Pilot Shortage (2015 Embry Riddle summit)
#212
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 12,833
Likes: 172
From: window seat
#213
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 514
Likes: 0
From: Left seat of a Jet
#214
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 265
Likes: 0
From: Captain - Retired
Don't call my Shirley!
The part that made me chuckle is when you thought the union contracts at the majors would never be modified to give away jobs at the low end. Because that's never happened!!!
The part that made me chuckle is when you thought the union contracts at the majors would never be modified to give away jobs at the low end. Because that's never happened!!!
#215
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 12,833
Likes: 172
From: window seat
Yeah yeah there's RJ's ergo soon we'll only have 2 pilots on property to fly a single 777 with the rest outsourced and also robots and teleportation etc.
#216
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 265
Likes: 0
From: Captain - Retired
We're not talking about the "low end" we're talking about wide body relief pilot jobs. No way those get signed away to accommodate out of seniority MPL fantasy pilots.
Yeah yeah there's RJ's ergo soon we'll only have 2 pilots on property to fly a single 777 with the rest outsourced and also robots and teleportation etc.
Yeah yeah there's RJ's ergo soon we'll only have 2 pilots on property to fly a single 777 with the rest outsourced and also robots and teleportation etc.
Never say never.
#217
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 12,833
Likes: 172
From: window seat
Do you think that every time you take off you're going to break the sound barrier because, at the time, the trend vector of your acceleration is so steep it will probably happen in a few minutes. Or every time you start climbing you're going to fly to the moon because if that rate continued on forever, well…

So I'll say it:
Never.
#218
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 265
Likes: 0
From: Captain - Retired
I was making perfect sense, and I was sticking to my point. I have no idea what point you were trying to make.
I was simply saying that historical observation does not suggest that the future trend will be any different.
I'm not even sure why you are arguing this point with me. All I said is your statement made me chuckle.
I wondered about you so I read back on some of your posts and your pattern seems to be based on a specific agenda.
Your priorities seem to be against the best interests of pilots as a profession and more in line with either an RAA executive or the owner of a large flight school.
Gloopy, can you explain what you do support? My agenda is very clear in that I support the long term restoration of the piloting profession and an improvement in career opportunities for pilots.
I will learn more by your response....
I was simply saying that historical observation does not suggest that the future trend will be any different.
I'm not even sure why you are arguing this point with me. All I said is your statement made me chuckle.
I wondered about you so I read back on some of your posts and your pattern seems to be based on a specific agenda.
- You seem very interested in promoting the growth of flight schools that can churn out large numbers of new airline pilots for cheap.
- You are very interested in maintaining the status quo of big union influence among airline pilots specifically with the regional to major path that has evolved and the seniority system that is required for this path.
- You are interested in encouraging the regional airline route as a good career path for pilots.
Your priorities seem to be against the best interests of pilots as a profession and more in line with either an RAA executive or the owner of a large flight school.
Gloopy, can you explain what you do support? My agenda is very clear in that I support the long term restoration of the piloting profession and an improvement in career opportunities for pilots.
I will learn more by your response....
#219
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 12,833
Likes: 172
From: window seat
I was making perfect sense, and I was sticking to my point. I have no idea what point you were trying to make.
I was simply saying that historical observation does not suggest that the future trend will be any different.
I'm not even sure why you are arguing this point with me. All I said is your statement made me chuckle.
I wondered about you so I read back on some of your posts and your pattern seems to be based on a specific agenda.
Your priorities seem to be against the best interests of pilots as a profession and more in line with either an RAA executive or the owner of a large flight school.
Gloopy, can you explain what you do support? My agenda is very clear in that I support the long term restoration of the piloting profession and an improvement in career opportunities for pilots.
I will learn more by your response....
I was simply saying that historical observation does not suggest that the future trend will be any different.
I'm not even sure why you are arguing this point with me. All I said is your statement made me chuckle.
I wondered about you so I read back on some of your posts and your pattern seems to be based on a specific agenda.
- You seem very interested in promoting the growth of flight schools that can churn out large numbers of new airline pilots for cheap.
- You are very interested in maintaining the status quo of big union influence among airline pilots specifically with the regional to major path that has evolved and the seniority system that is required for this path.
- You are interested in encouraging the regional airline route as a good career path for pilots.
Your priorities seem to be against the best interests of pilots as a profession and more in line with either an RAA executive or the owner of a large flight school.
Gloopy, can you explain what you do support? My agenda is very clear in that I support the long term restoration of the piloting profession and an improvement in career opportunities for pilots.
I will learn more by your response....

As for promoting the growth of flight schools, its clear that we lack sufficient infrastructure for training new pilots relative to projected demand. Its not necessarily a matter of more schools, but we do/will need more instructors and students going to flight schools. This isn't even debatable.
While we may collectively gain some amount of pricing power from a "shortage" that will be short lived and is not a strategy towards restoration. If we can't get enough new pilots into the system we will all suffer because our entire industry will lose out. Eventually the pressure to allow cabotage as well as further aiding and abetting foreign enemy airlines hell bent on poaching our entire industry out from under us will only increase if we can't find a way to asuage our pilot shortage at least to a reasonable degree.
As for taking the lower cost comments out of context, I think we have way too much 6 figure Bravo Sierra in all our education systems. Way too many flight schools are gravitating to insane all glass hyper expensive fleets/programs when what we need is experience. Its not going to be "cheap" either way, but the issues we face will only get worse if the only solution we throw at it is a 6 figure flight school model on top of a 6 figure bachleors degree. That's asinine, unsustainable and completely out of scale with reality.
The regional path is and always will be a great way to gain time and experience, but there are other great ways too. FWIW I am LOVING watching the dirt bag bottom feeder regionals scramble for pilots and raising compensation. I want thier costs to go up and go up a lot. That takes real pressure off of the bottom end of mainline scope issues, which we also need to address and improve.
Your thinly veiled point is still completely ridiculous though. You think that because there are 76 seat RJ's flying around that ergo soon legacy pilot groups will sign away widebody international FO positions to out of seniority MPL pilots. That is not going to happen. Ever.
Trends can be a useful tool, but its important not to take them out of context. Do you white knuckle your armrests and start screaming "AIRSPEED! STALL! AIRSPEED!" every time the other pilot slows 10 kts? That's the trend, after all.

Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Ryanthepilot
Flight Schools and Training
55
01-29-2015 05:09 PM
navymmw
Flight Schools and Training
23
07-11-2008 11:19 AM




