Comair updates?
Delta bought COMAIR before I was hired in 99 and they were the first "all jet" feeder to use the CRJ. During the Comair strike in 2000, as an attempt to narrow the gap between RJ pay and mainline, Delta pilots sent Strike Assesment checks and ensured that no Mainline metal was used to cover a Comair route as struck work. I was an FE on the 727 and it was my job to check the DALPA guide book we had so that mgmt couldn't break the Comair strike out of CVG. After a few months, mgmt agreed to make the Comair pilots the best paid in the industry. We thought we had helped the Comair pilots bring the piloting profession up closer to what it should be.
This was in 2000, and we were in the middle of C2K negotiations for mainline. In return for record payrates, DALPA agreed to unlimited 50 seat RJ's to help feed the mainline operation. We signed C2K in the summer of 2001..and 9/11 hit in September.
Let me be clear. I know there are good guys at Comair and Delta. I just don't like re-writing history as if Comair was a helpless victim without any responsibility for their demise.
We offered the first "preferential" interview deal for Comair guys in return for letting furloughed mainline pilots swing the gear.
We got the middle finger for our efforts..and that's why there is such an emotional response to the name "COMAIR"...at least from 1310 Delta pilots..
This was in 2000, and we were in the middle of C2K negotiations for mainline. In return for record payrates, DALPA agreed to unlimited 50 seat RJ's to help feed the mainline operation. We signed C2K in the summer of 2001..and 9/11 hit in September.
Let me be clear. I know there are good guys at Comair and Delta. I just don't like re-writing history as if Comair was a helpless victim without any responsibility for their demise.
We offered the first "preferential" interview deal for Comair guys in return for letting furloughed mainline pilots swing the gear.
We got the middle finger for our efforts..and that's why there is such an emotional response to the name "COMAIR"...at least from 1310 Delta pilots..
Delta pilots have this thing against Comair pilots, but it should really be directed at Comair Management. They were the ones that wouldn't agree to hiring the furloughed Delta guys. It was a long time ago, but I think management didn't want to deal with the increased training costs associated with training guys that were going to get recalled and then have a deal that increased the chances of pilots leaving.
I can assure you, you didn't get the middle finger from the Comair pilots. 80+% of us wanted to get out of Comair and would have done anything to get to Delta.
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 500
Likes: 0
+ 1
Also, I would like to go on the record as a Comair pilot (Ret.) that when JC Lawson wrote that famous letter he did not ask me to proofread it for him. It is the opinion of most of the people that I have talked with that JC pretty much went off the reservation with that letter.Also, one might form the opinion that SOME Delta pilots were just looking for an excuse, any excuse, to take out their frustration on all Comair pilots.I don't think most Delta pilots are that small.
Also, I would like to go on the record as a Comair pilot (Ret.) that when JC Lawson wrote that famous letter he did not ask me to proofread it for him. It is the opinion of most of the people that I have talked with that JC pretty much went off the reservation with that letter.Also, one might form the opinion that SOME Delta pilots were just looking for an excuse, any excuse, to take out their frustration on all Comair pilots.I don't think most Delta pilots are that small.
:-)
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 7,339
Likes: 0
DALPA is to blame for the plight of the Delta pilots after 9/11. Even though Comair went crazy, and turned away the Delta pilots, it should have never been their decision to make in the first place. If C2k gave mainline pilots a big pay bump for the option of unlimited 50 seaters, well then you can't be mad when management exercises that option.
Herc, my comment to remember Comair is about standing up to management Tyranny, pure and simple.
When Northwest bought Delta, Richard Anderson made no secret of the hatred he felt toward Comair and its' pilot group. He was determined to teach everyone in the regional industry this is what happens when you dare to change the status quo. I spoke to him face to face personally at a meeting in CVG at a Delta only meeting and when I mentioned Comairs' future he looked at me like I strangled his wife. I knew then it was over.
I as well as other pilots went to Comair during a time of economic turmoil. Comair hired us, I worked as a CSA and we couldn't wait for the Comair to start growing again, as we would be transferred to flight ops. However Richard had something else in mind and carried it out, in the process throwing a huge wrench in thousands of peoples' lives, namely all of CVG.
You can try to argue that point but look at what he did to Endeavour (Pinnacle) trying to force a concessionary contract on them (poverty wages) at a time when Delta is making RECORD PROFITS. Did he not say that if Endeavour didn't accept the contract they would become the next Comair?
What about the Eagle Pilots? US Airways group is also making record profits but told Eagle if you don't take these concessions we will make you Comair 2. If management can use Remember Comair as a rallying cry to screw over a professional labor force then we as pilots can use it to remember a group of professionals that stood up to management tyranny and said no more!
