OO vs. YX
#91
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,125
Likes: 1
It only went away because the mainline was not hiring. During those years, there was no real movement from any other regionals either, so AA WO's were not singled out in this.
I'd say the AA WO's did pretty well during those years. Yes, they downsized, but looking at the turmoil rest of the regional industry went through, AA WO wasn't a bad place to be.
Currently, there are no 10 year CA's at any WO's who are there because they can't move on. There are plenty of them at other regionals. So yes, the flow works, even though there was a 7-8 year gap because of the lost decade.
So based on the history lessons, I would say AA WOs are definitely some of the more stable regionals to be in. And currently they have other added benefits too - fast upgrades, no training delays and so on.
I'd say the AA WO's did pretty well during those years. Yes, they downsized, but looking at the turmoil rest of the regional industry went through, AA WO wasn't a bad place to be.
Currently, there are no 10 year CA's at any WO's who are there because they can't move on. There are plenty of them at other regionals. So yes, the flow works, even though there was a 7-8 year gap because of the lost decade.
So based on the history lessons, I would say AA WOs are definitely some of the more stable regionals to be in. And currently they have other added benefits too - fast upgrades, no training delays and so on.
You claim the WOs are stable. When I started at PSA in 2014, Envoy was downsizing. 2 years before that Envoy was strongly rumored to be sold off.
You claim captain pay at Envoy sucks but FO pay is about the same everywhere. This proves you don’t have any idea what you’re talking about. It’s more than just pay rates. 2nd year FOs at Endeavor, Republic, Skywest, Expressjet, and Air Wisconsin are all making more than any 5 year captain at the AA wholly owneds and they don’t have to fly their butt off to do it.
#92
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 2,035
Likes: 0
Dera, I’m starting to think you live in a fantasy world filled with unicorns and rainbows. No one is arguing which personal lucky situation is better. We’re talking about what the average new hire can expect. I don’t know about Envoy, but PSA and Piedmont flows are both around 10 years. Reserve is close to a year and increasing. At PSA, we’ve become extremely fat on pilots. With literally half of the airline on reserve... a new hire today will have to move up 450 spots on a 1900 pilot seniority list to hold a line. Currently that much movement will take about 16-22 months even accounting for new aircraft deliveries.
You claim the WOs are stable. When I started at PSA in 2014, Envoy was downsizing. 2 years before that Envoy was strongly rumored to be sold off.
You claim captain pay at Envoy sucks but FO pay is about the same everywhere. This proves you don’t have any idea what you’re talking about. It’s more than just pay rates. 2nd year FOs at Endeavor, Republic, Skywest, Expressjet, and Air Wisconsin are all making more than any 5 year captain at the AA wholly owneds and they don’t have to fly their butt off to do it.
You claim the WOs are stable. When I started at PSA in 2014, Envoy was downsizing. 2 years before that Envoy was strongly rumored to be sold off.
You claim captain pay at Envoy sucks but FO pay is about the same everywhere. This proves you don’t have any idea what you’re talking about. It’s more than just pay rates. 2nd year FOs at Endeavor, Republic, Skywest, Expressjet, and Air Wisconsin are all making more than any 5 year captain at the AA wholly owneds and they don’t have to fly their butt off to do it.
Careful, or Dera will say you contribute nothing and that you aren't even a pilot...
#93
In a land of unicorns
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 7,072
Likes: 102
From: Whale FO
Dera, I’m starting to think you live in a fantasy world filled with unicorns and rainbows. No one is arguing which personal lucky situation is better. We’re talking about what the average new hire can expect. I don’t know about Envoy, but PSA and Piedmont flows are both around 10 years. Reserve is close to a year and increasing. At PSA, we’ve become extremely fat on pilots. With literally half of the airline on reserve... a new hire today will have to move up 450 spots on a 1900 pilot seniority list to hold a line. Currently that much movement will take about 16-22 months even accounting for new aircraft deliveries.
You claim the WOs are stable. When I started at PSA in 2014, Envoy was downsizing. 2 years before that Envoy was strongly rumored to be sold off.
You claim captain pay at Envoy sucks but FO pay is about the same everywhere. This proves you don’t have any idea what you’re talking about. It’s more than just pay rates. 2nd year FOs at Endeavor, Republic, Skywest, Expressjet, and Air Wisconsin are all making more than any 5 year captain at the AA wholly owneds and they don’t have to fly their butt off to do it.
You claim the WOs are stable. When I started at PSA in 2014, Envoy was downsizing. 2 years before that Envoy was strongly rumored to be sold off.
You claim captain pay at Envoy sucks but FO pay is about the same everywhere. This proves you don’t have any idea what you’re talking about. It’s more than just pay rates. 2nd year FOs at Endeavor, Republic, Skywest, Expressjet, and Air Wisconsin are all making more than any 5 year captain at the AA wholly owneds and they don’t have to fly their butt off to do it.
The union number, which is very pessimistic obviously, is 8.8 years for a new hire. First 2 months, I moved up 6 months. It will be 6-7 years unless there's a huge world event that messes everyone up. Those are impossible to forecast so no point to add them to any reasonable prediction.
I sincerely hope PSA/PDT will get improvements soon. Right now the prospects aren't great there.
And yes, AA WO's have been relatively stable in the regional industry. Look back 20 years and you see what I mean. Nothing is 100% stable when it comes to regionals, that's a fact.
And sorry you didn't understand what I meant by the FO pay. I should've been more clear. I meant year 1-2 pay. At Envoy, you will upgrade around year 2, so anything beyond that doesn't matter. After that you go to CA pay, and yes, it sucks.
#95
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 177
Likes: 0
From: Holiday Inn, King Non-Smoking
#96
Line Holder
Joined: May 2016
Posts: 453
Likes: 15
Over 87 at YX is 125%. That is not per credit hour, that is block hour or deadhead time.
#97
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jun 2017
Posts: 1,125
Likes: 1
I've made it pretty obvious that my comments are for Envoy 175 new hire. It's been a 50/50 chance lately, so pretty much by definition, what average new hire can expect.
The union number, which is very pessimistic obviously, is 8.8 years for a new hire. First 2 months, I moved up 6 months. It will be 6-7 years unless there's a huge world event that messes everyone up. Those are impossible to forecast so no point to add them to any reasonable prediction.
And yes, AA WO's have been relatively stable in the regional industry. Look back 20 years and you see what I mean. Nothing is 100% stable when it comes to regionals, that's a fact.
And sorry you didn't understand what I meant by the FO pay. I should've been more clear. I meant year 1-2 pay. At Envoy, you will upgrade around year 2, so anything beyond that doesn't matter. After that you go to CA pay, and yes, it sucks.
The union number, which is very pessimistic obviously, is 8.8 years for a new hire. First 2 months, I moved up 6 months. It will be 6-7 years unless there's a huge world event that messes everyone up. Those are impossible to forecast so no point to add them to any reasonable prediction.
And yes, AA WO's have been relatively stable in the regional industry. Look back 20 years and you see what I mean. Nothing is 100% stable when it comes to regionals, that's a fact.
And sorry you didn't understand what I meant by the FO pay. I should've been more clear. I meant year 1-2 pay. At Envoy, you will upgrade around year 2, so anything beyond that doesn't matter. After that you go to CA pay, and yes, it sucks.
1. You did not make it obvious at first. Your first few comments on this thread were pretty broad making it sound like anyone hired at Envoy will have a similar situation as you (which btw, isn’t that great).
2. The union number for flow is actually pretty accurate. Of course you move up the list very quickly at first. Same as the PSA pilots, but that trend doesn’t continue. New hires will move up 20-30 spots a month when they first start and then it will greatly slow down. I’m in the top 30% at PSA. Besides the flow pilots I’ve only moved up 0-3 spots a month for the past year.
3. So you’re saying the past 4-5 years might have been crappy for Envoy, but as long as you were willing to stay 20 years eventually everything will come back around.
4. I still don’t understand what the heck you’re talking about. You’re saying since you upgrade after 2 years at Envoy pay doesn’t matter beyond that? What?! Almost every regional is upgrading pilots after 2-3 years. Those people go from making more as an FO than any AA wholly owned captain.... to making literally 30k-70k more than you do once they upgrade in about the same amount of time as you. How many of your regular line flying captains at Envoy are making 130k+++ as a captain after 3-4 years?
You sound like an Amish person who’s never left the farm to see what else is out there.
#99
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jan 2019
Posts: 159
Likes: 0
#100
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Mar 2011
Posts: 3,495
Likes: 297
From: 737 FO


