AA/ENV to suspend MIA operations May 7
#82
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 584
Likes: 0
From: pilot
The major problem with your theory is that it is not a preferential hiring program. Delta and United have preferential hiring programs. AA has a direct seniority based system that is - for convenience - called "flow." Now, the ENY/PDT/PSA interview is itself the AA interview. Every pilot hired in seniority order can transfer to AA when their seniority will hold a slot at AA. This is very much like you would bid a new base, or new equipment by seniority. Same thing. I know for a fact that the AAG legal department was very concerned about the newer "flow" program creating an extremely valid argument supporting single carrier. They still are, which is why they have slowly throttled the flow/transfer from it's original 60% of all new AA new hires down to about 35% of all AA new hires.
While they are definitely not being paid as AA pilots, or under the work rules of AA pilots.... there is a legal argument to be made that they should be as a single carrier. However, I would advise the PSA/ENY/PDT guys not to pursue that at this time. While it would be good for the industry to take the regional flying back to mainline; it would guarantee that almost every PSA/PDT/ENY pilot gets furloughed in October as the APA guys would love to have 5,000 pilots junior to them right now.
While they are definitely not being paid as AA pilots, or under the work rules of AA pilots.... there is a legal argument to be made that they should be as a single carrier. However, I would advise the PSA/ENY/PDT guys not to pursue that at this time. While it would be good for the industry to take the regional flying back to mainline; it would guarantee that almost every PSA/PDT/ENY pilot gets furloughed in October as the APA guys would love to have 5,000 pilots junior to them right now.
if you were a PSA, envoy or Piedmont pilot and every pilot senior to you was electing not to flow you would be the first guy out... right.
so follow this for a second. American does not have any new hire classes running and they furlough 1000 pilots. It takes 3 years for all the furloughed pilots to get recalled. Then they run the first new hire class in a 3.5 year period of time. Guess what. It added 3.5 years to your flow time. Call it what you want. It’s a preferential hiring program. Until a pilot “flows” and is handed their AA badge and given an APA number they do not work for American Airlines.
I was a captain at PSA which happened to be owned by the same holdings company as American. I enjoyed access to a preferential hiring program that didn’t even require me to interview. All I had to do was have a clean record for the preceding two years and have two years aggregate captain experience. I was not an American pilot.
Saying anything otherwise is not being honest.
#83
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 470
Likes: 0
i know how it works. I was a captain at PSA up until February of this year when I left.
if you were a PSA, envoy or Piedmont pilot and every pilot senior to you was electing not to flow you would be the first guy out... right.
so follow this for a second. American does not have any new hire classes running and they furlough 1000 pilots. It takes 3 years for all the furloughed pilots to get recalled. Then they run the first new hire class in a 3.5 year period of time. Guess what. It added 3.5 years to your flow time. Call it what you want. It’s a preferential hiring program. Until a pilot “flows” and is handed their AA badge and given an APA number they do not work for American Airlines.
I was a captain at PSA which happened to be owned by the same holdings company as American. I enjoyed access to a preferential hiring program that didn’t even require me to interview. All I had to do was have a clean record for the preceding two years and have two years aggregate captain experience. I was not an American pilot.
Saying anything otherwise is not being honest.
if you were a PSA, envoy or Piedmont pilot and every pilot senior to you was electing not to flow you would be the first guy out... right.
so follow this for a second. American does not have any new hire classes running and they furlough 1000 pilots. It takes 3 years for all the furloughed pilots to get recalled. Then they run the first new hire class in a 3.5 year period of time. Guess what. It added 3.5 years to your flow time. Call it what you want. It’s a preferential hiring program. Until a pilot “flows” and is handed their AA badge and given an APA number they do not work for American Airlines.
I was a captain at PSA which happened to be owned by the same holdings company as American. I enjoyed access to a preferential hiring program that didn’t even require me to interview. All I had to do was have a clean record for the preceding two years and have two years aggregate captain experience. I was not an American pilot.
Saying anything otherwise is not being honest.
But we’re still going to AA 3.5 years later. That’s still a flow. Crappy, but it’s not a preferential interview. There is no interview, unless they changed something I’m not aware of that doesn’t make the flow a preferential interview because there isn’t one to begin with
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
#84
i know how it works. I was a captain at PSA up until February of this year when I left.
if you were a PSA, envoy or Piedmont pilot and every pilot senior to you was electing not to flow you would be the first guy out... right.
so follow this for a second. American does not have any new hire classes running and they furlough 1000 pilots. It takes 3 years for all the furloughed pilots to get recalled. Then they run the first new hire class in a 3.5 year period of time. Guess what. It added 3.5 years to your flow time. Call it what you want. It’s a preferential hiring program. Until a pilot “flows” and is handed their AA badge and given an APA number they do not work for American Airlines.
I was a captain at PSA which happened to be owned by the same holdings company as American. I enjoyed access to a preferential hiring program that didn’t even require me to interview. All I had to do was have a clean record for the preceding two years and have two years aggregate captain experience. I was not an American pilot.
Saying anything otherwise is not being honest.
if you were a PSA, envoy or Piedmont pilot and every pilot senior to you was electing not to flow you would be the first guy out... right.
so follow this for a second. American does not have any new hire classes running and they furlough 1000 pilots. It takes 3 years for all the furloughed pilots to get recalled. Then they run the first new hire class in a 3.5 year period of time. Guess what. It added 3.5 years to your flow time. Call it what you want. It’s a preferential hiring program. Until a pilot “flows” and is handed their AA badge and given an APA number they do not work for American Airlines.
I was a captain at PSA which happened to be owned by the same holdings company as American. I enjoyed access to a preferential hiring program that didn’t even require me to interview. All I had to do was have a clean record for the preceding two years and have two years aggregate captain experience. I was not an American pilot.
Saying anything otherwise is not being honest.
Now, that said, you really need to spend some time and google and read about single carrier petitions and the criteria that is looked at when they decide if a single carrier system exists or not.
Here, I'll even give you a recent decision that did involve AA already AFTER the bankruptcy that has AAG legal so very concerned about a single carrier petition...….… two different companies owned by the same holdings company....
https://atd142.org/wp-content/upload...No.-15-FUI.pdf
Here's one for two legally separate corporations, but one sells the tickets for the other and runs/directs their entire operation.
https://nmb.gov/NMB_Application/wp-c...SWAPA-ALPA.pdf
“[a]ny organization or individual may file an application, supported by evidence of representation or a showing of interest . . . seeking a determination whether a single system of transportation exists.” Section 19.501 states that actions by the Carriers constitutes the existence of a single transportation system, such as published combined schedules or combined routes; standardized uniforms; common marketing, markings, or insignia; integrated essential operations such as scheduling or dispatching; centralized labor and personnel operations; combined or common management, corporate officers, and board of directors; combined workforce; and common or overlapping ownership.
it's essentially met and been a single carrier for years, but ALPA loses 5,000 members and APA doesn't want their friends, family and squadron buddies starting out at $40k a year, waiting 5 years to break $100k without killing themselves.
Last edited by Cujo665; 05-08-2020 at 08:20 AM.
#85
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 584
Likes: 0
From: pilot
The point to my post is that WO pilots do not work for AA. Also there are people posting the flow will not be slowed down that much by what’s going on now.
WO pilots are not hired at American until they start at American. That flow program exists only to staff the regional. It has nothing to do with staffing American.
we can call it whatever we want as long as we are honest. Envoy PSA and Piedmont pilots do not work for American.
WO pilots are not hired at American until they start at American. That flow program exists only to staff the regional. It has nothing to do with staffing American.
we can call it whatever we want as long as we are honest. Envoy PSA and Piedmont pilots do not work for American.
#86
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Nov 2016
Posts: 2,607
Likes: 12
The point to my post is that WO pilots do not work for AA. Also there are people posting the flow will not be slowed down that much by what’s going on now.
WO pilots are not hired at American until they start at American. That flow program exists only to staff the regional. It has nothing to do with staffing American.
we can call it whatever we want as long as we are honest. Envoy PSA and Piedmont pilots do not work for American.
WO pilots are not hired at American until they start at American. That flow program exists only to staff the regional. It has nothing to do with staffing American.
we can call it whatever we want as long as we are honest. Envoy PSA and Piedmont pilots do not work for American.
The ONLY one saying we're AA employees now is just ONE poster that everyone here tries to reject and correct. And he doesn't even work for Envoy anymore. You're arguing semantics with Cujo665 who is NOT that person... and who also does not work here anymore (he was once a high level union rep so has good info about the past though).
#87
The fact remains. AAG is in the colleges and universities telling pipeline candidates that this is their one and only interview for their entire career. They'll complete training in college, teach at the College as an Envoy employee, then transfer from pipeline instructor to Envoy Pilot, can bid the equipment and base they want based upon their seniority, and when their seniority holds it, can bid to go train on the Boeing or Airbus at AA under the APA contract instead of the ALPA contract.
It will be very hard to say that is not a single carrier. They themselves are the ones advertising a single cradle to grave interview.
If you want to say they are not an American Airlines pilot currently, I would 100% agree. The only person saying that to anybody is that company stooge who changes his screen name every few weeks to some different variation of mine. He's got Cujo envy.
#88
Banned
Joined: Jul 2019
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
I've been trying to resist responding to your posts here but I can't anymore. There's a little bit of not being aware of your surroundings here:
The ONLY one saying we're AA employees now is just ONE poster that everyone here tries to reject and correct. And he doesn't even work for Envoy anymore. You're arguing semantics with Cujo665 who is NOT that person... and who also does not work here anymore (he was once a high level union rep so has good info about the past though).
The ONLY one saying we're AA employees now is just ONE poster that everyone here tries to reject and correct. And he doesn't even work for Envoy anymore. You're arguing semantics with Cujo665 who is NOT that person... and who also does not work here anymore (he was once a high level union rep so has good info about the past though).
Both IQ levels are the same. Very plausible stupidity coincidence
PS how was that accelerated 12 pilots help you pool. Nice negotiation for yourself at other pilots expense.
#89
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 584
Likes: 0
From: pilot
Don't be moronic; of course they do. They are working for AA like any contractor works for AA. The passengers on the planes are AA passengers, not PSA, PDT or ENY passengers. They are not currently employed by AA would be an accurate statement.
Wrong again. They've already been told they're hired; they just have to complete the time at the regional level first. Essentially and apprenticeship. Their AA start date is deferred, that's all.
They are not employed yet by American; they are most definitely working for American, and have been hired at American; with a start date deferred and dependent upon their seniority list position at their regional. A subtle but significant difference.
The fact remains. AAG is in the colleges and universities telling pipeline candidates that this is their one and only interview for their entire career. They'll complete training in college, teach at the College as an Envoy employee, then transfer from pipeline instructor to Envoy Pilot, can bid the equipment and base they want based upon their seniority, and when their seniority holds it, can bid to go train on the Boeing or Airbus at AA under the APA contract instead of the ALPA contract.
It will be very hard to say that is not a single carrier. They themselves are the ones advertising a single cradle to grave interview.
If you want to say they are not an American Airlines pilot currently, I would 100% agree. The only person saying that to anybody is that company stooge who changes his screen name every few weeks to some different variation of mine. He's got Cujo envy.
Wrong again. They've already been told they're hired; they just have to complete the time at the regional level first. Essentially and apprenticeship. Their AA start date is deferred, that's all.
They are not employed yet by American; they are most definitely working for American, and have been hired at American; with a start date deferred and dependent upon their seniority list position at their regional. A subtle but significant difference.
The fact remains. AAG is in the colleges and universities telling pipeline candidates that this is their one and only interview for their entire career. They'll complete training in college, teach at the College as an Envoy employee, then transfer from pipeline instructor to Envoy Pilot, can bid the equipment and base they want based upon their seniority, and when their seniority holds it, can bid to go train on the Boeing or Airbus at AA under the APA contract instead of the ALPA contract.
It will be very hard to say that is not a single carrier. They themselves are the ones advertising a single cradle to grave interview.
If you want to say they are not an American Airlines pilot currently, I would 100% agree. The only person saying that to anybody is that company stooge who changes his screen name every few weeks to some different variation of mine. He's got Cujo envy.
the recruiters are lying to people to get them to voluntarily work for below standard wages and work rules because they are already “hired” at American. Without an APA number and a single contract it will never be any different.
#90
It is most definitely not a preferential hiring program like you've been insisting. We specifically designed it to not be.
The fact that they have made it so seamless to go from college to a 777 flight deck is one of the very things they're concerned may be used against them in a single carrier employee class petition. "Cradle to Grave" was the word used at our MEC/company meetings to describe their vision of how the pipeline and flow would work. It has worked exactly as envisioned.
You really should spend some time reading the cases I linked above, and the RLA single carrier criteria.
It's somewhat moot, since it would be difficult to get the ALPA attorneys to file and fight for single carrier since they'd lose 5,000 members. You'd be better off having the three regional MEC's hire an outside firm and do it together.
Getting the mergers committee spooled up - as has been happening recently - is a good idea.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
cashcow
Cargo
7
03-08-2007 12:43 PM



