Are Pilots Idiots?
#11
So many pilots perpetuate this myth. There are pilots sitting at home or in a crashpad right now getting paid - not an aircraft door in sight. There are pilots on a 2-day layover sitting in a hotel right now on a trip with pay determined by the trip-rig in their contract. They're going to get paid the same whether they fly that day or go to the hotel gym. How about the guys on sick leave or airport standby?The bottom line is, almost every airline pilot has some kind of monthly guarantee. Some have contracts with a min pay per day or at least a trip guarantee. They are all going to get paid something, even if the door of the aircraft never closes.
Now if you want to say - "We have agreed to only get paid more than the minimum for that day, trip or month when the door is closed" - I'll agree with you.
The large hourly wages of the jobs everyone wants are there in part to account for the "down" time between flights, pre-flight, etc. If we got paid for every hour we were actually on duty, do you really think a WB Captain at a major airline would make $260+ an hour?
We're basically salaried employees that get a bonus each month based on how much we actually work. I think you'd be hard pressed to find many pilots out there that get paid nothing if for some reason they don't fly.
#13
Thread Starter
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 294
Likes: 0
So many pilots perpetuate this myth. There are pilots sitting at home or in a crashpad right now getting paid - not an aircraft door in sight. There are pilots on a 2-day layover sitting in a hotel right now on a trip with pay determined by the trip-rig in their contract. They're going to get paid the same whether they fly that day or go to the hotel gym. How about the guys on sick leave or airport standby?The bottom line is, almost every airline pilot has some kind of monthly guarantee. Some have contracts with a min pay per day or at least a trip guarantee. They are all going to get paid something, even if the door of the aircraft never closes.
Now if you want to say - "We have agreed to only get paid more than the minimum for that day, trip or month when the door is closed" - I'll agree with you.
The large hourly wages of the jobs everyone wants are there in part to account for the "down" time between flights, pre-flight, etc. If we got paid for every hour we were actually on duty, do you really think a WB Captain at a major airline would make $260+ an hour?
We're basically salaried employees that get a bonus each month based on how much we actually work. I think you'd be hard pressed to find many pilots out there that get paid nothing if for some reason they don't fly.
#14
You claimed (as many do) that we only get paid when the door is shut or more accurately - when we are blocked out. That is not a true statement.
My other side point was that pilots have always had their pay based on flight hours (which are NEVER as high as duty hours). Even if a WB Captain made $500/hour, he'd still be getting paid for his flight hours rather than his duty hours. I doubt he would be complaining, though, do you? (well, maybe - he is a pilot after all
)To an airline, pilot pay is basically a fixed cost - give or take a little. Even if you felt they were paying you fairly, they have an average figure in mind per pilot. If you wanted your compensation based on 350 monthly duty hours, your hourly pay would not be as high (regardless of whether you felt the rate was fair or not). In the end, it's very likely your pay at the end of most months would be very similar regardless of how it was calculated.
#15
Thread Starter
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 294
Likes: 0
I'm not arguing pay rates with you - I agree they should all be higher.
You claimed (as many do) that we only get paid when the door is shut or more accurately - when we are blocked out. That is not a true statement.
My other side point was that pilots have always had their pay based on flight hours (which are NEVER as high as duty hours). Even if a WB Captain made $500/hour, he'd still be getting paid for his flight hours rather than his duty hours. I doubt he would be complaining, though, do you? (well, maybe - he is a pilot after all
)
To an airline, pilot pay is basically a fixed cost - give or take a little. Even if you felt they were paying you fairly, they have an average figure in mind per pilot. If you wanted your compensation based on 350 monthly duty hours, your hourly pay would not be as high (regardless of whether you felt the rate was fair or not). In the end, it's very likely your pay at the end of most months would be very similar regardless of how it was calculated.
You claimed (as many do) that we only get paid when the door is shut or more accurately - when we are blocked out. That is not a true statement.
My other side point was that pilots have always had their pay based on flight hours (which are NEVER as high as duty hours). Even if a WB Captain made $500/hour, he'd still be getting paid for his flight hours rather than his duty hours. I doubt he would be complaining, though, do you? (well, maybe - he is a pilot after all
)To an airline, pilot pay is basically a fixed cost - give or take a little. Even if you felt they were paying you fairly, they have an average figure in mind per pilot. If you wanted your compensation based on 350 monthly duty hours, your hourly pay would not be as high (regardless of whether you felt the rate was fair or not). In the end, it's very likely your pay at the end of most months would be very similar regardless of how it was calculated.
