Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Delta (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/delta/)
-   -   Any "Latest & Greatest" about Delta? (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/delta/36912-any-latest-greatest-about-delta.html)

Carl Spackler 12-06-2011 04:51 PM


Originally Posted by alfaromeo (Post 1097511)
What blows my mind is that there are perfect examples for you to study out there on how to get steam rollered by the other side and yet you keep looking the guys that have gotten their butts kicked and continue to say "hey let's be like them." Why should we continue the tactics that have produced the best results over the last five years when we can copy the guys that have gotten nothing. Excellent plan.

You're the only one talking about following the "steam rolled" examples alfaromeo. The rest of us are talking about following the examples of SWA and FDX. The sad fact is that while we're studying those successful examples, you MEC bureaucrats are busy mischaracterizing them in the hopes of getting us the results of the "steam rolled." All the flight pay loss in the world couldn't make me do what you do here alfaromeo.

Carl

slowplay 12-06-2011 04:57 PM


Originally Posted by Carl Spackler (Post 1097657)
You've built a history of staying on as an unelected MEC bureaucrat helping to undercut Delta pilots keeping us below our competitors and partners like SWA and Air France etc. You've done this by fighting to ensure management's spin gets properly disseminated to line pilots for the express purpose of crushing our hopes of ever leading this industry again. You've done it on full flight pay loss as well. You must be so proud.

Carl

As usual, you're clueless to the facts. You continue your bush(wood) league attacks to blow up your own golf course, just as in your movie.

The "bureaucrats" you malign while taking a swipe at me came into office after the tough typists like you had given away 32.5% of our pay. Those tough guys had typed how they were going to protect the pension, then were stunned when it went into liquidity shortfall. Then that group told everyone to "remain calm, all is well," then jumped into early retirement and the PRP program in the 3 months prior to bankruptcy. Real tough, those guys.

Those bureaucrats then salvaged $1.3 billion in real cash from the equity claim and another $650 million when the pension terminated. They got 3 years of 415C contributions to the retirement plan pre-tax, and helped get a Roth option for the total value of the remainder. They fought off a hostile takeover that would have furloughed 1500 of the 6800 remaining Delta pilots. They helped engineer a merger with another post-bankruptcy airline that increased compensation for their members by 22% and put 50 million shares of company stock in their pockets. And except for companies that haven't gone bankrupt (like FedEx, UPS, and SWA) the pay they negotiated leads the rest of the passenger industry. Oh, and Delta was the only legacy airline not to furlough during the 2008 economic downturn.

I'll take those type of bureaucrats over a keyboard ninja like you anyday. With your history, you must be so proud...:rolleyes:

"Crushing our hopes"... that's rich. You must be one really weak dude.:eek:

Carl Spackler 12-06-2011 04:57 PM


Originally Posted by alfaromeo (Post 1097511)
If you really have creative ideas then let us know. In general, when I hear "you need to think outside the box" it shows a person out of airspeed and ideas and running on testosterone. You claim to have a magical formula where we can get everything we want easily. Let's have it.

We showed you MEC bureaucrats our latest creative idea with the Flight Pay Loss resolution. The MEC responded to us and our LEC reps by telling us to shove the resolution. So now it's dead. It was far too important for the MEC to keep hidden what MEC bureaucrats like you get paid.

Like 4,000 others of my Delta brothers, my next creative idea is to vote in an in-house union. This will get you back to the Brazil trips that you want so bad. :rolleyes:

Carl

gloopy 12-06-2011 04:59 PM


Originally Posted by sinca3 (Post 1097528)
Dude, there is one piece of talent in there that would get my vote as hottest "bar maid" in the land!!!:eek:

What's his name?

Schwanker 12-06-2011 05:00 PM

Carl,
First off, I agree with you 90+ % of the time. One question on the balance sheet as it does give me cause for concern. Maybe you can help.

Asset - Approx 9.8B in goodwill

Ours is much larger than others (AMR has none).

Is this really an asset and how is it calculated?
UAL is 4.5B...

