Go Back  Airline Pilot Central Forums > Airline Pilot Forums > Regional
GAO report on "Great Pilot Shortage" >

GAO report on "Great Pilot Shortage"

Search

Notices
Regional Regional Airlines

GAO report on "Great Pilot Shortage"

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 03-03-2014 | 03:56 PM
  #71  
Cubdriver's Avatar
Moderator
 
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 6,056
Likes: 0
From: ATP, CFI etc.
Default

He (John 3-16) should also understand there are many high grade captains at just about all the US regionals that are stuck there for life. It's a (poor) gamble, and I assure you there is stiff competition for jobs at the majors.
Reply
Old 03-03-2014 | 05:50 PM
  #72  
Octagon's Avatar
Whats a line?
 
Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
From: Hotel Furniture
Default

So, we all agree; the entry level pay is far to low to attract all but the most ambitions who can and will find a way to survive on that kind of pay. Some make just enough to be stuck for life. The "I got mine so wait your turn" attitude has exacerbated us into this situation. And no matter how Shiny the jet, low QOL will not bring new people into the industry.

Now what do we do with this information?
Reply
Old 03-03-2014 | 05:59 PM
  #73  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 480
Likes: 0
Default

Originally Posted by Octagon
So, we all agree; the entry level pay is far to low to attract all but the most ambitions who can and will find a way to survive on that kind of pay. Some make just enough to be stuck for life. The "I got mine so wait your turn" attitude has exacerbated us into this situation. And no matter how Shiny the jet, low QOL will not bring new people into the industry.

Now what do we do with this information?

It sure is funny how 'paying your dues' only gets steeper and harder. Why does every generation think they had it horribly and punish the next? Compared to what I expect, I'm frequently let down by the character and integrity of mainline pilots I know. On the other hand, I'm always shocked at how GOOD the quality of the average regional crew is. Now that regional crews on E195s are flying mainline missions, what gives?
Reply
Old 03-03-2014 | 06:41 PM
  #74  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 2,035
Likes: 0
Cool

Originally Posted by HermannGraf
Eat my words?

I been doing this for 19 years and one thing I do know

We have highly qualified FOs that in general do an awesome job. Many times better than many Captains.
The pay scale on the FO side is based on a fast upgrade and that payscale is not up to date with reality.

What do you think you do better than an 8 year FO while he is getting half your pay?

Do you seriously think that he is not as responsible for the safety of the flight as you and that he is not thinking about the safety of the flight at all times and that he will do everything in his power to make sure that flight is completed in a safe manner? Are you aware that he is qualified to take over and become the PIC if you are incapacitated or screwing up seriously? You better as there has been many examples of that. I hold the FOs to a higher standard and believe they are highly qualified and I know that the only difference between a senior FO and a Captain is the time in the company and the opportunity to upgrade or not. It has nothing to do with qualifications ability or quality.

The reason for your extreme pay comparing to the FOs is that you sign for the AC? That is your argument for a 300 to 450% pay comparing with the lowest paid FOs?

Let me tell you that if you screw something up "they" the FAA or the company will go after the FO as much as after you. We have had many examples of that.

Today the FOs are held to the same qualification than Captains with PIC type and an ATP and a min qualification of 1500 hours. That was the old qualification for Captains in 121 operation. I am not saying the Captain should not be paid more than FOs but the FOs pay scales should be about 70% of the captain pay, no less. That is a fair difference for signing for the aircraft.

While the requirements for FOs at 121 ops are many times the old one the pay is the same. I do not believe that is right.

We need to raise the FO payscale substantially. No pilot with 1500 hours ATP and PIC typed should have to start at poverty wages.

I am willing to share with the guys at the bottom to take them up to an acceptable level. You are not. We just have to agree to disagree.





I really don't know why you keep preaching for anyone at a regional having to take pay cuts? There are no overpaid regional pilots period!! If you're not management, I don't understand your need to keep insinuating one group needs to take a pay cut in order to give a pay increase to another? This is typical management "divide and conquer" tactics. The low pay for new hires at all regionals will have to come up if management really wants to resolve their inability to attract those new hires... NO one will need to take pay cuts to make this happen!
Reply
Old 03-04-2014 | 05:50 AM
  #75  
Flying Ninja's Avatar
Need More Flight Time!
 
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 400
Likes: 0
From: Flight Simulator X
Default

Originally Posted by Paid2fly
NO one will need to take pay cuts to make this happen!
Can you provide more details on how this can come to reality? My understanding of pilot pay is that management says, we're giving your pilot group $100M. The pilot union (composed of very senior pilots) then come up with a pay scale, present it to its pilots to vote, and that's how the scale comes about.