Now about your Vendetta against Comair pilots - so an entire workforce had it out to screw over Delta mainline pilots so that is the reason he shut Comair down? All 2000+ pilots? SERIOUSLY????? Herc I am going to defer this to someone in the know or I am sure if you did a search of this thread, type in Comair MEC or management,
perhaps that may enlighten you. I personally have yet to meet one Comair pilot that had it out for you guys. But please, opposing views are always welcome here.
Lets' face it, Deltas' current CEO is a complete anal orifice who Eagles' manangement tried to copy and I watched with pleasure as it blew up in their face. This fight this phrase to REMEMBER COMAIR is not about Delta and Comair pilots ****ing match, its' about management trying to intimidate a work group into concessions or be shut down like Comair and that work group, any work group saying yes, we remember Comair and we're not taking it anymore just like they didn't!!
REMEMBER COMAIR!!
Twisted Sister - We're Not Gonna Take It (Official Video) - YouTube
When Northwest bought Delta, Richard Anderson made no secret of the hatred he felt toward Comair and its' pilot group. He was determined to teach everyone in the regional industry this is what happens when you dare to change the status quo. I spoke to him face to face personally at a meeting in CVG at a Delta only meeting and when I mentioned Comairs' future he looked at me like I strangled his wife. I knew then it was over.
I as well as other pilots went to Comair during a time of economic turmoil. Comair hired us, I worked as a CSA and we couldn't wait for the Comair to start growing again, as we would be transferred to flight ops. However Richard had something else in mind and carried it out, in the process throwing a huge wrench in thousands of peoples' lives, namely all of CVG.
You can try to argue that point but look at what he did to Endeavour (Pinnacle) trying to force a concessionary contract on them (poverty wages) at a time when Delta is making RECORD PROFITS. Did he not say that if Endeavour didn't accept the contract they would become the next Comair?
What about the Eagle Pilots? US Airways group is also making record profits but told Eagle if you don't take these concessions we will make you Comair 2. If management can use Remember Comair as a rallying cry to screw over a professional labor force then we as pilots can use it to remember a group of professionals that stood up to management tyranny and said no more!
Now about your Vendetta against Comair pilots - so an entire workforce had it out to screw over Delta mainline pilots so that is the reason he shut Comair down? All 2000+ pilots? SERIOUSLY????? Herc I am going to defer this to someone in the know or I am sure if you did a search of this thread, type in Comair MEC or management,
perhaps that may enlighten you. I personally have yet to meet one Comair pilot that had it out for you guys. But please, opposing views are always welcome here.
Lets' face it, Deltas' current CEO is a complete anal orifice who Eagles' manangement tried to copy and I watched with pleasure as it blew up in their face. This fight this phrase to REMEMBER COMAIR is not about Delta and Comair pilots ****ing match, its' about management trying to intimidate a work group into concessions or be shut down like Comair and that work group, any work group saying yes, we remember Comair and we're not taking it anymore just like they didn't!!
REMEMBER COMAIR!!
Twisted Sister - We're Not Gonna Take It (Official Video) - YouTube
Autopilot..
"Remember Comair" obviously means very different things to each of us. I do not have a vendetta against all Comair pilots and understand how difficult the last 15 yrs have been to both sides of the "Comair" debate. If "remember comair" means raising pilot wages at the regional level up to where they should be, then I support your efforts. If RJ pilots are able to use their time to get a better gig, then I support it. If the impending pilot shortage results in mainline recapturing ALL domestic flying we lost and bringing ALL pilots on the same team, then I support it.
However, "Remember Comair" means something completely different to me. Those are my memories and there are 1310 other pilots at Delta with similar sentiments.
Looks like your hatred toward Anderson is only matched by my opinion of JC Lawson..hopefully that can be common ground moving forward.
Just got back from a long trip..I'm done.
FalconHerc out..
Last edited by CGfalconHerc; 02-16-2014 at 02:03 PM.
Works Every Weekend
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,210
Likes: 0
I thought the other points you made were actually quite good. It's nice to get a glimpse from the opinion of a mainline guy every now and again. This one though... you're reaching quite a bit.
To be clear, I'm certainly no CPA carrier growth advocate. I'm going to have a beer and a victory cigar every time a regional dies. It is just a bit unfortunate to see things blamed on a regional when they had nothing to do with the contract that caused the snafu.
So the Delta guys got all hot and bothered over an absolutely massive pay-scale, and were willing to sell the little airplane flying to get it. And then you're angry at Comair when the contract your pilot group voted in gets used as it was drawn up?
I thought the other points you made were actually quite good. It's nice to get a glimpse from the opinion of a mainline guy every now and again. This one though... you're reaching quite a bit.
