Adlerdriver

Neither response is "textbook", so I wouldn't read much into that personally.

chi05

I don't think you can read too much into that. It's pretty common for pilots to be inconsistent in their ATC phraseology.

CRM114

Hopefully because all the guys who are qualified have integrity and can see CNN for what it is? Viewers go from one media circus to the next shaking their heads about how the media got it all wrong, but they still don't turn the TV off.

Toasty

This so-called transcript is questionable.

Having flown in and out of KL over the years, I NEVER heard such casual conversation between MAS crew and ATC. At best it is a very bad translation, at worst fictitious. Are we really to believe they got take-off clearance without the wind even being mentioned by ATC?

Captain Bligh

Maybe it's a thread of unprofessionalism, that may some day start the whole sweater to unravel; but when I find a controller to be particularly annoying, obviously in training, or extra pedestrian, I often revert to less than standard phraseology. Especially when it's late in the duty period and the long awaited hand off (last transmission) comes.

"Goodnight!"

Too late in my career for domestic CPDLC to save me, but even if just to eliminate frequency hand offs from the chatter, it will be better.

Does anyone else find it causes tension when one controller works multiple sectors and you can only hear about every third plane respond? It feels like all those unanswered transmissions may have been for you.

I would read nothing into the transmission transcripts from MH370 without hearing the tapes.

Caution Terrain

Don Lemon claims to have a pilot friend at a commuter airline who takes PICTURES WHILE FLYING. Zombie Plane.

Out of the Past

MH370: New Inmarsat data narrows missing airliner's flight path.

Inmarsat today has said the ping timings increased in time. Seems to me like they have been the only ones providing reliable data all along.
According to them, in order for the pings to have increased in time it could only have gone north (passing through countries radar) or south through Indonesia (passing through a countries radar).
They say it is not possible for them to have traveled over the open ocean and then turned south like has been thought up until now.

JamesNoBrakes

They've got everyone talking about them, lots of people in this thread are watching, that's the point. Attract attention. It's absolutely hilarious to see people come back and shout and cry that it so "biased" or things are batentely wrong. They are giving people exactly what they want, except, those same people are simply not honest with themselves about what they want. They want adventure, they want drama, they want impressive and magnificent story. If it was simply "shut up until we know more" it would be boring and no one would watch, there'd be no news at all. Some of us could care less either way, but many people feed on that, and they are many of the most vocal ones speaking out against the media. The whole point is to attract people to watch the commercials (so basic, but so many people can't see the forest for the trees). You'll get people that are indifferent, people that like the stories, and people that hate the stories. It really doesn't matter as long as they watch it, and that's exactly what the networks fox, abc, nbc, cnn, etc, all want. Anyone who thinks differently about any one of them is simply kidding themselves.

It's human nature to want there to be "more" than is apparent. We want things to emotionally make sense, for there to be "closure", to have all the puzzle pieces fit perfectly into what we think is the right story. We want this so bad that we'll watch and belief all kinds of crazy things. Natural defense mechanisms lead to this, and to a point, they can be healthy, as they help someone perform under stress. When we can no longer function productively they are a hindrance.

Amjadian

Got to love the media. All the speculations, all the so called experts they bring on live tv. There was some dude yesterday on CNN that claimed the FO sounded suspiciously with the way he spoke with air traffic controllers. I mean seriously???

RhinoPherret

Removed..........