Scope Proposal at American
#51
When a stock fall to its current level they may have no choice. The market will determine AMR's future. The Market can unfortunately short them into BK. Come on, your are a smart guy. You honestly think management can dig you out of this 20 billion+ hole? The game is over. Goldman suggested filing in 2004 and they're right. AMR can not post a profit under its current model. They can no longer borrow money with out paying loan shark pricing. Sorry but its the reality.
#52
Line Holder
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 93
Likes: 0
From: Unqalified
I love reading this. You guys are all holding out for the moon and you will end up with nothing. Once chapter 11 happens you will end up working with a USAIR type contract and your pension stripped. Time to man up and relize your company is in the wost financial shape of any large carrier. I understand the desire for a better contract this is not the time to be fight. I would worry about saving your job and pension first then fight another day.
Let the goons threaten to lock the doors, then offer to buy the padlock. ANYTHING given away under (perceived) duress will NOT come back for a decade.
#53
Like I said but maybe you missed it even though you quoted it, I read it to mean if they give him 25% he'll think about giving in. Not like we haven't seen that or been there before. I was pointing out that with the NWA comment. I never said it was Carl but his pilot group. They got at least 50%+1 to buy into that even after they supposedly hated Mesaba's Avro. Always love those go away comments. Does it ever work?
#54
Line Holder
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 1,832
Likes: 5
From: 737 Left
The best plan for scope is to put all jets on mainline property. For that matter, if it says American on the paint, it should be an American aircraft, or DAL or US Air, etc.... Then work out the payrates associated with the seat size. No outsourcing.
#55
Banned
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 8,350
Likes: 0
Sorry, I'm still me, but it is good to see another voice of reason here.
All this bluster and chest pounding aside, the real losers will be those hoping for a career at AA and the folks in the right seat who will probably be there even longer. While there may be some captains posting here aside from myself, the majority of the discontent appear to be from FO's!
Again, I get all the angst and frustration due to the past decade of stagnation. That gentlemen and ladies is the nature of the business we all made a conscious decision to join. If one of you actually signed a "fairness" contract during your indoc, please post a copy here. We will either change, adapt, and seize future opportunities or there will be a different model going forward.
All this bluster and chest pounding aside, the real losers will be those hoping for a career at AA and the folks in the right seat who will probably be there even longer. While there may be some captains posting here aside from myself, the majority of the discontent appear to be from FO's!
Again, I get all the angst and frustration due to the past decade of stagnation. That gentlemen and ladies is the nature of the business we all made a conscious decision to join. If one of you actually signed a "fairness" contract during your indoc, please post a copy here. We will either change, adapt, and seize future opportunities or there will be a different model going forward.
LOL !!!
Sorry pal, but most of the captains I talk to are not on your capitulation train whistlestop tour. Time to go down the hall and tell your superiors this tack failed as well.
You're not getting many points for originality.
#56
Banned
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 8,350
Likes: 0
When a stock fall to its current level they may have no choice. The market will determine AMR's future. The Market can unfortunately short them into BK. Come on, your are a smart guy. You honestly think management can dig you out of this 20 billion+ hole? The game is over. Goldman suggested filing in 2004 and they're right. AMR can not post a profit under its current model. They can no longer borrow money with out paying loan shark pricing. Sorry but its the reality.
The POINT is, it's gotten SO BAD here that far too many are ready to take their chances with BK if it comes to that vs. getting dunked once again in the 2003 pupster trough. You're probably right......THE GAME IS OVER.

Since you're NOW arguing AMR is all but certain to file for Chapter 11 protection, then it matters little what AA pilots do at this point. So then, tell me why again agreeing to any CBA that is MASSIVELY concessionary would be of any use except to management ?
Before you answer, confer with your bosses as well and try and do better then your deskmate Tomahawk.
#58
Banned
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 8,350
Likes: 0
Perhaps the lighting is bad in the Media war room at CP ?
#59
Like I said but maybe you missed it even though you quoted it, I read it to mean if they give him 25% he'll think about giving in. Not like we haven't seen that or been there before. I was pointing out that with the NWA comment. I never said it was Carl but his pilot group. They got at least 50%+1 to buy into that even after they supposedly hated Mesaba's Avro. Always love those go away comments. Does it ever work?
#60
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 262
Likes: 0
Ahh.........the "divide and conquer" beverage is offered, with a fear chaser I see too.
LOL !!!
Sorry pal, but most of the captains I talk to are not on your capitulation train whistlestop tour. Time to go down the hall and tell your superiors this tack failed as well.
You're not getting many points for originality.
LOL !!!
Sorry pal, but most of the captains I talk to are not on your capitulation train whistlestop tour. Time to go down the hall and tell your superiors this tack failed as well.
You're not getting many points for originality.

I've been in this very spot early in my career with all the same anger being expressed here.
As a relatively new FO in 1990-91, I remember receiving a letter from the senior leadership to the effect that I'd be a captain in 5-6 years during contract negotiations. I was a full-fledge member of the entitlement club. I wanted mine and didn't much care how the company would pay for it. Of course I would not become a captain in 5-6 years, actually turned out to be 10.5 years. Of course we went on to hire most of the folks posting here in the fast moving late nineties.
I walked the picket line in the 1997 contract dispute. So where did I make the turn? As I've gotten older and hopefully a bit wiser, I've come to realize that absent a viable, consistently profitable and sustainable enterprise, I had no long-term future nor do any of us!
The tenor of this board is primarily about what we as a pilot group deserve. There's very little if any mention of the 65,000plus other employees here. It's truly the ultimate in elitism and I have been just as guilty of it in the past. I see no sense from the group here that all 75,000plus employees at AA and AE are in this together!
I will say it again, all the bluster and chest pumping will not result in some utopian outcome where we get everything we want regardless of the cost!
Maybe many of you don't appear to really care about a great pension and are living for the moment. But I'll take a good(doesn't have to be the top) income, good working conditions and a solid retirement any day!
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