To be clear, I'm certainly no CPA carrier growth advocate. I'm going to have a beer and a victory cigar every time a regional dies. It is just a bit unfortunate to see things blamed on a regional when they had nothing to do with the contract that caused the snafu.
I thought the other points you made were actually quite good. It's nice to get a glimpse from the opinion of a mainline guy every now and again. This one though... you're reaching quite a bit.
To be clear, I'm certainly no CPA carrier growth advocate. I'm going to have a beer and a victory cigar every time a regional dies. It is just a bit unfortunate to see things blamed on a regional when they had nothing to do with the contract that caused the snafu.
Pete,
So the one sentence that "Delta pilots agreed to unlimited 50 seaters in return for C2K pay" makes everything ok?! Ah yes, the greedy delta pilots sold their soul and got what's coming to them. Ygtbsm..
After the successful Comair strike, "unlimited 50 seaters" didn't seem to be enough of a threat to replace nearly all of our 727 and 737 flying. In fact, the C2K negotiating slogan was "Restoring the Profession". Our pay rates, Comair pay rates and RJ growth would be a rising tide for all of us and attract the best pilots to Delta. We were making $1B and hiring 1000 pilots a year..allowing more RJ flying would put more Delta pax on jets vs Brazilia's..which they seemed to want.
Then 9/11...events unfolded as I described previously. We didn't ask for a halt to rj growth. We didn't ask to displace down to the LEFT seat of the jets OUR company was buying to fly OUR passengers...we asked to sit in the RIGHT seat of the most junior plane in return for preferential hiring at OUR company. The whole idea was "we supported RJ guys in the past with the strike AND acknowledging their contribution by agreeing to more rj growth in OUR new contract that raised the bar for EVERYONE.
I also throw back a cold one when an RJ company goes down, but I still have empathy for the pilots, employees, families who have to land on their feet. I've been there, done that. And I certainly don't get " hot and bothered" about a paycheck earned at someone else's expense.
Last edited by CGfalconHerc; 02-17-2014 at 07:58 AM.
Works Every Weekend
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,210
Likes: 0
Pete,
So the one sentence that "Delta pilots agreed to unlimited 50 seaters in return for C2K pay" makes everything ok?! Ah yes, the greedy delta pilots sold their soul and got what's coming to them. Ygtbsm..
After the successful Comair strike, "unlimited 50 seaters" didn't seem to be enough of a threat to replace nearly all of our 727 and 737 flying. In fact, the C2K negotiating slogan was "Restoring the Profession". Our pay rates, Comair pay rates and RJ growth would be a rising tide for all of us and attract the best pilots to Delta. We were making $1B and hiring 1000 pilots a year..allowing more RJ flying would put more Delta pax on jets vs Brazilia's..which they seemed to want.
Then 9/11...events unfolded as I described previously. We didn't ask for a halt to rj growth. We didn't ask to displace down to the LEFT seat of the jets OUR company was buying to fly OUR passengers...we asked to sit in the RIGHT seat of the most junior plane in return for preferential hiring at OUR company. The whole idea was "we supported RJ guys in the past with the strike AND acknowledging their contribution by agreeing to more rj growth in OUR new contract that raised the bar for EVERYONE.
I also throw back a cold one when an RJ company goes down, but I still have empathy for the pilots, employees, families who have to land on their feet. I've been there, done that. And I certainly don't get " hot and bothered" about a paycheck earned at someone else's expense.
So the one sentence that "Delta pilots agreed to unlimited 50 seaters in return for C2K pay" makes everything ok?! Ah yes, the greedy delta pilots sold their soul and got what's coming to them. Ygtbsm..
After the successful Comair strike, "unlimited 50 seaters" didn't seem to be enough of a threat to replace nearly all of our 727 and 737 flying. In fact, the C2K negotiating slogan was "Restoring the Profession". Our pay rates, Comair pay rates and RJ growth would be a rising tide for all of us and attract the best pilots to Delta. We were making $1B and hiring 1000 pilots a year..allowing more RJ flying would put more Delta pax on jets vs Brazilia's..which they seemed to want.
Then 9/11...events unfolded as I described previously. We didn't ask for a halt to rj growth. We didn't ask to displace down to the LEFT seat of the jets OUR company was buying to fly OUR passengers...we asked to sit in the RIGHT seat of the most junior plane in return for preferential hiring at OUR company. The whole idea was "we supported RJ guys in the past with the strike AND acknowledging their contribution by agreeing to more rj growth in OUR new contract that raised the bar for EVERYONE.
I also throw back a cold one when an RJ company goes down, but I still have empathy for the pilots, employees, families who have to land on their feet. I've been there, done that. And I certainly don't get " hot and bothered" about a paycheck earned at someone else's expense.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