Just asking (trying to understand)

Carl Spackler 12-06-2011 05:10 PM


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1097526)
Lots of lawsuits like this and there will be lots more. Someone always wants to blame someone or something when things turn south.

And someone always wants to deflect away from what the JURY said. The JURY said that ALPA is guilty of misrepresenting the TWA pilots. Not blaming somebody else, guilty of misrepresenting their own pilots. TWA pilots.


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1097526)
In the end they are almost always settled for a few pennies and cash to the lawyers.

Sure not the case at United. That was millions. Sure not the case with ALPA's own in-house union of clerical workers. They got $800,000.


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1097526)
The chances of ALPA or their insurance agent paying large checks to TWA pilots is not very high.

Pure speculation on your part.


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1097526)
Keep in mind one important principle of the law. To get damages you have to show where and how you were damaged and convert that to a financial loss.

Funny you should mention it. The court is in the process of doing just that.


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1097526)
Had TWA pilots not accepted the APA offer would they be better or worse off today. Anyone who knew TWA's status at the merger can probably answer that.

Pure speculation on your part. But speculation that is required if you want to continue to apologize for a union found GUILTY of misrepresenting their own members at TWA.

Carl

Carl Spackler 12-06-2011 05:14 PM


Originally Posted by sailingfun (Post 1097553)
I did not even know about the lawsuit a year ago. Not sure what you mean by phases. No damages have been awarded or even determined yet.

But since the time you DID know of the lawsuit, you did nothing but "predict" ALPA's total victory and portrayed TWA pilots as ungrateful cry babies who wanted to blame other people. That's what he meant.

Carl

Carl Spackler 12-06-2011 05:20 PM


Originally Posted by cni187 (Post 1097674)
I hate to see Carl so worked up all the time! Hey Carl tell us about the good old days when the FA's were hot and pilots were gods!

Don't worry about it brudda. We "gods" can handle it. :D

Carl

Ferd149 12-06-2011 05:21 PM

Geeze this thread $ucks anymore.

Carl, Slow, Alfa......thanks for answering the real question I asked several pages back.

KMA Motherz

Ferd

DAL 88 Driver 12-06-2011 05:25 PM


Originally Posted by slowplay (Post 1097702)
Those bureaucrats then salvaged $1.3 billion in real cash from the equity claim and another $650 million when the pension terminated. They got 3 years of 415C contributions to the retirement plan pre-tax, and helped get a Roth option for the total value of the remainder. They fought off a hostile takeover that would have furloughed 1500 of the 6800 remaining Delta pilots. They helped engineer a merger with another post-bankruptcy airline that increased compensation for their members by 22% and put 50 million shares of company stock in their pockets.

Oh it sounds so impressive when you quote big numbers like that! :rolleyes: Why don't you post how many 10's of billions of dollars this pilot group has given up over the past decade in pay cuts, loss of pay due to stagnation caused by outsourcing, and loss of retirement benefits? Why don't you post where our current W2 buying power is compared with where it was prior to the pay cuts? (Hint: that "22%" you brag about amounts to essentially a COLA to our bankruptcy/emergency pay rates.) It should also be noted that the vast majority of the note, claim dollars, and equity stock went into our retirement accounts. It was a nice boost to those accounts, to be sure. But when contrasted with the loss of our pension and the performance of the market these past few years, most in this pilot group probably come out behind.... some way behind.

So, in essence, the real accomplishment of DALPA is that you did something unique. Something that had never been done before. You got "gains" as part of a merger. And you did it using "proactive engagement." A novelty that while it appears impressive on the surface, when viewed in the context of the big picture, we're all left holding the bag with diminished retirement accounts for most and W2 buying power that is about 40% below what we had a decade ago. Most of us can afford a standard of living for our families that is consistent with what we could afford during the darkest days of Delta's bankruptcy.

But congratulations! At least you have something for your resume, should you ever need a job with that Swelbar dude. (do they make an emoticon for "disgusted?")


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:30 AM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands