Are Pilots Idiots?
#42
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 246
Likes: 0
From: CL-65 CA
I agree that, with large RJs, pilots should get paid more. The only effective way to do that is if the majors take over their regional feed. Unfortunately, the economics will not allow this. If we got pay and benefits commensurate with the majors, it would be in their best interest to do it themselves as it would defeat the purpose of subcontracted labor. You need only look at American/AE to see that we are nowhere near getting the benefits we deserve (the bankruptcy court encouraged American to "diversify" their regional feed to remain competitive--or, in other words, seek out a lowest bidder contract)
The ONLY true way to do this would be at the mainline level. As subcontracted labor, we have no rights. We will always work in the grey area between black and red as we compete against each other to provide "lowest bidder" services. Legacy pilots complain all the time that we took their flying but their greed allowed the lawyers and penny-pinchers to allow RJs to proliferate outside of their contract protections. The mainline pilots needs to negotiate significant changes in their contract to reduce the amount of RJs flying. Until that happens, we can whine and complain until we are blue in the face. It won't change anything.
The ONLY true way to do this would be at the mainline level. As subcontracted labor, we have no rights. We will always work in the grey area between black and red as we compete against each other to provide "lowest bidder" services. Legacy pilots complain all the time that we took their flying but their greed allowed the lawyers and penny-pinchers to allow RJs to proliferate outside of their contract protections. The mainline pilots needs to negotiate significant changes in their contract to reduce the amount of RJs flying. Until that happens, we can whine and complain until we are blue in the face. It won't change anything.
#43
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 211
Likes: 0
#44
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2013
Posts: 12,533
Likes: 1,129
The big bennifit regionals provide to mainline is less exposer to to aircraft leases, cheaper maintenance, flight attendants...etc. Mainline could staff the flight deck with its pilots. They would be trained by them, to thier standards and procedures and flow up the ranks of seniority....they would be thier own pilots flying the cheap regional aircraft. The regional could make money by owning the aircraft, flight attendants, Maint...etc
#45
Thread Starter
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 294
Likes: 0
That statement doesn't make sense. I'm pretty sure mainline holds titles on a bunch of the RJs in service right now. Plus, you think a mainline pilot union would allow their pilots to fly on aircraft that are maintained outside of the airline's control? The only discount the mainline gets is on labor. The leases have to be covered somehow, the insurance paid, the crews trainined. These are all fixed costs. Of course, you could argue that the maintenance is less acceptable but it is acceptable enough for FAA certification. In that case, there is still a fixed price on parts. If anything, one could argue that places like American could get deals with suppliers for bulk orders of parts because they own hundreds of jets versus tens.
#46
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 324
Likes: 0
First (in case you only read the first line) - I agree with you 100% that regional pilots are grossly underpaid.
If I was your high school English teacher, you'd get an F for reading comprehension.
Did you actually read my entire first post in this thread or just skim it?
I was merely commenting on HOW most of us are actually paid - not WHAT any of us are paid. So, there were no comparisons made between WB Captain pay at a major and regional pilot pay as you seem to be claiming.
I think if you read the posts I made here this afternoon, you'll see that I basically agree with just about everything you just posted (except the mischaracterization of my original post).
If I was your high school English teacher, you'd get an F for reading comprehension.
Did you actually read my entire first post in this thread or just skim it?I was merely commenting on HOW most of us are actually paid - not WHAT any of us are paid. So, there were no comparisons made between WB Captain pay at a major and regional pilot pay as you seem to be claiming.
I think if you read the posts I made here this afternoon, you'll see that I basically agree with just about everything you just posted (except the mischaracterization of my original post).
I still see a comparison. There is a drastic difference between a widebody salary and smaller aircraft such as regionals, so much that it is almost irrevelent what a widebody pilot makes compared to a regional guy.
In my point of view, regional rates are so low that it hardly does any justice to compare how much regional people work to their actual pay. The widebody part, well it just doesn't fit.
In the short term, I believe management will have to raise the pay significantly regardless of what type of duty pay pilots may be getting.
Anyway, no offense to you!
Last edited by outaluckagain; 02-27-2014 at 04:51 PM.
#48
I read your entire post, and I do see a comparison between widebody pilots and the rest of us. I do see that it was not the spirit of your entire post, but rather an example of what the rate is for a widebody pilot as it relates to the entire picture.
I still see a comparison. There is a drastic difference between a widebody salary and smaller aircraft such as regionals, so much that it is almost irrevelent what a widebody pilot makes compared to a regional guy.
In my point of view, regional rates are so low that it hardly does any justice to compare how much regional people work to their actual pay. The widebody part, well it just doesn't fit.
In the short term, I believe management will have to raise the pay significantly regardless of what type of duty pay pilots may be getting.
Anyway, no offense to you!
I still see a comparison. There is a drastic difference between a widebody salary and smaller aircraft such as regionals, so much that it is almost irrevelent what a widebody pilot makes compared to a regional guy.
In my point of view, regional rates are so low that it hardly does any justice to compare how much regional people work to their actual pay. The widebody part, well it just doesn't fit.
In the short term, I believe management will have to raise the pay significantly regardless of what type of duty pay pilots may be getting.
Anyway, no offense to you!
I used the WB Captain pay as the extreme in order to make my point. Which was that looking at our current monthly pay as it stands today, NO pilot would get their current hourly pay rate if we were paid for all our hours on duty instead of our flight hours. I could have attempted to make my point in my first post by typing:
"If we got paid for every hour we were actually on duty, do you really think a first year FO at a regional airline would make $20 an hour?"
But I don't think that would have been as effective since I was attempting to point out that ALL our hourly pay rates are inflated, especially the ones at the top(which is WHY I used that example). That's because we're getting paid on ~80-ish (give or take) flight/credit hours each month rather than the ~300-ish we spend away from base or the ~150-ish we spend on duty.
I think you're fixating on the fact that an RJ F/O probably SHOULD be getting his current pay rate for every hour he is on duty in order to make his compensation something close to reasonable - while you couldn't say the same thing about the WB Captain.
Clear as mud? Either way, I'm done. Cheers.
#49
The big bennifit regionals provide to mainline is less exposer to to aircraft leases, cheaper maintenance, flight attendants...etc. Mainline could staff the flight deck with its pilots. They would be trained by them, to thier standards and procedures and flow up the ranks of seniority....they would be thier own pilots flying the cheap regional aircraft. The regional could make money by owning the aircraft, flight attendants, Maint...etc
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post