Now, if that is the case, then at the very best, there will be no increase for the senior years, particularly at the captain side of the scale, and an increase on the low FO side. At the worst, the seniors will take a pay cut, and move that excess over to the low FO side.

It seem to me to be the "let's help our own" mentality. This doesn't seem to be a "divide and conquer" mentality. For you to suggest this makes me think that NOBODY is going to give up any pay to help out the little guys coming through the door.

Correct me if I'm wrong or don't understand how this pay scale becomes reality.
Reply
Old 03-04-2014 | 09:02 AM
  #76  
tomgoodman's Avatar
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 6,248
Likes: 0
From: 767A (Ret)
Default

Originally Posted by Flying Ninja
My understanding of pilot pay is that management says, we're giving your pilot group $100M.
If they say that, do not believe them. Management brings a pot of money into the room, but they never reveal how much is inside. Pilot negotiators try to get all of it, but if they fail, management hauls the remaining amount back to the office.
Reply
Old 03-04-2014 | 09:26 AM
  #77  
HermannGraf's Avatar
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 267
Likes: 0
From: CR7
Default

Originally Posted by Flying Ninja
Can you provide more details on how this can come to reality? My understanding of pilot pay is that management says, we're giving your pilot group $100M. The pilot union (composed of very senior pilots) then come up with a pay scale, present it to its pilots to vote, and that's how the scale comes about.

Now, if that is the case, then at the very best, there will be no increase for the senior years, particularly at the captain side of the scale, and an increase on the low FO side. At the worst, the seniors will take a pay cut, and move that excess over to the low FO side.

It seem to me to be the "let's help our own" mentality. This doesn't seem to be a "divide and conquer" mentality. For you to suggest this makes me think that NOBODY is going to give up any pay to help out the little guys coming through the door.

Correct me if I'm wrong or don't understand how this pay scale becomes reality.

Thank you for saving me time explaining.

You get it and most do but we have the ones at the top of the scales or getting there that do not and that because they are selfish and greedy. They never had to survive on FO Regional pay for 10 years. They are the ones not willing to give up anything to help anyone else and they demand to get equal raise if the ones at the bottom get any. They are making six figures plus at the Regional level and claim they are lowly paid (every pilot at the Regionals are badly paid they claim) at the same time they do not give a **** about the guys making 25K at the bottom. Reality of things is that the Regional business model can't afford to pay all guys six figures. If it would then there would be no purpose for the majors to have Regional doing their flying. The Regionals gets the flying because they can operate cheaper and that because they pay less. We all get that and understand that there is not much more room, there is some but not much but there is a lot to do about the pay scales and how unfair the division of the available cash for the crew has been done. There is no other industry with the extreme of two people working together doing the same job while one getting paid 4 to 5 times what the other one is making. People should not make the same, not even for the same job, that is not my point, seniority should pay more and more responsibility should pay more but never 4 to 5 times what the guys doing the same job at the bottom is making and specifically not at the Regional level where the salaries at the bottom are ridiculously low. The guys that believes getting 4 or 5 times what the bottom guy is getting is right while the bottom guy is on food stamps are the guys that also believes it is right for a CEO to make in one year 80 times what the lowest paid pilot is making and have the arrogance to tell the guy at the bottom that he is the problem. He will even tell him, if you do not like the pay don't take the job.
Well guess what, there are not many taking the job anymore and if we do not find solutions the highest paid one will also lose his job (with all that follows) because without new pilots attrition will kill every Regional out there.

Last edited by HermannGraf; 03-04-2014 at 10:06 AM.
Reply
Old 03-04-2014 | 03:29 PM
  #78  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 212
Likes: 0
From: emb-145 ca
Default

Originally Posted by HermannGraf
Thank you for saving me time explaining.

You get it and most do but we have the ones at the top of the scales or getting there that do not and that because they are selfish and greedy. They never had to survive on FO Regional pay for 10 years. They are the ones not willing to give up anything to help anyone else and they demand to get equal raise if the ones at the bottom get any. They are making six figures plus at the Regional level and claim they are lowly paid (every pilot at the Regionals are badly paid they claim) at the same time they do not give a **** about the guys making 25K at the bottom. Reality of things is that the Regional business model can't afford to pay all guys six figures. If it would then there would be no purpose for the majors to have Regional doing their flying. The Regionals gets the flying because they can operate cheaper and that because they pay less. We all get that and understand that there is not much more room, there is some but not much but there is a lot to do about the pay scales and how unfair the division of the available cash for the crew has been done. There is no other industry with the extreme of two people working together doing the same job while one getting paid 4 to 5 times what the other one is making. People should not make the same, not even for the same job, that is not my point, seniority should pay more and more responsibility should pay more but never 4 to 5 times what the guys doing the same job at the bottom is making and specifically not at the Regional level where the salaries at the bottom are ridiculously low. The guys that believes getting 4 or 5 times what the bottom guy is getting is right while the bottom guy is on food stamps are the guys that also believes it is right for a CEO to make in one year 80 times what the lowest paid pilot is making and have the arrogance to tell the guy at the bottom that he is the problem. He will even tell him, if you do not like the pay don't take the job.
Well guess what, there are not many taking the job anymore and if we do not find solutions the highest paid one will also lose his job (with all that follows) because without new pilots attrition will kill every Regional out there.
The majors are rolling in BILLIONS $$$ IN PROFITS. There is plenty of money available if they want to use it. If not, fine. Then there will be no new pilots. Done. If they really want pilots to staff the regionals, they will need to pay a lot more in the future because the majors (by the very creation and expansion of the regionals) killed the dream of actually getting a job at the majors someday... THEY DID THIS. THIS IS THEIR MESS. Reallocation of payroll is no solution, you're speaking as if that is a fixed number. Tell the majors to either bring a lot more money in to get pilots on property, or give them something other than lip-service and false dreams and promises of a mainline job... someday... when they get around to being able to give you one, after all their buddies and CP friends and kids and interns have been accommodated.

Kill the dream and guess what? Well, we're seeing what! No more dumb, hopeful, someday-I'm-gonna-fly-a-widebody-to-Europe kids showing up to learn to fly anymore. Well, they killed the dream, it's DEAD, and this is what it looks like. No new pilots is what it looks like. They made the regionals a stagnant, hard to escape career mud-pit. They can live with the consequences.

I hope they don't touch regional FO pay by a penny. I hope every regional is dead or part of mainline just for pilot supply in 10 years or less. That's the new dream.

Graf, you have to be management. Only management would think to solve the problem your way.

Last edited by CaptainNameless; 03-04-2014 at 03:45 PM.
Reply
Old 03-04-2014 | 06:35 PM
  #79  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 2,035
Likes: 0
Wink

Originally Posted by CaptainNameless
The majors are rolling in BILLIONS $$$ IN PROFITS. There is plenty of money available if they want to use it. If not, fine. Then there will be no new pilots. Done. If they really want pilots to staff the regionals, they will need to pay a lot more in the future because the majors (by the very creation and expansion of the regionals) killed the dream of actually getting a job at the majors someday... THEY DID THIS. THIS IS THEIR MESS. Reallocation of payroll is no solution, you're speaking as if that is a fixed number. Tell the majors to either bring a lot more money in to get pilots on property, or give them something other than lip-service and false dreams and promises of a mainline job... someday... when they get around to being able to give you one, after all their buddies and CP friends and kids and interns have been accommodated.

Kill the dream and guess what? Well, we're seeing what! No more dumb, hopeful, someday-I'm-gonna-fly-a-widebody-to-Europe kids showing up to learn to fly anymore. Well, they killed the dream, it's DEAD, and this is what it looks like. No new pilots is what it looks like. They made the regionals a stagnant, hard to escape career mud-pit. They can live with the consequences.

I hope they don't touch regional FO pay by a penny. I hope every regional is dead or part of mainline just for pilot supply in 10 years or less. That's the new dream.

Graf, you have to be management. Only management would think to solve the problem your way.






Thank you for saving me time by explaining that.

You get it, and most non management actual pilot flight crews do. We have taken it in the shorts long enough, and now it has finally come to a point where the worst regionals are canceling flights, and even grounding entire fleets of aircraft due to lack of staffing. If the major airlines that need/want the feed would like to continue getting it, they will need to come to the plate with MORE money. They are making BILLIONS in profits, and don't need to line their pockets by getting us to keep working for poverty wage! Period, end of the story!!!
Reply
Old 03-04-2014 | 09:42 PM
  #80  
atpcliff's Avatar
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 3,215
Likes: 0
From: Capt
Default

[QUOTE]29-year USAF fighter pilot, now retiring, 50 years old, ATP, 4,000 hours, haven't flown since 2006 (due to staff and command jobs that take you away from the cockpit).

Reading this thread is pretty eye-watering. I haven't gotten a call from a major and have been considering doing a stint in the regionals to get current/qualified, thus making me more marketable to a major./QUOTE]

Have u Applied at Atlas???
Reply
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
sellener
Part 135
21
03-24-2009 07:29 PM
Herc130AV8R
Military
25
03-22-2008 05:22 PM
PCNUTT
Cargo
37
05-23-2007 08:12 PM
SWAjet
Corporate
40
05-02-2007 05:01 AM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Your Privacy Choices