#16
Line Holder
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 1,212
Likes: 22
From: Two Wheeler FrontSeat
Yeah I hear what you are saying but why not just call it what it is. Instead of 20/hr for a 75 hour guarantee, just say 4/hr for time on duty. It might do us more justice to have headlines read "Pilot's make less than half minimum wage" Plus the fact that we are not being paid overtime. They worked it out so that we are salaried but under the "hourly" category minus the overtime benefits.
#17
Yeah I hear what you are saying but why not just call it what it is. Instead of 20/hr for a 75 hour guarantee, just say 4/hr for time on duty. It might do us more justice to have headlines read "Pilot's make less than half minimum wage" Plus the fact that we are not being paid overtime. They worked it out so that we are salaried but under the "hourly" category minus the overtime benefits.
What Can New Pilots Make? Near Minimum Wage - WSJ.com
This just doesn't fly: Some airline pilots barely make living wage - NBC News
The public who reads these articles may be surprised and even sympathetic but they don't negotiate your contracts. They're the ones who have expected to fly across the country for the equivalent of bus fare for the last 30 years. They also know that no one put a gun to your head and made you take the job. It's doubtful the pay scale was a secret when you took it either.
It's not going to change unless you make it happen. Overtime is something you negotiate. Some of us have it in some form or another. Don't vote for your next contract unless it's there (along with proper pay rates). Vote no until it's right, strike over it, leave or deal with it. Your choice - sounds harsh but that's the way it is.
#18
Thread Starter
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 294
Likes: 0
I don't think it's a big secret that regional pilots are underpaid - however you want to do the math. The headlines are there and easy to find.
What Can New Pilots Make? Near Minimum Wage - WSJ.com
This just doesn't fly: Some airline pilots barely make living wage - NBC News
The public who reads these articles may be surprised and even sympathetic but they don't negotiate your contracts. They're the ones who have expected to fly across the country for the equivalent of bus fare for the last 30 years. They also know that no one put a gun to your head and made you take the job. It's doubtful the pay scale was a secret when you took it either.
It's not going to change unless you make it happen. Overtime is something you negotiate. Some of us have it in some form or another. Don't vote for your next contract unless it's there (along with proper pay rates). Vote no until it's right, strike over it, leave or deal with it. Your choice - sounds harsh but that's the way it is.
What Can New Pilots Make? Near Minimum Wage - WSJ.com
This just doesn't fly: Some airline pilots barely make living wage - NBC News
The public who reads these articles may be surprised and even sympathetic but they don't negotiate your contracts. They're the ones who have expected to fly across the country for the equivalent of bus fare for the last 30 years. They also know that no one put a gun to your head and made you take the job. It's doubtful the pay scale was a secret when you took it either.
It's not going to change unless you make it happen. Overtime is something you negotiate. Some of us have it in some form or another. Don't vote for your next contract unless it's there (along with proper pay rates). Vote no until it's right, strike over it, leave or deal with it. Your choice - sounds harsh but that's the way it is.
#19
Unfortunately, as long as these jobs are viewed as a stepping stone instead of a potential career location, it probably won't change.
#20
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 324
Likes: 0
So many pilots perpetuate this myth. There are pilots sitting at home or in a crashpad right now getting paid - not an aircraft door in sight. There are pilots on a 2-day layover sitting in a hotel right now on a trip with pay determined by the trip-rig in their contract. They're going to get paid the same whether they fly that day or go to the hotel gym. How about the guys on sick leave or airport standby?The bottom line is, almost every airline pilot has some kind of monthly guarantee. Some have contracts with a min pay per day or at least a trip guarantee. They are all going to get paid something, even if the door of the aircraft never closes.
Now if you want to say - "We have agreed to only get paid more than the minimum for that day, trip or month when the door is closed" - I'll agree with you.
The large hourly wages of the jobs everyone wants are there in part to account for the "down" time between flights, pre-flight, etc. If we got paid for every hour we were actually on duty, do you really think a WB Captain at a major airline would make $260+ an hour?
We're basically salaried employees that get a bonus each month based on how much we actually work. I think you'd be hard pressed to find many pilots out there that get paid nothing if for some reason they don't fly.
Regradless of what you refer to as getting paid to sit or sleep in a hotel room, the pay is too low. How can wages well below what it takes to pay a modest mortgage and save for retirement be considered acceptable by any means.
Pilots commonly make the mistake of assuming that years of low pay after accummalating massive debt will be "made up for" later. Later may never come!! You could easily never get hired by a major or even get furloughed when you do finally get hired. Just look at those UA guys who had been on furlough for the better part of a decade.
I really think pilots shoud stop looking at themselves as "future widebody captains", and take a good hard look at their current situation and try to make improvements from there.
Look, I'm trying to say that a regional pilot has the same job and responsibility as a major, so why work for such low wages?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



