still have a lot of friends there and I want to see you guys do well.
im also just not convinced about this being about red tape. sure you can move a little faster, but other union carriers dont really have a problem landing some extra flying in a short period of time (RAH, XJT, etc) and relationships arent damaged so long as neither side abuses the other.
I worked at skywest for a short period of time and I really had a great time with my fellow pilots there. I quickly earned a reputation for being pro-union, but I always respected others who were adamently opposed and went on to build strong friendships with them. I was unreasonably harsh on this board in the past and since then have lightened up, because I know where your coming from in your reasoning for not wanting a union. But hey what can I say, I still care because I do still have a lot of friends there and I want to see you guys do well.
#60
What's fishy? Why would they not want us to be able to work directly with crew support to fix pay issues etc.? I know exactly what your talking about though because I was at an employer previously who literally it seemed was out to screw us. There are very few companies out there who still treat their employees right. Guys I fly with at skywest as a rule are trying to do a good job, trying to get out on time, trying to watch spending (except on the last leg of a 4 day) Gotta get home you know. If you treat your employees right they will treat you right, thats how it is at skywest, I thought you used to work here, didn't you? Maybe I'm thinking of somone else. These are the very reason we don't have a union yet.
As far as why don't they want a union, well, thats simple it throws a big ol bunch of red tape into the works and slows everything down. Want to pick up some more work,,,, gotta ask the union etc. etc. Not having a union makes it easier for us to get new work, its not everything but just one more feather in our cap when potential new relationships are built. Just one more small reason to maybe lean our way.
As far as why don't they want a union, well, thats simple it throws a big ol bunch of red tape into the works and slows everything down. Want to pick up some more work,,,, gotta ask the union etc. etc. Not having a union makes it easier for us to get new work, its not everything but just one more feather in our cap when potential new relationships are built. Just one more small reason to maybe lean our way.
Second, the only reason a union would make it more difficult to pick up more flying is if management is trying to screw the pilots over (pay cut, 90 seat airplane for 50 seat pay, etc.). If management wants to maintain the conditions of you CBA while adding flying, the union wouldn't really have a reason to slow it down.
I've said it before and I'll say it again: The relationship between SkyWest management and pilots does not have to deteriorate if ALPA is elected. If the pilots elect good people to the MEC and management puts forth a good faith effort, things can be like they are now except with a legally binding contract.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



