Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   American (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/)
-   -   Furlough Estimates (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/american/129761-furlough-estimates.html)

MEFLIGHT 08-04-2020 06:11 PM


Originally Posted by Dobbs18 (Post 3105074)
yes yes yes!!!! I am glad I am not the only one on here who sees this! I was beginning to doubt my reading comprehension and reasoning skills. We just "voluntary" ****ed ourselves.

The most junior pilot may disagree with that, it's all perspective.

Dobbs18 08-04-2020 06:13 PM


Originally Posted by rcflying53 (Post 3105071)
The company may not publish furlough numbers, but they are publishing the approximate amount of ZTL and EOM available for each 4 part status. So, we should be able to figure ball park furlough numbers from those I’d think.

they said best estimate and they said those numbers are not minimums...those numbers don't mean much without a number of furloughs. Without a furlough number there is no way to keep the company in check with these "awards"(more like penalties).

rcflying53 08-04-2020 06:22 PM


Originally Posted by Dobbs18 (Post 3105079)
they said best estimate and they said those numbers are not minimums...those numbers don't mean much without a number of furloughs. Without a furlough number there is no way to keep the company in check with these "awards"(more like penalties).

I agree with you.

I’ll just sit back and give a day or two for the BOD to explain the reasoning behind this 20-0 vote. They know the furlough numbers and if they say they don’t, it’s a lie.

Dobbs18 08-04-2020 06:32 PM


Originally Posted by MEFLIGHT (Post 3105077)
The most junior pilot may disagree with that, it's all perspective.

so just like with covid-19, thousands more must suffer because the jr pilot might get furloughed. Just like the 70 year old who might die so we all have to stay at home and run this economy into the ground. Look I am all for doing something to help mitigate furloughs, I just think this is a $hit deal....Its a seniority industry we all knew this when we signed up and we all knew the risks at being at the bottom(harsh I know, but true). I just think this is going to push way way more people into self furlough status aka. ZTL then was ever going to be the case initially and we have no way of holding the company accountable with the numbers now! We could have come up with a much better deal with set numbers/goal to reach. And if the company wants to say no no we can't give you furlough numbers, we'll tell them to pound sand and make them pay for all the training and furloughing cost. They are going to "furlough" now 1000s!!!! more with no monetary cost for doing so...they get the the grand-slam homerun to win the WS in the bottom of the 9th in game 7, and what do we get??? Nothing! Its the same results for us at the end of the day with or without the deal except now its going to effect way way more of us and it will happen overnight instead of being drawn out over months.

Da40Pilot 08-04-2020 07:32 PM

The irony is....let's say you're in the bottom 100 and you do nothing, and they were planning on furloughing 1000, and 1100 bid for a Zero line but you didn't, guess what? Those bottom 100 won't get furloughed and will get to keep doing what they're doing. Without the company releasing furlough numbers (which I am sure they will) this is just a game of russian roulette.

wiz5422 08-04-2020 08:42 PM


Originally Posted by Da40Pilot (Post 3105127)
The irony is....let's say you're in the bottom 100 and you do nothing, and they were planning on furloughing 1000, and 1100 bid for a Zero line but you didn't, guess what? Those bottom 100 won't get furloughed and will get to keep doing what they're doing. Without the company releasing furlough numbers (which I am sure they will) this is just a game of russian roulette.

Or just furlough those 100 to save more money.

m78fl370 08-04-2020 09:16 PM

This is going to lead to WAY more guys without pay this fall than would have been if the company just had to furlough the old fashioned way.

biigD 08-05-2020 03:39 AM

I'm gonna wait for the Q&A before getting spun up but yeah, the language about selecting a ZTL in leu of a furlough is concerning. Not sure why it couldn't just be written to release a furlough number, ZTLs are awarded, the furlough number is reduced by those taking a ZTL not inside the original furlough footprint, then furlough based on the new number (including anyone that was awarded a ZTL if they fall inside).

I don't speak legalese however, so I'll see what the union says.

Dadv1023 08-05-2020 04:15 AM


Originally Posted by NotMrNiceGuy (Post 3103066)
10X? Wow. That sounds like a lot.

The only people that think that superficial view of Europe vs. the US are doing so through their convenient political lens. Look, I love Europe. Fantastic locations, history, and scenery. There may even be a case that QOL there if you make less than $45K/€/£. But above that threshold, it’s not even close.

Tech:
US - Google, Facebook, Twitter, Uber, Netflix, Amazon, Apple, etc.
Europe - Nokia?
Education:
US - 7 out of top 10 universities in the world. Other three in the UK.
Transportation:
I’m guessing you like the train system? It’s true, many major EURO cities have great subway systems and city infrastructure. But beyond that, the trains were unreliable and not punctual. Plan an extra 45 minutes for everything (German/Italy) experience.
Welfare/Social Programs:
This is where it’s political. If that’s what you like, then it’s probably some kind of Utopia to you. But in Germany, those folks pay between 7-8% of gross for that healthcare. The UK is no different. Denmark is off the charts. Not to mention employer contribution of the same percentage. That’s more than three times what comes out of my paycheck. And the actual care? My wife had a baby here and abroad. The level of care is not the same. She said she felt like she was at a five star resort having the baby here in the US. No sharing rooms with other patients. Own bathroom. Meals that consisted of more than just bread and cheese.

Europe is definitely first world and is really nice. But nowadays, Americans tend to forget why their ancestors came here. Until you actually experience it, I think that European mystique is more hype than substance. It’s just annoying to hear over and over how incredible Europe is by those that just repeat talking points and have never spent any meaningful time there.


classic pilot, a genius on every topic.....

EasternShore 08-05-2020 04:21 AM

The very junior individuals that bid ZTL’s can thank the senior guys that get furloughed since we’re now abrogating seniority. Thank them for paying their dues and getting hired at the company quicker. But oh well, “You’ll be senior someday”.

As long as we’re selectively using he seniority list, I’ll take a 777 CA spot..

The 900 or so that we’re on the bubble and now have to bid ZTL are probably justified going active shooter.

The BOD should have to stand in front of the 900, DALPA and UALPA and justify why they lowered the bar. Not sure if there was an attorney present when they negotiated this deal? I guess we can be happy that the BOD didn’t concede anything🤷🏼‍♂️ Lowering the ALV looks a lot better now. Could the APA be on the hook for any litigation out of this? Will any reps be voted out in the upcoming elections or does apathy and status quo prevail..

Furlough Mitigation could’ve been achieved by doing absolutely nothing if this was the alternative. The aPA gave the company a blank check to furlough 2500 regardless of voluntary or involuntary.

Haven't seen a deal this bad since the trail of tears. Maybe the APA will throw in some covid blankets for the furloughees and their families this winter🥴


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:17 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands